Was I wrong in my review?

Posted By Message

DrMeg
Back home!

Member since 5/08

1858 total posts

Name:
Meg

Was I wrong in my review?

DH and I just got a puppy a few weeks ago and have been looking for a dog walker, for when I travel for work. Who knew it would be such a PITA.
Anyway I contacted this one guy who I had found through Yelp. I explained what we needed and he said he could do it, and suggested a meeting so he could meet us and our dog and vice versa. I scheduled it for Thursday evening at 6:30. Thursday evening comes and goes and the guy doesn't show up. DH and I discussed calling him to find out what happened, but agreed that if someone can't show up to a first meeting we would question how reliable they were when actually scheduled to take care of our dog.

The next morning I wrote the following review of his business on Yelp:
"This is a review based solely on a phone interaction with Dan because he wasn't even courteous enough to show up for a meeting he suggested.
I called to inquire about house visit services for our puppy and Dan told me he thought it was something he could do. He suggested a meeting to discuss and so he could meet our dog. He never showed up and didn't even bother to call. If it was a service he didn't want to provide or we were outside of his service area he should have just said so on the phone.
I wouldn't want to leave my dog in the care of someone so unprofessional!"

Within about 10 min he left me a voicemail in which it was clear he read the review. He didn't mention it but said that he had wrote down our meeting for Friday but then realized maybe it was for Thursday and to give him a call if I wanted to still meet on Friday night. About an hour later I get a nasty text from him saying he saw my "swift review" and how I should have called him and been concerned for his well being or that he had the wrong address (meanwhile I knew he had my phone number if he did have the wrong address). And that he was glad that we wouldn't be working together if I wasn't understanding of a mistake in scheduling.

I didn't respond because I knew it wouldn't be worth it because DH and I wouldn't give him a second chance. And for us, if you are hiring someone and their service is highly based on reliability and scheduling, showing up for your first appointment is pretty important. Do you think I was wrong to review his business the way I did?

Posted 6/1/14 2:38 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

InShock
life is good

Member since 10/06

9258 total posts

Name:

Was I wrong in my review?

I don't think it was the nicest thing to do. The guy is human - we all make mistakes. You should have at least called him/followed up before writing the review, IMO.

Posted 6/1/14 2:42 PM
 

MDF
.

Member since 5/05

2313 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Was I wrong in my review?

Posted by InShock

I don't think it was the nicest thing to do. The guy is human - we all make mistakes. You should have at least called him/followed up before writing the review, IMO.

i agree. I would never write a bad review without at least trying to figure out why he didn't show.

Posted 6/1/14 2:54 PM
 

DrMeg
Back home!

Member since 5/08

1858 total posts

Name:
Meg

Re: Was I wrong in my review?

Posted by MDF

Posted by InShock

I don't think it was the nicest thing to do. The guy is human - we all make mistakes. You should have at least called him/followed up before writing the review, IMO.

i agree. I would never write a bad review without at least trying to figure out why he didn't show.



Fair enough. His excuse for the issue was that he took my phone call when he was preoccupied. Which to me, then don't answer the phone and let me leave a message or ask to call me back. We just felt like what if he made a mistake like that when he was scheduled to care for our dog and never showed up.

Posted 6/1/14 3:01 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Was I wrong in my review?

As a professional, I always confirm appointments before making the trip.

While the OP could've called to see if was still coming, I don't think she's necessarily in the wrong for saying what she did.

In that kind of business especially, you need to be organized.

If he has enough time to be hanging out on Yelp, he has enough time to get appt days and times straight.

Posted 6/1/14 3:02 PM
 

MomMom
LIF Toddler

Member since 9/10

428 total posts

Name:
hi

Re: Was I wrong in my review?

I don't think the review was warranted. It was a one time instance and you didn't even give him a chance to explain. I would be hesitant to leave negative reviews, especially if someone KNOWS where I live. Maybe I am paranoid but you never know who you are dealing with.

Message edited 2014-06-01 15:29:30.620000.

Posted 6/1/14 3:16 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Was I wrong in my review?

I am the odd one out I guess but I don't think you were wrong in writing the review. He had a scheduled appointment and didn't have the courtesy to show up OR call to let you know he wouldn't be coming OR to apologize after the fact. First impressions are EVERYTHING and he regardless of WHY, that guy screwed up.

If he's trying to gain people's business (and trust) I think it's in his best interest to be on top of his appointments and potential customers..........particularly nowadays with social media where in an instant you can can be bad mouthed.

I don't think it's your responsibility as a potential customer to have tracked him down to see what was wrong and why he didn't show up. That's ridiculous. You gave him an opportunity to gain your business and he screwed up, too bad.

I'm sure had you NOT written the review he would have NEVER contacted you again. The ONLY reason he reached out was because you slammed him on Yelp, not because he cared that he messed up.

Posted 6/1/14 3:28 PM
 

JME78
LIF Adult

Member since 11/09

3672 total posts

Name:

Re: Was I wrong in my review?

Posted by Hofstra26

I am the odd one out I guess but I don't think you were wrong in writing the review. He had a scheduled appointment and didn't have the courtesy to show up OR call to let you know he wouldn't be coming OR to apologize after the fact. First impressions are EVERYTHING and he regardless of WHY, that guy screwed up.

If he's trying to gain people's business (and trust) I think it's in his best interest to be on top of his appointments and potential customers..........particularly nowadays with social media where in an instant you can can be bad mouthed.

I don't think it's your responsibility as a potential customer to have tracked him down to see what was wrong and why he didn't show up. That's ridiculous. You gave him an opportunity to gain your business and he screwed up, too bad.

I'm sure had you NOT written the review he would have NEVER contacted you again. The ONLY reason he reached out was because you slammed him on Yelp, not because he cared that he messed up.




I totally agree. He was unprofessional and you had every right to share your experience.

Posted 6/1/14 4:01 PM
 

wakemeup

Member since 10/13

1397 total posts

Name:

Re: Was I wrong in my review?

While I do think that you should have contacted him first before leaving the review, I agree with the PPs - he probably only contacted you because of your review and was very unprofessional in his response. That alone would make me edit the original review and include the new interaction with him.

Posted 6/1/14 4:32 PM
 

TheDivaBrideandTeddyFrog
Leah's here!

Member since 9/07

5404 total posts

Name:
Sabrina

Was I wrong in my review?

I am half and half because I am a softy, but I prefer professionalism. We once had the same thing happen with a brick mason and on Angie's List..the mason showed up at my house and asked me how I could write such a review (I basically just wrote that I would have entertained a quote from him had he called back or something to that effect) but he showed up so ANGRY, which made my impression worse! I couldn't believe he showed up and demanded I take it down because he had the wrong phone number or said he got a weird disconnected message when he called me...I called Angie's List and complained but at the end of the day, took down the review because what he did was weird...

I don't think this guy you're dealing with sounds that way, but maybe I would have met with him and then still decided to go elsewhere, but maybe once gave the benefit of the doubt if you had an overall good vibe..

Message edited 2014-06-01 16:33:40.737000.

Posted 6/1/14 4:32 PM
 

M514
Hi

Member since 8/10

6011 total posts

Name:

Was I wrong in my review?

I dont think I would have left a review. I would have just moved on to finding another dog walker. He didnt show up, his loss.

Posted 6/1/14 5:08 PM
 

bella321
Blessed!

Member since 3/09

1952 total posts

Name:
Kristy

Re: Was I wrong in my review?

Posted by M514

I dont think I would have left a review. I would have just moved on to finding another dog walker. He didnt show up, his loss.



ITA. Dog walkers, in my experience, tend to be unprofessional people looking for some easy money on the side. Sorry to say, I'm not surprised he didn't confirm / follow up with you.

Posted 6/1/14 5:15 PM
 

Strawberry2468
It's summatime

Member since 3/09

4739 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: Was I wrong in my review?

Many people write this on care.com when people don't show for interviews. As someone who has rearranged my already hectic schedule and had several people no-show on me, I appreciate knowing ahead of time that a person has the tendency to flake. If he couldn't make it he should have called. It's not your job to call him to check on his well being!!

Posted 6/1/14 5:49 PM
 

BabyLove08
Love her!

Member since 2/08

3673 total posts

Name:

Re: Was I wrong in my review?

Posted by JME78

Posted by Hofstra26

I am the odd one out I guess but I don't think you were wrong in writing the review. He had a scheduled appointment and didn't have the courtesy to show up OR call to let you know he wouldn't be coming OR to apologize after the fact. First impressions are EVERYTHING and he regardless of WHY, that guy screwed up.

If he's trying to gain people's business (and trust) I think it's in his best interest to be on top of his appointments and potential customers..........particularly nowadays with social media where in an instant you can can be bad mouthed.

I don't think it's your responsibility as a potential customer to have tracked him down to see what was wrong and why he didn't show up. That's ridiculous. You gave him an opportunity to gain your business and he screwed up, too bad.

I'm sure had you NOT written the review he would have NEVER contacted you again. The ONLY reason he reached out was because you slammed him on Yelp, not because he cared that he messed up.




I totally agree. He was unprofessional and you had every right to share your experience.




I 100% agree too! I would have done and felt as the poster did.

Message edited 2014-06-01 18:11:37.800000.

Posted 6/1/14 6:11 PM
 

BargainMama
LIF Adult

Member since 5/09

15660 total posts

Name:

Re: Was I wrong in my review?

Posted by MomMom

I don't think the review was warranted. It was a one time instance and you didn't even give him a chance to explain. I would be hesitant to leave negative reviews, especially if someone KNOWS where I live. Maybe I am paranoid but you never know who you are dealing with.



I wouldn't have left that type of review purely because like you said, the person knows EXACTLY where you live.

Posted 6/1/14 6:58 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
This is SOOOO Wrong Jesaroo 5/26/05 22 Families Helping Families ™
Sorry Wrong Board! LIMOMx2 5/21/05 5 TTC
Would it be wrong if... preciouslove 5/20/05 9 Families Helping Families ™
WTH is wrong with people - LOOK at this! MrsJ 5/20/05 36 TTC
Wrong paint color?? jms100303 5/18/05 12 Home
(sorry if wrong forum)some good printable toys r us coupons pschica 5/13/05 14 Families Helping Families ™