Walmart decision?

Posted By Message

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Walmart decision?

Thank the Supreme Court for one thing: In its appalling decision in the Walmart gender discrimination case handed down Monday, the justices supplied future historians with a brilliant symbol of how the United States has essentially become a giant gated community enjoyed by the powerful, with most of the citizenry living outside and struggling to nourish themselves.

Walmart is nothing if not a monument to the benefits of mass organization, an exemplar of all the good things that can be extracted by those who assemble themselves into a single large-scale entity. As the largest retailer on earth, the company is generally able to dictate the terms of trade with the thousands of merchants who keep the shelves of its stores stocked with cut-rate goods, tapping factories in China and middlemen traders in Latin America. Walmart has a habit of placing multiple orders with multiple factories for the same products, then forcing each to accept lower prices at the last minute or walk away with nothing.

By dint of its scale, it is able to capture the lowest prices for just about everything, from shipping to labor to contracting services. At its global procurement office in the southern China boomtown of Shenzhen, Walmart makes representatives from surrounding factories sit together in a bare-bones waiting room before they get a chance to negotiate with the retailer's agents. Should the reps balk at Walmart's price, they know that the buying agent can just step out into the waiting room and find someone else from another factory -- someone desperate enough to deliver for whatever the company is paying. This is the power of being not only huge but organized into one entity.

Strip away the myriad technicalities, and what the Supreme Court essentially decreed this week is that Walmart's employees -- or really any group of people who happen to work for a colossal corporation -- are not entitled to organize themselves similarly to enhance their power to pursue their own interests.

The court ruled that female workers may not be considered a class for the purposes of a lawsuit in which they accuse the company of years of gender discrimination, because they worked in many different stores in many different American communities, making their experiences effectively individual.

"Respondents wish to sue for millions of employment decisions at once," Justice Antonin Scalia wrote in the lead opinion for the court in the five votes to four decision supporting the giant retailer. "Without some glue holding together the alleged reasons for those decisions, it will be impossible to say that examination of all the class members' claims will produce a common answer to the crucial discrimination question."

As if to underscore the absurdity of this disparity, Scalia noted that Walmart has a written policy barring discrimination: The mere act of writing this down at headquarters somehow confers immunity against claims of a breach of that policy -- not that there's any glue providing coherence to the experience of workers as a class!

In other words, the fact that they happen to work for a single enormous employers whose decisions are so consequential that they alone can influence the prices of certain commodities does not amount to a common experience -- not in the minds of the most powerful arbiters in the land.

Rather, each Walmart is its own separate unit, for the purposes of the lawsuit. Walmart gets to be a behemoth when it is setting the prices for the patio furniture and volleyball sets that it purchases from factories in Mexico and China, but when its employees want to band together to address alleged abuses in the court system, suddenly the Walmart corporation might just as well be a collection of little mom-and-pop shops that happen to have the same name.

The court suggested that the Walmart workers could pursue relief to their claims by filing their own individual lawsuits, but that is no option for low-wage employees who typically earn so little that many rely upon food stamps, say labor experts. (Another wonderful American story: Taxpayers subsidizing giant, publicly traded corporations by keeping their low-wage employees alive. But I digress.)

For the workers, this legal "solution" amounts to the equivalent of asking Walmart to negotiate directly with every factory that produces its products on an individual basis, and not impose the price by wielding the power of its scale.

For the labor movement, this is a distressing development. Another crucial weapon in a diminishing arsenal -- the class action lawsuit -- has been effectively blunted, even as corporate employers gain new powers. Last year, the Supreme Court decreed that corporations can essentially funnel as much money into political campaigns as they choose, unlike individuals. The realities of increasingly global trade has added to the options that management can employ as it arbitrages labor costs across every community, putting workers in Detroit in direct competition with their counterparts in Shenzhen.

And for American society writ large, the decision is nothing short of a disaster, a formal affirmation from the Supreme Court that huge corporations enjoy special rights denied to the people who depend on their wages to pay their bills.

Not lost on anyone is the simple fact of widening inequality, with increasing shares of the spoils of American commerce accruing to a narrowing group of people. Chief executives of huge companies are seeing their pay soar, while rank-and-file employees watch another year go by with essentially no raise -- if they are fortunate enough to be employed at all.

We are indeed becoming more like a gated community for the wealthiest Americans, with manicured lawns for those on the inside, and dumpster diving for the working class - -yes, class, a designation that exists by dint of economic reality, no high court affirmation required. The Supreme Court just reinforced the front gate.
-----------------
I'm surprised no one has commented on this.

It still surprises me that one of the largest companies consistently discriminates against women and yet women don't think twice about shopping there...Chat Icon Source: Huffington Post

Message edited 2011-06-21 16:25:34.647000.

Posted 6/21/11 4:24 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

WhatNow
Say Cheese!

Member since 1/06

8033 total posts

Name:
A (formerly WhatNow?)

Re: Walmart decision?

Can someone sum up how they discriminate again women? You have me totally lost here: must be the heat!Chat Icon

Posted 6/21/11 4:31 PM
 

Pomegranate5
LIF Adult

Member since 2/11

4798 total posts

Name:
Pomegranate5

Re: Walmart decision?

I think the court's decision is disappointing. I don't know enough about the legal issues to say I'm surprised by the ruling. But I'm definitely saddened by it as a woman.

I don't shop at WalMart for a lot of reasons.....this is just another of them.

Posted 6/21/11 4:45 PM
 

karacg
Babygirl is 4!

Member since 5/05

17076 total posts

Name:
Kara®

Re: Walmart decision?

Walmart destroyed my business, and the businesses of many like me. And our clients and suppliers.

I am in no way surprised by the accusations, or the judgement for that matter. $$ is and always will be king...unfortunately.

Posted 6/21/11 4:59 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Walmart decision?

Posted by WhatNow

Can someone sum up how they discriminate again women? You have me totally lost here: must be the heat!Chat Icon



Talk about MAJOR case of rambling without even talking about the topic trying to be discussed.

Posted 6/21/11 5:00 PM
 

skip123
Trying...

Member since 8/06

2759 total posts

Name:

Re: Walmart decision?

I never set foot there...thankfully we have plenty of other shopping options here...

I feel bad for the areas where it is the ONLY place to shop......

Posted 6/21/11 5:14 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Walmart decision?

Posted by skip123

I never set foot there...thankfully we have plenty of other shopping options here...

I feel bad for the areas where it is the ONLY place to shop......



Actually in MANY States, Walmart IS the place to go to. They hire many people locally who have no education, they are cheap. They cater to a lot of lower income people.

Posted 6/21/11 5:16 PM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: Walmart decision?

Posted by smdl

Posted by skip123

I never set foot there...thankfully we have plenty of other shopping options here...

I feel bad for the areas where it is the ONLY place to shop......



Actually in MANY States, Walmart IS the place to go to. They hire many people locally who have no education, they are cheap. They cater to a lot of lower income people.




And I'm sure they add to the population of low income people by paying minimum wage and keeping folks at part-time levels to avoid giving them benefits.

There is a high cost associated with low prices. I prefer Costco where I know the lowest paid worker is still pulling in $11+ an hour and most have access to benefits.



Posted 6/21/11 5:41 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Walmart decision?

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by smdl

Posted by skip123

I never set foot there...thankfully we have plenty of other shopping options here...

I feel bad for the areas where it is the ONLY place to shop......



Actually in MANY States, Walmart IS the place to go to. They hire many people locally who have no education, they are cheap. They cater to a lot of lower income people.




And I'm sure they add to the population of low income people by paying minimum wage and keeping folks at part-time levels to avoid giving them benefits.

There is a high cost associated with low prices. I prefer Costco where I know the lowest paid worker is still pulling in $11+ an hour and most have access to benefits.






I am talking where Walmart is the "strongest". In rural areas in NC for example. There is nothing really around for 30-35 miles. Then you have a Walmart in the middle of a super small town. EVERYBODY goes there on Saturday night. Like it's the Mall. There is no Costco for another 35 miles minimum. There might be a Lowe's across the street.

Posted 6/21/11 5:44 PM
 

hanna7636
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

921 total posts

Name:

Re: Walmart decision?

I have a family member who works for Walmart and loves it. She is a cashier and owns a home. Where she is from Walmart is the place to go.

I cannot give my opinion on this case because I did not hear the evidence but I did hear on 1010 this morning they can sue Walmart but not through a class action suit because every case is different.

No matter how you feel about the pay of workers at these kind of stores realize that the prices will go up so if you are willing to pay it than have the workers be paid more. Walmart, etc are not going to pay them out of their profits.

Posted 6/21/11 5:52 PM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: Walmart decision?



No matter how you feel about the pay of workers at these kind of stores realize that the prices will go up so if you are willing to pay it than have the workers be paid more. Walmart, etc are not going to pay them out of their profits.



Costco has excellent prices and treats their workers well - it can be done.

And their shareholders seem pretty satisfied based on this
http://finance.yahoo.com/echarts?s=COST+Interactive#chart1:symbol=cost;range=my;indicator=volume;charttype=line;crosshair=on;ohlcvalues=0;logscale=on;source=undefined


Posted 6/21/11 6:00 PM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Walmart decision?

Sorry... but... I think the Court got it right here. These women do not qualify as a class under FRCP 23 for the redress they are seeking, based on the information about their claims i've seen available...

I have no opinion on the merits of their claims.

Posted 6/21/11 6:12 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Walmart decision?

Posted by annoyedTTCer



No matter how you feel about the pay of workers at these kind of stores realize that the prices will go up so if you are willing to pay it than have the workers be paid more. Walmart, etc are not going to pay them out of their profits.



Costco has excellent prices and treats their workers well - it can be done.

And their shareholders seem pretty satisfied based on this
http://finance.yahoo.com/echarts?s=COST+Interactive#chart1:symbol=cost;range=my;indicator=volume;charttype=line;crosshair=on;ohlcvalues=0;logscale=on;source=undefined





But many States don't have Costco or only in the bigger towns/cities. Walmart is so strong because in many many areas that's ALL there is. Walmart is making towns bigger and stronger. I don't agree with what they do but they DO provide to small communities. That's why they grew to be so big as a company.

Most Walmart in some states are super walmart with full groceries. Same for Target. Many are super target.

Posted 6/21/11 6:30 PM
 

WhatNow
Say Cheese!

Member since 1/06

8033 total posts

Name:
A (formerly WhatNow?)

Re: Walmart decision?

Posted by smdl

Posted by WhatNow

Can someone sum up how they discriminate again women? You have me totally lost here: must be the heat!Chat Icon



Talk about MAJOR case of rambling without even talking about the topic trying to be discussed.



I was referring to this line:
Posted by nrthshgrl

It still surprises me that one of the largest companies consistently discriminates against women and yet women don't think twice about shopping there...Chat Icon Source: Huffington Post


that' why I asked that question. I mean, maybe they do, who knows... I personally love Walmart and shop there every time we go to Poconos for the summer. All I gathered from the article is that Walmart is run by shrewd businessmen who are wiling to do anything to keep their prices down.

Posted 6/21/11 7:07 PM
 

Alexandra17
Keep It Positive

Member since 4/09

6262 total posts

Name:
Alexandra (ali)

Re: Walmart decision?

Posted by Bearcat

Sorry... but... I think the Court got it right here. These women do not qualify as a class under FRCP 23 for the redress they are seeking, based on the information about their claims i've seen available...

I have no opinion on the merits of their claims.



what does that mean? Lawyer language! lol

Posted 6/21/11 7:12 PM
 

Kahuna
LIF Toddler

Member since 4/10

497 total posts

Name:

Re: Walmart decision?

Posted by smdl

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by smdl

Posted by skip123

I never set foot there...thankfully we have plenty of other shopping options here...

I feel bad for the areas where it is the ONLY place to shop......



Actually in MANY States, Walmart IS the place to go to. They hire many people locally who have no education, they are cheap. They cater to a lot of lower income people.




And I'm sure they add to the population of low income people by paying minimum wage and keeping folks at part-time levels to avoid giving them benefits.

There is a high cost associated with low prices. I prefer Costco where I know the lowest paid worker is still pulling in $11+ an hour and most have access to benefits.






I am talking where Walmart is the "strongest". In rural areas in NC for example. There is nothing really around for 30-35 miles. Then you have a Walmart in the middle of a super small town. EVERYBODY goes there on Saturday night. Like it's the Mall. There is no Costco for another 35 miles minimum. There might be a Lowe's across the street.




Those small southern and midwest towns had small mom and pop stores till Walmart came in and obliterated their businesses. Once thriving downtowns are now ghost towns because Wally World moved in.

Posted 6/21/11 7:14 PM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Walmart decision?

Posted by Alexandra17

Posted by Bearcat

Sorry... but... I think the Court got it right here. These women do not qualify as a class under FRCP 23 for the redress they are seeking, based on the information about their claims i've seen available...

I have no opinion on the merits of their claims.



what does that mean? Lawyer language! lol



their claims have too many differences for them to meet the standards under the law to qualify them as a class and enable them to pursue a suit against walmart as a class action. it does not mean their claims are no good, or that they can't sue... they simply don't meet the reqirements to do it as a class action.

that make more sense? Chat Icon

Posted 6/21/11 7:32 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Walmart decision?

Posted by Kahuna

Posted by smdl

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by smdl

Posted by skip123

I never set foot there...thankfully we have plenty of other shopping options here...

I feel bad for the areas where it is the ONLY place to shop......



Actually in MANY States, Walmart IS the place to go to. They hire many people locally who have no education, they are cheap. They cater to a lot of lower income people.




And I'm sure they add to the population of low income people by paying minimum wage and keeping folks at part-time levels to avoid giving them benefits.

There is a high cost associated with low prices. I prefer Costco where I know the lowest paid worker is still pulling in $11+ an hour and most have access to benefits.






I am talking where Walmart is the "strongest". In rural areas in NC for example. There is nothing really around for 30-35 miles. Then you have a Walmart in the middle of a super small town. EVERYBODY goes there on Saturday night. Like it's the Mall. There is no Costco for another 35 miles minimum. There might be a Lowe's across the street.




Those small southern and midwest towns had small mom and pop stores till Walmart came in and obliterated their businesses. Once thriving downtowns are now ghost towns because Wally World moved in.



No doubt but I remember when I lived in NC and going to some small towns and you will have those "people of Walmart". At 9pm Walmart was packed and people would just go there for "hanging out".

Posted 6/21/11 7:59 PM
 

Kate
*****

Member since 5/05

7557 total posts

Name:
Kate

Re: Walmart decision?

Posted by Bearcat



their claims have too many differences for them to meet the standards under the law to qualify them as a class and enable them to pursue a suit against walmart as a class action. it does not mean their claims are no good, or that they can't sue... they simply don't meet the reqirements to do it as a class action.

that make more sense? Chat Icon



Exactly. How could they ALL have been discriminated in the exact same way? And this is the most slanted "news" article I've ever read.

Posted 6/21/11 9:05 PM
 

mosa77
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

2122 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Walmart decision?

I shop at walmart because the prices are so cheap living on long island is exspensive and for people who are struggling its nice to have a place to get stuff cheap . as a person who has worked in retail all my life I can say that most of the companies here that I have worked for pay minimum wage and only want part timers so they dont have to give insurance and pay there women employess less money then there men . walmart has a bad rep and yes if i could afford to shop elsewhere i def would but in this economy im going to go where I get the most for my money Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 6/21/11 10:21 PM
 

IrishLasss334
I'll be there soon!

Member since 1/08

6549 total posts

Name:
Patty

Re: Walmart decision?

I shop at Walmart occasionally, it's not convenient to my house and it's usually crowded.

I won't lie, I don't know details about this case. But Walmart is not the only company that does this! UPS does the same thing - they hire drivers part time and it takes forever to possibly become full time - ALOT of trucking companies work this way.

Also, when DH worked for LIJ/Schneiders (before North Shore took over) - they had the same policy with the mental health workers in the psych wards - you worked "part time" - to limit the benefits...my DH had to document the abuse of his "part time" status to make him full time and get benefits - it took a year.

Walmart maybe in the forefront as far as the news as far as this is concerned, but they are far from the only company that does it.

Posted 6/22/11 7:13 AM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Walmart decision?

Posted by IrishLass

I shop at Walmart occasionally, it's not convenient to my house and it's usually crowded.

I won't lie, I don't know details about this case. But Walmart is not the only company that does this! UPS does the same thing - they hire drivers part time and it takes forever to possibly become full time - ALOT of trucking companies work this way.

Also, when DH worked for LIJ/Schneiders (before North Shore took over) - they had the same policy with the mental health workers in the psych wards - you worked "part time" - to limit the benefits...my DH had to document the abuse of his "part time" status to make him full time and get benefits - it took a year.

Walmart maybe in the forefront as far as the news as far as this is concerned, but they are far from the only company that does it.




Banks have done that for YEARS with their bank tellers. They were some of the first one to do that so they would have not to pay benefits since they were PT workers.

Posted 6/22/11 7:43 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
How much is the largest Similac powder at Walmart? bean 6/7/06 3 Parenting
free sample of the walmart brand formula )paren'ts choice) and sign up for thier coupon list!! wowcoulditbe 6/3/06 2 Pregnancy
Thank you for your thoughts to my last post, I finally made a decision. LIPrincess 5/30/06 3 Infertility
Is it a bad decision to go food shopping Friday night? KaRiSsA 4/12/06 16 Families Helping Families ™
If you are opposed to the TSA's decision to put knives back on our airplanes please come in----( HELP) skygirl 12/13/05 17 Families Helping Families ™
Need ur love & support.. My never-ending fiasco Decision towards bottom... HereWeGoAgain 9/30/05 13 Families Helping Families ™