Union vs. non-union

Posted By Message

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Union vs. non-union

I work for the largest health system on LI.

Yesterday someone came around advertising a health fair in our building for ALL employees.

When I went downstairs to check it out, I practically got my ass tossed out of there with a snotty attitude because I "wasn't a union employee and this was for THEM." Several of my coworkers experienced the same.

I always hear how great it is to be part of a union, but what exactly are all the perks? Even asking people I work with, it seems like a lot of it is speculation.

When inquiring about jobs at certain sites, I have been told things like "forget it they're union you'll never get in".

I hear that union jobs pay more and have amazing benefits (I already think mine are pretty good) but what else is the secret? Chat Icon

Posted 5/1/14 5:33 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

SusiBee
. . . . .

Member since 3/09

8268 total posts

Name:
S

Re: Union vs. non-union

DH is union, and I think the biggest "perk" is health insurance for retirees, spouses included. Part of the dues goes towards this, as well as a set deduction from every paycheck. The current negotiation will include spousal coverage for the rest of their life, instead of just the one year upon retirees death.

Pension is another big "perk" although DH contributes a set amount every paycheck towards the fund. There are other benefits, money towards childcare, scholarships, access to counseling, more that I don't know about.

The biggest negative - once the contract expires, there are no wage increases until the next contract is ratified. DH has been withiut a contract for 3 years.

Posted 5/1/14 5:56 AM
 

ourlivesstartnow2012
New Year, New Everything!

Member since 6/12

2689 total posts

Name:

Union vs. non-union

We aren't in the health care system but I am a union family. Our benefits are better then the non-unions out there in our field. We also have more training and free classes that provide more education and special certificates. Union also means safety is provided by contractors and safer jobs (we're in construction).

We have several retirement funds set up for when the time comes. We have full medical and dental, including after retirement. We have our wages increase every year as per the contract. Our union stands behind us if a contractor has let an employee go for the wrong reasons. Also helps with workers comp and disability (we're privately insured). The union also helps with finding work. And if an employee doesn't pay correctly, follow labor laws, behind on benefits, etc, the union steps in.

We also have free lawyers for wills, house closings and purchases, etc. There is more but I think I covered the important things besides our brotherhood and sisterhood. I know if I see a brother or sister and need some help we are always there for each other!

Posted 5/1/14 7:40 AM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: Union vs. non-union

I guess it depends on the union.

DH was NYPD and our healthcare was awesome. Low copays on doctors and drugs, (before he retired I used to be $5 for all drugs, even brand names that were super expensive) no copays on dental, everything covered if you used a dentist who accepted PBA insurance, nothing out of pocket.
And he paid nothing out of his check for those benefits either.
Benefits continue for him and his family after he retires

A pension after 20 years (that has changed now to 25 I think) where he is bringing him pretty much the same to stay home than to work due to tax benefits etc

Free lawyers for house closings, family issues, etc

I am sure there are more that I am missing.

Posted 5/1/14 9:24 AM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Union vs. non-union

Posted by NervousNell

I guess it depends on the union.

DH was NYPD and our healthcare was awesome. Low copays on doctors and drugs, (before he retired I used to be $5 for all drugs, even brand names that were super expensive) no copays on dental, everything covered if you used a dentist who accepted PBA insurance, nothing out of pocket.
And he paid nothing out of his check for those benefits either.
Benefits continue for him and his family after he retires

A pension after 20 years (that has changed now to 25 I think) where he is bringing him pretty much the same to stay home than to work due to tax benefits etc

Free lawyers for house closings, family issues, etc

I am sure there are more that I am missing.




Same except different PD, although things are changing a bit now and he's not near retirement. Also for some reason their dental plan sucked so we use mine.

Posted 5/1/14 9:26 AM
 

blu6385

Member since 5/08

8351 total posts

Name:

Union vs. non-union

DH is in a union and it blows. seriously I don't know why they even have one. I was in a better union when I worked at waldbaums part time then his is. It was good cause we paid like $55 a month for dues and that covered at least health insurance. now we are paying $110 a week for family coverage and union dues and I don't know why. he has no retirement he only has something called a security fund or something like that. no life insurance benefits nothing. they have a cut down his hours and barley now get 40 which I thought they had to get minimally of but the union is no where to be found to fight for them. I asked if he could get out of the union cause I honestly feel they are collecting dues for no reason at all!!

Posted 5/1/14 9:41 AM
 

BriBri2u
L'amore vince sempre

Member since 5/05

9320 total posts

Name:
Mrs. B

Re: Union vs. non-union

Posted by SusiBee

DH is union, and I think the biggest "perk" is health insurance for retirees, spouses included. Part of the dues goes towards this, as well as a set deduction from every paycheck. The current negotiation will include spousal coverage for the rest of their life, instead of just the one year upon retirees death.

Pension is another big "perk" although DH contributes a set amount every paycheck towards the fund. There are other benefits, money towards childcare, scholarships, access to counseling, more that I don't know about.




This is pretty much the same for DH. Except for the spouse coverage and contract parts. He also has a 401k that his company matches.

Negative is that he really won't make that much more salary wise since he is almost at 'scale' (he has another 24 years to go - been in for 21).

Its not that bad of a negative when you consider that we have really great health coverage across the board - medical, dental, vision etc and do not pay a lot for it. So it balances its self out.

Message edited 2014-05-01 10:01:14.987000.

Posted 5/1/14 9:59 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Union vs. non-union

Posted by ourlivesstartnow2012

We aren't in the health care system but I am a union family. Our benefits are better then the non-unions out there in our field. We also have more training and free classes that provide more education and special certificates. Union also means safety is provided by contractors and safer jobs (we're in construction).

We have several retirement funds set up for when the time comes. We have full medical and dental, including after retirement. We have our wages increase every year as per the contract. Our union stands behind us if a contractor has let an employee go for the wrong reasons. Also helps with workers comp and disability (we're privately insured). The union also helps with finding work. And if an employee doesn't pay correctly, follow labor laws, behind on benefits, etc, the union steps in.

We also have free lawyers for wills, house closings and purchases, etc. There is more but I think I covered the important things besides our brotherhood and sisterhood. I know if I see a brother or sister and need some help we are always there for each other!



Pretty much my answer but I'll add a bit more.

Health insurance is free.
Amazing Rx coverage.
Healthcare reimbursement for uncovered expenses.- my company has similar benefits.
Tuition is non taxable (camps/daycare was included) - my company has similar benefits.
Kids sleepaway camp for 2 weeks is cost $240.

For me the most important is the job safety.

When we had work done in our building, people were joking about union guys on coffee breaks but I can tell you those guys are on their feet all day. My co-workers are yammering in the lunch room & surfing the internet plus we have 6 elevators we can take downstairs. The construction workers in the building have 2 freight elevators that are packed to the gills because every guy has to take a break at the same time.

Outside of construction, I think due process is the biggest advantage. Non-union, I can fire someone tomorrow & they are on their own getting another job, they can attempt to sue the company but unless I fired them for an illegal reason (race, religion, sex, etc) we are employment at will. If we had a union here, I would need to show cause, there is a process I'd need to follow & if it's a large enough union, that person can go to another job. If my cause is enough, then yes they can be fired. Being in a union doesn't mean you can suck at your job & no one can do anything.

Even better, when a company lays off a staff, doesn't hire anyone else & asks you to pick up the slack & work extra hours with no extra pay or a small bonus (which happened frequently in the past years at numerous companies), the employee either sucks it up or they can look somewhere else- not happening if they are union. They have rules they need to follow.

I think the biggest issue I see with unions is PR. They are vilified by corporations any chance they get. If you really want to see the advantages of a union, google Walmart. That's a perfect example of how a company with a lot of power over their employees & lots of money for government lobbying will take advantage of their staff any chance they get.

Biggest negative I see: Union reps selling out when negotiating contracts & benefits are eroding.

Message edited 2014-05-01 10:18:41.093000.

Posted 5/1/14 10:17 AM
 

PhyllisNJoe
My Box Is Broken

Member since 6/11

9145 total posts

Name:
Phyllis

Re: Union vs. non-union

Were you not given the option to be part of the union? Or did you choose not to and now wondering if you should have?

I never worked for a company with a union but if I did, I would have joined in a heartbeat. They are there for you. And usually the benefits of being in a union are great.

Posted 5/1/14 10:43 AM
 

tourist

Member since 5/05

10425 total posts

Name:

Re: Union vs. non-union

My husband also works for a large hospital system & is non-union.

Most of their departments are non-union ( I think even the nurses.)

They had a union come around a couple of years ago, but in his case there weren't really any benefits. This particular union applied to certain departments, and his was one of them, but it wasn't really related to the other departments.

His particular issue was that the union's retirement plan wasn't as good as the hospital's.

There wasn't really a individual choice to join or not--there was going to be a vote, but I don't think it even got that far, but if the vote passed, all of the employees in the effected departments (even if his entire department voted no) would have to join the union.

Since the union advocates for a large number of people in the same field, employed by different hospitals, it will be beneficial for some & not others.

I think most large hospitals have good benefits anyway, but I think unions can be useful with things like maximum hours worked without a break & things like that for shift employees (like nurses.)

Posted 5/1/14 11:24 AM
 

Cheeks24
Living a dream

Member since 1/08

8589 total posts

Name:
Cheeks

Union vs. non-union

DH is union and his benefits are really good. However there have been changes for new employees being hired that aren't as good.

Posted 5/1/14 11:26 AM
 

blue11
LIF Adult

Member since 2/11

1706 total posts

Name:
kat

Union vs. non-union

I don't work for a union, but from what I see and hear (and I'm sure it depends on the union) are pension, union negotiated salary increases and it is VERY hard to fire a union employee.

Posted 5/1/14 12:27 PM
 

lynnd126
LIF Adult

Member since 3/11

2630 total posts

Name:

Union vs. non-union

I don't see too many perks with the union you're referring to. One big negative is that the system doesn't match 401 or contribute to that cash balance plan if you're in it.

Posted 5/1/14 12:34 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Union vs. non-union

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Were you not given the option to be part of the union? Or did you choose not to and now wondering if you should have?

I never worked for a company with a union but if I did, I would have joined in a heartbeat. They are there for you. And usually the benefits of being in a union are great.




Only certain parts of the health care system are unionized. For example, I believe all of LIJ is but NSUH is not.

We were a free standing program not affiliated with the health system at all at one point.

You can't pick if you want to be a part of it.

I think the attitude is what annoyed me more than anything.

Chat Icon

Posted 5/1/14 2:19 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Union vs. non-union

Posted by lynnd126

I don't see too many perks with the union you're referring to. One big negative is that the system doesn't match 401 or contribute to that cash balance plan if you're in it.



My coworker told me that we're probably better off where we are because you have to start over from scratch if you go to one of the unionized programs anyway.

Posted 5/1/14 2:20 PM
 

JenMarie
One day at a time

Member since 11/07

7397 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Union vs. non-union

DH is union. Healthcare and retirement benefits are definitely great. When we bought our house there was a program that gave us $500 back in the form of a gift card and it offers us protection in case of a furlough. And like someone else said, it's difficult to fire a union employee. Someone at DHs company was fired. I thought rightfully so. The union fought it and he was brought back. Contracted salary increases are a plus too.

Posted 5/1/14 2:47 PM