Transitioning from formula to milk...not going well...HELP!

Posted By Message

NYchic
Girl & boy

Member since 6/09

2357 total posts

Name:

Transitioning from formula to milk...not going well...HELP!

DD turned 1 last week. We just had her checkup and ped said there is no need to do the mix of part formula/part milk unless DD doesn't take to the milk. So I first tried straight up milk...she drank an ounce and was done...that was in a bottle. I tried giving more with her breakfast in her sippy cup and she just sipped it - not even an ounce. I got her to drink maybe 2-3 more oz over the course the of the day but that was it. She used to drink 3 8oz bottles of formula.
I decided last night to do part formula, part milk - she wouldn't drink it at first...then after going to a more quiet room and really calming her down I got her to drink maybe 4 oz...she usually guzzles her 8oz of formula before bed.
Do I just need to give it time?
I feel bad she's not taking to it. I will continue to mix a little formula hoping she'll take to it. Not sure if it's the sudden cold temperature she doesn't like.
My issue yesterday was she only sipped her water too - I just didn't feel she took in enough fluids which is my main concern.

Any tips are appreciated.
I know it was only 1 day so I do need to give it time - but this morning she didn't even take an ounce...she took a sip and pushed it away so fast.

TIA!

ETA: Since yesterday with the start of milk, she cries when she "pushes" like she is in so much pain. Could the milk be constipating her? I feel she hasn't consumed enough of it yet to be affecting her poops. But yesterday and today I could see she was really struggling and while I've seen her push hard before - she's never ever cried when "going". Yesterday and today she cried out and I could see she was in pain.

Message edited 2011-06-29 14:54:05.787000.

Posted 6/29/11 12:07 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

TimmysMom
LIF Infant

Member since 1/11

298 total posts

Name:
Tara

Re: Transitioning from formula to milk...not going well...HELP!

All I can offer is to just keep trying. DS took to the milk with no issue. But the LO that I watch wasn't so easy. I offered it to her at both bfast and lunch every day. I also supplimented with water in between. eventually after a week or so she was drinking about 6-7oz total a day with me.

Also, the ped had told us that as long as they were getting the calcium from somewhere, milk didn't have to be the primary source. DS eats cheese, yogurt....

Does your LO take a bottle 3x a day still? Maybe just try cutting back on the bottles during the day? DS only gets a bottle at night now and last night was his first "Milk Only" bottle. I just warmed it a little like I did when I gave him the formula bottle and he sucked it down like a champ.

Posted 6/29/11 12:14 PM
 

NYchic
Girl & boy

Member since 6/09

2357 total posts

Name:

Re: Transitioning from formula to milk...not going well...HELP!

thanks...
I just started on milk yesterday so prior to yesterday - yes she was still taking her 3 formula bottles from bottles 3x a day. Now unsure if she's just not into the bottle and should be trying milk from a cup...or if it's the milk that's the issue and she's just not into.
So I'm trying both - keep offering her both. She doesn't seem into milk from either right now.
But again it's just day 1 so I'm not sure...I have to give it time I guess.

I'm just concered about her fluid intake...I don't think she's getting enough.
I read a post yesterday about how much does your 1 yr old drink and some people were saying 20oz of milk and 20 oz of water...I'm lucky if my DD sips 4 oz of water a day. I was in shock at how much other kids her age are consuming in terms of fluid.

I will keep trying though...thanks.
Also bumping for more...there has to be more people out there who had issues transitioning???

Posted 6/29/11 2:52 PM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: Transitioning from formula to milk...not going well...HELP!

I am doing the transition slow- it has to reason that the milk will taste MUCH different than the formula- just the smell alone is a whole other world.

I did one ounce one week, 2 the next, etc.
Then she got bad diaherra from it so I slowed it down.

We are up to 4 ounces a bottle and 2 oz formula and she is 1 year old.

I say , dont' do cold turkey- it's way too much of a shock on the digestive system too- keep up the slow transition...

Message edited 2011-06-29 15:03:35.520000.

Posted 6/29/11 2:57 PM
 

BAM 2009
I am who I am!!!

Member since 5/09

6081 total posts

Name:

Re: Transitioning from formula to milk...not going well...HELP!

We started with 1oz of milk and the rest formula. Every 3-4 days I added another ounce of milk until it was all milk.. DS had a milk protein allergy and we wanted to start slow. He got really constipated from the milk... I had to give him 100% pear juice every other day to help him go... He is ok now with it. But I had to cut back on all other dairy products to keep him from getting backed up.

Posted 6/29/11 2:59 PM
 

NYchic
Girl & boy

Member since 6/09

2357 total posts

Name:

Re: Transitioning from formula to milk...not going well...HELP!

Posted by NervousNell

I am doing the transition slow- it has to reason that the milk will taste MUCH different than the formula- just the smell alone is a whole other world.

I did one ounce one week, 2 the next, etc.
Then she got bad diaherra from it so I slowed it down.

We are up to 4 ounces a bottle and 2 oz formula and she is 1 year old.

I say , dont' do cold turkey- keep up the slow transition...



thanks...this makes sense. my ped just made it sound like there would be no issue and go for it cold turkey...she said unless i had lots of formula leftover i wanted to use up. i think i'll start doing this...so i just make the formula same as before with the water - then just add milk? that simple?
thanks! also does your DD still take it from a bottle?

Posted 6/29/11 3:04 PM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: Transitioning from formula to milk...not going well...HELP!

Posted by NYchic

Posted by NervousNell

I am doing the transition slow- it has to reason that the milk will taste MUCH different than the formula- just the smell alone is a whole other world.

I did one ounce one week, 2 the next, etc.
Then she got bad diaherra from it so I slowed it down.

We are up to 4 ounces a bottle and 2 oz formula and she is 1 year old.

I say , dont' do cold turkey- keep up the slow transition...



thanks...this makes sense. my ped just made it sound like there would be no issue and go for it cold turkey...she said unless i had lots of formula leftover i wanted to use up. i think i'll start doing this...so i just make the formula same as before with the water - then just add milk? that simple?
thanks! also does your DD still take it from a bottle?



Yeah. The peds say that, but in reality, I don't care for it.
Yes, you make the formula the same.
I poured an ounce of milk in the bottle and topped the rest with prepared formula.
Then 2 ounces milke the next week, etc

And yes, she still does bottles. I don't care.
She takes water from a sippy, knows full well how to use it, but wont' drink formula or milk from it.
So IMO it's better to have her get her milk and nutrients from a bottle than not at all just to follow some "rule"


Posted 6/29/11 3:06 PM
 

NYchic
Girl & boy

Member since 6/09

2357 total posts

Name:

Re: Transitioning from formula to milk...not going well...HELP!

Posted by NervousNell

Yeah. The peds say that, but in reality, I don't care for it.
Yes, you make the formula the same.
I poured an ounce of milk in the bottle and topped the rest with prepared formula.
Then 2 ounces milke the next week, etc

And yes, she still does bottles. I don't care.
She takes water from a sippy, knows full well how to use it, but wont' drink formula or milk from it.
So IMO it's better to have her get her milk and nutrients from a bottle than not at all just to follow some "rule"




agree 100% on the bottle vs sippy...i was just unsure if it's the bottle she's lost interest in...but it's got to be the milk since that's the new thing. I'll try mixing and from a bottle since that's what she's used to - thanks again!!!
also...funny your DD got the runs...mine is crying and trying so hard and pushes out a hard log! I wish she'd loosen up a bit! the milk only seems to have made it worse.

Posted 6/29/11 3:12 PM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: Transitioning from formula to milk...not going well...HELP!

Posted by NYchic

Posted by NervousNell

Yeah. The peds say that, but in reality, I don't care for it.
Yes, you make the formula the same.
I poured an ounce of milk in the bottle and topped the rest with prepared formula.
Then 2 ounces milke the next week, etc

And yes, she still does bottles. I don't care.
She takes water from a sippy, knows full well how to use it, but wont' drink formula or milk from it.
So IMO it's better to have her get her milk and nutrients from a bottle than not at all just to follow some "rule"




agree 100% on the bottle vs sippy...i was just unsure if it's the bottle she's lost interest in...but it's got to be the milk since that's the new thing. I'll try mixing and from a bottle since that's what she's used to - thanks again!!!
also...funny your DD got the runs...mine is crying and trying so hard and pushes out a hard log! I wish she'd loosen up a bit! the milk only seems to have made it worse.



You know, it started out as the runs and now it is definitely harder and more pebble like- but no tears so far!
I swear this milk does a NUMBER on them!

Posted 6/29/11 3:15 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Transitioning to milk soon. Question for those who warmed DC's formula LittleBlueBug 10/13/10 8 Parenting
Transitioning From Breast Milk to Formula and Need Help... Gina674 7/29/09 2 Parenting
Soy Formula - what happens at 1 yr when transitioning to milk? jambalady 4/6/09 4 Parenting
Working on transitioning DD from formula to whole milk and she seems to be allergic.... johnsae 4/30/08 4 Parenting
Transitioning from powder formula to milk? Kissy331 7/16/10 6 Parenting
questions about transitioning from formula to milk headoverheels 8/3/09 5 Parenting