To HSG or not to HSG

Before TTC again, would you guys get an HSG on your remaining tube if you only had one tube left?

I just had an ectopic where my right tube was removed, so I only have my left tube remaining. My doctor said my left tube looked normal during the laparscopy, but she didn't do an HSG at that time. She said if I want one she can do it in 3 weeks. I hear the procedure hurts and I'm a little scared. Is it worth doing it even if my remaining tube looked ok during the laparascopy? If I get pregnant again they will monitor me oh so closely anyway. What do you think?

TIA

ETA: I definitely do not mean to sound like a little bit of pain would stop me from doing something to help us conceive and have a healthy pregnancy. It is the timing of everything right now. I've just had an extremely painful surgery & recovery (resulting in likely decreased chances of fertility of course - and the end of a pregnancy which we had been so happy and excited about) and the idea of having more go on with those parts turns my stomach right now - however, if there is a definite benefit and increase to my fertility, it is worth it to me. Maybe it is just the timing and I need a few weeks off. I only had the tube removed 7 days ago. Thanks for the insight and info!

Message edited 8/8/2008 4:10:38 PM.

Re: To HSG or not to HSG

I think it is worth it. if you have a problem with your other tube, you are going to have issues getting pregnant.

I had an HSG and it didn't hurt at all.

Re: To HSG or not to HSG

I would have it done. Although some people have found it painful, most only have minor discomfort.
Whatever it is, it only lasts for a few moments and afterwards you will know for sure what is going on.
If the remaining tube is blocked, you will have to opt for IVF. But, if it isn't you can try again naturally. And the HSG can improve your chances of getting PG naturally.
My friend had an ectopic, had an HSG after to check the remaining tube and was PG three weeks later.

Re: To HSG or not to HSG

Re: To HSG or not to HSG

I would have it done. I lost my right tube to a ruptured ectopic, but I had previously had an ectopic in the left tube. During the surgery to remove the ruptured tube my dr. said that the left tube (which had also had lap surgery to remove the ectopic) looked o.k., however he recommended an HSG to make sure.

I did the HSG, which for me was quite painful, and discovered that the left tube was actually blocked. My doctor predicted that if I did manage to get pg naturally, it would likely be another ectopic.

We (after a year of soul searching and me getting emotionally ready and brave enough to start) chose to do IVF - really our only option. Before the IVF I had my left tube and whatever was left of my right tube removed on the advice of my RE.

I am now 12 weeks pregnant. I would definitely recommend doing the HSG to know for sure if there are any blockages - it's worth it to know, IMO.

Re: To HSG or not to HSG

I am so sorry you went through this. It's an absolute nightmare!

My situation isn't all to different from Lee's.

I suffered an ectopic in January. My left tube was removed. You know, it's funny my OBGYN said the Methotrexate worked on all of her patient's except me. I know more people that had to have the surgery bc the shot didn't work!

I had the HSG in March. You will need to wait until you get AF and have the test done between days 5-9 of your cycle. It was quite painful for me but every woman is different. There are many women that felt nothing more than mild discomfort. My remaining tube was/is open. Unfortunately, the tube isn't working properly. We are making to move to IVF next month.

The HSG will let your doctor know if you have any blockages but it can't determine the tubes ability to act as the conduit between your ovary and uterus as it's supposed to. This is my situation.

Short answer, I would recommend the HSG. It at the very least will let your doctor know if there is an actual blockage or not. It's a good start.

Are you seeing an OBGYN or have you moved on to a infertility specialist/RE?

I know all to well what you went through. Feel free to FM any time

Message edited 8/8/2008 6:20:56 PM.

Re: To HSG or not to HSG

Posted by MAYBEPREGERS

I am so sorry you went through this. It's an absolute nightmare!

My situation isn't all to different from Lee's.

I suffered an ectopic in January. My left tube was removed. You know, it's funny my OBGYN said the Methotrexate worked on all of her patient's except me. I know more people that had to have the surgery bc the shot didn't work!

I had the HSG in March. You will need to wait until you get AF and have the test done between days 5-9 of your cycle. It was quite painful for me but every woman is different. There are many women that felt nothing more than mild discomfort. My remaining tube was/is open. Unfortunately, the tube isn't working properly. We are making to move to IVF next month.

The HSG will let your doctor know if you have any blockages but it can't determine the tubes ability to act as the conduit between your ovary and uterus as it's supposed to. This is my situation.

Short answer, I would recommend the HSG. It at the very least will let your doctor know if there is an actual blockage or not. It's a good start.

Are you seeing an OBGYN or have you moved on to a infertility specialist/RE?

I know all to well what you went through. Feel free to FM any time

Re: To HSG or not to HSG

I would do it. If your only tube is blocked you have to know that before your next step.

I had an HSG. It was a little uncomfortable for about a minute but that was about it.

Good Luck!