time outs??

Posted By Message

krislee316
LIF Adolescent

Member since 8/09

531 total posts

Name:
Kristy

time outs??

At what age do you start them DD is 14 months old is it too soon? Will she even get it at this age?

Posted 6/30/11 7:44 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

mylove
LIF Zygote

Member since 10/10

33 total posts

Name:

Re: time outs??

I'd like to know this as well..

Posted 6/30/11 7:55 PM
 

Ever-After
Goals w/o plans r just wishes

Member since 6/09

2585 total posts

Name:
C

Re: time outs??

It depends on the child. This past summer I helped out in the Toddler Room at my preschool and the teacher would put the kids in timeout. Sometimes if they were throwing fits or purposely stealing toys, hitting, etc she would have them sit away from the other children to cool down. I saw that the kids did respond to this. I mean, they hated having to sit and then would behave themselves when they got out of it. Just the 'threat' of time out would sometimes make them chill. That room ranged from ages 1 to 2 1/2. I don't know EXACTLY how old the children were that she had sit down, but I'm guessing only the ones old enough to understand, otherwise it's a useless technique.

Message edited 2011-06-30 20:04:30.077000.

Posted 6/30/11 8:03 PM
 

NYchic
Girl & boy

Member since 6/09

2357 total posts

Name:

Re: time outs??

I have a 12 mo old and she would definitely NOT understand a time out or understand to sit somewhere and not move if i told her to. She barely understands NO when she goes to touch an outlet plug. She just imitates me and holds up her finger and repeats my "no, no, no".....
So now I'm curious to hear what age people start time outs too...I def. think 14 mos is too young for them to understand.

Posted 6/30/11 9:41 PM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: time outs??

I'm pretty sure DS would understand them at 14m, but I found other ways of disciplining that are much easier and happier.

Posted 6/30/11 9:55 PM
 

NYchic
Girl & boy

Member since 6/09

2357 total posts

Name:

Re: time outs??

Posted by mommyIam

I'm pretty sure DS would understand them at 14m, but I found other ways of disciplining that are much easier and happier.



please share the easier and happier ways!

my DD is 12 mos and honestly I can't imagine her doing anything that would require a time out...she has no siblings to fight with though....what are 12-14 mo olds doing that need a time out? Just curious. My DD just does things that are dangerous for her - like go near the outlets that all have outlet covers on but I tell her no b/c I want her to know they are dangerous. But nothing that needs actual reprimanding. Am I lucky I don't have this problem?

Posted 6/30/11 10:01 PM
 

krislee316
LIF Adolescent

Member since 8/09

531 total posts

Name:
Kristy

Re: time outs??

Posted by mommyIam

I'm pretty sure DS would understand them at 14m, but I found other ways of disciplining that are much easier and happier.



Please do share

Posted 6/30/11 10:02 PM
 

thisisme
LIF Adolescent

Member since 3/06

560 total posts

Name:
ME

Re: time outs??

At 14 months, my DD most DEFINITELY understood the concept of a time out. At 13 months now, my DS absolutely has no clue and is obliviousChat Icon
So it totally depends on the child.
I distract my son with other things to change his behavior. Or, I will give him a "time out" by ignoring him or putting him down if I was holding him.

Posted 6/30/11 10:02 PM
 

krislee316
LIF Adolescent

Member since 8/09

531 total posts

Name:
Kristy

Re: time outs??

Posted by NYchic

Posted by mommyIam

I'm pretty sure DS would understand them at 14m, but I found other ways of disciplining that are much easier and happier.



please share the easier and happier ways!

what are 12-14 mo olds doing that need a time out? Just curious.



My DD is the sweetest litttle angel until she doesnt get her way then she screams points her finger at me( which I think is adorable and cant help but laugh to myself) she also gets so mad that she will go over to the couch or whatever is near by and bite it out of anger and if I/DH am holding her she will hit us.

Posted 6/30/11 10:05 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: time outs??

for us it was between 11m and 14m


ETA: time out in our house was always danger related at first.. so it became lesson of right and wrong. No touching the electrical wires. No going into the bathroom. NO HITTING! It moved into actual discipline, no you will not get your way to sit and scream, you're being a brat, welcome to time out. No I wouldn't call her a brat. She got put in timeout for throwing food or just refusing to cooperate. *shrug* worked for us, it works for her.

That said she gets away with murder. I let her do whatever as long as she's safe, hasn't been told not to (can't blame her if she didn't know) and isn't purposely looking for time out because I SWEAR she did stuff just to GET into time out.

As she got older, timeouts were less and less. Just the threat of timeout was enough. However, I NEVER threaten timeout without following through, its this or time out, your choice. If she doesn't choose quickly its time out. So she's learned to be fast in reply.

I can say that I haven't given AJ time out in months. Sure she screams, gets outrageous but mostly takes herself to her room to pout or play without a word from me. If she gets toddler annoying well that's different not even timeout helps with that!!!

But biggies in my house with NO choice just immediate time out

- Hitting
- Kicking
- Biting (she bit my butt once and I screamed time out and she's NEVER done it again)
- Hurting

Everything else is discussed first with options.

Message edited 2011-07-01 01:19:52.407000.

Posted 6/30/11 10:27 PM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: time outs??

I can't sleep Chat Icon

okay, I talk about this all the time, I feel like it gets a lot of eye rolling, and I totally understand why. I was doing a lot of eye rolling until I just decided to try it. And when I did, I was in awe how easy and simple and gentle discipline can be.

DS is a wild tornado with strong body and mind of evil genius and yet we coexits quite merrily. He is a climber so he likes to climb up to the kitchen table and try to get to the chandelier (which is very pretty and sparkly in the morning sunlight and I get it that its irresistible). He realized it was too far, he figured out to move the table and chairs (cheap Ikea crap) Chat Icon

I don't say no, unless he is in immediate danger.

I block him and tell him "I will not let you climb up here".

If he actually got up there, if hes not in immediate danger, I stop and think about why he would even do it. What is he gaining from doing it? I realized he needs a place to practice his skills. I say "You are such a good climber, I love that your so strong and brave, but I can't let you climb up there its dangerous you can get hurt" I show him something else he can climb instead.

After a couple of days, he doesn't bother climbing up to the kitchen table. I stacked up some heavy boxes and gave him a safe area to climb.

Its just one example, but in general, I don't believe he needs to be really disciplined because his sense of what is good and bad is confused. He doesn't quite get the why, and he doesn't know how to tell me he needs my attention in a civil way.

I believe his bad actions are a result of his feeling injustice in this world. He's disabled, lost, confused, can't express himself fully, and small. Its a wonder toddlers aren't crazier to me. I feel like putting him in a time out would just teach him to bottle up feelings and ignore emotions. I want him to know that I understand what he's going through and that I will give him solutions for dealing with it, in a way that I feel is civil and just and he has no option than to accept it, if he doesn't there are consequences, he's still small enough for me to physically move him away or block him, but he has to know the reason "danger" is clearly understood. "I don't want you to" is less so and takes a bit more insistence, but I can just say "I don't want you to do it, and I wont let you" and he backs off.


Anything I say to him, I say at his eye level. I am slow and demand to be heard. We have been "disciplining" him since 8m. At 8m I was considering time outs with my little evil genius. I'm so grateful to have found another way, and I really hope it keeps working for us.

I learned a lot of what I know from Janet Lansbury, she wrote no books or sells anything, she just writes a parenting blog.

Here are some relevant articles:

Toddler Testing - 3 Steps to End the Nightmare

Free as a Dog - Parenting with Calm Control

Baby Discipline - Person to Person

Toddler Discipline without Shame

Message edited 2011-07-01 00:47:03.833000.

Posted 7/1/11 12:16 AM
 

BeachMom
Love my 4 kiddos!

Member since 11/08

8346 total posts

Name:
Kristie

Re: time outs??

We started time outs around 13-14 months. it's really only less than a minute to remove them from the situation and let them know that what they're doing is not appropriate.

Posted 7/1/11 9:09 AM
 

NYchic
Girl & boy

Member since 6/09

2357 total posts

Name:

Re: time outs??

Posted by mommyIam

I can't sleep Chat Icon

okay, I talk about this all the time, I feel like it gets a lot of eye rolling, and I totally understand why. I was doing a lot of eye rolling until I just decided to try it. And when I did, I was in awe how easy and simple and gentle discipline can be.

DS is a wild tornado with strong body and mind of evil genius and yet we coexits quite merrily. He is a climber so he likes to climb up to the kitchen table and try to get to the chandelier (which is very pretty and sparkly in the morning sunlight and I get it that its irresistible). He realized it was too far, he figured out to move the table and chairs (cheap Ikea crap) Chat Icon

I don't say no, unless he is in immediate danger.

I block him and tell him "I will not let you climb up here".

If he actually got up there, if hes not in immediate danger, I stop and think about why he would even do it. What is he gaining from doing it? I realized he needs a place to practice his skills. I say "You are such a good climber, I love that your so strong and brave, but I can't let you climb up there its dangerous you can get hurt" I show him something else he can climb instead.

After a couple of days, he doesn't bother climbing up to the kitchen table. I stacked up some heavy boxes and gave him a safe area to climb.

Its just one example, but in general, I don't believe he needs to be really disciplined because his sense of what is good and bad is confused. He doesn't quite get the why, and he doesn't know how to tell me he needs my attention in a civil way.

I believe his bad actions are a result of his feeling injustice in this world. He's disabled, lost, confused, can't express himself fully, and small. Its a wonder toddlers aren't crazier to me. I feel like putting him in a time out would just teach him to bottle up feelings and ignore emotions. I want him to know that I understand what he's going through and that I will give him solutions for dealing with it, in a way that I feel is civil and just and he has no option than to accept it, if he doesn't there are consequences, he's still small enough for me to physically move him away or block him, but he has to know the reason "danger" is clearly understood. "I don't want you to" is less so and takes a bit more insistence, but I can just say "I don't want you to do it, and I wont let you" and he backs off.


Anything I say to him, I say at his eye level. I am slow and demand to be heard. We have been "disciplining" him since 8m. At 8m I was considering time outs with my little evil genius. I'm so grateful to have found another way, and I really hope it keeps working for us.

I learned a lot of what I know from Janet Lansbury, she wrote no books or sells anything, she just writes a parenting blog.

Here are some relevant articles:

Toddler Testing - 3 Steps to End the Nightmare

Free as a Dog - Parenting with Calm Control

Baby Discipline - Person to Person

Toddler Discipline without Shame



THanks - notebooking this for when I need it. I am almost embarassed to say it but DD is 12 mos and a little angel. I honestly can't imagine having to give her a time out for anything...she just doesn't do anything wrong or bad yet. I also really don't think she'd understand just yet me reasoning with her or giving her a time out...she would definitely not understand a time out. She does understand no I think...but would not ever just sit somewhere for a time out i I told her to - she absolutely would not comprehend that just yet.
I guess every child really is different.

Posted 7/1/11 11:52 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Discipline with a 3 yr. old-time outs not working MrsH 4/14/11 6 Parenting
what is a good age to start introducing time outs to a toddler?( and partial vent at MIL!!) hunnybunnyxoxo 12/22/10 21 Parenting
I need help. How do you discipline/do time outs with a 15m old? Bridex100 7/14/10 2 Parenting
If time outs arent effective what else can I do? eddiesmommy 11/18/09 8 Parenting
At what age do/did you start giving time outs? KartveliT 2/10/09 8 Parenting
Please help me. Time outs.... BaroqueMama 1/15/08 11 Parenting