Thoughts on a family tradition

Posted By Message

EricaAlt
LIF Adult

Member since 7/08

22665 total posts

Name:
Erica

Thoughts on a family tradition

Sorry, this is gonna be a little long

My MIL is one of three sisters. She's the youngest. The oldest Brenda has 3 daughters, then Linda has a boy and girl and my MIL has a girl and boy
Hanukkah tradition for years was all the kids get gifts so when the oldest daughter of Brenda turned 18 she stopped getting. The three daughters of Brenda's got married and each had two kids so then it went to everyone buying Hanukkah gifts for all Brenda's grandchildren. My DH, SIL, and the kids of Aunt Linda gave gifts to them. This was the tradition for years. My DH was buying em stuff since college b.c the oldest is 17 now.
Hope you're still following.
Ok, so all the kids of the three girls got gifts for years from everyone.
We came with tons of toys in the cars and left empty while they had e opposite. Came with garbage bags to bring home all the stuff.
DH and his cousin Shawn (aunt Linda's son) got married. First Linda's son and had a girl 4 years ago so the three girls just started bringing the gifts. Then I had Mason two years ago around the same time Shawn had his son.
Well, over the recent holidays when we were all together the three girls decided it's getting too much and we should stop giving gifts.
I totally understand b.c it was getting out of control. I told this to DH for years we're gonna get screwed. I just had a baby in july so pretty much he won't get anything. My SIL is engaged and ****** b.c when she has kids they wont get anything.
Honestly, I'm ok with it, but I think it got stupid. Suddenly the three girls have to buy and they want it to end. Seems like my MIL and her sisters are having issues now. My mil and aunt Linda aren't happy whole Brenda is fine with it.
If you made it this far then thanks for listening.
Thoughts?
Mind you... Forgot to add one of Brenda's daughters has lost her job and her DH too so they have no money. It started b.c they said they weren't coming b.c they can't afford to buy.

Posted 10/4/11 11:35 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Thoughts on a family tradition

Buying gifts should NEVER cause resentment, they should be given because you want to and love the recipients.

I think that your MIL and her sisters had their hearts in the right place when they came up with the gifts-for-kids-only rule but they didn't really think through to the future when there would be grandkids coming at all stages of life.

My opinion is to leave the gift-giving decisions to you and your DH only. Give to whomever you want Chat Icon Allowing others to dictate what you do will only make you resentful later! But you also need to expect that those who have no money or are already resentful may not buy gifts for your kids and you've got to be okay with that Chat Icon

Posted 10/4/11 11:41 AM
 

PoppySeed
LIF Infant

Member since 10/09

358 total posts

Name:

Re: Thoughts on a family tradition

In my family we buy gifts as a family for each of the kids. So each kid would get a gift from Aunt Brenda & her family and one gift from Aunt Agnes & her family. It makes it a LOT easier. Like your family, it's only for the kids. So there's 8 kids now, but since it's split between a bunch of people and you're not buying for your own kids or nieces & nephews, it comes out to the equivalent of buying one gift. I think there's even a price limit (I think around $20 for each gift) so things don't get out of hand.

Posted 10/4/11 11:50 AM
 

Mkr09
.....

Member since 5/05

7550 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Thoughts on a family tradition

What we started doing in my family is to do a grab bag. What if you guys put in the names of all the kids under 18 in a grab bag? Say you have 2 kids so you pick 2 names, Brenda's daughters each have 2 kids so they pick 2 names. That way everyone still gets a gift to open, but it's not out of control.

Posted 10/4/11 11:50 AM
 

EricaAlt
LIF Adult

Member since 7/08

22665 total posts

Name:
Erica

Re: Thoughts on a family tradition

Thanks! I totally agree. It's different b.c I'm newer in the family so I guess everyone is upset about the tradition changing.
I also said I'm fine with my boys not getting stuff. They're second cousins. While it's nice they're so close and all I still have 5 of my own nieces and nephews to get for and including my own kids. I said we should give to charity instead of all these toys. Most of them I give away anyway. It's too much

Thanks. I'm leaving it to my mil and her sisters now to figured it out

Posted 10/4/11 11:51 AM
 

Eireann
Two ladies and a gentleman!

Member since 5/05

12165 total posts

Name:

Re: Thoughts on a family tradition

I guess we had a similar situation through the years in our family...my dad being the youngest of five sons, then my own children being among the youngest of their generations (my son being the absolute youngest--for now).

First, the past is the past. It doesn't bother me that older cousins may have gotten more gifts, etc. It was getting out of hand. In our family, we always had an adult Secret Santa (I know you're Jewish, but you can do the equivalent, I guess...) where one adult buys for one adult. Now with aaaaallll of the little kids, we also do a kid Secret Santa. So, I pull out three kids' names from the hat since I have three kids myself and so on...

Last year was the first year of the kids' gift exchange and it went great! While my DC I guess will get less gifts in the long run that's fine with me (less I have to buy too!)

Posted 10/4/11 11:54 AM
 

jlk51496
Mom of 3 - YIKES! =)

Member since 10/09

6758 total posts

Name:
Katie

Re: Thoughts on a family tradition

def sounds like it is time for a grab bagso every child walks out with ONE gift!

That is what we do/did in our family!

Posted 10/4/11 12:23 PM
 

KrisT
Two Boys for Me!!

Member since 1/07

5213 total posts

Name:
Kristin

Re: Thoughts on a family tradition

I agree with the others and think you should do a Secret Santa (well not Santa!) or a grab bag.

Posted 10/4/11 12:50 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
thoughts? parents using family members address maybesoon 1/26/11 23 Parenting
Thoughts? Family/Bat Mitzvah/Invite related lipglossjunky73 2/12/09 11 Parenting
X POST: prayers/good thoughts for DHs family please ml110 11/24/08 0 Prayers
Can you keep my family in your thoughts tomorrow, please?UPDATE 7/11 BaroqueMama 7/9/08 42 Families Helping Families ™
Repost from families...Just keep my family in your thoughts beautyq115 7/8/08 18 TTC
Thoughts about telling our family the big news!!! MommaToBe 6/8/08 9 Pregnancy