thoughts?

Posted By Message

rosalie
LIF Infant

Member since 5/10

309 total posts

Name:
rosalie

thoughts?

I feel bad for the girl, but $20mil of taxpayer money?

http://www.aolnews.com/nation/article/california-oks-20m-for-jaycee-dugards-kidnap-suffering/19539059

(July 1) -- California lawmakers have approved a $20 million settlement for the family of Jaycee Dugard, who was kidnapped in 1991 as an 11-year-old girl and held prisoner in a backyard for almost two decades.

Authorities say Dugard was held captive by a convicted rapist named Phillip Garrido, who fathered two children with her. Though parole officers had been supervising Garrido since 1999, they failed to discover Dugard at his home.

Dugard and her family filed claims against the state in February, charging negligence on the part of the Corrections Department. The family is seeking psychological, physical and emotional damages.

With only one senator opposed and a unanimous vote in the Assembly, lawmakers today approved the award to Dugard's family.

"We've got to be much more prudent in terms of how we provide oversight for released prisoners in the state of California," Assemblyman Ted Gaines told The Associated Press.

Garrido and his wife, Nancy, have pleaded not guilty to kidnapping and raping Dugard. They are accused of snatching her from outside her South Lake Tahoe home in 1991, when she was just 11.

Dugard, now 30, didn't resurface until August of last year. That's when authorities realized that the woman named "Allisa" who had accompanied Garrido to a meeting with his parole officer was, in fact, the missing girl.

The state Department of Justice had recommended that lawmakers agree to the Dugard family's claim. A legislative analysis of the bill warned that if it went to trial, the damages the state might face could be "extremely high," The Los Angeles Times reported.

The analysis noted that the Dugard case "had a unique and tragic character," and that authorities "missed opportunities to identify" Dugard while she was being held prisoner.

The $20 million, part of a routine "claims bill," will compensate Dugard and her two children for counseling and for the education that Dugard missed out on, The Sacramento Bee reported.

"Jaycee and her children, now 13 and 16, are now living in seclusion and will need many years of therapy, education and health care," Assemblyman Felipe Fuentes told the AP.

The settlement will come out of the state's general fund, which pays most government expenses. California, which is facing a $19 billion deficit, is entering the fiscal year without a budget, the AP noted.

Posted 7/2/10 10:46 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Cheeks24
Living a dream

Member since 1/08

8589 total posts

Name:
Cheeks

Re: thoughts?

I think $20 million is a bit much, but it does mention she will be getting the education she missed out on and public school is funded by taxes.

Posted 7/2/10 10:53 AM
 

justmefornow
LIF Adolescent

Member since 9/08

859 total posts

Name:
n

Re: thoughts?

It sounds like a lot of taxpayers money but I cannot imagine arguing that she and her girls shouldn't have it. Chat Icon

Posted 7/2/10 10:56 AM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: thoughts?

Posted by justmefornow

It sounds like a lot of taxpayers money but I cannot imagine arguing that she and her girls shouldn't have it. Chat Icon



i agree, that girl was tortured for her entire life. It was plain negligence that let it go unnoticed. I think she deserves every penny. Id be more than happy to spend my tax money on it. Its a better use than some other things they waste tax money on.

Posted 7/2/10 11:06 AM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: thoughts?

All I will say is that I can sympathize with the parole officers who were responsible for supervising Garrido. Career criminals are VERY good at hiding information if they really want to, and without knowing the full facts of the case I cannot say that it was neglect that allowed him to hide Dugard all these years.

Unless the family can prove that there were actual instances of neglect that would have led to her discovery I don't agree with this settlement. That opens up the state to a whole host of lawsuits for crimes committed by supervised offenders (both on probation and parole). BIG can of worms.

Posted 7/2/10 11:15 AM
 

Deeluvsvinny
DONE

Member since 10/08

4952 total posts

Name:
Whatever

Re: thoughts?

Posted by eddiesmommy

Posted by justmefornow

It sounds like a lot of taxpayers money but I cannot imagine arguing that she and her girls shouldn't have it. Chat Icon



i agree, that girl was tortured for her entire life. It was plain negligence that let it go unnoticed. I think she deserves every penny. Id be more than happy to spend my tax money on it. Its a better use than some other things they waste tax money on.



ITA. There's been reports that the officers routinely went to the house and never noticed she was there. Such a tragedy.

Posted 7/2/10 11:31 AM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: thoughts?

Posted by eddiesmommy

Posted by justmefornow

It sounds like a lot of taxpayers money but I cannot imagine arguing that she and her girls shouldn't have it. Chat Icon



i agree, that girl was tortured for her entire life. It was plain negligence that let it go unnoticed. I think she deserves every penny. Id be more than happy to spend my tax money on it. Its a better use than some other things they waste tax money on.



I agree tooChat Icon

Posted 7/2/10 11:35 AM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: thoughts?

Posted by headoverheels

All I will say is that I can sympathize with the parole officers who were responsible for supervising Garrido. Career criminals are VERY good at hiding information if they really want to, and without knowing the full facts of the case I cannot say that it was neglect that allowed him to hide Dugard all these years.

Unless the family can prove that there were actual instances of neglect that would have led to her discovery I don't agree with this settlement. That opens up the state to a whole host of lawsuits for crimes committed by supervised offenders (both on probation and parole). BIG can of worms.



I agree. I haven't followed this case that closely, but as a social worker, I can definitely relate because when something happens with a client, even if you did everything you could possibly do to help them, we are often the first ones criticized for not doing our jobs.

Posted 7/2/10 11:39 AM
 

mbg1007
LIF Adult

Member since 3/09

1247 total posts

Name:

Re: thoughts?

Posted by mzsocialworker1

Posted by headoverheels

All I will say is that I can sympathize with the parole officers who were responsible for supervising Garrido. Career criminals are VERY good at hiding information if they really want to, and without knowing the full facts of the case I cannot say that it was neglect that allowed him to hide Dugard all these years.

Unless the family can prove that there were actual instances of neglect that would have led to her discovery I don't agree with this settlement. That opens up the state to a whole host of lawsuits for crimes committed by supervised offenders (both on probation and parole). BIG can of worms.



I agree. I haven't followed this case that closely, but as a social worker, I can definitely relate because when something happens with a client, even if you did everything you could possibly do to help them, we are often the first ones criticized for not doing our jobs.




I agree that we shouldnt rush to judgment on parole officers or police or whoever, but from what I read there was a whole lot of negligence and incompetence going on with this case, werent police called out to his house numerous times bc of neighbors complaints about the backyard situation and the polce never even checked it out?

Posted 7/2/10 12:08 PM
 

julesrbf
Baby Girl

Member since 6/09

3882 total posts

Name:

Re: thoughts?

Posted by justmefornow

It sounds like a lot of taxpayers money but I cannot imagine arguing that she and her girls shouldn't have it. Chat Icon



ITA.

Posted 7/2/10 12:22 PM
 

CouponKT
Our family is complete

Member since 6/06

16494 total posts

Name:
K

Re: thoughts?

Posted by headoverheels

All I will say is that I can sympathize with the parole officers who were responsible for supervising Garrido. Career criminals are VERY good at hiding information if they really want to, and without knowing the full facts of the case I cannot say that it was neglect that allowed him to hide Dugard all these years.

Unless the family can prove that there were actual instances of neglect that would have led to her discovery I don't agree with this settlement. That opens up the state to a whole host of lawsuits for crimes committed by supervised offenders (both on probation and parole). BIG can of worms.



wait, wait, wait....

the parole officers must have gone to the house with blinders on if they missed the tent city in the backyard where these girls were actually living. How did they not see that or check that out!!?

Posted 7/2/10 12:35 PM
 

DancinBarefoot
06ers Rock!!

Member since 1/07

9537 total posts

Name:
The One My Mother Gave Me ;-)

Re: thoughts?

Posted by mbg1007

Posted by mzsocialworker1

Posted by headoverheels

All I will say is that I can sympathize with the parole officers who were responsible for supervising Garrido. Career criminals are VERY good at hiding information if they really want to, and without knowing the full facts of the case I cannot say that it was neglect that allowed him to hide Dugard all these years.

Unless the family can prove that there were actual instances of neglect that would have led to her discovery I don't agree with this settlement. That opens up the state to a whole host of lawsuits for crimes committed by supervised offenders (both on probation and parole). BIG can of worms.



I agree. I haven't followed this case that closely, but as a social worker, I can definitely relate because when something happens with a client, even if you did everything you could possibly do to help them, we are often the first ones criticized for not doing our jobs.




I agree that we shouldnt rush to judgment on parole officers or police or whoever, but from what I read there was a whole lot of negligence and incompetence going on with this case, werent police called out to his house numerous times bc of neighbors complaints about the backyard situation and the polce never even checked it out?



Yes, the police were called numerous times, and at least once there was a specific complaint about the backyard. The evidence released to the media thus far showed that the police never went into the backyard to investigate the complaints.

Posted 7/2/10 1:02 PM
 

DancinBarefoot
06ers Rock!!

Member since 1/07

9537 total posts

Name:
The One My Mother Gave Me ;-)

Re: thoughts?

Posted by Mici C

I think $20 million is a bit much, but it does mention she will be getting the education she missed out on and public school is funded by taxes.



Not just her education - but also that of her two kids. That's 3 public educations.

Posted 7/2/10 1:03 PM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: thoughts?

Posted by DancinBarefoot

Posted by mbg1007

Posted by mzsocialworker1

Posted by headoverheels

All I will say is that I can sympathize with the parole officers who were responsible for supervising Garrido. Career criminals are VERY good at hiding information if they really want to, and without knowing the full facts of the case I cannot say that it was neglect that allowed him to hide Dugard all these years.

Unless the family can prove that there were actual instances of neglect that would have led to her discovery I don't agree with this settlement. That opens up the state to a whole host of lawsuits for crimes committed by supervised offenders (both on probation and parole). BIG can of worms.



I agree. I haven't followed this case that closely, but as a social worker, I can definitely relate because when something happens with a client, even if you did everything you could possibly do to help them, we are often the first ones criticized for not doing our jobs.




I agree that we shouldnt rush to judgment on parole officers or police or whoever, but from what I read there was a whole lot of negligence and incompetence going on with this case, werent police called out to his house numerous times bc of neighbors complaints about the backyard situation and the polce never even checked it out?



Yes, the police were called numerous times, and at least once there was a specific complaint about the backyard. The evidence released to the media thus far showed that the police never went into the backyard to investigate the complaints.



I stated in my post, I didn't know the details of the case, if there was actual neglect or not. If that was the case then YES I believe the state and supervising agency should be held accountable.

Posted 7/2/10 1:21 PM
 

johnsae
Sip.

Member since 3/06

18677 total posts

Name:

Re: thoughts?

No amount of money is enough for what she went through.

Posted 7/2/10 5:11 PM
 

saraH
happy birthday sweet kate!

Member since 5/05

16555 total posts

Name:
I know that God exsists, I held her in my arms...

Re: thoughts?

Posted by johnsae

No amount of money is enough for what she went through.




agreed.

Posted 7/2/10 5:24 PM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: thoughts?

Posted by johnsae

No amount of money is enough for what she went through.



Agreed.

And I do feel there was extreme negligence here.

Posted 7/2/10 5:43 PM
 

Bugaboo
Relax!

Member since 5/05

2133 total posts

Name:

Re: thoughts?

Posted by johnsae

No amount of money is enough for what she went through.



ITA. And from what I read there was a lot of negligence by the state. If the state went to trial they would end up paying a WHOLE LOT MORE if they lost.

Her and her kids will need a lifetime of therapy. Chat Icon

Posted 7/2/10 6:21 PM
 

JessInCA
live laugh love

Member since 8/06

5082 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: thoughts?

As a California tax payer, I'm not thrilled that so much money is coming out of the general fund, especially with the dire circumstances of our state's finances right now.

HOWEVER... I can't deny the fact that they're deserving of restitution, and it has to come from somewhere. It's outright negligence that they "missed" what was going on in this case.

Posted 7/2/10 7:12 PM
 

Stacey1403
Where it all began....

Member since 5/05

24065 total posts

Name:

Re: thoughts?

Posted by CouponMom

Posted by headoverheels

All I will say is that I can sympathize with the parole officers who were responsible for supervising Garrido. Career criminals are VERY good at hiding information if they really want to, and without knowing the full facts of the case I cannot say that it was neglect that allowed him to hide Dugard all these years.

Unless the family can prove that there were actual instances of neglect that would have led to her discovery I don't agree with this settlement. That opens up the state to a whole host of lawsuits for crimes committed by supervised offenders (both on probation and parole). BIG can of worms.



wait, wait, wait....

the parole officers must have gone to the house with blinders on if they missed the tent city in the backyard where these girls were actually living. How did they not see that or check that out!!?



ITA


I have read a lot about this case and they have admitted to not even going into the house and checking anything out. Someone called and said they heard children in his backyard and he is a registered sex offender. You know if a neighbor called and said he was growing pot in his backyard they would have checked it out!!

She deserves every penny in my book!

Posted 7/2/10 7:22 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Please keep my baby boy in your thoughts and prayers..... preciouslove 12/19/05 73 Pregnancy
I never do this but I really really need your good thoughts today... UPDATE 10/7 Leeners 10/6/05 54 Families Helping Families ™
what are your thoughts.. re: World trade center? 04bride 10/4/05 42 Families Helping Families ™
UPDATED!!!Please cross your fingers and wish happy thoughts to Juliette for Monday!!! UPDATED!!! aliasPook 9/10/05 14 Parenting
VMA's!!!! Without further adieu, I would like to share DH's thoughts on the pre-show..... kathleeng 8/28/05 5 Families Helping Families ™
So Debg....What thoughts are running through your head right now? btrflygrl 8/19/05 12 Families Helping Families ™