Those who commute into Penn

Posted By Message

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Those who commute into Penn

Lately I'm noticing a lot more people asking for money.

Yesterday I was waiting for DH to meet me so we could take a later train and standing by the McDonalds. Two men approached me for money.

Then DH came and a woman approached both of us.

Then this am I was at Starbucks and I was fixing my coffee and the milk and sugar bar and I patiently waited for this man to use the sugar dispenser. It looked like he was using a boatload of sugar but I just waited until he was done. He puts it down, I pick it up and use it. He turns to me and asks me for a cup of coffee.

Now, I give to charity plenty, I have given to people asking for change..but it seems that if I stop at Penn I get hit almost every time.

If I'm running for a train or a subway that doesn't happen but once I'm planted somewhere for a few minutes I feel that I get bombarded.

Last night I was looking for a garbage can to throw out trash and at every can were a few people lingering there. They were not commuters.

I don't want to seem rude and I'm certainly not adverse to helping people out when they are down. I'm generous to a fault sometimes. I just think I'm seeing it a lot more.

It's pretty sad. I would like to do something but what? Obviously I can't give to everyone but where do you draw the line?


Posted 3/11/11 2:18 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

isabelle2137
LIF Adult

Member since 12/06

1076 total posts

Name:

Re: Those who commute into Penn

I was just thinking the same thing. I was walking through Penn at 8:15 this morning and was surprised how many homeless people I saw. It definitley seems way more than usual. Chat Icon

Posted 3/11/11 2:22 PM
 

bicosi
life is a carousel

Member since 7/07

14956 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Those who commute into Penn

I stopped giving to people a long time ago and I've been commuting into the city for well over 11 years.. Most of them use the funds to drink or smoke and not for food.. the one time I actually offered the person food, they rejected me and cursed me out.. that's when I stopped all together..

Posted 3/11/11 2:23 PM
 

PearlJamChick
No one sings like you anymore.

Member since 7/10

9264 total posts

Name:
Petticoated Swashbuckler

Re: Those who commute into Penn

I've noticed a lot more lately as well, though I commute in to Port Authority.

But even last week, there was a guy who was crouched over at the end of mine and DH's block. I had seen him around for awhile....never bothers a soul....the weather was cruddy, and DH and I bought him a coffee and bagel to help him warm up a little.

I usually don't give out money...I don't want to have my wallet open when I'm on the subway or street. But I never mind giving/buying a person food. Everyone needs to eat.

It's hard. I know what you mean...no one should have to live like that. And you never know what, exactly, put a person on the streets. And then there are the people who just don't want anyone's help, regardless of what they're offering.

You could always volunteer somewhere. A shelter, a soup kitchen, a food pantry. You could donate clothes to shelters and food to soup kitchens and food pantries.

Posted 3/11/11 2:27 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Those who commute into Penn

I work upstairs from Penn so I see it all of the time.

My line has been drawn at I don't give money to those that ask. Period. I give to charities throughout the year, donate clothes, household items on a regular basis. I do kick in for street musicians.

I've seen the same people that ask for money, shivering & going through withdrawal in the early mornings. I thought one was having a seizure until a cop in Penn told me it was just heroin withdrawal.Chat Icon

Posted 3/11/11 2:51 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Those who commute into Penn

As a social worker, I am seeing a lot of organizations that help people out affected.

Even the program I work for......which is for survivors of traumatic brain injury. I have been working for this program since '05. Back in the day, anyone really with a brain injury could get a housing subsidy.

Not anymore. You MUST be coming from a nursing home setting now, so now there's a whole bunch of people out there with TBI who are not able to afford rent.

One of the regions I work in also the budget has gotten cut so much they really are not able to afford to take people on who require a lot of services to maintain their independence in the community. If you require 24/7 care.......forget about it.

This is only ONE population too. Imagine this spread across the board.

Not everyone sadly has family to turn to, and depending on one's situation, a lot of families get burnt out trying to help so people end up on the street.

Posted 3/11/11 2:52 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Those who commute into Penn

Posted by nrthshgrl

I work upstairs from Penn so I see it all of the time.

My line has been drawn at I don't give money to those that ask. Period. I give to charities throughout the year, donate clothes, household items on a regular basis. I do kick in for street musicians.

I've seen the same people that ask for money, shivering & going through withdrawal in the early mornings. I thought one was having a seizure until a cop in Penn told me it was just heroin withdrawal.Chat Icon



I don't work with the S/A population for the most part (some of the people I do work with have a history). In any event, I always tell myself that if they want help, there are organizations out there where they can get it.

I know someone in my personal life who is doing this right now. He got himself on foodstamps and Medicaid and attend an outpatient S/A program. Fortunately, his parents provide the roof over his head which may be part of the problem........that's probably another thread though!

Posted 3/11/11 2:56 PM
 

Lisa
I'm a PANK!!!

Member since 5/05

22334 total posts

Name:
Professional Aunts No Kids

Re: Those who commute into Penn

when its raining or crappy out I notice more homeless people in Penn

Posted 3/11/11 3:02 PM
 

billswife
LIF Infant

Member since 1/08

216 total posts

Name:

Re: Those who commute into Penn

I commute to Penn everyday. There is this one guy that I have seen a couple of times walking through the train for money. He always says the same excuse.

Posted 3/11/11 3:26 PM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: Those who commute into Penn

It breaks my heart every single time. I do volunteer and donate but I think this is a problem that shouldn't exist in this country. We have to take care of our people better. I know some people have only themselves to blame but it still tears me apart.

I give change every now and then and sometimes buy food for them but I'm only one person and I can't go bankrupt myself for them.

Posted 3/11/11 3:31 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Those who commute into Penn

When I bought a guy a muffin, he complained that it came with no coffee & then asked for money.

That was the last time I gave someone money in Penn.

Posted 3/11/11 3:42 PM
 

KittyGags
LIF Adult

Member since 7/09

5614 total posts

Name:

Re: Those who commute into Penn

Late at night I see a TON of them.

I don't give them money-EVER.

Posted 3/11/11 4:35 PM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: Those who commute into Penn

I think it's a sign that the world is ending in 2012
















Chat Icon
Chat Icon

Posted 3/11/11 4:38 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Those who commute into Penn

Posted by NervousNell

I think it's a sign that the world is ending in 2012
















Chat Icon
Chat Icon



So you're saying they're like the animals that go silent before a natural disaster? Hmm...there's a theory. I'll hang on to my cash in case you're wrong.Chat Icon

Posted 3/11/11 4:57 PM
 

ODonnell
.

Member since 9/05

5983 total posts

Name:

Re: Those who commute into Penn

I just had a guy approach me as I was paying for a sandwich at Hot & Crusty this lunchtime. He hassled all of the customers by the counter and was verbally abusive.

I give most of the time but it really upsets me when they yell or curse me out if I don't, which I have noticed a lot lately. Last week I was in the Church on Park and 38th and a homeless man followed me in asking for money. I really had only $1 to light a candle and when I said I didn't have any money he called me a lying b!tch. It left me feeling like I had done something wrong.Chat Icon

Posted 3/11/11 5:56 PM
 

WannaBeAMom11
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

7391 total posts

Name:
Name

Re: Those who commute into Penn

yeah its always worse when the weather is bad. I feel bad but at the same time if i gave money everyday i would be broke. I see more and more everyday especially the old white haired guy, the guy who takes his leg off and the lady who sells the doily things. I feel terrible but really dont know what to do for them.

Posted 3/11/11 9:37 PM
 

BaysideForever
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

9976 total posts

Name:

Re: Those who commute into Penn

I sometimes offer to buy them food instead of handing them money. This is usually more expensive, but it usually weeds out the addicts and the liars who just want cash because many times I was rudely rejected. I don't like when I am offering help in the ways I can or feel comfortable doing so and then am cursed at or get garbage thrown at me.

One time my brother gave this guy a sandwich (I was very young at the time but with him) and the guy took the sandwich and then chucked it at my brothers head!! What a waste of money. It makes me sad thinking he was doing a good thing and that guy turns around and does that.

Also, my parents had to sell their house and move. They had to get rid of a million things literally. Basically everything they had in the house they needed to get rid of as well (all of the furniture in every room, all of the stuff in the attic, all of the stuff in the basement, kitchen supplies and dishes, treadmill, tv's, clothes, games). They tried to donate it all to charity and not one organization wanted it. No one picked up items. All of it ended up getting hauled into a dumpster basically. It was so sad, this was good stuff and we couldn't find any charities who would pick it up and take it. That crushed me because it is wasteful to the environment and I know there are people out there that could have benefitted from the items.

Posted 3/12/11 9:58 AM
 

alli3131
Peanut is here!!!!!!

Member since 5/09

18388 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Those who commute into Penn

I commute through Penn and work above Grand Central. They are both bad and horrible if the weather is bad. The cops don't do anything either. These people can get help if they want it so I don;t feel bad for then in the least.

Posted 3/12/11 10:31 AM
 

hanna7636
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

921 total posts

Name:

Re: Those who commute into Penn

It is not illegal to ask someone for money but it is illegal to harass them.

I used to live in the East Village and people who threaten me if I did not give them money. I never give homeless people money I donate to charity.

Posted 3/12/11 11:45 AM
 

MrsKS
Thank You St. Gerard.....

Member since 12/09

8306 total posts

Name:
Kerri

Re: Those who commute into Penn

I was a MTA train rider for MANY years... and I saw panhandlers DAILY... multiple times a day. Some were legitimate and others weren't.
I try not to give to them but sometimes there are just some that look an sound so desperate that I can't help it.

What I do try to do is look at their shoes or sneakers. Sometimes I see them panhandling with the newest hottest pair of sneakers on. Sneakers that cost more than mine and are clearly newer. I don't ever give to those people.

Other times I can see and hear the desperation... and I have given food out to people (i've even given away parts of my lunch before).

And I saw a lady with a little girl standing outside of McDonalds one day begging for money. I think she even had a sign, I can't remember. But something just urged me to give her money. I gave her a $5 and as I walked away I heard her say to the little girl "come on baby lets go in and get some breakfast". My heart melted and I was so happy I gave her money that she used for food for them that day.

So all in all, I try not to give to them but at times I just feel compelled.

I think I have noticed more recently... but recently as in the last 5 years. However they have always been around. I don't recall a time where I didn't see at least a few a week.

Posted 3/14/11 3:59 AM
 

MrsKS
Thank You St. Gerard.....

Member since 12/09

8306 total posts

Name:
Kerri

Re: Those who commute into Penn

Posted by hanna7636

It is not illegal to ask someone for money but it is illegal to harass them.

I used to live in the East Village and people who threaten me if I did not give them money. I never give homeless people money I donate to charity.




Oh yea... there certainly are nasty ones!! really nasty!!! I've seen that for sure. And sometimes they are talking about how hungry they are and when someone reaches into their bag to give them food I've seen the person called cheap! Like are you REALLY hungry?? so hungry that you are panhandling telling everyone how you are starving and you are handed food and then you insult the person???

Posted 3/14/11 4:02 AM
 

janet
WITH LOVE MY ANGEL MISS YOU!!!

Member since 5/05

12823 total posts

Name:
janet

Re: Those who commute into Penn

I dont travel to Penn , But I did learn my lesson in Rocky Point. I have worked there for now 3 and a half years. There is a "homeless" guy or I thought homeless guy, turns out he is loaded and a drunk. He gets kicked out of his house on a daily bases from his wife. I always felt bad for him and I have gotten him food, ciggs, and money. Then I found out what the real story was and NEVER again. I felt so taken.

Posted 3/14/11 6:55 AM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Those who commute into Penn

I don't take my wallet out on the street, period. When I used to ride the train into Penn, I would only take money out if I were buying something. If it seemed very crowded, I didn't buy things.

I give to charities and haven given people my lunch or leftovers when they want them, but I don't give out money in public at all anymore. On a few occasions, I have brought people into a McDonalds and bought them coffee or food. I have found that if people really are looking for something to eat, they will take you up on an offer of food.

Posted 3/14/11 11:33 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Where do you live and how long is your commute? SweetTooth 8/31/06 70 Families Helping Families ™
Just what I like to see on my morning commute.. nrthshgrl 3/3/06 18 Families Helping Families ™
People who commute to NYC and didn't go to work on Monday... MrsJ 2/15/06 16 Families Helping Families ™
so how about this for a commute this morning.. mable 1/26/06 16 Pregnancy
For those of you with a long commute. . . tourist 10/17/05 19 Families Helping Families ™
Am I the only one with a long crappy commute? MrsProfessor 9/19/05 12 Families Helping Families ™