This may be a question with no real answer....

Posted By Message

2BadSoSad
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

6791 total posts

Name:

This may be a question with no real answer....

But it is what I think every time something like this happens.

Why do you think in this day and age that people are choosing to take out, with mass casualties and injuries, their frustrations, their anger, the disenchantment, or whatever it is on mass groups on innocent people?

I feel like this didn't happen 50 years ago. I know it has happened in times of civil unrest, I know it has happened in horrific ways during times of war and corrupt governments.

I am talking about seemingly everyday people taking out their anger with whatever on groups of innocent people. This marathon, the Atlanta Olympics, every shooting, why do you think this happens?

Do you think its the ready access to information (how to cause mass casualties), do you think its the media, what? I just don't understand it.

There had to be angry and disenfranchised people 50 years ago but they didn't do this.

I know our mental health system is broken, I know that. Still, why not take it out on those you ARE angry at, why innocent people, why innocent children and innocent people. I just cannot wrap my head around WHY anyone or what would drive anyone to do these kinds of things to people who are NOT what causes their strife, had nothing to do with whatever they are angry at.

Why now? What is going on?

(I should add, I am assuming this is a domestic attack based on the reports of how crude the device was)

Message edited 2013-04-16 00:54:44.093000.

Posted 4/15/13 11:16 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

gina409
TWINS!

Member since 12/09

27635 total posts

Name:
g

Re: This may be a question with no real answer?

i am no expert and i think this is a part not the whole thing and by far NO excuse but i think the stress today plays into it..with money and jobs and etc etc

Posted 4/15/13 11:58 PM
 

Ayne11
Yep

Member since 1/09

18021 total posts

Name:

Re: This may be a question with no real answer?

I ask myself this all the time and the only things I can come up with are

Im not really religious at all but I feel, No one has a healthy real fear of God or higher power anymore. Or morals. Who's fault is that the parents? I honestly don't know who failed them along the way. Maybe they failed themselves.

Social media gives everyone this "false" sense of importance and/or superiority. People all of a sudden feel emboldened.
The media sensationalizes the attackers then in turn they see it glorification. Finally they will get the attention they either never had or feel is owed to them.

These are just my personal thoughts that swim in my head when stuff like this happens.

Message edited 2013-04-16 00:05:14.590000.

Posted 4/16/13 12:00 AM
 

meloyellow
LIF Adult

Member since 3/13

1843 total posts

Name:

Re: This may be a question with no real answer?

It's definitely a combination I think. I blame media most of all. They sensationalize these stories playing them on endless 24 hour loops. They focus on the terror and the fear rather than the sense of community and comaradery of people coming together. They play the same gruesome images over and over. It only shows other copycats how much attention their actions can get.

Mental health is another big issue. Also, the economy, jobs, disappointment in government and lack of trust that they have our best interests at heart. Wars, children are dying abroad in these wars with seemingly no end in sight. People losing their homes...living paycheck to paycheck with costs and taxes constantly headed upwards while income is down. All these things together create the perfect storm.

Posted 4/16/13 12:09 AM
 

2BadSoSad
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

6791 total posts

Name:

Re: This may be a question with no real answer?

Posted by Ayne11

I ask myself this all the time and the only things I can come up with are

Im not really religious at all but I feel, No one has a healthy real fear of God or higher power anymore. Or morals. Who's fault is that the parents? I honestly don't know who failed them along the way. Maybe they failed themselves.

Social media gives everyone this "false" sense of importance and/or superiority

The media sensationalizes the attackers then in turn they see it glorification. Finally they will get the attention they either never had or feel is owed to them.

These are just my personal thoughts that swim in my head when stuff like this happens.



I am not particularly religious right now either. But I have thought this, I even said the same thing in a thread I started on here during the Newtown Shooting. I said the same exact thing about the lack of the "fear of God" Do I know if that is why, no, I have NO idea. Do I think it is a factor, maybe? Do I think there are other factors at play, I sure do.

My disconnect is that their HAD to be people who felt this way 50 years ago (an arbitrary dateline) but they STILL didn't do this. There HAS to be something in our society today that is causing or driving SICK SICK people to do this. It is probably far out of my league of understanding, and that is why I don't get it, but I just don't understand (and maybe bc Im a rational human being) why NOW, what is the disconnect between now and then that everyday humanity thinks nothing of taking out hundreds of people at once.

Message edited 2013-04-16 00:33:04.843000.

Posted 4/16/13 12:10 AM
 

2BadSoSad
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

6791 total posts

Name:

Re: This may be a question with no real answer?

Posted by meloyellow

It's definitely a combination I think. I blame media most of all. They sensationalize these stories playing them on endless 24 hour loops. They focus on the terror and the fear rather than the sense of community and comaradery of people coming together. They play the same gruesome images over and over. It only shows other copycats how much attention their actions can get.

Mental health is another big issue. Also, the economy, jobs, disappointment in government and lack of trust that they have our best interests at heart. Wars, children are dying abroad in these wars with seemingly no end in sight. People losing their homes...living paycheck to paycheck with costs and taxes constantly headed upwards while income is down. All these things together create the perfect storm.



I agree that there is so much in society today that is different, and I agree with you and Gina. But what is wired different in us that this has become the way the disenfranchised express their hatred and disgust and frustration? Surely the people of the depression (as just one example) knew more economic despair than we have ever known and they didn't do this (and again, I know we are more "sophisticated" today) but even with the resources available to them then, they didn't do this. I just don't understand the escalation of violence and misdirection of anger on innocent people.

Posted 4/16/13 12:14 AM
 

2BadSoSad
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

6791 total posts

Name:

Re: This may be a question with no real answer?

Thank you for everyone for sharing. I don't think ANY of us, as rational decent human beings even with our flaws can ever really understand it and we may just be talking in circles here, but I just want to see whatever everyone else thinks. Only bc I think this every time something like this happens.

I don't think anyone is right, i don't think any of us is wrong. I have no desire to start any kind of debate, I am just trying to understand and maybe someone has more insight than I do, KWIM?

Posted 4/16/13 12:17 AM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: This may be a question with no real answer....

I think I am fortunate sometimes that I can't wrap my head around the crazy that goes into something like this.

I know it goes on in other countries though (although not sure how far back either, would be interesting to look into if it was more than 50 years ago) and if you watch news or documentaries, you see these "leaders" who have gone off the deep end, who recruit people seemingly from a young age and fill them with such hate that this is their path in life. Violent extremists.

I think the environment one grows up in can have a lot to do with it; add on a mental health issue and it's a recipe for disaster.

I do think though that in this day and age we have so much financial stress, class/race differences, politics are thrown in your face CONSTANTLY from social media, there's also A LOT of misinformation out there too on social media that people latch onto.

I'm not looking to get into a debate either, but based on FB postings only, I get annoyed daily about how ignorant many seemingly educated, down to earth people are just around basic entitlements programs in our country.

Sometimes I feel that the farther we come as a society, the further we step back.

I also think times have always been violent if you think of different events that have occurred throughout history.

Message edited 2013-04-16 06:12:21.200000.

Posted 4/16/13 6:03 AM
 

Paramount
Sweet!

Member since 7/12

4289 total posts

Name:

Re: This may be a question with no real answer....

I FIRMLY believe its 3. reasons:

1. They are truly mentally unstable. I dont care how "sane" a person is, you have to be bat shit crazy to want to "do" something like this.

In combanation with:

2. They think it might be fun

3. Winner winner chicken dinner: GLORY and FAME and COPYCAT. Right now its everywhere. Social media, news, radio, internet. Its all over the world. EVERYONE knows what happened. Its all we talk about.

These people's payout is the aftermath and seeing what happens. What they just did is now world headlines. Every TV program stops. Everything is about the event. Months later we are still talking about Newtown. And look at all the glory and fame the shooter got?

So I think #3 is the main reason, but it goes hand in hand with the mentally unstable.

I for one have not commented on anyone status. I have not "sent prayers" or "thoughts". I will not perpetuate the payoff to whomever did it.

Posted 4/16/13 9:56 AM
 

tourist

Member since 5/05

10425 total posts

Name:

Re: This may be a question with no real answer....

Well, things like this did happen 50 years ago, but you said you weren't counting civil unrest.

I don't know if you can really separate it out like that. 1963 was during the civil rights movement, so things like this did happen.

I don't know what this person or group's motive was, but they probably had some gripe, that in their mind is as serious as the political issues of the past.

Message edited 2013-04-16 10:20:24.443000.

Posted 4/16/13 10:10 AM
 

Jenny614
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

1065 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: This may be a question with no real answer....

I really dont want to start any drama, I just want to add something to this post that will probably fuel some more thought. You have all made really good points, and being a Psychologist and human being, I find the OP's question really interesting.

Although no particular person or party has been given full blame, the speculation is that this was domestic. Like I said, you all have made great and valid points, but why hasnt anyone mentioned the word terrorist? Immediately, we jump to mental illness, the economy, morals, religion, overall environment, etc. From what I have observed in previous incidents, if this was done by someone from a different country, then they are immediately labeled as evil terrorist pigs. And not that those people are not evil terrorists, they fit the bill and they are...but why dont we ever give Americans that title? In my opinion, what happened yesterday was terrorism, and I dont care where they are from, what their mental status is, how much debt they have, and whether or not they fear God. Im just curious to what you think, and would love to hear some non-aggressive feedbackChat Icon

Posted 4/16/13 1:11 PM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: This may be a question with no real answer....

Posted by Jenny614

I really dont want to start any drama, I just want to add something to this post that will probably fuel some more thought. You have all made really good points, and being a Psychologist and human being, I find the OP's question really interesting.

Although no particular person or party has been given full blame, the speculation is that this was domestic. Like I said, you all have made great and valid points, but why hasnt anyone mentioned the word terrorist? Immediately, we jump to mental illness, the economy, morals, religion, overall environment, etc. From what I have observed in previous incidents, if this was done by someone from a different country, then they are immediately labeled as evil terrorist pigs. And not that those people are not evil terrorists, they fit the bill and they are...but why dont we ever give Americans that title? In my opinion, what happened yesterday was terrorism, and I dont care where they are from, what their mental status is, how much debt they have, and whether or not they fear God. Im just curious to what you think, and would love to hear some non-aggressive feedbackChat Icon



Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 4/16/13 1:16 PM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: This may be a question with no real answer....

It's actually been worse in the past compared to today:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_massacres_in_the_United_States

We just never heard about it because we weren't alive then, and we didn't have instantaneous social media back then.

Even mass shootings were happening 50 years ago:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_rampage_killers

Posted 4/16/13 10:12 PM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: This may be a question with no real answer....

Posted by Jenny614

I really dont want to start any drama, I just want to add something to this post that will probably fuel some more thought. You have all made really good points, and being a Psychologist and human being, I find the OP's question really interesting.

Although no particular person or party has been given full blame, the speculation is that this was domestic. Like I said, you all have made great and valid points, but why hasnt anyone mentioned the word terrorist? Immediately, we jump to mental illness, the economy, morals, religion, overall environment, etc. From what I have observed in previous incidents, if this was done by someone from a different country, then they are immediately labeled as evil terrorist pigs. And not that those people are not evil terrorists, they fit the bill and they are...but why dont we ever give Americans that title? In my opinion, what happened yesterday was terrorism, and I dont care where they are from, what their mental status is, how much debt they have, and whether or not they fear God. Im just curious to what you think, and would love to hear some non-aggressive feedbackChat Icon



because ever since 9/11, most people in the US associate the word terrorism with muslim attacks. When in reality, the word is all encompassing of any kind of attack of this nature - whether perpetrated by someone from overseas or a disgruntled neighbor who lives right next door.

this absolutely was an act of terrorism, in the true definition of the word


Posted 4/16/13 10:52 PM
 

Adri
Joy!

Member since 5/05

3116 total posts

Name:
A

Re: This may be a question with no real answer....

My thoughts... I think violence have existed many years ago. What changes is that now we can get updated information from the media and internet. That didn't happen before, so people didn't really now what was happening in other cities or countries.

About terrorism, I think the word is associated now with foreign acts of violence, when those acts can be domestic. In some countries those acts of violence are prove to be domestic, but that doesn't mean they are not terrorism, imo.

Posted 4/16/13 11:26 PM
 

MrsMessina
Thankful for our miracles!

Member since 2/07

7254 total posts

Name:

Re: This may be a question with no real answer....

I think things like this did happen back then- we just didn't have the instant media access that we have now. Not everyone had a cell phone to video with to pass on to a news channel, etc... By the time word travelled, the event was long over.
It's scary to see these things happen. I just keep reminding myself that there's so much more good in the world than the bad

Posted 4/17/13 10:28 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
I'm not sure this is a silly question with no real answer but.. KevinNKristin8-15-08 1/14/11 8 Pregnancy
Can someone answer a baby food making question for me real quick?? MrsBurtch525 1/30/10 3 Parenting
Can someone answer a B6 question for me real quick? SummerMiracle 8/22/08 3 TTC
Real Estate Question - can anyone answer? familyof4 6/30/09 3 Home
Interview Question: How do you answer the question - "Why are you looking to move on from your current job?" HoneyBadger 4/14/09 14 Career
Question.. Real World Inspired megsmom 8/3/05 11 Families Helping Families ™