The Gap on LIRR

Posted By Message

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

The Gap on LIRR

The father of Natalie Smead, the teenager who fell in the gap at Woodside and then died when she crawled under the platform into the path of an oncoming train is suing LIRR for 5 million dollars.

Thoughts?

Link to newsday article

Posted 10/24/06 11:54 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: The Gap on LIRR

I didn't read the article, but I think that THe LIRR is negligent. I don't know if they will get 5 m, but the family should be compensated. Maybe then, the LIRR will get their act together.

Posted 10/24/06 11:56 AM
 

Shelly
She's 7!!!

Member since 8/05

14624 total posts

Name:

Re: The Gap on LIRR

It is so dangerous. While I was pregnant one leg fell in the gap when someone knocked into me. Thankfully the train was stopped and several people helped me up. I was so scared I thought I could die or lose my leg (thanks to an old episode of the show Homicide). I stayed calm until I got on the train, when I couldn't help but cry.

It is so dangerous!! They really need to fix it.

I hope her family wins. As a former PI attorney $5 is very little for the death of a young, healthy person.

Posted 10/24/06 12:03 PM
 

colesmom
Brady's mom too!

Member since 5/05

1989 total posts

Name:
Lea

Re: The Gap on LIRR

I heard a couple of conductors discussing it last week and they made sense. They basically said that there's always been a gap but theres never been such a HUGE problem with it. They said what there HASNT always been are Ipods, cellphones, etc. to really distract people.
I totally agree though that the shoving to get on (especially express trains) has GOT to STOP. If there were a Gap on the train a couple of weeks ago I def. would have been in it. I stopped commuting years ago and only recently had to go in several times. I dont know how you all do it!

Posted 10/24/06 12:11 PM
 

saraH
happy birthday sweet kate!

Member since 5/05

16555 total posts

Name:
I know that God exsists, I held her in my arms...

Re: The Gap on LIRR

i have to say i don't think the LIRR is at fault here. they knew she was there and were getting help to get her out and she chose to crawl under the train. its tragic yes, but the gap has been there since there have been trains.

i feel badly for the parents, but i don't think suing the LIRR will make a difference.

Message edited 2006-10-24 12:15:25.273000.

Posted 10/24/06 12:15 PM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: The Gap on LIRR

Posted by BNL2005

i have to say i don't think the LIRR is at fault here. they knew she was there and were getting help to get her out and she chose to crawl under the train. its tragic yes, but the gap has been there since there have been trains.

i feel badly for the parents, but i don't think suing the LIRR will make a difference.



How can you say that? If you were trapped under the train wouldn't you try to get out? Would you just lie there and wait to get run over? It's human nature to try to save yourself. Are you saying the passenger was at fault because she tried to save her own life? She was scared out of her mind as I would be.

This is only my opinion but the LIRR has been negligent in the past about many things. This is not the first time somebody has fallen through the gaps. I commute every day and I see all kinds of stupidity..mostly driven my the management of the LIRR.

Posted 10/24/06 12:26 PM
 

Trouble
I am going 2 be a BIG brother?

Member since 5/06

684 total posts

Name:
"HearzBellz"

Re: The Gap on LIRR

Posted by colesmom

I heard a couple of conductors discussing it last week and they made sense. They basically said that there's always been a gap but theres never been such a HUGE problem with it. They said what there HASNT always been are Ipods, cellphones, etc. to really distract people.
I totally agree though that the shoving to get on (especially express trains) has GOT to STOP. If there were a Gap on the train a couple of weeks ago I def. would have been in it. I stopped commuting years ago and only recently had to go in several times. I dont know how you all do it!



The newer trains have a bigger gap. I have noticed it recently when I switched my train time & now I get an older train in the am.

I have been pushed into the train at Jamaica, and have gotten a heel or a tip of my shoe stuck in the gap. Chat Icon

Posted 10/24/06 12:27 PM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: The Gap on LIRR

Posted by Blu-ize

Posted by BNL2005

i have to say i don't think the LIRR is at fault here. they knew she was there and were getting help to get her out and she chose to crawl under the train. its tragic yes, but the gap has been there since there have been trains.

i feel badly for the parents, but i don't think suing the LIRR will make a difference.



How can you say that? If you were trapped under the train wouldn't you try to get out? Would you just lie there and wait to get run over? It's human nature to try to save yourself. Are you saying the passenger was at fault because she tried to save her own life? She was scared out of her mind as I would be.

This is only my opinion but the LIRR has been negligent in the past about many things. This is not the first time somebody has fallen through the gaps. I commute every day and I see all kinds of stupidity..mostly driven my the management of the LIRR.



I agree-the MTA is making money hand over fist and passenger safety should be in the top 5 list of their budget priorities. Regardless of what ingfluences it(phones, I Pods) there should not be a big enough gap that someone could actually fall through!

Posted 10/24/06 12:30 PM
 

saraH
happy birthday sweet kate!

Member since 5/05

16555 total posts

Name:
I know that God exsists, I held her in my arms...

Re: The Gap on LIRR

Posted by Blu-ize

Posted by BNL2005

i have to say i don't think the LIRR is at fault here. they knew she was there and were getting help to get her out and she chose to crawl under the train. its tragic yes, but the gap has been there since there have been trains.

i feel badly for the parents, but i don't think suing the LIRR will make a difference.



How can you say that? If you were trapped under the train wouldn't you try to get out? Would you just lie there and wait to get run over? It's human nature to try to save yourself. Are you saying the passenger was at fault because she tried to save her own life? She was scared out of her mind as I would be.

This is only my opinion but the LIRR has been negligent in the past about many things. This is not the first time somebody has fallen through the gaps. I commute every day and I see all kinds of stupidity..mostly driven my the management of the LIRR.



yes i agree i would panic too and do what i could to get out. its a tragic situation that could have been avoided. that is what i was trying to say.

Posted 10/24/06 12:30 PM
 

Lisa
I'm a PANK!!!

Member since 5/05

22334 total posts

Name:
Professional Aunts No Kids

Re: The Gap on LIRR

I ALWAYS look down and take a big step into the train when boarding. There has always been a gap...sometimes bigger than others...

Posted 10/24/06 12:30 PM
 

Lisa
I'm a PANK!!!

Member since 5/05

22334 total posts

Name:
Professional Aunts No Kids

Re: The Gap on LIRR

Personally I think people sue over the craziest things but to ask for $5MM dollars for an 18 y/o life is not alot

Posted 10/24/06 12:33 PM
 

jerrysgirl
I love my hot dog!!

Member since 6/06

5357 total posts

Name:
E & J

Re: The Gap on LIRR

What about the rude people who shove you on or off the train. i would blame falling in the gap has something to do with them.

Posted 10/24/06 3:22 PM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: The Gap on LIRR

The transit system in Japan works where there are shovers that shove you into the train to pack you in. They have no gaps.

Posted 10/24/06 3:25 PM
 

Lanabean
Yoginis

Member since 11/05

9202 total posts

Name:
Lana

Re: The Gap on LIRR

My FIL fell through the gap and needed stitches on his knee....he just wasn't looking. He doesn't blame the railroad; he was being careless.

Now, my sister walks with a cane. She's asked for a hand before. The LIRR wants to know if you need assistance. If you don't ask and you need help, and you fall, it's kinda your fault.

Posted 10/24/06 3:25 PM
 

MrsNaunie
Kai helps my father dump out.

Member since 9/06

1181 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: The Gap on LIRR

It's a complete shame. Chat Icon
But they should use that $5 mill. to fix the problem maybe.

Posted 10/24/06 3:28 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Huntington toddler falls through LIRR train gap at Penn Station Stacey1403 9/7/06 12 Families Helping Families ™
LIRR RANT PiyoPika566 3/23/06 6 Families Helping Families ™
LIRR from Massapequa to NYC Ang-Rich 3/17/06 3 Families Helping Families ™
Baby Gap Coupon Smileyd17 3/16/06 3 Parenting
Baby gap coupon Smileyd17 3/16/06 5 Pregnancy
Gap Maternity? Ali1 3/6/06 10 Pregnancy