Tax/ Bank question

Posted By Message

HeathKernandez
Our Ron is an awesome Ron

Member since 4/07

9091 total posts

Name:
baby fish mouth

Tax/ Bank question

So my bank won't cash our tax return check b/c the check has both of our names on it and the checking account is in my name.

DH & I have SEPARATE bank accounts...

My bank told me the only way I could cash this check is to either open up a joint account or go to a check cashing place...

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

why should I have to pay a fee?

Does anyone know about this? How else can I get this check cashed/ or deposited??

When we got married and both our names were on the checks, all we had to do was both SIGN the checks to get it deposited. This is so frustrating, i need this $

Posted 5/21/09 2:07 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MrsPJB2007
MBA at your service!

Member since 7/06

12020 total posts

Name:
MJ

Re: Tax/ Bank question

totally p*ssed cause i typed a response and it didn't go thru...grrr


Yes the bank is right -- its for protection for spouses..so one can't take all the money from the other. Its dumb in your case because he obviously is okay with it--but its the rules.

So either add him and then take him off later or go together to a check cashing place


ETA: this really is only the case with FEDERAL checks that they get so crazy, cause the government asks them to be this way. Direct deposit for tax refunds is the same way--we have to make sure the account is in both names or else the dept of treasury won't deposit the money and later mails a check , delaying the process

Message edited 2009-05-21 14:17:56.280000.

Posted 5/21/09 2:16 PM
 

HeathKernandez
Our Ron is an awesome Ron

Member since 4/07

9091 total posts

Name:
baby fish mouth

Re: Tax/ Bank question

Posted by MrsPJB2007

totally p*ssed cause i typed a response and it didn't go thru...grrr


Yes the bank is right -- its for protection for spouses..so one can't take all the money from the other. Its dumb in your case because he obviously is okay with it--but its the rules.

So either add him and then take him off later or go together to a check cashing place


ETA: this really is only the case with FEDERAL checks that they get so crazy, cause the government asks them to be this way. Direct deposit for tax refunds is the same way--we have to make sure the account is in both names or else the dept of treasury won't deposit the money and later mails a check , delaying the process



BOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! Yeah I figured this has to do with only Federal checks.

funny though-- DH called his bank and they said as long as we both come in with our IDs we can cash it... weird.

Posted 5/21/09 2:41 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: Tax/ Bank question

Tell the teller he/she is an idiot and get a supervisor.

You should be able to deposit it if both people signed/endorsed the check.

Try depositing it at a different bank. It's probably just your bank.

Posted 5/21/09 5:59 PM
 

Beth
The Key to your new home....

Member since 2/06

24849 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Tax/ Bank question

never had this issue when I was married

only my name was on the account- and never an issue with out tax return

direct deposit and cashing the check

I bank with Citi Bank

Posted 5/21/09 7:29 PM
 

Shroggie
Don't Worry...Be Happy

Member since 5/06

6261 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax/ Bank question

Posted by ave1024

Tell the teller he/she is an idiot and get a supervisor.

You should be able to deposit it if both people signed/endorsed the check.




wow...an idiot?

i'm never one to take offense at things but this really bothers me.

where i work (and i am the supervisor), the teller would would tell the customer that the check must go into a joint account as well...it's just our policy.

maybe it's their policy tooChat Icon


Posted 5/21/09 7:43 PM
 

june262004
But I love the Snow!

Member since 5/05

15379 total posts

Name:
Kristin

Re: Tax/ Bank question

Posted by ave1024

Tell the teller he/she is an idiot and get a supervisor.

You should be able to deposit it if both people signed/endorsed the check.

Try depositing it at a different bank. It's probably just your bank.




And calling the teller an idiot is gonna get you crap sorry...

Its the GOVT not the teller or managers fault!

Posted 5/21/09 7:46 PM
 

sweetie

Member since 8/06

1730 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax/ Bank question

Don't know if this is the best option but i usually just deposit the check at the atm & they always accept it.

Posted 5/21/09 8:11 PM
 

Jessica
I'm a mommy :)

Member since 1/06

7322 total posts

Name:
~Jess~

Re: Tax/ Bank question

I work at a bank
PLEASE don't tell the teller she's an idiot!

Where I work, even if both of you have single accounts there, since the check is made out to john AND jane as oppsed to john OR jane, you would either need to open a joint checking acct w/ both names on there or cash it with BOTH of you present there

main reason being....let's say you guys are going through a divorce....You come in and cash a check that was meant for both of you against you single account, your husband can come in and make the branch liable for it since he was not there to authorize it.

Posted 5/21/09 8:16 PM
 

Shroggie
Don't Worry...Be Happy

Member since 5/06

6261 total posts

Name:

Re: Tax/ Bank question

Posted by Jessica


Where I work, even if both of you have single accounts there, since the check is made out to john AND jane as oppsed to john OR jane, you would either need to open a joint checking acct w/ both names on there or cash it with BOTH of you present there



same here

Posted 5/21/09 8:23 PM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Tax/ Bank question

Posted by ave1024

Tell the teller he/she is an idiot and get a supervisor.

You should be able to deposit it if both people signed/endorsed the check.

Try depositing it at a different bank. It's probably just your bank.



The teller isn't an idiot. It's perfectly within the bank's rights to have the policy explained to the OP.

Posted 5/21/09 8:27 PM
 

Karen
Just chillin'!!

Member since 1/06

9690 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: Tax/ Bank question

Posted by Shroggie

Posted by ave1024

Tell the teller he/she is an idiot and get a supervisor.

You should be able to deposit it if both people signed/endorsed the check.




wow...an idiot?

i'm never one to take offense at things but this really bothers me.

where i work (and i am the supervisor), the teller would would tell the customer that the check must go into a joint account as well...it's just our policy.

maybe it's their policy tooChat Icon





I agree, at my bank that is their policy too, for ALL checks, not just federal checks. We kept a very small joint savings account for this purpose.

Posted 5/21/09 8:48 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: Tax/ Bank question

Posted by june262004

Posted by ave1024

Tell the teller he/she is an idiot and get a supervisor.

You should be able to deposit it if both people signed/endorsed the check.

Try depositing it at a different bank. It's probably just your bank.




And calling the teller an idiot is gonna get you crap sorry...

Its the GOVT not the teller or managers fault!




See it's not the government telling the banks to do this. If it was, show me what treasury law says that a federal check made out to a married couple MUST be deposited in a joint account.

There is no such FEDERAL law. There is no such FEDERAL rule. These "rules" are simply bank rules designed to cover their own butts.

I did try to deposit a joint federal check into my personal Citibank account once. The Citibank teller tried to tell me they can't do this. Bla bla bla has to have both names on the account.

I called BS on it, got a supervisor. I told the supervisor to show me what federal regulation states that federal checks have any higher bearing than bank or personal checks.

I told the supervisor to read the endorsement and cash the damm check. Guess what? They cashed the check.

The bottom like is... There is no IRS rule that states what bank account the check can be deposited into.

Federal banking rules do prohibit the bank from cashing (or depositing) a joint Treasury check when only one of the payees has endorsed it. But once both people endorsed it, the regular rules of the UCC apply and that check can be cashed by just one spouse (they both don't have to show up at the bank to cash it) or deposited into the account of just one spouse.

I would say worst case scenario both parties can show up to the bank, both show ID, and both sign the check in front of the teller. But that is really stretching it.

If somebody can show me a federal treasury rule that says joint federal checks have to go to joint accounts, i'll change my stance on this. Otherwise this is just bank rules made out to cover their own butts.

Posted 5/21/09 9:38 PM
 

HeathKernandez
Our Ron is an awesome Ron

Member since 4/07

9091 total posts

Name:
baby fish mouth

Re: Tax/ Bank question

Posted by sweetie

Don't know if this is the best option but i usually just deposit the check at the atm & they always accept it.



I did use the ATM. I called the bank b/c I noticed it did not go through yet and it's been 3 days.

I was told this is a Gov't regulation, not the banks. But my husband's bank said they'll deposit it if we're both present...

Posted 5/22/09 8:41 AM
 

HeathKernandez
Our Ron is an awesome Ron

Member since 4/07

9091 total posts

Name:
baby fish mouth

Re: Tax/ Bank question

Posted by ave1024


See it's not the government telling the banks to do this. If it was, show me what treasury law says that a federal check made out to a married couple MUST be deposited in a joint account.

There is no such FEDERAL law. There is no such FEDERAL rule. These "rules" are simply bank rules designed to cover their own butts.

I did try to deposit a joint federal check into my personal Citibank account once. The Citibank teller tried to tell me they can't do this. Bla bla bla has to have both names on the account.

I called BS on it, got a supervisor. I told the supervisor to show me what federal regulation states that federal checks have any higher bearing than bank or personal checks.

I told the supervisor to read the endorsement and cash the damm check. Guess what? They cashed the check.

The bottom like is... There is no IRS rule that states what bank account the check can be deposited into.

Federal banking rules do prohibit the bank from cashing (or depositing) a joint Treasury check when only one of the payees has endorsed it. But once both people endorsed it, the regular rules of the UCC apply and that check can be cashed by just one spouse (they both don't have to show up at the bank to cash it) or deposited into the account of just one spouse.

I would say worst case scenario both parties can show up to the bank, both show ID, and both sign the check in front of the teller. But that is really stretching it.

If somebody can show me a federal treasury rule that says joint federal checks have to go to joint accounts, i'll change my stance on this. Otherwise this is just bank rules made out to cover their own butts.



That's interesting... If my husband's bank gives us a hard time, I'll try this...

Posted 5/22/09 8:42 AM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Tax/ Bank question

Posted by ave1024

Posted by june262004

Posted by ave1024

Tell the teller he/she is an idiot and get a supervisor.

You should be able to deposit it if both people signed/endorsed the check.

Try depositing it at a different bank. It's probably just your bank.




And calling the teller an idiot is gonna get you crap sorry...

Its the GOVT not the teller or managers fault!




See it's not the government telling the banks to do this. If it was, show me what treasury law says that a federal check made out to a married couple MUST be deposited in a joint account.

There is no such FEDERAL law. There is no such FEDERAL rule. These "rules" are simply bank rules designed to cover their own butts.

I did try to deposit a joint federal check into my personal Citibank account once. The Citibank teller tried to tell me they can't do this. Bla bla bla has to have both names on the account.

I called BS on it, got a supervisor. I told the supervisor to show me what federal regulation states that federal checks have any higher bearing than bank or personal checks.

I told the supervisor to read the endorsement and cash the damm check. Guess what? They cashed the check.

The bottom like is... There is no IRS rule that states what bank account the check can be deposited into.

Federal banking rules do prohibit the bank from cashing (or depositing) a joint Treasury check when only one of the payees has endorsed it. But once both people endorsed it, the regular rules of the UCC apply and that check can be cashed by just one spouse (they both don't have to show up at the bank to cash it) or deposited into the account of just one spouse.

I would say worst case scenario both parties can show up to the bank, both show ID, and both sign the check in front of the teller. But that is really stretching it.

If somebody can show me a federal treasury rule that says joint federal checks have to go to joint accounts, i'll change my stance on this. Otherwise this is just bank rules made out to cover their own butts.


Just because federal law isn't mandating that banks have this policy does NOT mean that banks CANNOT have this policy. Look at the language you yourself put in bold -- it says the check CAN be cashed by one spouse. It does not say that the bank MUST cash the check...

Posted 5/22/09 9:02 AM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: Tax/ Bank question

Posted by Kara

Just because federal law isn't mandating that banks have this policy does NOT mean that banks CANNOT have this policy. Look at the language you yourself put in bold -- it says the check CAN be cashed by one spouse. It does not say that the bank MUST cash the check...




The bank can TRY to create any policy they want, doesn't mean it's enforceable. This is why everybody seems to think it's the FED that doesn't allow this. This is nothing but bank propoganda.

The UCC rules were created for this very reason, to dictate what types of indorsements are permitted. And in this case, as long as both parties have indorsed the check, the check should be depositable.

In this case, the bank would be in violation of UCC Code §3-204 and §3-205. Your average teller is probably not aware of what UCC even stands for. But I betcha the bank manager knows.

The next time a bank refuses this type of deposit with the proper indorsements affixed to the check, get the teller's name, the bank manager's name, and tell the bank manager you are going to report them both to Andrew Cuomo's office (Attorney General) for violation of the UCC Code. Watch how fast that check gets cashed after you say this.

You are the lawyer Kara... show me what FEDERAL law states that these checks MUST be deposited into a joint account. I already showed what the law states otherwise. The UCC code overrules any "bank policies".

Message edited 2009-05-22 09:25:59.020000.

Posted 5/22/09 9:25 AM
 

timanda
Puppy Love

Member since 6/08

1627 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: Tax/ Bank question

Posted by Beth

never had this issue when I was married

only my name was on the account- and never an issue with out tax return

direct deposit and cashing the check

I bank with Citi Bank



Ditto. Our refund was direct deposited into my account and DH is not on the account with me.

It seems stupid - if he is willing to endorse the check you should be able to cash it IMO.

Posted 5/22/09 10:00 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
tax question how much are you getting back-if you dont mind me asking raken40 3/21/06 46 Families Helping Families ™
Tax people... I have a question dandj 3/15/06 9 Families Helping Families ™
1099 Tax question agrech 3/13/06 10 Families Helping Families ™
Question about Income Tax. danielleandscott 2/28/06 7 Families Helping Families ™
Homeowners...tax question KaRiSsA 2/3/06 1 Home
Coop Owners - Tax Question dandj 1/17/06 5 Home