Tattletale & Discipline

Posted By Message

CouponKT
Our family is complete

Member since 6/06

16494 total posts

Name:
K

Tattletale & Discipline

I wonder how to treat this situation and looking for advice.

How do you handle DC#1 tattling on DC#2 when DC#2 is clearly doing something wrong. I don't want DC#1 to get the satisfaction of me yelling at DC#2, but in some situations, discipline is necessary at that time.

Does that make sense? Chat Icon

What do you do?

Posted 2/4/11 11:29 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

bicosi
life is a carousel

Member since 7/07

14956 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Tattletale & Discipline

What is it that DC#2 is doing?

I know that with my two younger ones, it is hard to really teach them the difference between tattling and telling, because what they are really doing at this age is making sense of the rules. Rules make them feel secure and tattling is almost a way of checking to make sure that the rules have not changed.

When they are older, it's not that hard to make a distinction between tattling and telling a grown-up something for a good reason. (which is what I am trying hard to teach my 6yo). I've explained to them that they are only responsible for their own behavior, and to let his/her teachers or other children's parents worry about the other children. The exceptions are if someone does something that is hurtful to him/her, and does not stop when they "use her words," he/she can ask a grown-up for help. I am careful to phrase it that way - ask for help and the teacher will help you solve the problem - rather than make it about getting the offender in trouble. The other exception is if telling will help the other child; for example, if he/she sees his/her friend doing something dangerous and he/she doesn't want them to get hurt.

It's a work in progress because you don't want them to run to you for every single silly thing but at the same time, you don't want to deter them from NOT telling you something in the event it involves their safety, kwim?

At home, any time any of them come to me tattling or telling, I will go over and have them talk to EACH OTHER...they need to work things out for themselves and explain to each other how it makes them feel....

I know I jumped all over but I hope that helps. Chat Icon

Message edited 2011-02-04 12:09:24.303000.

Posted 2/4/11 11:56 AM
 

CouponKT
Our family is complete

Member since 6/06

16494 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Tattletale & Discipline

I agree with what you are saying and never thought of it that way with testing what the rules are.

For example, DS was playing with the curtains earlier. DD wanted me to yell at him, but I didn't want her to have the satisfaction of him being in trouble. So I said loudly enough to hear "he knows he is not allowed to play in the curtains, so he will leave them alone". So he got the point and wasn't really yelled at. He wasn't hurting anything and wasn't in danger, it's just that he knows he is not allowed to do that.

Only if he is in immediate danger would I jump and act on her telling me. She knows what is dangerous.

Posted 2/4/11 12:01 PM
 

bicosi
life is a carousel

Member since 7/07

14956 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Tattletale & Discipline

I think you handled it perfectly.. I also think it's that you have a big girl on your hands (lol) my older DD is exactly like that. she is the regulator as I call her in my house lol she even rats my mom out if she doesn't do things the way I do them..

Posted 2/4/11 12:10 PM
 

MaMaTeenie
Party of 5

Member since 4/08

6489 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Tattletale & Discipline

What about when DC#1 tattles on Daddy! Chat Icon

Posted 2/4/11 1:02 PM
 

bicosi
life is a carousel

Member since 7/07

14956 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Tattletale & Discipline

Posted by MaMaTeenie

What about when DC#1 tattles on Daddy! Chat Icon



EASY! Let DADDY handle it! lol

Posted 2/4/11 1:05 PM
 

iluvmynutty
Mom to E&M

Member since 12/08

1762 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Tattletale & Discipline

I work in a K - 1 building and the school social worker teaches the kids that the difference between tatteling and telling is tattleing is when what you say will get someone in trouble and telling is when you say something to an adult to keep another kid safe or out of trouble! Meaning If a kid was running with scissors, that is unsafe and you should tell an adult but if a kid said poopy-head and another kid told an adult that would be getting the other kid in trouble. This lesson works really well and nips all the tattleing in the bud. Maybe you can modify it for the ages of your children.

Posted 2/5/11 7:05 AM
 

TaraHutch
True beauty

Member since 10/07

9888 total posts

Name:
Tara

Re: Tattletale & Discipline

Posted by iluvmynutty

I work in a K - 1 building and the school social worker teaches the kids that the difference between tatteling and telling is tattleing is when what you say will get someone in trouble and telling is when you say something to an adult to keep another kid safe or out of trouble! Meaning If a kid was running with scissors, that is unsafe and you should tell an adult but if a kid said poopy-head and another kid told an adult that would be getting the other kid in trouble. This lesson works really well and nips all the tattleing in the bud. Maybe you can modify it for the ages of your children.



This helps me, as a teacher when these moments happen, when they tattle on stupid insignificant stuff. My school uses this Open Circle method and there's all these buzz words (I don't do the 'open circle' sessions with my students being the music teacher but I have knowledge of the buzz words)....I tell my kids I only want to hear if another child is doing something Dangerous or Destructive (known as double d's - though that kinda cracks me up Chat Icon).

Posted 2/5/11 8:44 AM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: Tattletale & Discipline

Posted by TaraHutch



This helps me, as a teacher when these moments happen, when they tattle on stupid insignificant stuff. My school uses this Open Circle method and there's all these buzz words (I don't do the 'open circle' sessions with my students being the music teacher but I have knowledge of the buzz words)....I tell my kids I only want to hear if another child is doing something Dangerous or Destructive (known as double d's - though that kinda cracks me up Chat Icon).



This sounds like a good suggestion ( Chat Icon at double D's)

Posted 2/5/11 9:12 AM
 

TaraHutch
True beauty

Member since 10/07

9888 total posts

Name:
Tara

Re: Tattletale & Discipline

Posted by brownie

Posted by TaraHutch



This helps me, as a teacher when these moments happen, when they tattle on stupid insignificant stuff. My school uses this Open Circle method and there's all these buzz words (I don't do the 'open circle' sessions with my students being the music teacher but I have knowledge of the buzz words)....I tell my kids I only want to hear if another child is doing something Dangerous or Destructive (known as double d's - though that kinda cracks me up Chat Icon).



This sounds like a good suggestion ( Chat Icon at double D's)



glad I'm not the only juvenile to find that funny!Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/5/11 10:24 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
How would you discipline your toddler if he/she hits you, bites you and pinches you out of anger? adeline27 9/9/09 12 Parenting
Can you please share your form of discipline for your toddler ..... babybugsmum 7/22/09 5 Parenting
how can i educate myself on the different methods of discipline? bonitachyc 7/19/09 5 Parenting
tell me about your discipline techniques in your 16-18 month old... jes81276 5/25/09 3 Parenting
I'm upset right now (almost in tears) & need advice on how to discipline an 18 month old adeline27 4/4/09 13 Parenting
Do you allow other people to discipline your child? (kind of long story) greenybeans 2/14/08 9 Parenting