Such thing as better on formula than bm?

Posted By Message

KatiNoE
LIF Adolescent

Member since 8/11

702 total posts

Name:
Kati

Such thing as better on formula than bm?

I'll start by saying I'm not trying to create any drama here. I absolutely feel that everyone should feed there baby in the way that works for them and their baby.

When dd was about 3 or 4 months old she had a tough time with gas and spitting up. I bfed her from day one until slowly weaning between 11-14 months onto cow's milk. She never had any formula. At one point my mil had suggested switching to formula since it might be easier on her belly and cause less gas. At the time I completely dismissed her. (Admittedly I don't take advice well from her. I also have a hard time taking advice from my mom if I haven't asked for it.)

Now that #2 is on the way I plan to bf again but I'm wondering if I was too quick to brush my mil off. Does anyone know of a baby who struggled with gas and spitting up on bm and then had an easier time with formula?

Sheesh... sorry to ramble.

Posted 9/16/13 2:00 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

alli3131
Peanut is here!!!!!!

Member since 5/09

18388 total posts

Name:
Allison

Such thing as better on formula than bm?

From what I hear cause I didn't bf. .....gassinessncould be controlled by your diet. So if the baby is gassy I would change my diet before saying ok to formula.

Posted 9/16/13 2:24 PM
 

VikingChick
LIF Adult

Member since 5/11

1024 total posts

Name:
Anna

Such thing as better on formula than bm?

I have certainly heard of babies who had a rough time with BM, but many times, the problems seem to be solved when mom adjusts her eating somewhat- problems with dairy or chocolate or broccoli or whatever. Could take a lot of work to figure it out or it could be pretty easy.
Personally, I don't know anyone who had an easier time with formula, although I think that someone did post something like that not too long ago.
I feel like I also see people who say their baby is having a hard time with x formula or y formula, and it takes experimentation to find something that works. So I don't think that simply switching to formula would be the magic cure all that your MIL thinks.
JMO. Hope you have an easy time BF baby, since that is what you seem to want to do. :)

Posted 9/16/13 2:35 PM
 

MrsT809
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

12167 total posts

Name:

Such thing as better on formula than bm?

I agree with the two above posts. DD did fine no matter what I ate although it turns out she does have a milk allergy and is on soymilk. I have a friend who gave up bfing bc the baby was very gassy and spit up a lot and she ate very little dairy (although she didn't eliminate it entirely). The baby has a milk protein allergy and reflux and ended up having to go through 3 different formulas as well as reflux meds and still has a tough time. I've seen many people have to switch formulas and bottles bc of gassiness and also many who had to adjust their diet if bfing. Hopefully your next LO has an easier time and you don't have to worry about it!

Posted 9/16/13 2:44 PM
 

Calla
My girls

Member since 7/05

4303 total posts

Name:

Re: Such thing as better on formula than bm?

Unless you are going to the super expensive prescription formulas I do not think you can expect it would have been better. There is no reason to think your standard supermarket formula would be easier on her belly.

Posted 9/16/13 2:46 PM
 

littlehorses
LIF Zygote

Member since 9/13

24 total posts

Name:

Such thing as better on formula than bm?

DS1 was a different baby once I started supplementing with formula. Not so much with gas and spitting up, but b/c he was (and still is) such a big eater. He was taking 8 oz at a clip starting at 2 mo old and I just wasn't able to keep up. DS2 is now 10 weeks and I am having a hard time supplementing because the nursing is going so well. Too bad I have to go back to work in 2 weeks.

It's so hard to believe that two of your own kids could be so different from each other - you have you do what works for you and each baby. I hope nursing works out for you with this baby also. Good luck!

Posted 9/16/13 2:51 PM
 

jax1023
LIF Adult

Member since 3/07

1165 total posts

Name:
Jackie

Re: Such thing as better on formula than bm?

Some kids are also just spitters- my 16 month old occasionally still spits up if he's running around too much after eating.

Your next dc may not be as big of a spitter. I would say give bf a go, and honestly, formula is much much harder to digest, so it's unlikely to improve tummy issues.

Posted 9/16/13 3:14 PM
 

cateyemm
Twins!

Member since 7/10

8027 total posts

Name:

Re: Such thing as better on formula than bm?

Posted by alli3131

From what I hear cause I didn't bf. .....gassinessncould be controlled by your diet. So if the baby is gassy I would change my diet before saying ok to formula.



Chat Icon
I have twins. One spit up for her first 3 months, one has a stomach of steel. I had to completely eliminate dairy for a few months and then she grew out of it. Your next dc might be completely different.

Keep in mind that once you cut out dairy, it can take up to 2-3 weeks for it to completely leave your system and that there is dairy in a lot of things. You should definitely give it a try!

Message edited 2013-09-16 15:21:57.543000.

Posted 9/16/13 3:21 PM
 

Oldusernewname
LIF Toddler

Member since 12/12

412 total posts

Name:

Re: Such thing as better on formula than bm?

I BF my DS and still BF am and pm, he was EBF for 8 mo, no baby food, no formula, just BM and he was always very gassy and would wake up a lot from hunger and/or gas. I tried cutting out certain foods, this and that, but nothing made it better. Then someone suggested I try formula, I tried one night and that was the night he slept though the night, didn't wake up to eat and didn't wake up from gas. I didn't think anything of it and went back to EBF, then I tried formula again, before bed, and again he slept all night.
Since that day I started giving him formula at night, before bed, he only got it for about 2 weeks and then we started him on cows milk during the day plus am/pm BF, but for sure he slept better and had less gas whenever he had formula.
He still wakes up at night, at least 2x , but def not as gassy as he used to be when he was EBF.

Message edited 2013-09-16 16:00:33.950000.

Posted 9/16/13 3:57 PM
 

Ltdentway99
LIF Adult

Member since 9/06

1752 total posts

Name:

Re: Such thing as better on formula than bm?

Posted by alli3131

From what I hear cause I didn't bf. .....gassinessncould be controlled by your diet. So if the baby is gassy I would change my diet before saying ok to formula.




Chat Icon

Posted 9/16/13 5:14 PM
 

ChristinaM128
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

4043 total posts

Name:
Christina

Re: Such thing as better on formula than bm?

I never bf, and in the end my dd had a very severe milk protein allergy. Had I bf, I would have had to avoid ALL dairy, soy, whey, casein. Basically impossible to eat and still get needed nutrients. My GI doctor said that most women who bf babies with such a severe level of allergy end up switching to formula anyways. So I suppose that is one scenario where formula is just a lot easier and possibly healthier.

Posted 9/16/13 8:45 PM
 

hope316
LIF Adult

Member since 8/07

1085 total posts

Name:

Such thing as better on formula than bm?

Some babies out grown spitting up between 6-12 months

Posted 9/16/13 8:56 PM
 

pharmcat2000
Mom of 2 + 1

Member since 10/05

7395 total posts

Name:
Catherine

Re: Such thing as better on formula than bm?

My ped suggested this to me when my dd was very gassy and spitting up a lot. He told me to stop BFing and try her on Alimentum. He suspected a milk protein allergy. I made the switch, and also brought her to a GI doc who said she was perfectly normal, no allergy, and to give her whatever I wanted to...BM, formula, whatever I preferred. He said babies GI systems are the last systems to mature, and it doesn't usually happen til about 3-4 months old. He told me to just be patient, do what I was doing for her, and it would all get better soon. I put her back on BM, and eventually she got better. Funny thing happened too, when I started to wean her, every time she started to catch a cold, I gave her more BM (I had loads frozen), she never got the cold!

Posted 9/16/13 11:20 PM
 

MrsDamonSalv7319
Somewhere in Westeros

Member since 10/10

4495 total posts

Name:

Re: Such thing as better on formula than bm?

Posted by alli3131

From what I hear cause I didn't bf. .....gassinessncould be controlled by your diet. So if the baby is gassy I would change my diet before saying ok to formula.




This. My Dd had a milk protein allergy and if I switched to formula I would have had to switch to the milk/soy free kind. Instead, I cut dairy from my diet and went on to breastfeed DD until she was 2 ( she outgrew the milk allergy around 15 months).

IMO, there is very rarely/never a reason to switch to formula, if you are 100% commited to BF. There is always a way to make it work!

Posted 9/16/13 11:54 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
New to this formula thing... CaMacho 1/11/10 10 Parenting
do formula fed babies sleep better ? mamasita27 6/14/08 20 Parenting
How long would you try a new formula for b/f deciding it isn't better? itsbabytime 5/1/08 5 Parenting
Moms whose DC has reflux - did anyone find formula worked better for DC than BM? itsbabytime 1/21/08 5 Parenting
Do you have a preference with formula? If so, which do you think is better? mitabtrfly 8/13/07 8 Parenting
I did a stupid thing tonight...Can anyone make me feel better about it? robynfs 10/30/05 16 Families Helping Families ™