The $1,800 figure is difficult to use as a comparison when so many areas have different home values. $1,800 on $200K home is a much higher percentage than $1,800 on a $400K home.

So what percentage of your home's market value (you can't really use assessed value either because each municipality uses a different formula to determine assessed value) do you pay in school taxes and municipal taxes.

Our annual school taxes are 0.8% the market value of our home (this is after STAR)

Our annual municipal taxes are 0.6% the market value of our home

You can go here to find out about tax rates across NYS