Spinoff to McCain Op-Ed article

Posted By Message

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

Spinoff to McCain Op-Ed article

What do you pay towards your health insurance for single or family?

I am wondering because although I don't like the idea of taxing an employer contribution, I think the tax amount would be less than people realize. I am not trying to support McCain (I have not decided who to vote for), I am just wondering how much of that aritcle is Spin and how much the plan would impact the average person.

Before DH and I were married I was covered as a domestic partner, the gov't does not recoginze domestic partnership so we had to pay tax on the amount his company paid for my insurance, it did not make much of a difference in our taxable income (even though his company pays a substancial portion of the insurance policy) and made more sense than me paying the $250 a month a single policy cost through my employer.

To answer my own poll: family coverage through my DH is $15 a month, through my employer it would be $600 a month.

Posted 9/17/08 12:36 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Beth
The Key to your new home....

Member since 2/06

24849 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Spinoff to McCain Op-Ed article

regardless of what you pay- the point of having your health insurace and 401K and other things taken out "Pre-Tax" it lowers your overall tax burden

our health insurace system is messed up enough- this isn't going to help at all- in fact- this is the only thing that I like about our current system

Posted 9/17/08 12:40 PM
 

JennChris
life moves fast

Member since 5/05

4225 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: Spinoff to McCain Op-Ed article

My DH own his own business.. we used to pay $1000 a month for our insurance Chat Icon We couldn't afford it, but with kids we can't afford not to have it.... My DH has since starting working for another company (one of the reasons being that he couldn't afford everything that comes with owning your own business) and they pay $400 so we were still paying the $600 difference.. this month we are switching to a High Deductible plan hoping that will save us some money.. The whole insurance thing makes me sick! Something needs to be done to make it better!

Posted 9/17/08 12:42 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Spinoff to McCain Op-Ed article

I just want to point out, that $15 wouldn't be what you are taxed on, you'd be taxed on the amount your (or your husbands) employer pays on YOUR behalf.

your husband only pay a fraction of the total healthcare costs.

and $600 times 12 is $7200...even if you were eligible for the max deduction, that is still 2200 MORE than what you are being taxed on.

and really, that is not even the true evil behind his plan...it's the deregulating of it and what that could mean.

Posted 9/17/08 12:43 PM
 

KvsGrl
Round 2!!

Member since 1/07

1202 total posts

Name:
Samantha

Re: Spinoff to McCain Op-Ed article

One of the many hats I wore at my last job was the benefit plans administrator. Company costs for health insurance were about $1200 per family and $600 for individuals per month. Employees did not pay anything for health insurance. If I understand the proposal correctly, assumming that you are in the 28% tax bracket, $336 would be deducted from your paycheck if you have a family plan and $168 will be deducted for individuals. That is $4032 or $2016 annually, respectively! I hope this gets the attention it deserves, although I am sure the McCain administration will do what it does best - manipulate the media

Chat Icon

Posted 9/17/08 12:45 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: Spinoff to McCain Op-Ed article

My family pays 350 a month, not including dental.

To add a a tax on our entire price of our coverage plan would bring that up higher.

Add on my deductibles and co-pays...5K per family is a joke.

Posted 9/17/08 12:49 PM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to McCain Op-Ed article

Right now, we are very fortunate. Nothing (except the usual office copayments). This covers DH, me, and our son. We have great access to doctors also, most accept the plan.

Most do not have this sort of benefit though, and there have been times in my life when I have not. We do need to address health care--too many people pay too much or worse, can't pay and have no health care plan.

Posted 9/17/08 12:55 PM
 

CathyB

Member since 5/05

19403 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to McCain Op-Ed article

DH's company only pays half the monthly premium so our monthly contribution before co-pays is about $600 if I remember right. *sigh*

Posted 9/17/08 12:56 PM
 

Shelly
She's 7!!!

Member since 8/05

14624 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to McCain Op-Ed article

I pay $600 for my DH on my job's health insurance. I pay $200 for my daughter separately.

Posted 9/17/08 12:59 PM
 

Beth
The Key to your new home....

Member since 2/06

24849 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Spinoff to McCain Op-Ed article

Posted by cjik

Right now, we are very fortunate. Nothing (except the usual office copayments). This covers DH, me, and our son. We have great access to doctors also, most accept the plan.

Most do not have this sort of benefit though, and there have been times in my life when I have not. We do need to address health care--too many people pay too much or worse, can't pay and have no health care plan.



that's great- but I am sure the company incurs a cost for this- and you would be taxed on that

I used to pay $160 out of pocket- but now that I see my COBRA paperwork the cost is $800

so if I was still working there- I would be taxed on the $800 per month- and would no longer get $160 taken OFF my monthly taxes

Posted 9/17/08 12:59 PM
 

DandN
Twins are here!

Member since 3/06

3597 total posts

Name:
Deirdre

Re: Spinoff to McCain Op-Ed article

I pay approximately $160 a month for my family plan - LOVE my employer and my union!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted 9/17/08 1:03 PM
 

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

Re: Spinoff to McCain Op-Ed article

Posted by Ophelia

I just want to point out, that $15 wouldn't be what you are taxed on, you'd be taxed on the amount your (or your husbands) employer pays on YOUR behalf.

your husband only pay a fraction of the total healthcare costs.

and $600 times 12 is $7200...even if you were eligible for the max deduction, that is still 2200 MORE than what you are being taxed on.

and really, that is not even the true evil behind his plan...it's the deregulating of it and what that could mean.



I understand that we would not be taxed on the $15 but the much larger amount that his company pays. That was really what had me interested, we DID pay tax on what his employer paid towrads my insurance and it was very little - even with a company that makes a very large contribution to our health insurance.

I am not saying I agree with McCain, but I feel , this aspect of the policy is not what should be focused on because it is minor, but it is what will probably grasp the most attention from the general public, because it sounds like it will cost them a lot of money.

I think encouraging people to shop around for insurance is a bad idea, I do agree that we will end up with many more uninsured people.

At this point I really don't agree with what either candidate has had to offer for health care, but I also don't have a solution to offer up myself.

Posted 9/17/08 1:05 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to McCain Op-Ed article

I pay nothing towards my company's health benefits.

DH's benefits cover us as a family. He pays nothing as well. Perk to being union!

Posted 9/17/08 1:16 PM
 

BunnyWife
Insert Witty Comment Here

Member since 5/07

8274 total posts

Name:
BunnyWife

Re: Spinoff to McCain Op-Ed article

DH pays about $275 a year for both of us. He has a VERY good insurance plan. We are very lucky that his company pays so much of it.

Posted 9/17/08 1:31 PM
 

sunnyplus3
:)

Member since 11/05

8749 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to McCain Op-Ed article

Its very difficult for people that have always had employers that pay a large portion or most of their benefits to think of anything other than a system that enables them to have low co-pays & have their premium be taken from pre-tax earnings or be covered entirely by their employer.
Those of us that have owned small businesses and/or worked for small businesses that don't qualify for the low rates of huge group plans think differently.
There are many different ways you can lower your premiums & use accounts like flex & HSAs to cover higher co-pays or deductibles. I believe we need to start self insuring more & relying on freebees less. I wonder how many people that complain heavily about their health insurance premiums have plasmas & Tivos & gas guzzling cars. I'm not buying into the "we can't afford it". Some people can't afford it, most of us HERE can afford it but don't want to because it takes away from other things we'd RATHER spend our money on.
The government is broken, but so is our mentality. My famiy's health is MY responsibilty-not my employers or Uncle Sam's.
I'm not saying I agree with McCain's plan, but at least he admits the government NEEDS to collect tax dollars to keep this country running.
Unlike Obama who plans to allow everyone(including illegal immigrants?) to get 'affordable' insurance with no plan on where the money will actually come from to pay for it. The insurance companies aren't willing to lower their rates & every doctor I've spoken to doesn't want to become a government employee. Someone explain to me what magic Obama has up his sleeve to make THAT work?
We can't keep printing more money....eventually we will pay.

Posted 9/17/08 1:40 PM
 

JRG71
*****************

Member since 5/05

5025 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to McCain Op-Ed article

We pay 179/bi weekly for a family plan thru my DH's plan - It's subsidized thru the hospital he works for.

Posted 9/17/08 1:46 PM
 

Sassyz75
Turning a new page

Member since 5/05

9731 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: Spinoff to McCain Op-Ed article

Posted by KellyFG

Its very difficult for people that have always had employers that pay a large portion or most of their benefits to think of anything other than a system that enables them to have low co-pays & have their premium be taken from pre-tax earnings or be covered entirely by their employer.
Those of us that have owned small businesses and/or worked for small businesses that don't qualify for the low rates of huge group plans think differently.
There are many different ways you can lower your premiums & use accounts like flex & HSAs to cover higher co-pays or deductibles. I believe we need to start self insuring more & relying on freebees less. I wonder how many people that complain heavily about their health insurance premiums have plasmas & Tivos & gas guzzling cars. I'm not buying into the "we can't afford it". Some people can't afford it, most of us HERE can afford it but don't want to because it takes away from other things we'd RATHER spend our money on.
The government is broken, but so is our mentality. My famiy's health is MY responsibilty-not my employers or Uncle Sam's.
I'm not saying I agree with McCain's plan, but at least he admits the government NEEDS to collect tax dollars to keep this country running.
Unlike Obama who plans to allow everyone(including illegal immigrants?) to get 'affordable' insurance with no plan on where the money will actually come from to pay for it. The insurance companies aren't willing to lower their rates & every doctor I've spoken to doesn't want to become a government employee. Someone explain to me what magic Obama has up his sleeve to make THAT work?
We can't keep printing more money....eventually we will pay.



but insurance that is employer sponsored isn't a "freebie"- it is part of the compensation package. I have a hard time believing if health insurance is now taxed, that the employer is going to increase salaries to make up for it.
Also- while I understand your frustration re: our consumer society- we NEED people to buy things (whether you think they are a need or a want) because that consumption is what our economy is based on. If people now have to direct more of their income to health care, what do you think is going to suffer? purchases of other items- this in turn will have a negative impact on the overall economic health of our country- in order for people to be employed- people need to be buying. Taking more money out of people's paychecks isn't going to help that- especially when, down the road, they'll probably (under the McCain plan) have to pay MORE for health insurance.

Posted 9/17/08 1:56 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: Spinoff to McCain Op-Ed article

I am not looking for any "freebies"

I think the majority of Americans with medical bills they are facing aren't looking for "freebies" either.

I am lucky enough to have savings to pay for all of our out of pocket bills. IT was a housefund that was never touched...but you give birth to a baby who took a seizure and has asthma...well there goes our secret housefund.

I am VERY lucky. I am also very compassionate to those who are hardworking, with co-pays and deductibles that find themselves in an unexpected medical crisis.

I guarentee you...a mother of an sick child who is getting hit left and right with bills is not at Best Buy TV shopping.

Its a shame too...hardworking people...who pay for insurance...aren't allowed to buy a TV?? incase someone in their house gets sick?? Chat Icon

Posted 9/17/08 2:03 PM
 

sunnyplus3
:)

Member since 11/05

8749 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to McCain Op-Ed article

Posted by Sassyz75

but insurance that is employer sponsored isn't a "freebie"- it is part of the compensation package. I have a hard time believing if health insurance is now taxed, that the employer is going to increase salaries to make up for it.
Also- while I understand your frustration re: our consumer society- we NEED people to buy things (whether you think they are a need or a want) because that consumption is what our economy is based on. If people now have to direct more of their income to health care, what do you think is going to suffer? purchases of other items- this in turn will have a negative impact on the overall economic health of our country- in order for people to be employed- people need to be buying. Taking more money out of people's paychecks isn't going to help that- especially when, down the road, they'll probably (under the McCain plan) have to pay MORE for health insurance.



purchases of other items are going to suffer anyway because the days of easy, cheap credit for everyone are over. People are going to have to buy what they can afford. I agree that its going to be brutal on our economy for a while. I think individuals should look into what health insurance options are available to them & possibly go outside of the norm with some self insurance.
Secondly when was the last time a president was actually successful in making a change of any kind to our health insurance system?

Posted 9/17/08 2:05 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: Spinoff to McCain Op-Ed article

Posted by KellyFG


Secondly when was the last time a president was actually successful in making a change of any kind to our health insurance system?



Hillary 2012

Posted 9/17/08 2:07 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Spinoff to McCain Op-Ed article

Posted by KellyFG


purchases of other items are going to suffer anyway because the days of easy, cheap credit for everyone are over. People are going to have to buy what they can afford. I agree that its going to be brutal on our economy for a while. I think individuals should look into what health insurance options are available to them & possibly go outside of the norm with some self insurance.
Secondly when was the last time a president was actually successful in making a change of any kind to our health insurance system?



this, I promise you, is a disaster of epic proportions waiting to happen.

it is simply NOT that simple. at all.

Posted 9/17/08 2:11 PM
 

KvsGrl
Round 2!!

Member since 1/07

1202 total posts

Name:
Samantha

Re: Spinoff to McCain Op-Ed article

Posted by Sassyz75

we NEED people to buy things (whether you think they are a need or a want) because that consumption is what our economy is based on.



Ditto. Exactly why the markets are watching Best Buys Earnings release as closely as Lehman/Barclays arrangement today.

Posted 9/17/08 3:47 PM
 

Cpt2007
A new love!

Member since 1/08

5946 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: Spinoff to McCain Op-Ed article

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by KellyFG


purchases of other items are going to suffer anyway because the days of easy, cheap credit for everyone are over. People are going to have to buy what they can afford. I agree that its going to be brutal on our economy for a while. I think individuals should look into what health insurance options are available to them & possibly go outside of the norm with some self insurance.
Secondly when was the last time a president was actually successful in making a change of any kind to our health insurance system?



this, I promise you, is a disaster of epic proportions waiting to happen.

it is simply NOT that simple. at all.



agreed. and it's not as easy as one would think to get coverage in the private sector. you have to fit their idea of "healthy" to even be covered. So let's say, that you happen to be overweight (not obese, just overweight with a slightly higher BMI than you should), you won't be covered. You will be denied coverage b/c the insurance companies will deem you a "risk." So, not only will we have people be uninsured, we'll have ER costs go up b/c people won't have access to preventative care. The market does not and cannot cure all.

Posted 9/17/08 4:24 PM
 

Cpt2007
A new love!

Member since 1/08

5946 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: Spinoff to McCain Op-Ed article

to answer the OPs question, my DH and I each have a self only plan (we are both Fed Govt employees). It is cheaper for us this way than to do self and family. We pay $169 per month for us both for our HMO. We have separate, supplemental dental and vision plans since our HMO's coverage is abysmal.

Posted 9/17/08 4:27 PM
 

SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!

Member since 3/06

32345 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to McCain Op-Ed article

for DH and I, approx $75-80 a month for medical, dental and vision

Posted 9/17/08 9:03 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Good article about homeowners insurance and what's NOT covered SweetestOfPeas 7/20/06 1 Home
Did anyone see this article in the NYTimes casey31 3/23/06 8 Adoption
Interesting article in this month's Parenting magazine (April 2006) CathyB 3/18/06 4 Adoption
Interesting article in this week's People CathyB 3/18/06 1 Infertility
Interesting article regarding IVF casey31 3/16/06 5 Infertility
Interesting article LuckySV 3/15/06 0 Home