Spinoff on boys and manicures.

Posted By Message

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Spinoff on boys and manicures.

OK. I realize this might start a debate, but I hope it doesn't turn into drama, but I really am curious -



ETA: what I am really asking is: Is there a double standard for boys and girls and if so, why does it exist? Has it changed over time?

Message edited 2009-06-27 12:19:06.643000.

Posted 6/27/09 11:48 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Spinoff on boys and manicures.

DS has a kitchen playset outside (it's often his restaurant, and he gives us menus, then gives us plates of his "creations" Chat Icon ). He has his own pretend cooking supplies inside, and he helps DW with cooking. We are trying to get him to join gymnastics this summer, but so far, he doesn't seem to want to. He plays with his sister's dolls, and pushes the doll stroller around.

DD is in karate right now, and I have a feeling she'll be doing a lot of traditional "boy" things as she gets older. She also loves playing with her brother's trucks, water guns and Transformers.

IMO, women LOVE men who can cook. What is more masculine than having women fall all over my son? I think boys who don't learn to cook, or do some traditional "female" activities are missing out on a whole lot of the female population when they get older.

Posted 6/27/09 12:00 PM
 

Ang-Rich
Beyond Compare

Member since 5/05

17988 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff on boys and manicures.

I said that I would let him but I would not like it.

Why I would not like it is really not up for debate. I am entitled to that as I am his parent. But like I said, if he asked I would let him.

We had this debate a while back over uggs...at the end of the day who cares what we each would or would not allow for our own children? So long as I don't push my opinions on another child (and people don't push theirs on mine) I see no reason to go back and forth.


I understand that you may just want to know why someone thinks or acts differently from you but the truth is....everyone has the right to do so. We each shout that out when someone opposes our parenting style...this is no different.

Not wanting my son to have a manicure makes me no less of a good mom.

Posted 6/27/09 12:01 PM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: Spinoff on boys and manicures.

Sure the double standard is alive.

I know grown men who have manicures and I dont think that is weird, but a 6 yr old Boy I do... I wouldnt want my son to have it done, but at the same time I would if it made him happy, thats my ultimate goal....so while the stereotype og Girly vs. Manly might be alive in my mind still I would break it for my son in an instant.

Message edited 2009-06-27 12:10:29.160000.

Posted 6/27/09 12:09 PM
 

Elizabeth
Mom of Three

Member since 9/05

7900 total posts

Name:
"MOMMY!!!"

Re: Spinoff on boys and manicures.

Posted by Ang-Rich

I said that I would let him but I would not like it.

Why I would not like it is really not up for debate. I am entitled to that as I am his parent. But like I said, if he asked I would let him.

We had this debate a while back over uggs...at the end of the day who cares what we each would or would not allow for our own children? So long as I don't push my opinions on another child (and people don't push theirs on mine) I see no reason to go back and forth.


I understand that you may just want to know why someone thinks or acts differently from you but the truth is....everyone has the right to do so. We each shout that out when someone opposes our parenting style...this is no different.

Not wanting my son to have a manicure makes me no less of a good mom.




Amen! ITA. I saw on the other thread, it was beginning bc someone threw this guy out there Chat Icon at someone else's opinion. I almost commented but why bother? Then I saw this thread. Really why does it matter? I said I wouldn't on the other thread but didn't feel the need to go into why. Doesn't make me fearful of my son doing "girly" things, I actually don't see how a manicure for a small boy means the same thing as them going to gymnastics or playing with a play kitchen, etc. I personally just don't see why my son needs to have his cuticles pushed back and his hands soaked by a stranger. Maybe bc I don't bring my DD either... so just bc someone said they won't doesn't mean as much as is being assumed.

Posted 6/27/09 12:12 PM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Spinoff on boys and manicures.

Posted by Ang-Rich

I said that I would let him but I would not like it.

Why I would not like it is really not up for debate. I am entitled to that as I am his parent. But like I said, if he asked I would let him.

We had this debate a while back over uggs...at the end of the day who cares what we each would or would not allow for our own children? So long as I don't push my opinions on another child (and people don't push theirs on mine) I see no reason to go back and forth.


I understand that you may just want to know why someone thinks or acts differently from you but the truth is....everyone has the right to do so. We each shout that out when someone opposes our parenting style...this is no different.

Not wanting my son to have a manicure makes me no less of a good mom.





I TOTALLY wasn't implying that you (or anyone who wouldn't allow their son to do "girly" things) is a bad mom, and I hope I didn't come across that way!!

I was just wondering about the double standard in and why it exists.. I think I am going to edit my post to reflect that more!

Posted 6/27/09 12:18 PM
 

Violet
content

Member since 7/06

1860 total posts

Name:
Mama :)

Re: Spinoff on boys and manicures.

there's definately a double standard for boys and girls, it's just the way our society is. But I will not raise my children that way. My DD will grow up playing with trucks if she wants. She should also help dad mow the lawn, take out the garbage etc... If and when we have a boy, he can totally get a manicure if that's what makes him happy. What is the harm in that?

ETA: I personally do not think kids needs manicures, and only plan to take my children (DD right now) on special occasions. I want them to know that they shouldn't take life's luxuries for granted.

Message edited 2009-06-27 12:27:36.750000.

Posted 6/27/09 12:24 PM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Spinoff on boys and manicures.

I don't see why this post is a problem. We all are a big group of "friends." Aren't these the sort of things people discuss among friends? If you don't want to share or feel it is private then simply don't answer....I come on this board to ask advice about feeding, habits etc. but its also nice to have healthy adult discussion too!

I do think gender roles are alive and well. they are ingrained in a lot of people. I would like to think that I would have no problem with my boys playing with dolls, dancing, getting manicures and I don't think I would, but who knows? I'll get back to you in about 5 years.

Posted 6/27/09 12:30 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Spinoff on boys and manicures.

Posted by Elizabeth

Posted by Ang-Rich

I said that I would let him but I would not like it.

Why I would not like it is really not up for debate. I am entitled to that as I am his parent. But like I said, if he asked I would let him.

We had this debate a while back over uggs...at the end of the day who cares what we each would or would not allow for our own children? So long as I don't push my opinions on another child (and people don't push theirs on mine) I see no reason to go back and forth.


I understand that you may just want to know why someone thinks or acts differently from you but the truth is....everyone has the right to do so. We each shout that out when someone opposes our parenting style...this is no different.

Not wanting my son to have a manicure makes me no less of a good mom.




Amen! ITA. I saw on the other thread, it was beginning bc someone threw this guy out there Chat Icon at someone else's opinion. I almost commented but why bother? Then I saw this thread. Really why does it matter? I said I wouldn't on the other thread but didn't feel the need to go into why. Doesn't make me fearful of my son doing "girly" things, I actually don't see how a manicure for a small boy means the same thing as them going to gymnastics or playing with a play kitchen, etc. I personally just don't see why my son needs to have his cuticles pushed back and his hands soaked by a stranger. Maybe bc I don't bring my DD either... so just bc someone said they won't doesn't mean as much as is being assumed.



yeah, i got the Chat Icon in the other thread. I just dont see the need for it. And frankly was offended by it, bc its condesending and implies that Im outdated, holding my son back from doing things he may enjoy, that Im not "with the times". yes, I play into gender roles.......and I see nothing wrong with that. Im not outdated or close-minded, just traditional.

ETA - my sister and brother and I all grew up with gender roles in place, we played with barbie, while my brother had tonka trucks. We turned out to be well adjusted normal people and are not damaged in anyway from not having trucks or barbies when we were younger. We are not confused as adults, and we dont necessarily play into traditional gender roles as adults....i.e Im more of the bread winner in my family, while DH does the laundry and cooks. So its not that DS isnt exposed toi alternative roles and I think he should be out working while his one day wife is barefoot and pregnant. I was simply talking about toys and activities as children. He is going to be just fine.

Message edited 2009-06-27 12:40:01.807000.

Posted 6/27/09 12:35 PM
 

mommy2B3
2 boys 2 girls!!!!

Member since 7/08

3324 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Spinoff on boys and manicures.

Honestly, my thoughts have and will continue to change. I remember being in middle school and seeing a guy getting a mani and my friends and I were laughing at him, because that was "girly." But then I made DH get a mani/pedi for the wedding, and for certain times that we have been together, that my thought on it changed to not girly, but a cleaner look KWIM? But I still have my guard up a bit about having DS have a doll, I'm not sure what I will do when he is older, but if he wants one I will decide then.

I think we all have to do what is comfortable for us, and our lives. Everyone is different, and we can all learn from eachother, which is my ultimate goal.

Posted 6/27/09 12:46 PM
 

Rycois
Blessed with 2blue/2pink

Member since 12/05

13341 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Spinoff on boys and manicures.

Honestly, I am very "liberal" according to my DH. Not much bothers me and I don't play into the gender specific roles. However, HE does, so I try to pick my battles on what matters to me.

Do I give a cr!p if Ryan wants to dress in my 4-yr old sister's play clothes and carry a purse? Personally, no. But DH would be upset - so I won't be encouraging this play (or bragging about it to DH Chat Icon )

Some things, I've already told DH he'll have to get used to. He made a comment about a boy having a play kitchen. I kindly pointed out to him that he (DH) does the cooking every night in our household, as does his father - so what's the problem? So, we'll compromise and he'll get one with a BBQ attached to it.

I don't think that DH gets that somethings are just "children zone" - not girl, not boy - just children. It's healthy and normal for each gender to play with everything. I find, limiting a child pushes them to rebel - so my theory is to be pretty open minded and let them make their own decisions (within reason and without neglecting parenting responsibilities).

I'm sure DH and I will have some bumps along the way given that we see things differently. He's not SO extreme about it, but it does annoy me that he cares so much about something that is healthy and have already warned him, if we have a daughter, there will never be sep. rules for girl v. boy. He agrees - so at least I know that this is more about his own hang ups and he's not going to be purposely unfair.

Message edited 2009-06-27 12:48:01.277000.

Posted 6/27/09 12:46 PM
 

Elizabeth
Mom of Three

Member since 9/05

7900 total posts

Name:
"MOMMY!!!"

Re: Spinoff on boys and manicures.

Posted by DRMom

I don't see why this post is a problem. We all are a big group of "friends." Aren't these the sort of things people discuss among friends? If you don't want to share or feel it is private then simply don't answer....I come on this board to ask advice about feeding, habits etc. but its also nice to have healthy adult discussion too!




The edit button at work. I am not saying the OP meant anything offensive, I know she was curious and worded it differently than she actually meant it. But the original post sounded more like anyone who said they wouldn't want their son to get a manicure was against them doing "girly" things. I think the post as it stands now is much more of a discussion friendly post.

Posted 6/27/09 12:50 PM
 

Bridex100
Two Under Two Mommy

Member since 3/08

10420 total posts

Name:
Momx100

Re: Spinoff on boys and manicures.

Gender roles are very much still in existence.

I would prefer DS to play with boy toys but if he liked to pay chef or whatever with a kitchen set, that would be fine too.

DH is a guy's guy though. He would probably tell DS not to play with girl toys. We'll have to cross that bridge when we get there.

Posted 6/27/09 12:56 PM
 

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Re: Spinoff on boys and manicures.

I don't think there is a 'double standard' as such.

I think each parent raises their child in a way that makes them comfortable. Some parents feel very strongly about 'appropriate' gender identification, while others care less about that. And I think that there are more parents that are 'flexible' with gender identity for their daughters and less so for their sons. I don't think this is wrong or right.. it just is what it is. If your child is happy, well adjusted and loved - I don't care what choices you make relevant to his or her clothing/activities, etc..

What DOES bother me is when parents can't wrap their heads around why anyone would choose to do things differently than they do. It baffles and upsets me.

I might allow my son to get a manicure but that doesn't make me anymore open minded or better than someone who feels uncomfortable with the idea. It also doesn't make me a better or a worse mom for letting my son test the gender roles. That's how *I* do things. I know FABULOUS mother's who wouldn't allow their son's to have play kitchen's or allow their daughter's to play football. All it says about them is how they feel about gender identity.. it speaks NOTHING about their ability to parent well.

Posted 6/27/09 1:21 PM
 

Bops
My 3 wishes

Member since 12/07

13625 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff on boys and manicures.

Yeah, unfortunately that "double standard" is still very alive and well IMO....Not only in children but with men and women also in many ways...

I didnt respond on the manicure thread, because I don't have a strong feeling about it either way...Heck, I don't even barely get manicures, so for us its such a non -issue Chat Icon ....But if I saw someones elses DS getting one, I wouldnt even bat an eye...

But anyway, my DS took dance when he was 2.5 , plays with kitchen stuff, loves baby dolls, Polly Pockets, tea parties etc...

He also is big into sports, matchbox cars, tools and all the "typically" boy related toys...he doesnt care what it is, as long as he can have fun with it...
And anyone of you that have ever met my DS, know that he is all BOY - with a capitol "B" !

Certain things definately get a raised eyebrow from my DH , but even he is seeing that all these previously thought "gender specific" toys are a bunch of BS and they don't bother him so much...I'm sure my DD will play w/ my DS's transformers and all that stuff too Chat Icon

Posted 6/27/09 1:28 PM
 

ckone
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

3014 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff on boys and manicures.

I am someone that really likes to let my son feel comfortable expressing himself, he only three. When I bought him a play kitchen and people would ask what I was getting him for x-mas some people would react somewhat suprised. Frankly i was surprised...I didn't see the big deal at all. He went through a stage when he was two when he wanted to carry around a purple bag with a diaper in it. I was told by a couple of people that I was brave to let him walk around with a bag ...WHAAAATTTTT..

They last Summer he decided to wear mittens everywhere for about a week and a wool hat. Yes it was 90 degrees but he was so happy and he was safe so I didn't see a big deal.

It's surprising how much of a double standard there really is.

Posted 6/27/09 9:05 PM
 

Ang-Rich
Beyond Compare

Member since 5/05

17988 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff on boys and manicures.

Posted by rojerono

I don't think there is a 'double standard' as such.

I think each parent raises their child in a way that makes them comfortable. Some parents feel very strongly about 'appropriate' gender identification, while others care less about that. And I think that there are more parents that are 'flexible' with gender identity for their daughters and less so for their sons. I don't think this is wrong or right.. it just is what it is. If your child is happy, well adjusted and loved - I don't care what choices you make relevant to his or her clothing/activities, etc..

What DOES bother me is when parents can't wrap their heads around why anyone would choose to do things differently than they do. It baffles and upsets me.

I might allow my son to get a manicure but that doesn't make me anymore open minded or better than someone who feels uncomfortable with the idea. It also doesn't make me a better or a worse mom for letting my son test the gender roles. That's how *I* do things. I know FABULOUS mother's who wouldn't allow their son's to have play kitchen's or allow their daughter's to play football. All it says about them is how they feel about gender identity.. it speaks NOTHING about their ability to parent well.



As always...you said this all so well! Thank you!

Posted 6/27/09 9:48 PM
 

twicethefun
Loving life

Member since 7/06

4088 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff on boys and manicures.

I would not allow my son to have a manicure, but when he is older he can do what he likes.

My son's favorite color was pink until he was about three and suddenly decided he liked blue better. He has had a kitchen since he was one and still considers it his kitchen even though he is now five, never plays with it anymore and has a baby sister who loves it. He has enjoyed baby dolls and play houses as much as my daughter. I have never turned him away from "girls" toys. One of his favorite presents was a vacuum that he got from mom and dad. My husband cooks and cleans (although not as much as me since I only work pt. ) My daughter plays with all her brothers tos, airplanes, superheroes and baseballs. I never discourage her either...and yet.....

My son has short hair, will not be allowed to get his ears pierced until he is eighteen and wears boys clothes (but when he was younger his favorite dress up item was a pink jacket.) My daughter has longer hair, wears bow and clips and girly clothes. She does not have her ears pierced, but probably will be allowed when she is 10 or so.

If someone else wants to get their little boy a manicure or grow his hair long that's totally fine by me...but its not happening with my son. Its not my style, and while he is little he has to live by my rules. Wow I sound like my parentsChat Icon

Message edited 2009-06-28 02:00:24.660000.

Posted 6/28/09 1:51 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
My boys at 6 months old! Michelle 3/21/06 29 Multiple Births
Fun t-shirts and onsies for boys? Jenhos 3/20/06 19 Parenting
Knit christening outfits for boys........ lorimarie 3/15/06 5 Parenting
Our boys are being neutered today... Shanti 3/7/06 7 Pets
Mommies of boys MrsBumbleb 3/3/06 16 Parenting
Moms of big boys my3bugs 2/19/06 8 Parenting