DancinBarefoot
06ers Rock!!
 Member since 1/07 9537 total posts
Name: The One My Mother Gave Me ;-)
|
Spinoff - crunchberries
Court of Appeals of Michigan. William L. FISHER, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. Karen LOWE, Larry Moffet and State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company, Defendants-Appellees. Docket No. 60732. Submitted Nov. 3, 1982. Decided Jan. 10, 1983. Released for Publications May 6, 1983.
A wayward Chevy struck a tree Whose owner sued defendants three. He sued car's owner, driver too, And insurer for what was due For his oak tree that now may bear A lasting need for tender care.
The Oakland County Circuit Court, John N.O'Brien, J., set forth The judgment that defendants sought And quickly an appeal was brought. Court of Appeals, J.H. Gillis, J., Gave thought and then had this to say: 1) There is no liability Since No-Fault grants immunity; 2) No jurisdiction can be found Where process service is not sound; And thus the judgment, as it's termed, Is due to be, and is, Affirmed.
West Headnotes [1] Automobiles 48A 251.13 48A Automobiles 48AV Injuries from Operation, or Use of Highway 48AV(D) Effect of No Fault Statutes 48Ak251.13 k. Vehicles, Persons or Occurrences Within Restrictions. Most Cited Cases
Defendant's Chevy struck a tree- There was no liability; The No-Fault Act comes into play As owner and the driver say; Barred by the Act's immunity, No suit in tort will aid the tree; Although the oak's in disarray, No court can make defendants pay, M.C.L.A. § 500.3135.
[2] Process 313 4 313 Process 313I Nature, Issuance, Requisites, and Validity 313k3 Necessity and Use in Judicial Proceedings 313k4 k. In General. Most Cited Cases
No jurisdiction could be found Where process service was unsound; In personam jurisdiction Was not even legal fiction Where plaintiff failed to well comply With rules of court that did apply. GCR 1963, 105.4.
*418 **67 William L. Fisher, Troy, in pro. per. Romain, Donofrio & Kuck, P.C. by Ernst W. Kuck, Southfield, for defendants-appellees. Before BRONSON, P.J., and V.J. BRENNAN and J.H. GILLIS, JJ.
J.H. GILLIS, Judge.
*419 [1][2] We thought that we would never see A suit to compensate a tree. A suit whose claim in tort is prest Upon a mangled tree's behest; A tree whose battered trunk was prest Against a Chevy's crumpled crest; A tree that faces each new day With bark and limb in disarray; A tree that may forever bear A lasting need for tender care. Flora lovers though we three, We must uphold the court's decree. Affirmed.FN1
FN1. Plaintiff commenced this action in tort against defendants Lowe and Moffet for damage to his “beautiful oak tree” caused when defendant Lowe struck it while operating defendant Moffet's automobile. The trial court granted summary judgment in favor of defendants pursuant to GCR 1963, 117.2(1). In addition, the trial court denied plaintiff's request to enter a default judgment against the insurer of the automobile, defendant State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company. Plaintiff appeals as of right. The trial court did not err in granting summary judgment in favor of defendants Lowe and Moffet. Defendants were immune from tort liability for damage to the tree pursuant to § 3135 of the nofault insurance act. M.C.L. § 500.3135; M.S.A. § 24.13135. The trial court did not err in refusing to enter a default judgment against State Farm. Since it is undisputed that plaintiff did not serve process upon State Farm in accordance with the court rules, the court did not obtain personal jurisdiction over the insurer. GCR 1963, 105.4.
© 2009 Thomson Reuters/West. No Claim to Orig. US Gov. Works.
Message edited 2009-06-06 23:21:47.920000. |