Spanking toddlers
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
Spanking toddlers I know this is probably taboo but Im at my wits end & dont know how else to get my point across. I have NOT hit or spanked my son yet but Im wondering what your opinions are on this topic. Im by no means saying smacking across the face or beating (before I get flamed). Just curious if any of you have gave taps on the bottoms or on the hands & if so has it helped? |
|
Posted 9/23/09 8:30 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Spanking toddlers Spanking is not my cup of tea |
|
Posted 9/23/09 8:33 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking toddlers I smacked his hands or arm a few times and I find it just makes him act out more...and then I feel bad like I'm being a bad example. I don't do it. I try to ignore bad behavior instead, even though sometimes I'm burning up inside and want to smack his little hiney!!!! |
|
Posted 9/23/09 8:37 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking toddlers Posted by DanaRenee I smacked his hands or arm a few times and I find it just makes him act out more...and then I feel bad like I'm being a bad example. I don't do it. I try to ignore bad behavior instead, even though sometimes I'm burning up inside and want to smack his little hiney!!!! Thank you I feel the same way and it makes me feel better that Im not alone
|
|
Posted 9/23/09 8:38 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking toddlers I have spanked him three times now (up until today it was two times) and that's when he really is about to hurt himself - or me and him. |
|
Posted 9/23/09 8:41 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking toddlers Posted by Diana1215 I have spanked him three times now (up until today it was two times) and that's when he really is about to hurt himself - or me and him. I think I've told you when I did it but I'll tell it again First: At the park with Dags and he ran out of the gate and full speed ahead to the street. Once I got a hold of him I spanked his tush. I wanted him to know that was not a joke. He had been going in/out of the park a few times before that and each time I would bring him back -- so he just made a run for it that time. Second: Walking up the stairs to naptime, I was behind him, and all of a sudden he decided to have a tantrum and throw his body backwards - the two of us almost flew down the stairs. Once we got up there he got spanked. Today: He was BADDDD basically something similar to the second spanking happened - I literally thought after we got up the stairs that I was going to have this baby - he was kicking me and hitting me so hard, I couldn't even breathe. I didn't even really spank him though I was too upset. It was a light little tap. I knew about the first 2 incidents. So that sounds reasonable to let him know your serious when he could get hurt. I just find myself refraining all day...it makes me very sad. |
|
Posted 9/23/09 8:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking toddlers I think some situations warrant a spanking. ds is only 1 year so it hasn't happened yet but i'm not totally against it |
|
Posted 9/23/09 8:49 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking toddlers . Message edited 2009-09-24 00:41:07.627000. |
|
Posted 9/23/09 8:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking toddlers I don't believe in spanking kids. I know studies show that kids who are hit are more aggressive. I feel it just makes them act out more and sends the wrong message. It makes them think that you could solve things with violence. I personally want to teach my children that violence is not the way to solve problems. How can I tell them not to fight in school if when they do something at home they get a smack? |
|
Posted 9/23/09 8:58 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking toddlers Thanks everyone....I really really do not ever want to hit him....just get so frustrated. |
|
Posted 9/23/09 9:55 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking toddlers I have had two occassions where I have spanked DS on the backside...two that I remember clearly. Although there will always be regret on my part it was effective. I prefer not to do it but when push comes to shove I have and will again if necessary. |
|
Posted 9/23/09 10:23 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking toddlers Posted by Ang-Rich I have had two occassions where I have spanked DS on the backside...two that I remember clearly. Although there will always be regret on my part it was effective. I prefer not to do it but when push comes to shove I have and will again if necessary. Thank you.... |
|
Posted 9/23/09 10:44 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking toddlers This is something I have trouble with there are somethings that I think could warrant a spanking but sadly the little girl I watch gets spanked and I have to say she is more aggressive. I saw her get spanked once and turned around and hit her mother back. So I have made the choice not to do it. I have found that when time outs seem like I am not getting anywhere I find that sitting him down on the couch and talking not yelling to him about his bad behavior will nip the problem in the bud. Or usually if DS is being bad he is usually craving my attention so he will go in time out while I play with his toys.Usually that will make him behave to play with me. Good Luck with your decision. I am sure what ever one you make will be the right one. |
|
Posted 9/23/09 11:27 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking toddlers I don't see how I could teach her not to hit if I spank her. I'm using timeouts and taking things away. |
|
Posted 9/23/09 11:34 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking toddlers I was spanked as a child, for severe behavior such as that another poster described... where it endangered myself or others or both. I was FAR from an aggressive type of person, and a confident adult with just as many issues as anyone else. Of course there is always concern it can be overused as in the crime doesn't fit the punishment sort of thing. I'm pretty sure if my DD's ran into traffic I may react pretty strongly, being as I haven't been in that situation yet I can't say nor would I dare judge anyone else. I'm not sure kids get it when it comes to serious danger like that though. I also know, my mom used to spank then discuss what happened, like a debriefing. Making sure we understood why she did it and making sure we never did the thing we did again. I was never spanked for anything mundane. Not promoting it and again, I hope I would never, I could never imagine doing it to DD's b/c the last thing I'd ever want to do is be the cause of something that would hurt them, but again in an extreme situation where I could have lost either of them forever, I may react in a way I never would think I would. Maybe I'd even "spank"/kick myself if I didn't react strongly enough the first time and they're ended up being a second time that we weren't so lucky to live to tell about. Just my thoughts. |
|
Posted 9/23/09 11:36 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking toddlers Posted by jprimrose I don't believe in spanking kids. I know studies show that kids who are hit are more aggressive. I feel it just makes them act out more and sends the wrong message. It makes them think that you could solve things with violence. I personally want to teach my children that violence is not the way to solve problems. How can I tell them not to fight in school if when they do something at home they get a smack? I also don't believe it is morally right to hit children. I do not believe in inflicting physical pain on someone as a punishment. JMO I agree with this 100% I also think that if we want to teach our children respect we need to respect them and IMO hitting/spanking, etc are not respectful to any person. |
|
Posted 9/24/09 12:02 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking toddlers Posted by maybesoon I think some situations warrant a spanking. ds is only 1 year so it hasn't happened yet but i'm not totally against it I agree. AJ is 1 too. I was spanked. I didnt turn out aggressive - actually the opposite mostly - too timid. I had (and hopefully still have some) very good manners and was pretty much well behaved in fear of a spanking. It didn't damage me. I was taught respect and manners this way. Big deal? I'm talking about my father, my mother is a separate issue. My dad made our spankings into lessons where we had to wait for him (and calm down) and think about what we did .. then explain to him why we were about to get hit. Spontaneous spankings in public (back when parents could/would do that) were always when I was being bad (hiding in the coat racks, throwing a tantrum, backtalking) or if I was being stupid (playing too close to a street, etc) still I can say mostly he just yelled at us and threatened to hit us. *shrug* I dunno but i think right now without having come to that point yet that I am not ruling out a good spanking. Yeah so flame away. *sigh* |
|
Posted 9/24/09 12:23 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking toddlers I do not feel that ever hitting your child is acceptable. I can totally realte to the frustration but IMO hitting your child is having an adult temper tantrum. Become more consitent with the time outs, if they won't sit for them I would hold them in my lap facing out and ignoring them and it helped them get used to it and accept that they were not going to get my attention for negative behavior. THe times I have flet this close to spanking or hitting them I realize that I am the one that is frustrated and can not think clearly. I was spanked as a child and I will never inflict that on my child EVER. |
|
Posted 9/24/09 5:32 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking toddlers Posted by Xelindrya Posted by maybesoon I think some situations warrant a spanking. ds is only 1 year so it hasn't happened yet but i'm not totally against it I was spanked. I didnt turn out aggressive - actually the opposite mostly - too timid. I had (and hopefully still have some) very good manners and was pretty much well behaved in fear of a spanking. It didn't damage me. I was taught respect and manners this way. Big deal? Same here!! I was spanked as a child as well as others in my family and DH family and we turned out very well. We are very gentle and well mannered. I only slapped my daughter on her hands twice and it was necessary to do so. However, I do not spank her for every little thing that she does. Also, for the studies that proved that kids who are spanked are more aggressive I very much disgaree with them. I know quite a few kids who are not spanked and they are VERY aggressive and always hitting others and their tempers are disgusting. These studies are not always correct.
|
|
Posted 9/24/09 6:37 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking toddlers I don't beleive in spanking my child. (I grew up in a household of spanking ~ my brothers got it alot and I was allways in fear ~ I don't want my son to grow up and feel like that) |
|
Posted 9/24/09 9:22 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking toddlers Posted by Xelindrya Posted by maybesoon My dad made our spankings into lessons where we had to wait for him (and calm down) and think about what we did .. then explain to him why we were about to get hit. Wow I just had a flash back I do not want to spank but not completely against it. I would recommend to anyone if they are going to spank calm down first and not to spank out of anger or fustration. I can remember standing with my brother infront of my dad waiting for our spanking (normally it was both my bro & I getting in trouble together that warrented a spanking) Although I will never forget being spanked by my mom for something I didnt do! (as my brother watched and waited to til she was done before he told the truth! 30 yrs later she still feels horrible about it |
|
Posted 9/24/09 9:42 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking toddlers Not something I plan on doing (I was spanked occasionally as a kid and it didn't emotionally scar me, I just want to TRY to never to it with my kids). Message edited 2009-09-24 10:19:23.583000. |
|
Posted 9/24/09 10:18 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking toddlers Posted by Frankiesmom Posted by DanaRenee I smacked his hands or arm a few times and I find it just makes him act out more...and then I feel bad like I'm being a bad example. I don't do it. I try to ignore bad behavior instead, even though sometimes I'm burning up inside and want to smack his little hiney!!!! Thank you I feel the same way and it makes me feel better that Im not alone Your welcome! I just re-read my post and its not that I "ignore" the bad behavior, lol, I try to sit him in the time out chair and tell him that the behavior is unacceptable, over and over again if I have to! ...even tho I still want to smack his little butt!! |
|
Posted 9/24/09 10:20 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spanking toddlers I personally wouldnt do it unless he had put himself in SERIOUS danger, like running out into the middle of a busy road. |
|
Posted 9/24/09 10:33 AM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stride Rite... I don't get it! Dress shoes for toddlers UPDATE!!!! | smdl | 9/23/09 | 5 | Parenting |
| Toddlers that are finished with their crib | -DonnaMarie- | 3/6/06 | 3 | Parenting |
| What do your toddlers drink during the day? | MichaelsMommy | 3/3/06 | 6 | Parenting |
| SAHM's of Toddlers | ddunne2 | 2/3/06 | 1 | Parenting |
| Mommies with older kids AND toddlers.... | MrsERod | 1/10/06 | 14 | Parenting |
| Do your toddlers "get" the whole Santa/Christmas thing? | Ambersmom | 12/23/05 | 7 | Parenting |














These studies are not always correct.


30 yrs later she still feels horrible about it
