Spanking an almost 2-yr old

Posted By Message

LInative
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

1977 total posts

Name:
Cassie

Spanking an almost 2-yr old

So, DH, DS and I are spending Labor Day week in a beach house w/2 other couples. One is my BFF, her DH, and their baby. The other couple are THEIR friends and 2 yr old DD. I have met them 2 times but they live OOS so we're not close. My BFF shared w/me that they are not in a happy marriage, the DH is like a child and the wife picks up his slack (he is "between jobs" for an extended period of time, spends money like water, gets drunk w/his friends often etc.) Then my BFF said this mom "spanks" her DD, (probably out of frustration) and that one time she admitted she thought she hit her too hard. I was floored/mortified etc. I don't want to debate about the wrongness of this bc I think it's clear how I feel. The problem is I'm nervous that I may witness something during our vacation and am not sure how to handle it. I am leery of stepping into anyone's parenting business, but DH says he will definitely intervene if the child is being abused Chat Icon What is the right thing to do here?? I am sick thinking about it.

Message edited 2008-08-11 16:02:57.020000.

Posted 8/11/08 3:47 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

CookiePuss
Cake from Outer Space!

Member since 5/05

14021 total posts

Name:

Re: Spanking a 2 yr old

I agree with Dh, if the child is being abuse I would report it. If the mother is spanking within reason, I wouldn't say anything as that is her parenting style even though I might not agree with it.

Posted 8/11/08 3:50 PM
 

LInative
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

1977 total posts

Name:
Cassie

Re: Spanking a 2 yr old

You make a good point. I just hate to think what goes on behind closed doors.

Posted 8/11/08 3:53 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Spanking a 2 yr old

I think there is a difference between child abuse & spanking. It is a family decision on how they chose to discipline their child.

Sounds like a stressful Labor Day weekend to me.

Posted 8/11/08 3:55 PM
 

FelAndJon
needs to update her avatar pic

Member since 6/05

10212 total posts

Name:
Felice (aka LuckyBride2004)

Re: Spanking a 2 yr old

Posted by nrthshgrl

I think there is a difference between child abuse & spanking. It is a family decision on how they chose to discipline their child.

Sounds like a stressful Labor Day weekend to me.



I agree with this statement. I don't believe in hitting as punishment and that works for my family. That isn't to say that it does or doesn't work for other families.

I just wish you luck over the long weekend!Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 8/11/08 3:58 PM
 

LInative
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

1977 total posts

Name:
Cassie

Re: Spanking a Not yet 2-yr old

You're right! I just got the impression from my friend that the mom can't handle the baby on her own and resorts to this out of frustration. She isn't even 2 yet, will be 2 in Sept. I guess I will bite my tongue - my friend should be the one to address it if anything.

Posted 8/11/08 3:59 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Spanking a 2 yr old

There is spanking and spanking. If there is clear mean spirited spanking and much stronger than a little tap, I would open my mouth for sure.

It's not about parental style at that point.

Posted 8/11/08 4:00 PM
 

LIMOMx2
...

Member since 5/05

24989 total posts

Name:

Re: Spanking a 2 yr old

Spanking is way different then child abuse in my book if it is done within reason.

I was spanked as a child but I was in no way abused!!!

Posted 8/11/08 4:01 PM
 

Luv2bAmom
LIF Adult

Member since 2/08

1255 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Spanking a 2 yr old

I think that there is a HUGE gap between spanking and child abuse.

If a child is being abused then heck yeah step in, but if its just a a mother choosing spanking as a way to discipling her child well that is her own parenting style then I say stay out of it, think about it, you would not like her telling you how to raise your child, would you?

Message edited 2008-08-11 16:04:42.047000.

Posted 8/11/08 4:03 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Spanking an almost 2-yr old

Aw, that's rough. I'm not one to impose how I feel about other's parenting styles on them, so I wouldn't say anything at all unless the child was being abused. I do not think that spanking=child abuse unless it is someone who is clearly out of control. If you are that stressed out over it, I would consider not going. What's the point if you're just going to stress? On the other hand, maybe having all the kids together will be a relief for the mom.Chat Icon

Posted 8/11/08 4:07 PM
 

stickydust
Now a mommy of 2!!!

Member since 4/06

3164 total posts

Name:

Re: Spanking an almost 2-yr old

Posted by 5ofClubs

Spanking is way different then child abuse in my book if it is done within reason.

I was spanked as a child but I was in no way abused!!!



I completely agree with this! I do not think the mere act of spanking is tantamount to abuse. While it is not how I choose to discipline I think there is a clear difference between that and BEATING a child.

My parents spanked me and may sometimes have even lost their cool but I was certainly not abused. Honestly, unless you witness them actually beating their child I would just MYOB.

Posted 8/11/08 4:08 PM
 

LInative
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

1977 total posts

Name:
Cassie

Re: Spanking an almost 2-yr old

Posted by Luv2bAmom

you would not like her telling you how to raise your child, would you?



No I would not. But this child isn't even 2 yet (she will be in Sept) and knowing the family situation I just feel really bad for her...but I also don't think it's my place to step in. I am sure they wont do anything in front of us....and we're on vaca so maybe the stress factor wont be there as much.

Posted 8/11/08 4:11 PM
 

JRD2008
CT. here we come!!

Member since 5/08

2944 total posts

Name:
Kathleen

Re: Spanking an almost 2-yr old

Posted by stickydust

Posted by 5ofClubs

Spanking is way different then child abuse in my book if it is done within reason.

I was spanked as a child but I was in no way abused!!!



I completely agree with this! I do not think the mere act of spanking is tantamount to abuse. While it is not how I choose to discipline I think there is a clear difference between that and BEATING a child.

My parents spanked me and may sometimes have even lost their cool but I was certainly not abused. Honestly, unless you witness them actually beating their child I would just MYOB.



ITA with both of these statements

Posted 8/11/08 4:11 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
For those who flew with your baby's how old were they? mishy 3/24/06 11 Parenting
Old House or New? lululu 3/23/06 28 Home
Swimming lesson for 16 month old?? KSJ1210 3/22/06 1 Parenting
8 - 10 month old moms - Nap question MM2004 3/22/06 10 Parenting
More Nostalgia - Old School Playgrounds!!! usuk2004 3/22/06 38 Families Helping Families ™
My boys at 6 months old! Michelle 3/21/06 29 Multiple Births