So my nephew got engaged-advice please

Posted By Message

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

So my nephew got engaged-advice please

He's living with his boss now because living with his mom got to be too much.

He has a job, no benefits and has no money. The job is dead end. He is signing up for the reserves and hopes to get called for the police test.

He wants to get his fiancee a ring. Today he spoke to his father and asked to borrow $1K for a ring.

Since dad and I are POA for him, he had to ask us. His dad wants to loan him the money but the kid has no money and can't even pay his cell phone bill.

He has good intentions but he is not in reality. He said he would pay it back $100 week for 10 weeks.

I am inclined to say no. I think if he showed he can handle money, there wouldn't be an issue. His credit is shot from using credit cards and not paying them.

I know it's perfectly acceptable for his dad to give him the money and leave it at that but I think the kid needs a reality check. If he can pay $100 a week to his dad for the loan, then why can't he wait 10 weeks and save up for the ring like a responsible person?

He's 22 and I know that a lot of people get married at that age, but they have their act together much more.

I'm torn..I want to be happy for them, but I know this situation is messed up. If she is worth anything, she will wait for the ring. She's 24 and they have been together for 6 months. She lives at home.



Message edited 2008-06-07 17:06:05.220000.

Posted 6/7/08 4:57 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: So my nephew got engaged-advice please

Posted by Blu-ize

He's living with his boss now because living with his mom got to be too much.

He has a job, no benefits and has no money. The job is dead end. He is signing up for the reserves and hopes to get called for the police test.

He wants to get his fiancee a ring. Today he spoke to his father and asked to borrow $1K for a ring.

Since dad and I are POA for him, he had to ask us. His dad wants to loan him the money but the kid has no money and can't even pay his cell phone bill.

He has good intentions but he is not in reality. He said he would pay it back $100 week for 10 weeks.

I am inclined to say no. I think if he showed he can handle money, there wouldn't be an issue. His credit is shot from using credit cards and not paying them.

I know it's perfectly acceptable for his dad to give him the money and leave it at that but I think the kid needs a reality check. If he can pay $100 a week to his dad for the loan, then why can't he wait 10 weeks and save up for the ring like a responsible person?

He's 22 and I know that a lot of people get married at that age, but they have their act together much more.

I'm torn..I want to be happy for them, but I know this situation is messed up. If she is worth anything, she will wait for the ring. She's 24 and they have been together for 6 months. She lives at home.






It's simple. If he can afford $100 a week for 10 weeks, his fiancee will look forward to a ring in late August. it's not that long. I would NOT loan him the money. it teaches no responsibility.

Posted 6/7/08 5:07 PM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: So my nephew got engaged-advice please

I agree with this, but his dad wants to do it. I feel for him.

Dad and I are in charge of his father's money since his illness..brain injury. MY brother has never been good with money to begin with..I guess I want to save him from himself.

So I thought his dad could give him an engagment gift of say $200 and then he can save the rest for the ring.

I have a call into his mother..waiting to hear what she says.

The kid can't even pay his cell phone bill on time. He has 0 money in the bank.

Posted 6/7/08 5:11 PM
 

frosty
LIF Toddler

Member since 5/05

462 total posts

Name:

Re: So my nephew got engaged-advice please

How about a compromise? Have him save up $500, and let his dad lend him the other half.

Posted 6/7/08 5:21 PM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: So my nephew got engaged-advice please

Posted by frosty

How about a compromise? Have him save up $500, and let his dad lend him the other half.



This is a good idea too.

He needs to show some responsibility. As we all know well, he will NEED these skills in marriage.

Posted 6/7/08 5:24 PM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: So my nephew got engaged-advice please

Posted by frosty

How about a compromise? Have him save up $500, and let his dad lend him the other half.



that's what my dad suggested, but frankly I don't think he's seeing that money back any time soon. No matter what is loaned, I think it will never be re-paid.

It's more about responsibility than the money.

Posted 6/7/08 5:25 PM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: So my nephew got engaged-advice please

I don't know what the rush is...I'll find out later.

Posted 6/7/08 5:25 PM
 

SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!

Member since 3/06

32345 total posts

Name:

Re: So my nephew got engaged-advice please

what's the rush? wait until you can afford the ring and then get it.

Posted 6/7/08 6:10 PM
 

TJLealand3
LIF Adolescent

Member since 6/07

839 total posts

Name:
Thomas

Re: So my nephew got engaged-advice please

Smack him he's 22!!!!!!

Posted 6/7/08 6:47 PM
 

Beth
The Key to your new home....

Member since 2/06

24849 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: So my nephew got engaged-advice please

how does he plan on getting married when he doesn't even have $1K for a ring?

has he thought about where they are going to live? how they are going to pay for it?

I think he needs a strong dose of reality


Posted 6/7/08 7:30 PM
 

seaside
LIF Adult

Member since 6/08

3101 total posts

Name:

Re: So my nephew got engaged-advice please

Posted by Beth1210

how does he plan on getting married when he doesn't even have $1K for a ring?

has he thought about where they are going to live? how they are going to pay for it?

I think he needs a strong dose of reality





ITA. For his own good.

Posted 6/7/08 7:32 PM
 

donegal419
St. Gerard, pray for us.

Member since 7/07

7650 total posts

Name:
K

Re: So my nephew got engaged-advice please

i don't think the ring is the issue. many people get engaged and married without ever having an engagement ring, as nice as they might be.

First of all, he's so young. what's the rush and they've only been together for 6 months. that's not a long time at that age.

also, i think the bigger issue is how can he possibly get married and not save $1,000???? how will he pay for rent, utitlies, health care and other incidentals? how would they pay for a wedding, should they want a formal affair??

i think someone needs to sit down and talk with him about his reasons for wanting to get married and help him have a fruitful engagement (getting a better job, setting goals (job wise and savings wise), etc. etc.

If i were his fiancee i would much prefer that he get himself together than a ring.

Posted 6/7/08 7:36 PM
 

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: So my nephew got engaged-advice please

if he can afford to 'pay back' $100 a week, he can afford to save that for 10 weeks and then buy here the ring .....

Posted 6/7/08 7:38 PM
 

Jackie24
~We Did it~

Member since 7/06

6718 total posts

Name:
Jackie

Re: So my nephew got engaged-advice please

Susan, I think your gut instinct on this is right, he can wait ten weeks to get engaged and save up the 1k himself, if he can not do it then hopefully he will realize that this is not a priority. He may be a bit P'oed but it will teach him a lesson in the end.......coming from a 24 year old Chat Icon

Posted 6/7/08 7:55 PM
 

Dulcinea
Weekend Warrior

Member since 3/08

2530 total posts

Name:
Dulcinea

Re: So my nephew got engaged-advice please

I agree with the others here. If he can't even save up for a ring now how is he gonna save up for the wedding expenses and their first place together after they're married!

Alot of young people these days wait until they are financially ready before getting married, he needs to do the same.

If you help him now it's only gonna teach him to come to you again in the future when he needs another loan or handout.

Posted 6/7/08 10:49 PM
 

SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!

Member since 3/06

32345 total posts

Name:

Re: So my nephew got engaged-advice please

Posted by Dulcinea

I agree with the others here. If he can't even save up for a ring now how is he gonna save up for the wedding expenses and their first place together after they're married!

Alot of young people these days wait until they are financially ready before getting married, he needs to do the same.

If you help him now it's only gonna teach him to come to you again in the future when he needs another loan or handout.

ITA!

Posted 6/7/08 11:08 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: So my nephew got engaged-advice please

It's not about agreeing with his choices, it's a purely a financial decision. While it isn't a lot of money, he has no credit & is a poor choice for a loan.

Sounds like you need to decide as POA, do you act as your brother would on that request had he not been injured or do you act in his best interests?

If it were me, he would be waiting to August - and I would explain exactly why.

I don't envy your position. Being the bad guy always sucksChat Icon

Message edited 2008-06-08 07:47:38.973000.

Posted 6/8/08 12:10 AM
 

jax1023
LIF Adult

Member since 3/07

1165 total posts

Name:
Jackie

Re: So my nephew got engaged-advice please

My DH and I got engaged when I was 23 and he was 25, so not to much older than your nephew. He bought me a ring out of his savings, its not huge, its a nice size, but it was becauase he loves me. We're not into loans, so that wasnt an option

If he really loves this girl and they really want to get married, why does she need a 1k ring? Its just a symbol and that seems like a lot of money. He could go buy her a tine ring or a sapphire for 200 dollars and the meaning would be there.

I would say no and remind him its not about the money or the size of the ring.

At the very least if you decide to loan him the $, I would go with him to buy the ring, just to make 100% sure that is where the $ is going

Posted 6/8/08 12:18 AM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: So my nephew got engaged-advice please

I arranged to give him an engagement gift of $200 from his dad. After all, his father would do that regardless.

He has been talking about getting a second job for months to help get himself on his feet and he mentioned it tonight again.

He explained that he blew it by asking her to marry him w/o a ring. She's getting pressure from her co-workers and family that they're not really engaged until she has a ring. She picked out a setting and they agreed to put a CZ in it. that would be about $1K.

He feels the pressure to produce a ring. I asked him to save $100 a week until he can afford it. With the $200 he would only have to save for 8 weeks..I asked him if this was an option..he said no..his fiancee was Poed..I told him..then she ain't worth it jack!

I told him when he gets his part time second job and he has socked away some money in the bank, we will re-visit the loan..when I'm reasonably sure he's serious about his financial responsibility. I also offered to help him budget to afford the impending financial responsibilities ahead.

They are both so young and think they have it all figured out. Was I this naive?

He took her for a walk, came back, his dad gave him the $200 check and they both were happy. She was in tears..she was touched by the gift.

I played the bad cop here. Someone had to. I hope he does get that job and gets straightened out. He looked like he was going to cry when I turned him down.

Posted 6/8/08 12:54 AM
 

JandJ1224

Member since 6/06

5911 total posts

Name:
Jannette

Re: So my nephew got engaged-advice please

The same thing just came up with my sister, I said when he has enough saved for a ring then he can get a ring. I don't think its a good idea to put it on a cc or in your case lend the money. The ring is just the beg. the wedding is the expensive part, best to learn to be responsible and save now.

Posted 6/8/08 1:10 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
i have to share... pics of my nephew Tyler aliwnec10 4/21/08 15 Parenting
xpost on my nephew.. he had another set back need prayers janet 3/30/08 0 Prayers
I'm sorry but my nephew is adorable!!! (PIC FIXED!!) My3Shmoos 12/17/07 8 Parenting
RP from NFR- I need ideas of what to do Friday w/ my 11 1/2 year old nephew BMonster 8/24/06 1 Parenting
PLEASE help me come up with some ideas of what I can do with my nephew tomorrow? BMonster 8/24/06 11 Families Helping Families ™
here are 2 pics of me when i was a baby&little everyone says my niece and nephew look like me when i was young luvsbob4603 1/10/06 20 Families Helping Families ™