Sloan Kettering?!?

Posted By Message

BaysideForever
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

9976 total posts

Name:

Sloan Kettering?!?

Anyone have experience with sloan kettering? was your experience good or bad? please message me or post here.

Posted 1/5/15 1:38 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

tourist

Member since 5/05

10425 total posts

Name:

Re: Sloan Kettering?!?

Yes- I was treated there in 2012 & 2013 & continue to go for follow ups.

I highly recommend. Every situation is different, but for me, both the medical care & the level of service were excellent.

Posted 1/5/15 1:57 PM
 

hmm
Sweet

Member since 1/14

8016 total posts

Name:

Sloan Kettering?!?

I am editing to re-word. I realized I didn't answer your question and after reading what I wrote I did not like they way it sounded. I know my original post was reposted.

I have not used Sloan I only know others who have. Both went in for breast cancer. one chose Sloan bc her cousin was is an MD at sloan, the other person bc her SIL in an RN at Sloan. Both had different experiences, which can happen anyplace. One they missed a few spots and she had to go back in for surgery.

As someone who has been in the healthcare system, from what I know Sloan can be very selective as to the type of cases they will take on, they have a tendency to only like cases that will be successful.

I am in no way stating the care received will be poor.


Message edited 2015-01-05 21:54:19.317000.

Posted 1/5/15 2:27 PM
 

Daisy32
Mommy

Member since 2/08

8081 total posts

Name:

Re: Sloan Kettering?!?

Posted by tourist

Yes- I was treated there in 2012 & 2013 & continue to go for follow ups.

I highly recommend. Every situation is different, but for me, both the medical care & the level of service were excellent.


I agree. My husband was there in 2008. It wasnt a severe case...no radiation or chemo needed but the care he received was excellent.

Posted 1/5/15 2:29 PM
 

sunnyflies
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

1757 total posts

Name:

Sloan Kettering?!?

I was at Sloan Kettering in NYC in 2012 for breast cancer surgery and the care I got was excellent. It is a big place so it can feel overwhelming, but the staff runs it well and are friendly. Be prepared to wait at times. Bring a book.

I had radiation at its Commack center which is very welcoming and well run too. I did go elsewhere for chemo simply because I wanted to use cold caps to save my hair - which I was able to do - and at the time MSK wouldn't allow them. They do now.

Friends took their DD to MSK's NYC location for a second opinion after surgery at Stoneybrook, and doing so probably saved her life as not enough of her tumor had been removed.

Message edited 2015-01-05 18:45:38.780000.

Posted 1/5/15 6:40 PM
 

imyself

Member since 10/06

2938 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Sloan Kettering?!?

My dad and sister were both treated there. The doctors at Sloan saved their lives. I would go in a heartbeat if the need ever arises.

Posted 1/5/15 7:23 PM
 

Jacksmommy
My love muffin!

Member since 1/07

5819 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: Sloan Kettering?!?

Posted by hmm

sloan is not what it use to be years ago, even 10 yrs ago. People think they only take on the tough cases but thats not true. They ONLY take on cases they know they can help, cure etc. In other words, they only take on cases where it will be successful, as it help their numbers. Just know this when going to them, you can get the same care and maybe better elsewhere.

I do know people who had family (MD) work there and they really missed a lot during surgery etc.

I dont want to take away from the poster above Tourist, and her success.




This has been the case for a long time...when I was in 3rd grade they refused to treat my uncle.

Posted 1/5/15 7:36 PM
 

Anxious3
LIF Infant

Member since 1/13

164 total posts

Name:
floof

Sloan Kettering?!?

They saved my husband's uncle's life when no one else would touch him. The doctors there are at the very top of their fields. MSK has been consistently in the top 3 cancer treatment hospitals for decades for a reason.

Posted 1/5/15 8:19 PM
 

hmm
Sweet

Member since 1/14

8016 total posts

Name:

Sloan Kettering?!?

Message edited 2015-01-05 20:40:18.353000.

Posted 1/5/15 8:34 PM
 

aliwnec10
mom of 3 boys

Member since 4/06

11426 total posts

Name:
Ali

Re: Sloan Kettering?!?

my husband had surgery there and continues to go for checkups every 6 months.

Couldn't have been happier with his care and treatment.

Posted 1/5/15 8:36 PM
 

blessedmama2014
LIF Infant

Member since 10/14

226 total posts

Name:

Sloan Kettering?!?

I have family and friends who have been treated at MSK and can attest that patients receive amazing care, the entire staff is very caring and compassionate and the doctors are the best.

Posted 1/5/15 11:00 PM
 

mnmsoinlove
Mommy to 2 sweet girls!

Member since 3/09

8585 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Sloan Kettering?!?

My grandma will be seen there on Friday and we are hoping they will help her. Her doctors are basically throwing in the towel but we have been contacted by the doctors at Sloan saying they may be able to help. We are praying they will take her on.

Posted 1/6/15 7:27 AM
 

EclecticEsq10810
Bored Esq.

Member since 10/10

2156 total posts

Name:
L.

Re: Sloan Kettering?!?

They are a class act and I go for treatment there now (Commack) just for follow ups and CT scans after getting surgery at another hospital where their pathologist over-read the organs removed from surgery and claimed I had cancer Chat Icon (MSKCC pathology ruled it out and just said it was borderline that doesnt require chemo). They scheduled me for an appointment within ONE day of me calling which is better than a lot of other oncologists who put me on a month long waiting list just to see a doctorChat Icon. I def give MSKCC props for being excellent about this, especially for people who need to get treatment quickly and cant afford to sit and wait weeks for an appt.

Posted 1/6/15 8:14 AM
 

HomeIsWithU
Baby #2 on the way!

Member since 9/07

7816 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: Sloan Kettering?!?

My dad was treated at Sloan Kettering in NYC about 5 years ago for throat cancer. When no one else would touch him and they basically said it was hopeless, SK ended up saving his life. Believe it or not, they worked with NYU medical to put him through a trial that ended up working and then Sloan Kettering followed up with all the chemo treatments and follows ups during the trial. So, I would highly recommend both SK and NYU.

Posted 1/6/15 9:23 AM
 

ISpoilHim
I think I got this

Member since 11/10

1523 total posts

Name:
K

Sloan Kettering?!?

Everyone's experience is different.

IN 2012 we took my mom there. It was a process just to get an appt. She had lung cancer which had metastasized to the brain and the bones. The staff was fine and friendly. It was the actual doctor that she saw that I had a problem with. He was cold and lacked compassion. After a month long wait, she was seen only by a primary care doctor.
They knew before they scheduled the appt that they could not help her (they required that we forward all medical records prior to the appt being scheduled). It was a hard day for her and a lot of stress on her at the time.

A lot of people recommended that we take her there. But for us, it was a complete waste of time. We all would have just preferred honesty from the beginning.

But like I said everyone's experience is different. It has a lot to do with the type/stage of cancer. I am so glad for all the people that they have been able to help over the years, that is just not our experience.

Posted 1/6/15 9:43 AM
 

PearlJamChick
No one sings like you anymore.

Member since 7/10

9264 total posts

Name:
Petticoated Swashbuckler

Re: Sloan Kettering?!?

My personal experience with Sloan was a nightmare. On the administrative level, they didn't have me complete the new patient forms (not the insurance ones - the ones where they ask about lifestyle, ie., smoking, drinking, etc...they just told me that they don't really matter), they had my slides for weeks and basically refused to give them back to me in a timely manner - and then when I was scheduled to come in and get them, they couldn't find them...though they were SITTING RIGHT THERE ON THE RECEPTIONIST'S DESK the whole time. Chat Icon When it came to meeting the doctor, she told me this: "you could do chemo first or surgery first...it doesn't really matter" and "here's my card, email me if you have any more questions" Just kind of brushed me off. Like having stage three breast cancer is no biggie. They also would not let me see another doctor for a more concrete evaluation. It was one and done.

It was bizarre and incredibly stressful in what was already the most stressful time of my life. I broke out in my first case of hives ever because of the way they treated me (about the slides.)

I am friends with girls who have went there and are currently going there for treatment and many of them are unhappy, but feel that it's too late to change, at least right now while they are in treatment. On the other hand, I am friends with a few people who have gone there for years and love it.

Luckily, I had already met with doctors at NYU who were like steamrollers in terms of giving me a detailed treatment plan, getting me in for the MRI, PET/CT, other tests, etc. They didn't act like I was a cookie-cutter case.

Sloan does amazing things. I would never say that they don't. People I know are alive because of them. It just was not the right fit for me. Acting like my cancer was not a big deal was not the road I wanted to start on for my treatment.

Posted 1/6/15 10:16 AM
 

alli3131
Peanut is here!!!!!!

Member since 5/09

18388 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Sloan Kettering?!?

Posted by PearlJamChick

My personal experience with Sloan was a nightmare. On the administrative level, they didn't have me complete the new patient forms (not the insurance ones - the ones where they ask about lifestyle, ie., smoking, drinking, etc...they just told me that they don't really matter), they had my slides for weeks and basically refused to give them back to me in a timely manner - and then when I was scheduled to come in and get them, they couldn't find them...though they were SITTING RIGHT THERE ON THE RECEPTIONIST'S DESK the whole time. Chat Icon When it came to meeting the doctor, she told me this: "you could do chemo first or surgery first...it doesn't really matter" and "here's my card, email me if you have any more questions" Just kind of brushed me off. Like having stage three breast cancer is no biggie. They also would not let me see another doctor for a more concrete evaluation. It was one and done.

It was bizarre and incredibly stressful in what was already the most stressful time of my life. I broke out in my first case of hives ever because of the way they treated me (about the slides.)

I am friends with girls who have went there and are currently going there for treatment and many of them are unhappy, but feel that it's too late to change, at least right now while they are in treatment. On the other hand, I am friends with a few people who have gone there for years and love it.

Luckily, I had already met with doctors at NYU who were like steamrollers in terms of giving me a detailed treatment plan, getting me in for the MRI, PET/CT, other tests, etc. They didn't act like I was a cookie-cutter case.

Sloan does amazing things. I would never say that they don't. People I know are alive because of them. It just was not the right fit for me. Acting like my cancer was not a big deal was not the road I wanted to start on for my treatment.



I think this is probably an accurate description of them and just about any Dr.

You have to find the right fit for you and your situation This is NY and there are amazing Drs at many of the hospitals.

I would suggest 2nd opinions on anything. My FIL has stage 4 lung cancer and we had to find what would work for apps and surgeries etc.

Posted 1/6/15 10:36 AM
 

tourist

Member since 5/05

10425 total posts

Name:

Re: Sloan Kettering?!?

Posted by PearlJamChick

My personal experience with Sloan was a nightmare. On the administrative level, they didn't have me complete the new patient forms (not the insurance ones - the ones where they ask about lifestyle, ie., smoking, drinking, etc...they just told me that they don't really matter), they had my slides for weeks and basically refused to give them back to me in a timely manner - and then when I was scheduled to come in and get them, they couldn't find them...though they were SITTING RIGHT THERE ON THE RECEPTIONIST'S DESK the whole time. Chat Icon When it came to meeting the doctor, she told me this: "you could do chemo first or surgery first...it doesn't really matter" and "here's my card, email me if you have any more questions" Just kind of brushed me off. Like having stage three breast cancer is no biggie. They also would not let me see another doctor for a more concrete evaluation. It was one and done.




I was actually really surprised about the admin part. For me, they were super-efficient which was so much better than what I had been dealing with elsewhere. I expected it to be a red-tape nightmare b/c it is so big, but I find them to be really efficient in general. I see doctors in 3 different departments, so I do see differences there ( one always bills much later than the others, one has a longer wait time, etc). I have encountered the occasionally rude person or two, but they weren't the people I had the most contact with.

The treating cancer as no big deal thing is interesting. I think they do that because they want to instill confidence. I find in general ( MSKCC & elsewhere) the nurses & social workes tended to be more compassionate & the doctors are just more factual: here is what we can & cannot do.

After I had 2 consults & had my surgery scheduled, I met a friend of a friend who was the same kind of surgeon at a different hospital & he said to me that my case was "run of the mill." I get that he was trying to calm me down (and we were just talking socially, it wasn't a consult) & let me know that it was an easy surgery with a high success rate, but my life at that point felt anything but run of the mill.

I would still recommend them for a consult--I think you can get a feel right away if they are the right fit for you.

Although I had a good experience there, if I had been in your situation, I wouldn't have stayed there either. This is why we get multiple opinions.

Another bonus for me, is that they are a the forefront of the research for a lot of things & while my cancer was stage 1 & easily treatable, there were minor differences in procedure that made things easier on me, that the other hospital wasn't doing at the time. So while I may have has successful treatment elsewhere, treatment here was less traumatic.

Also, I have something come up a year later that could have possible been cancer (it wasn't) & they were able to handle that in a less invasive way than most hospitals. The size of the growth was over what the standard limit is for laparoscopic surgery, but they were doing this procedure for larger growths.

Posted 1/6/15 11:17 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Any Nicole's due in April that work at Sloan Kettering? krashnburn 12/17/06 0 Pregnancy
Prayers for my DH; Update - met Dr. at Sloan mrsej 7/30/10 14 Prayers
Anyone familiar with Memorial Sloan-Kettering area and Central Park Zoo and FAO Schwartz Domino 8/16/12 3 Parenting
Sloan Kettering-For Leighla DRMom 8/29/08 3 Families Helping Families ™