Silly/Interesting question posed by DH
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
Silly/Interesting question posed by DH This is one of those silly questions, being that I refuse to work today, had a rough day yesterday. So please humour me. |
|
Posted 2/6/13 10:08 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Silly/Interesting question posed by DH Crashing, but I'm fairly certain they always qualify their gender determination with a percentage, right? They never ever say it is 100% this or 100% that - do they? If they qualify it then I don't think there is a basis for a lawsuit at all...and they probably do that to cover their asses! |
|
Posted 2/6/13 10:11 AM
|
|
|
Silly/Interesting question posed by DH Agree, that is what I told him. |
|
Posted 2/6/13 10:22 AM
|
|
|
Silly/Interesting question posed by DH I agree with the pp...I don't think you can sue them if they never say it is 100%. |
|
Posted 2/6/13 10:23 AM
|
|
|
Re: Silly/Interesting question posed by DH I have no idea if you would have a cause of action, but seems to me like you should if that happens! |
|
Posted 2/6/13 10:35 AM
|
|
|
Re: Silly/Interesting question posed by DH A doctor is under no obligation to tell you the sex of the child-sonos are not done for sex determination. Message edited 2013-02-06 10:51:11.767000. |
|
Posted 2/6/13 10:46 AM
|
|
|
Re: Silly/Interesting question posed by DH This literally happened to me! My whole pregnancy I was told it was a girl, I got everything ready, bought pink clothes, the full nine, ended up being a boy. When I saw the sono, I thought it looked like a boy, but the nurse insisted it was a girl, and I agreed, what did I know. Message edited 2013-02-06 10:49:30.613000. |
|
Posted 2/6/13 10:49 AM
|
|
|
Re: Silly/Interesting question posed by DH Posted by neener1211 A doctor is under no obligation to tell you the sex of the child-sonos are not done for sex determination. No case. You have a 50/50 chance, and your DH determines what you have. It's not the doctor's fault that you took information and bought all pink or blue-that's your free will to do so. I'm not saying I would think you have a case, but I don't agree with this. If a doctor tells you "you are having a girl" of course he isn't forcing you buy pink clothes, but most people would go out and buy pink things because they are relying on what the doctor tells them. That is not the same as "I think it is a girl" or "most likely a girl." If a doctor told you that something looked off with a different body part and then he was wrong you would potentially have a cause of action. I know that this is different and the most important thing is a healthy baby, but it seems wrong to me that if a doctor tells you something and you rely on what turns out to be wrong information that you have no recourse. Yes, you have a 50/50 chance and DH determines what you have, but what does that have to do with anything? A doctor looking at a sono and determining the gender is not 50/50 - it is MUCH more accurate than that. |
|
Posted 2/6/13 10:57 AM
|
|
|
Re: Silly/Interesting question posed by DH They told me G/G at 14 weeks and confirmed at 22. then they turned around and they couldn't see anything after that. I was kinda out of it during the CS coming in and out at key points but I was waiting for the cries and the gender to confirm. Im not sure how common it is to mistake nowadays. My Dr wouldnt confirm unless they were 100% sure. |
|
Posted 2/6/13 11:02 AM
|
|
|
Re: Silly/Interesting question posed by DH Posted by dlj97 If a doctor told you that something looked off with a different body part and then he was wrong you would potentially have a cause of action. I know that this is different and the most important thing is a healthy baby, but it seems wrong to me that if a doctor tells you something and you rely on what turns out to be wrong information that you have no recourse. This is the key to this. What recourse do you want if the baby is the other gender? Just to have money returned on you spending on things? If that's the case, return things. Do you want to sue for mental anquish? Um, you knew you were either going to have a boy or girl. If something was 'off' on a different body part that the doctor didn't catch, still, they are human, they can miss things. For example, my 1st child's brain and skull didn't form, they didn't catch it until the 20 week sono. They SHOULD have found it with all the other tests they did, around 12 weeks. Was I going to sue the doctors because they didn't tell me the right information weeks 1-20? No, it wasn't their fault, it wasn't anyone's fault. All I wanted in my arms was a baby. And at that time, or even now, if someone came up to me and told me that they were suing their doctor because they were told they were having a girl, and they had a boy, I would tell them that they are out of their mind. If I were in the jury, I wouldn't give the parents a thing. NOW, on the other side, if they hadn't found anything on these tests, then on the 20 week test told me something was wrong, had me end my pregnancy and the baby was 100% fine, THEN I would have sued. To me, having been told a boy or girl and then having the other is not something you would change while in utero or after birth anyway. I guess the real issue in this situation would be, would it be moral or warranted or even accepted by others to sue because a gender was not seen correctly on a b&w screen-we're not even talking about a definitive test as an amnio here. So, in MY opinion, any lawyer taking a case like this is looking for money, and any parent who is holding their healthy child in their arms-boy or girl-and then sues because they were told the baby was the other gender is being petty, selfish and ridiculous. In MY opinion. Maybe there is a case based on legal precedent, I'm not a lawyer, so I can't say if there is. Message edited 2013-02-06 11:54:46.640000. |
|
Posted 2/6/13 11:41 AM
|
|
|
Silly/Interesting question posed by DH I think it would be ridiculous to try to sue for something like that. I agree with Neeners statements - what exactly can you quantify with a lawsuit based on the wrong gender. Barring any of the extreme scenarios, I don't think a lawsuit could at all be warranted. |
|
Posted 2/6/13 12:00 PM
|
|
|
Re: Silly/Interesting question posed by DH It would be a ridiculous lawsuit in my opinion. BUT i wouldn't be surprised if someone tried to sue because of that reason! |
|
Posted 2/6/13 12:26 PM
|
|
|
Silly/Interesting question posed by DH Thansk for everyone's response. I think DH was being more silly than anything, but then again with that man I never know. Lo |
|
Posted 2/6/13 3:58 PM
|
|
|
Re: Silly/Interesting question posed by DH Posted by neener1211 Posted by dlj97 If a doctor told you that something looked off with a different body part and then he was wrong you would potentially have a cause of action. I know that this is different and the most important thing is a healthy baby, but it seems wrong to me that if a doctor tells you something and you rely on what turns out to be wrong information that you have no recourse. This is the key to this. What recourse do you want if the baby is the other gender? Just to have money returned on you spending on things? If that's the case, return things. Do you want to sue for mental anquish? Um, you knew you were either going to have a boy or girl. If something was 'off' on a different body part that the doctor didn't catch, still, they are human, they can miss things. For example, my 1st child's brain and skull didn't form, they didn't catch it until the 20 week sono. They SHOULD have found it with all the other tests they did, around 12 weeks. Was I going to sue the doctors because they didn't tell me the right information weeks 1-20? No, it wasn't their fault, it wasn't anyone's fault. All I wanted in my arms was a baby. And at that time, or even now, if someone came up to me and told me that they were suing their doctor because they were told they were having a girl, and they had a boy, I would tell them that they are out of their mind. If I were in the jury, I wouldn't give the parents a thing. NOW, on the other side, if they hadn't found anything on these tests, then on the 20 week test told me something was wrong, had me end my pregnancy and the baby was 100% fine, THEN I would have sued. To me, having been told a boy or girl and then having the other is not something you would change while in utero or after birth anyway. I guess the real issue in this situation would be, would it be moral or warranted or even accepted by others to sue because a gender was not seen correctly on a b&w screen-we're not even talking about a definitive test as an amnio here. So, in MY opinion, any lawyer taking a case like this is looking for money, and any parent who is holding their healthy child in their arms-boy or girl-and then sues because they were told the baby was the other gender is being petty, selfish and ridiculous. In MY opinion. Maybe there is a case based on legal precedent, I'm not a lawyer, so I can't say if there is. I would never bring a lawsuit if my comes out as a , and I would be thrilled to have a , but it is not so easy as just return everything. I ordered thousands of dollars worth of furniture that isn't returnable and not usable for a boy. Obviously I just want a healthy baby, but it would suck if I had to swallow that cost and had furniture that I had nowhere to put!I don't think you would find any lawyer to take this case either, just to be clear! |
|
Posted 2/6/13 4:16 PM
|
|
|
Re: Silly/Interesting question posed by DH Posted by dlj97 I would never bring a lawsuit if my comes out as a , and I would be thrilled to have a , but it is not so easy as just return everything. I ordered thousands of dollars worth of furniture that isn't returnable and not usable for a boy. Obviously I just want a healthy baby, but it would suck if I had to swallow that cost and had furniture that I had nowhere to put!I don't think you would find any lawyer to take this case either, just to be clear! Totally understandable...I agree...it definitely would suck!
|
|
Posted 2/6/13 4:22 PM
|
|
|
Re: Silly/Interesting question posed by DH Posted by Gigi143 This literally happened to me! My whole pregnancy I was told it was a girl, I got everything ready, bought pink clothes, the full nine, ended up being a boy. When I saw the sono, I thought it looked like a boy, but the nurse insisted it was a girl, and I agreed, what did I know. These things happen, this was also years ago, now the machines are much more high tech, but really I don't think it ever even crossed my mind to sue, now it's just a funny story I can tell! I have a lawyer friend who i am messaging right now to see what she says! This happened to my sister, but my nephew was born in October so it was fairly recent! |
|
Posted 2/6/13 4:39 PM
|
|
|
Re: Silly/Interesting question posed by DH Why would this even be a real question? Who would sue over this, really? |
|
Posted 2/6/13 5:42 PM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Interesting silly thing | Stacey1403 | 5/4/07 | 17 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Trigger question (this may be a silly question) | marriedandttc | 3/19/11 | 2 | Infertility |
| Silly Question | Blazesyth | 6/18/05 | 4 | Home |
| Post your Silly Question HERE! | Holly | 5/23/05 | 14 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Silly Question... | preciouslove | 5/18/05 | 7 | Sports |
| Silly Reality Question | Redhead | 5/11/05 | 19 | Families Helping Families ™ |







but not to go and paint the room.
. I know each pregnancy is different, but with DD1 I was really sick in the beginning, never got over my food aversions and just looked like I was carrying a girl. With this pregnancy, I never got sick and feel so much better in general, and it looks like I am a carrying a boy. 

