Should I just let her starve?

Posted By Message

nicrae
He's here!

Member since 12/06

9289 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Should I just let her starve?

I am getting really tired of these nightly battles over dinner. Anything I make she won't eat. I am talking things that she normally has no problem with (ravioli, Chicken nuggets, those gerber grad things etc) I don't know what to do anymore Chat Icon Chat Icon I usually give in and either make her something else or let her eat applesauce and cheese for dinner.

I am tired of giving in and losing to a 2 year old Chat Icon

WWYD? Right now she has creamy chicken noodle with veggies sitting on a plate. Leave it there for her to eat and not offer anything else? or again let her have applesauce and cheese?

Posted 4/14/10 6:26 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

CookieMomster
Golden

Member since 5/09

6414 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Should I just let her starve?

OH god when you find out the answer to this please let me know. I am dealing with the same thing. In my house it was eat whats on your plate or go to bed hungry in DH's house it was "Well what do you want?" We are literally feuding over this. But many Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon's of support

Posted 4/14/10 6:30 PM
 

twinkletoes807
Mommy's Girls! ♥

Member since 11/07

10116 total posts

Name:
Gabi

Re: Should I just let her starve?

When my stepdaughter was 2.5-3 years old, DH and I had problems with her doing this at dinner time. We gave her what we were all eating and that was it. She had until everyone at the table was finished and if she didn't eat her dinner, then she didn't eat. Now, at 5 years old, she doesn't have a problem with eating dinner at our house. Chat Icon I think at this age, when you are able to communicate with DD, it is a power struggle. I always say, "If she's hungry, she will eat." Good luck! Chat Icon

Posted 4/14/10 6:46 PM
 

A3CM
Avatar Title

Member since 9/08

3762 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Should I just let her starve?

i have been told a child can go a few days of no eating without starving and that its harder on the parents then the child.

our therapist tells us to leave it there, and not make anything else for DS. if he doesnt eat it he doesnt eat it and not to give in.. if he says hes hungry offer him the same thing.

it is also the age.. children 2-5 go through the "i only want to eat..."

Posted 4/14/10 7:01 PM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: Should I just let her starve?

In my house, she eats what she gets or she goes without.

I'm not even the one who feeds DD most of the time (as an example, I'm typing this from my office right now and DD's probably finishing her dinner) but we're not running a restaurant... and a lot of the time, DH will ask her what she wants or will give her options anyway (at least with breakfast and lunch).

The only time we'll make her something else is if we've given her something she hasn't tried before - I can understand if she just doesn't like something. But if we know she eats it, then that's all she gets.

ETA: She has only gone to bed twice without dinner, and that was a while ago... since that time she knows the deal.

Message edited 2010-04-14 19:12:52.830000.

Posted 4/14/10 7:09 PM
 

Annie91606
Brotherly love

Member since 12/07

1816 total posts

Name:
Anne

Re: Should I just let her starve?

This is Liam too. He goes through these phases now. Mr. "eats like a champ" gives me push-back on everything I offer him for dinner. He does this for lunch too sometimes- breakfast he is still pretty good.

I don't force it. I just offer him the same things I always have. If he won't eat it, then fine- he is excused. I try again the next night.

I am 9 months pregnant and have no patience these days for these ridiculous tantrums. I understand how you feelChat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 4/14/10 7:09 PM
 

nicrae
He's here!

Member since 12/06

9289 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Should I just let her starve?

OK. I am glad to see everyone else has the same problems with their two year olds. I left the plate there and she ate two bites. I didn't offer her anything else. By now it is cold and gross and almost bedtime so I guess she is done for the night. I will do like you all suggested and stick to my guns! Chat Icon

Posted 4/14/10 7:14 PM
 

sunflowerjesss
Mommy to 3!

Member since 10/05

20369 total posts

Name:
Jesss, duh.

Re: Should I just let her starve?

I have always been relatively strict with dinner. He eats what is put before him or he doesn't eat at all.

Posted 4/14/10 7:17 PM
 

Peainapod
Peanuts are here!

Member since 1/09

13591 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Should I just let her starve?

my father always said "this isnt alice's restaurant.."

im not for force-feeding. my grandmother was always shoving food on us that we didnt like and made us feel bad with "waste not want not" and starving kids routine. she force fed my mother too as a kid--making her eat oatmeal every morning and my mom hates oatmeal. My mom said she would get to school and throw up every morning. i think thats why my mother hates to eat much and im kind of the same way. i can give two craps about food. I dont enjoy eating like lots of people do.

I wont force my kid to eat..they can eat whats there or go hungry. soon enough..they'll eat.

Posted 4/14/10 7:32 PM
 

megsm3
Life is Good!!

Member since 8/06

3867 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Should I just let her starve?

We never offer alternates. Some nights she eats everything on her plate, other nights she picks at her food, barely eating anything. I figure she will not starve herself.

Posted 4/14/10 9:27 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Should I just let her starve?

Posted by twinkletoes807

When my stepdaughter was 2.5-3 years old, DH and I had problems with her doing this at dinner time. We gave her what we were all eating and that was it. She had until everyone at the table was finished and if she didn't eat her dinner, then she didn't eat. Now, at 5 years old, she doesn't have a problem with eating dinner at our house. Chat Icon I think at this age, when you are able to communicate with DD, it is a power struggle. I always say, "If she's hungry, she will eat." Good luck! Chat Icon



i feel your pain Nicole! Dinner time is a battle here every night. We do the same thing as the above poster.

Posted 4/14/10 9:29 PM
 

Salason
♥

Member since 6/05

9878 total posts

Name:

Re: Should I just let her starve?

I am so in the same boat and have to start getting tougher. Glad to see I'm not the only one Chat Icon

Posted 4/14/10 9:31 PM
 

JenBenMen
party of five

Member since 9/06

11343 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Should I just let her starve?

i have a terrible 2 yr old eater

we offer him food at every meal---sometimes he eats--sometimes he doesnt

dinner has always been the worst and my ped said dont worry too much over dinner esp if they eat a good breakfast/lunch/snacks

if DS asks for a healthy snack like applesauce I give it to him

Posted 4/14/10 9:34 PM
 

LSP2005
Bunny kisses are so cute!

Member since 5/05

19461 total posts

Name:
L

Re: Should I just let her starve?

I leave it. I always make at least one thing that I know DS will eat as part of the meal. My rule is you have to taste one bite of everything on the plate. If he chews it and spits it out, fine. But I need to see one bite go into the mouth so he can experience the food. Usually after 15-20 or so tries with a new food he will eat it. Sometimes it takes me 40 times to introduce something. DS did get a LOT pickier when he turned 2 years old. Good luck. It is hard.

Posted 4/14/10 9:37 PM
 

mamasita27
OHANA

Member since 8/07

5974 total posts

Name:
MB

Re: Should I just let her starve?

she won't starve Chat Icon . we have the same problems with DD who will be 2 in May. Although (knock on wood) the last few days she's been eating up a storm! She is very picky. Monday night I made baked chicken breast, brown rice and boiled carrots (very boring dinner i know, but something i thought dd could partake in ) ...she wouldn't eat any of it. we gave her applesauce , hoping she might dip her chicken in it like she does with her nuggets sometimes and she still only ate the applesauce. that was what she had for dinner. This is what is recommended mostly I think buy peds etc. THey need to learn that you are not always going to have a "meal B" ready for them! it's really hard, but try it when you can!

Posted 4/14/10 10:14 PM
 

munchkinbugs
My little loves!

Member since 1/06

8093 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: Should I just let her starve?

I have the same problem....and I am double whammied by the fact that DH grew up in a house where his mother catered to his every need. He won't let DD go to bed hungry. So we don't really agree on taking a stand against her in regards to eating. I want to, he doesn't. So I am always making her a separate meal. She very rarely eats what we eat. So she may eat something like applesauce, a piece of cheese, and a banana for dinner. All healthy, but not a "meal". Very aggravating. I need to get her and DH on the same page as me.

Posted 4/14/10 10:40 PM
 

lvdolphins
My Loves!

Member since 5/05

46292 total posts

Name:

Re: Should I just let her starve?

Posted by AJandCJsMommy

i have been told a child can go a few days of no eating without starving and that its harder on the parents then the child.

our therapist tells us to leave it there, and not make anything else for DS. if he doesnt eat it he doesnt eat it and not to give in.. if he says hes hungry offer him the same thing.

it is also the age.. children 2-5 go through the "i only want to eat..."




Same here! DS is a little over 3. Last night was a battle to get him to eat chicken nuggets (mind you, one of his faves)..he ate 1 for dinner and that was it! Yes, he woke up asking for breakfast, but, wasn't crying/screaming for it.

Posted 4/14/10 10:47 PM
 

Kelly9904
Mommy to 2 amazing little boys

Member since 5/05

9306 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: Should I just let her starve?

I talked to my ped about this because DS has always been an amazing eater until he turned 2. Then it he started skipping meals and refusing things he normally loved.

The ped said not to worry, my job was to offer him food and he would eat if he was hungry. But at this age, its about power and eating when, how much etc is the one thing they can REALLY control.

I make one dinner, if he doesnt eat it, thats it. I really dont worry about it though, as long as he gets one meal a day I figure its good enough.
Chat Icon

ETA I think the more you 'give in" the longer and worse the stage probably will last.

Message edited 2010-04-14 22:51:12.473000.

Posted 4/14/10 10:48 PM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: Should I just let her starve?

Posted by sunflowerjesss

I have always been relatively strict with dinner. He eats what is put before him or he doesn't eat at all.



This is what I would do...and then add its not a restaurant. I'm so mean Chat Icon

Posted 4/14/10 10:49 PM
 

MrsGmomof3
...

Member since 6/08

3290 total posts

Name:
Irrelevant

Re: Should I just let her starve?

Someone else asked this a few weeks ago, and here is the answer I gave. I realize I am NOT in the majority, this is just my opinion:

No, I would not let a child "starve". If one of my children will not eat the dinner that I made, then they have the option of a bowl of cereal instead.

Let me explain:

IMO, food and eating "issues" start young. My mother was a "clean your plate" type... even if it was a food we HATED... And we SAT at that table until each and every single morsel was GONE. If that meant sitting at that table until well past dinnertime, then so be it. There were a few occasions when we were served our dinner from the night before for BREAKFAST because "there are starving children in the world and I am NOT allowing you to waste food!"

Needless to say, I have struggled with my weight my entire life.

When one of my children tells me that they are either not hungry, or finished eating before they have really eaten anything on their plates, or if they do not want to eat the meal served, I let it go. I tell them to take 1 or 2 more bites, (or pour a bowl of cereal) and then they can leave the table. If bedtime comes and they are hungry and ask for something, I give them either a yogurt, piece of fruit, or some crackers before bed. Nothing worse than waking up in the morning with a grumbling belly.

I do not want my children to grow up with the same food issues that I did. Its been a struggle for me my entire life. I really want them to learn to listen tp their bodies and if their bodies are not hungry, I will not force them to eat. Just the same, if they ARE hungry, I will never deny them food just to prove a point.

My children are 2, 5, and 6 years old. All are in the "normal" range for height and weight. THey are all healthy, eat a HUGE variety of foods and are extremely active.

We have to realize as adults that childrens bellies are roughly the size of their hand balled up into a fist. So they can eat a FRACTION of what we eat and feel "full". They also have fast metabolisms, and may really be hungry at "inoportune" times.

This is not saying that if my kid wakes up in the middle of the night asking for something to eat that I would give it to them, not at all... however, if as the day winds down, dinner is over, and they are getting ready for bed, if they ask for something, I give it to them.

Message edited 2010-04-15 12:24:40.847000.

Posted 4/15/10 12:18 PM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: Should I just let her starve?

DS is a picky eater, but he needs to at least try the food we give him. If he won't eat it and seems hungry, he can have a piece of cheese and a few crackers, but he's not getting a special meal.

If DH and I are eating something that I know he's just not going for at this point, he can have food he will eat like chicken nuggets, but for the most part, I want him eating food with us at this point. Or if I don't have dinner ready for DH and I and DS is hungry, I'll give him something he likes. Otherwise, he eats with us.

He is 28 months old.

Posted 4/15/10 4:00 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Should I just let her starve?

I don't give him another dinner...but since I am a softie, I will give him fruit or cheese....

But you know me, and know how I am about his foodChat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 4/15/10 4:03 PM
 

roxygrl8
......

Member since 6/06

2987 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Should I just let her starve?

Posted by babybug631

I have the same problem....and I am double whammied by the fact that DH grew up in a house where his mother catered to his every need. He won't let DD go to bed hungry. So we don't really agree on taking a stand against her in regards to eating. I want to, he doesn't. So I am always making her a separate meal. She very rarely eats what we eat. So she may eat something like applesauce, a piece of cheese, and a banana for dinner. All healthy, but not a "meal". Very aggravating. I need to get her and DH on the same page as me.



Agreed...very important. Just tell him to trust you, and see what happens. No harm done.

Posted 4/16/10 12:44 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Couple let kids starve to play video games....I swear some ppl should be STERILIZED!! MrsPJB2007 7/16/07 2 Families Helping Families ™
Let the Swelling Begin!! IrishTracy 6/9/05 7 Pregnancy
Let me hear TheInfamousOTG 5/23/05 12 Families Helping Families ™
Let's talk dental hygiene Cocoa 5/19/05 10 Families Helping Families ™
and they let these people vote for our President HarleyGirlFLA 5/19/05 4 Families Helping Families ™
Let's get Janet to 500 posts! Disneygirl 5/19/05 222 Families Helping Families ™