Shirley/Mastic Consensus

Posted By Message

MrsGT
LIF Infant

Member since 9/08

51 total posts

Name:
J

Shirley/Mastic Consensus

There are some gorgeous houses in this area. Even driving around the area proved to be a nice experience. Why does this region have such a poor reputation? Would you live there?

Posted 10/5/08 2:10 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
  |   Prudential Douglas Elliman Real Estate

Marcie
Complete Happiness :)

Member since 5/05

27789 total posts

Name:
LOVE being a Mommy!

Re: Shirley/Mastic Consensus

If you drive around the entire areas - Shirley, Mastic and Mastic Beach - you will find areas within - that will tell you why the area gets such a bad reputation.

I live in the area - honestly, I didn't think it was that bad, but all in all, I would love to move, but it isn't going to happen for us for a while.

What someone told me, was go to the supermarkets in the area and you will see the 'types' of people that live within the area.

I can tell you which supermarkets you can go to and be like Chat Icon and others where you are like - its not so bad.

Honestly, I don't think the schools are that bad, my child isn't in the schools yet - but I do have neices and nephews that go to the schools and have graduated from the schools and they are honor students

If you have any questions - feel free to FM me Chat Icon

Posted 10/5/08 2:20 PM
 

ready2ttc
LIF Toddler

Member since 8/08

383 total posts

Name:

Re: Shirley/Mastic Consensus

Check out the stores in the area, and drive around at night.

I think one of the problems with the area is that due to the low housing prices, there are lots of group homes for either homeless or welfare groups, and there are an unusually high number of pedophiles in the area (check out one of the watchdog sites). As always, see the school reports for school stats, but William Floyd has one of the lowest graduation rates/Regents scores in Suffolk County, and highest rates of subsidized lunches/breakfasts, etc.

I know students may succeed in any district, but we crossed off the 5 lowest performing districts in Suffolk, and William Floyd was one of them (as per newsday school report). we also checked out various other education reports.

Message edited 2008-10-05 15:08:32.727000.

Posted 10/5/08 3:02 PM
 

MrsGT
LIF Infant

Member since 9/08

51 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Shirley/Mastic Consensus

but we crossed off the 5 lowest performing districts in Suffolk, and William Floyd was one of them (as


Can you post the link to Newday's ranking of schools or list which others made the bottom five?
Interestingly, in '04 I think, the NY Times published a very lengthy article about the William Floyd area being an oasis for young NYC couples looking to own a home. I'm surprised to hear that the district is still bottoming out 4 years later.

Posted 10/5/08 3:38 PM
 

sunnyplus3
:)

Member since 11/05

8749 total posts

Name:

Re: Shirley/Mastic Consensus

I think that the area has the potential to be one of the most beautiful on Long Island. The waterfront there is amazing. Its unfortunate that so many people that live there are more transient types rather than people that want to lay down roots & help in the effort to change things. The few bad apples seem to ruin it for everyone.
I own an rental house in the area but I would venture to say its among the best kept on the block. The people that live in the area around that house are all nice, hardworking family people. My tenants love it there. Right now with the RE market on the decline there are some really good buys in the area but the rental population is growing and the number of vacant houses is growing.
I think there might be other areas that are more stable and around the same price range at this time.
As for the school district, I have many cousins and friends that graduated, a CPA, a licensed electrician, a school principle, a stand-up comedian & a flight attendent to name a few. There are problems there, but the district has helped the kids with GOOD PARENTS become successful people.

here's a link to another thread about finding out what a neighborhood is like
neighborhoods

Message edited 2008-10-05 16:50:23.150000.

Posted 10/5/08 3:41 PM
 

ready2ttc
LIF Toddler

Member since 8/08

383 total posts

Name:

Re: Shirley/Mastic Consensus

Posted by MrsGT

but we crossed off the 5 lowest performing districts in Suffolk, and William Floyd was one of them (as


Can you post the link to Newday's ranking of schools or list which others made the bottom five?
Interestingly, in '04 I think, the NY Times published a very lengthy article about the William Floyd area being an oasis for young NYC couples looking to own a home. I'm surprised to hear that the district is still bottoming out 4 years later.



Sure--I have the hard copy of the school report, but the bottom 3 in terms of % enrolling in 4 year schools are:
Wyandanch: 18%
William Floyd: 31%
Bridehampton: 38%

Bottom 4 for graduation rates are:
Wyandanch: 50%
Central Islip: 62%
William Floyd: 63%
Brentwood: 67%

I think I found the article you were thinking of, and you're right, it does make it sound like the area is changing. It doesn't mention NYC, but it does make it sound like the area is becoming more popular. But i think the fact that house prices are going down is making people who once could only afford that area to look to other more desirable areas. In 2004 that may have been one of only 3 or 4 areas where you could buy a home for under $300,000--now that isn't the case, and you can get a more desirable area for that price. Had prices continued to rise, as they had when that article was written, that area may have seen more of a change in demographics (IMO).

I also think that they need to clean up the image by getting rid of some of the pedophiles.

Message edited 2008-10-05 17:00:09.297000.

Posted 10/5/08 4:47 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Suffolk Residents (Mastic/Shirley, etc.)..Mosquito spraying starts today... Ambersmom 9/16/08 3 Families Helping Families ™
Suggestions for places in Mastic/shirley area to take a client out... PrincessP 8/17/08 1 Families Helping Families ™
ANyone in the Moriches, Shirley, Mastic area? JoeysMommy 1/30/06 8 Parenting
Port Jeff (Or station) Shirley/Mastic? june262004 7/13/05 26 Home
What girls on here live in the mastic / shirley area? TAD 6/6/05 5 Families Helping Families ™