Sears vs JCP for Pics

Posted By Message

LINewbie
Tigger the the Rescue!

Member since 8/08

5647 total posts

Name:
LB

Sears vs JCP for Pics

Deciding if we should take DS to get 1 year professional pics done. We do have coupons to both places.

Sitting fees are free for both, so does that mean the only thing we'd have to pay for is to buy prints? Does anyone know the prices? Is one cheaper than the other? Do you get proofs or anything so you can get copies made elsewhere? And do either do touchups? (I say this looking at DS's face with a cat scratch on it)

We did have pro pics taken once, for the church directory, and DS looks so fake. He was about 7 months then, so I am hoping now that since he can move more and smiles more and makes more faces that the photog won't have to do too many tricks to get him to smile. I don't want to hate the pics!

And how far in advance do you have to book? I want to have them taken in a couple of weeks.

Also do they both let you do a cake smash? I am debating doing it there or waiting until his actual birthday.

Thanks for any help! Chat Icon

Posted 3/10/12 12:48 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

DreamComeTrue
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/11

541 total posts

Name:

Re: Sears vs JCP for Pics

DS is 8 months and we have experience at both places.

Thanks to awesome coupons I've taken DS to Sears in Jan (6 mos), Feb (7 mos) and actually today we're heading there for 8 mos (went yesterday but he just woke from a nap and was fussing so we'll continue the shoot today). These montly shoots are just something small to do. I didn't go crazy buying enough to give pics to family. The Jan and Feb shoots I had coupons for and included 1 image on a cd so I can at least make copies of those to give out. Today's coupon is different so I won't be getting a cd. The pictures come out good enough for the memories and I like that they have a tripod which makes it easier to capture a smile at the click of a button. Their backgrounds are ok but props are slim.

We used JCPenney for our Christmas portraits and I have DS booked there in April for Easter/Spring/9mos. In my opinion the quality is better for those extra special occasions. Even the actual photo paper is thicker and of better quality. We spent more than I planned but I wanted a cd of the proofs and they are pricey. They have a good selections of background and props. However they do not use a tripod so they need both hands on the camera to take a shot and sometimes miss that split-second smile unless they have an assistant.

As for booking, you say you want to have them taken in a couple of weeks. Due to it being peak Easter/Spring portrait season, I would hurry. But otherwise for off peak seasons I can make an appointment with 1 week's notice.

I do not know anything about touch-ups. You would have to ask. And yes, both do cake smashes. I have asked. But I mentioned "if I brought a cloth..." so you may have to be responsible for that.

I believe Sears is 19.99 a sheet with no coupon. I'm not sure about JCP because I've only seen coupons for "3.99 a sheet plus no sitting". They both have "collections" which are packages that usually have "40% off" coupons or something like that. And for proofs, you have to pay for the image cd if you want to make your own copies. But if you just want to share on Facebook or something like that, they both e-mail you the proofs. It will just have the store logo going accross the photo.

My overall opinion: JCP if you don't get pics taken very often. HTH.

Posted 3/11/12 11:27 AM
 

FreeButterfly
hum...

Member since 5/05

6263 total posts

Name:

Re: Sears vs JCP for Pics

I got DC pic at JCP once because they had a cool prop/backround. I usually go to Sears. I feel they are the same quality, just Sears is closer to me.

The first time I went to Sears, I was upset - I paid a lot for a package and thought they'd touch it up a little. Once I realized it wasn't like that (at either), and I accepted it for what it was, I was very happy.

I usually just get 1-2 sheets and a collage. Only take DS when I have a coupon for a collage and for his birthday and Halloween.

I realized, i don't need a lot of pictures in different sizes. There are only so many people who want a pic of DS.

Posted 3/11/12 11:42 AM
 

Peainapod
Peanuts are here!

Member since 1/09

13591 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Sears vs JCP for Pics

i've always gotten good deals at JCP with their coupons and i joined their portrait club so i dont pay sitting fees any time I go.

they are always good with DS there and we get great quality photos.

I dont buy the cd of pics b/c thats just $$$ but I buy the prints and do well with those.

Posted 3/11/12 1:27 PM
 

LINewbie
Tigger the the Rescue!

Member since 8/08

5647 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Sears vs JCP for Pics

Thanks for the help! My mom said she'd pay Chat Icon and she has coupons for using her JCP card so that is where we are going.

Posted 3/17/12 7:03 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
did you get studio pics (JCP, sears, kiddie kandids) done at every birthday, or just the first? browneyedgirl 7/27/10 6 Parenting
Ellie's First Birthday pics from Sears cloddy 6/1/07 40 Parenting
1st Birthday Pics From Sears...(YAH) LIMOMx2 5/25/07 40 Parenting
Took Allison to sears today .. with pics 04bride 4/9/07 9 Parenting
Our AWESOME Sears Portrait Experience (pics)... LIMOMx2 3/12/07 36 Parenting
Jenna's 2 year pics from Sears DaniRN 10/3/06 24 Parenting