do you agree with

Forum Opinion Poll
they should be punished at school and home 10 52.63%
school does the punishment for things that happen at school 2 10.53%
other 7 36.84%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

School vs Home punishments

Posted By Message

my3boys
I love these boys

Member since 7/07

2711 total posts

Name:
Melissa

School vs Home punishments

Just wondering what you guys think-
Recently my 12yr old received 2days of lunch detention for drawing on his desk in school with pencil. So he had to go back to the classroom and earse it and then the following 2days he had to spend lunch in a class rm. My 1st reaction was to punish him at home. However the day this happened my son had his 12yr check up at the doctors and he mentioned it to the dr that he didn't feel it was fair to be punished at home being he was punished at school. So the ped said to me he had to agree because he feels when they get in trouble in school the school will give them a punishment to fit the crime and home when they do something wrong then us as parents do the punishment.

So just wondering do you agree with this or not??

Posted 2/9/10 6:52 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Kidsaplenty
Sister love

Member since 2/06

5971 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: School vs Home punishments

Depends on the severity of it. For something like that I'd just talk to DC about it. But for fighting, being disobedient or disrespectful I would punish them at home as well.

Posted 2/9/10 6:54 PM
 

MamaB17
Back for baby #3

Member since 5/09

4065 total posts

Name:
N

Re: School vs Home punishments

Honestly I would have done what you did. I would also punish them at home to reinforce what happened at school. JMO. Especially at that age they are aware of what they are being punished for. For smaller children I think punishing them more in relation to exactly what happened in school or something done at school helps them to relate it. KWIM?

Posted 2/9/10 6:54 PM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: School vs Home punishments

I read the poll wrong and chose other, but I feel they should be punished at both.

I was raised that I got in trouble at home for getting in trouble at school, but the school has every right to punish a kid for breaking the rules. If schools couldn't punish kids for misbehaving, they'd lose all control.

Posted 2/9/10 6:55 PM
 

CathyB

Member since 5/05

19403 total posts

Name:

Re: School vs Home punishments

My kids aren't old enough to be getting punishments in school so I can't be sure what I'd do, but I tend to think I'd punish them at home too. When I was in school if I was punished in school I was also punished at home. I realized pretty fast it wasn't worth getting in trouble at school since my parents would lecture and ground me too.

Posted 2/9/10 6:56 PM
 

nicrae
He's here!

Member since 12/06

9289 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: School vs Home punishments

As a teacher I think it depends on the situation. For your DS's I think it was enough for the school to give him lunch detention. If it was something else like cutting class then I'd feel that both home and school are necessary.

Posted 2/9/10 6:59 PM
 

my3boys
I love these boys

Member since 7/07

2711 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: School vs Home punishments

I kinda agree to an extent to ans my own question. Since he did only draw on the desk I agreed with the and just let him have the detention. However if it was something worse I would off deff took away his stuff at home. Trust me I take everything away when ever need be because he is at that age and he's trys to test me in everyway possibleChat Icon

When I go back to the office I'm going to ask again but be a little more specific because I just can't believe that he would feel that way if lets say a chid threw something at the teacher or got into a fight kwim.

Posted 2/9/10 7:01 PM
 

Elizabeth
Mom of Three

Member since 9/05

7900 total posts

Name:
"MOMMY!!!"

Re: School vs Home punishments

Posted by greeneyes361708

Depends on the severity of it. For something like that I'd just talk to DC about it. But for fighting, being disobedient or disrespectful I would punish them at home as well.



I agree.
You didn't mention what he wrote on the desk, if it was something hurtful or offensive about another student or teacher, vulgar, disrespectful, etc., I'd punish him at home too. If it was doodling and defacing it but not in an offensive way, I think the punishment at school was fine. Esp since he was able to clean it off. If it was something, even if not offensive in nature, but needed to be specially cleaned by a custodian or replaced in any way, then there would be further punishment at home. It definitely depends on the situation.

Posted 2/9/10 7:03 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Suffolk, school officials offer free home drug test kits Nifheim 1/12/10 11 Families Helping Families ™
child sent home from school for crucifix drawing Otherme 12/15/09 9 Families Helping Families ™
Sex offender moves to parents' home near elementary school in Long Island City JennZ 10/26/09 2 Parenting
Why do people home-school their kids? sticklee 7/16/09 20 Families Helping Families ™
At home Therapy/Vs School Krystal 7/1/09 8 Children With Special Needs
Elementary activity to send home before school starts? My3Shmoos 8/10/08 2 Teachers