Robbie Officially Knows..

Posted By Message

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Robbie Officially Knows..

.. that Rob and I have been 'Santa' for all these years.

He's had a sneaking suspicion for a while now. He started in kindergarten asking indirect questions about how Santa gets to all the kids, etc..

Gradually he became more and more direct in his questioning. To the point that I was evading his questions and changing the subject everytime it came up.

Finally - this weekend - Robbie asked me flat out if Santa existed. He cornered me and Rob and demanded an answer.

So we told him. We explained that Santa was 'real' in the sense that there is a spirit of Christmas and that what we are given is an extra sense of generosity and love for fellow man. We explained that we channeled a lot of this love and generosity into spending time buying him and his brother gifts and taking care to wrap them and leave them under the tree because it shows the magic in a way that children can understand.

He seemed.. relieved. A little disappointed, but mostly relieved. He had been warring with himself. He wanted to believe his parents, but he also felt that Santa was not logical and there were too many things that didn't add up for him. For those that don't know - Robbie is driven by logic and reason in ways that baffle me. He wants to be a scientist. I sometimes still can't believe he is MY child.

It has benefits too. We told him he's not allowed to tell his brother or anyone else.. because now he is part of a secret and he needs to show how mature he is. We also threatened him with a reduced amount of booty should the secret be imparted brother to brother. Moreover, we let him know that since he is AWARE that we are the bringers of good tidings and gifts, he is MORE obligated than ever to behave because now he knows "Santa" really IS watching. His response? "Oh Please.. you know I'm the good one."Chat Icon

So - selfishly - *I* felt bad. Robbie asked me why i looked glum and I told him that I wanted the magic to last longer. He told me that he was still trying to figure out what I told him about t=0 so there was plenty of other magic for him in the world.

Man, I love that kid.Chat Icon

Posted 10/19/09 7:47 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

ChrisDee
My Girls

Member since 11/06

9543 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: Robbie Officially Knows..

Jordan is in 3rd grade(she is 8 1/2) and still believes. She is aware that some people do not believe in Santa. Some kids on the bus told her that there is no Santa. I just tell her that if you do not believe than Santa does not bring you anything for Christmas(which is sorta true) She thinks the other kids are silly for not believing. I plan on making it last as long as I can.

Posted 10/19/09 7:54 AM
 

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Re: Robbie Officially Knows..

Posted by ChrisDee

Jordan is in 3rd grade(she is 8 1/2) and still believes. She is aware that some people do not believe in Santa. Some kids on the bus told her that there is no Santa. I just tell her that if you do not believe than Santa does not bring you anything for Christmas(which is sorta true) She thinks the other kids are silly for not believing. I plan on making it last as long as I can.



A good portion of Robbie's friends believe in Santa still and he was warned that I had better not get ANY calls from other moms telling me that he's trying to get other people not to believe. He immediately rattled off the name of 5 friends who tell all the kids that Santa doesn't exist. I told him that he'd better keep HIS lips zipped and not worry about what Gavin, Matt, Brian and the others say. I think he will because he really enjoys knowing something that the others don't know.

And you are right to want that magic to last. I STILL feel sad that Robbie no longer believes.Chat Icon

Message edited 2009-10-19 08:12:12.887000.

Posted 10/19/09 8:11 AM
 

NW2006
LIF Adolescent

Member since 7/06

535 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Robbie Officially Knows..

AWWWW...Chat Icon

I'm saving this because I love your explaination. And I love his response. Chat Icon

Why do they have to grow up at all?? Chat Icon

Posted 10/19/09 8:53 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Well not officially trying yet but... AJsMommy122 6/10/05 3 TTC
I am officially a Stste certified teacher!! YAY 04bride 6/6/05 15 Families Helping Families ™
I'm officially off the pill! lily 6/5/05 9 TTC
So I am officially here.... Moehick 5/27/05 17 TTC
I AM OFFICIALLY INVITING..... MrsERod 5/13/05 13 Families Helping Families ™
Officially joining you! Adri 5/12/05 15 Pregnancy