Question for Speech Pathologists/Evaluators

Posted By Message

Kathy116
Hey baby!

Member since 6/05

1855 total posts

Name:
me

Question for Speech Pathologists/Evaluators

My DS is 2 1/2 years old.

Short version:
He was tested today, and did not perform a certain task. As soon as evaluator left, I asked him to perform the task, and he did it, above and beyond.
Anyone else feel like DC not testing accurately?
--------------------------------------------

Long version:


He has received speech therapy and I recently discontinued therapy because he no longer responded to his therapist (he would run and hide, pretend he was sleepy, and the second she left, he'd jump up and act happy.) So, she took him as far as she could and it was time for a change.

Then, I got to thinking, DS is doing really well, expressing his needs, desires "Mommy, I want 'X" or "where's Sofia?" etc. He also follows directions (sometimes, if he's not being difficult).

So, I had him re-evaluated today, and he was so excited when the evaluator came over, that he ran around the house, showing her various toys, etc.
He didn't want to engage with her.

He finally did, and she felt his expressive language was within the norm...but his receptive language was lacking. A lot of this was based on the fact that he would not point to any pictures when asked, "Point to the ball" or "point to the house" etc. He just would not do it. And there were only four pictures on the page.

What as so frustrating, is that I know he does this, but he wouldn't do it for her.

She felt that he didn't understand what was being asked.
So, he got no "credit" for that.

SO.....one hour after she left, I sat down with him, took out a book that is not all that familiar to him (it's a book of words, objects) The pages are filled with about 10 to 30 objects (not four like the test)...every time I asked him to point to an object, he did so, the first time, and got it correct. Things like, train, dog, animals, shapes, different clothing, furniture, etc.

Then, I tested him and asked him to get his sister the baby, and he did so. I then asked him to get her Mickey Mouse, and he did so.

SO, here's my dilemma...did he test accurately? Is this common for children to clam up with evaluators? Is it possible that there is some issue with him responding to people other than those he's familiar with? He loves people, children, and is not in nursery school, he's home with me.

I'm so confused. I hate all this testing stuff.....

Thanks for letting me vent.

I'd love to hear everyone's experiences with testing as well.

Message edited 2009-02-09 18:18:11.120000.

Posted 2/9/09 6:02 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Porrruss
Nya nya nya

Member since 5/05

11618 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: Question for Speech Pathologists/Evaluators

A good evaluator will take into account "non compliance" through informal assessments (like something play-based) and parent interview/checklist. Did you fill anything out asking about tasks he's able to do at home?

Did his previous therapist feel he had any other deficits or was he being released from therapy?

Posted 2/9/09 6:56 PM
 

Porrruss
Nya nya nya

Member since 5/05

11618 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: Question for Speech Pathologists/Evaluators

Grrrr.....double post

Message edited 2009-02-09 18:58:40.607000.

Posted 2/9/09 6:57 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Another "gender dream" question... did your DH have dreams? CaMacho 2/9/09 2 Pregnancy
Question for speech therapists Jackie24 1/17/09 6 Teachers
Question about Obama's acceptance speech Mommy2Boys 11/7/08 22 Families Helping Families ™
Another allergy question-Speech Delay and Food Allergy aliasPook 7/6/08 15 Parenting
A thank you for those who helped with EI for speech and a quick question RMA9728 3/6/08 5 Parenting
Speech Impediment Question yankinmanc 12/28/07 9 Parenting