Question About Socialism

Posted By Message

Sunshyne
LIF Adolescent

Member since 9/07

563 total posts

Name:
Elissa

Question About Socialism

I just came out of a Poli Sci class & there was a 95 minute debate & now, unfortunately, I have to write a paper (wonderfulChat Icon )... here is the crux: people are terrified of Obama and the possibility of socialism. We have public schools, libraries, police forces & private ones. Theoretically, the public ones are examples of socialist ideals (I never thought about this before), so..... why are these institutions not seen as concerning in this country with regard to maintaining a capialistic econmoic system? My head is spinning.....help. Thanks.

Posted 10/22/08 11:56 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: Question About Socialism

You know, the whole socialism claim is flawed, and I don't recall anyone calling Obama's economic plans socialism until the McCain campaign gave them that label. Why? To scare the hell out of everyone.

Any tax system basically takes money from some people/businesses and goes out into other things--the war in Iraq, schools, roads, etc. So why is it suddenly socialism if Obama is suggesting a change in the people/businesses that money is taken from? His plan bears some similarities to Clinton's, and I seem to recall those years as some very good years economically.

As far as post offices, schools, etc., I do not think these are signs of socialism. They are institutions the govt. has established for the good of all citizens--except maybe for the post office, the others do not hurt our capitalistic system--they help it.

Posted 10/22/08 12:08 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Question About Socialism

I think there is a "book definition" of a political doctrine and there is a the "real" World.

Most countries are not just one doctrine.

For example:

The US is labeled a Capiltalist country. But if you really study it you will see trace of socialism, the green party (with the environment laws, etc...).

France is labeled a Socialist country. Yet, you do have private companies. Most of them actually. It's not all own by the State. So while it's more "federal" than the US, there is still capitalism full force in a Socialist country.

ETA: The US have some some of "socialism" already. Unemployment, Social Security. It's all Federal and deducted out of your paycheck automatically. The Republican Party never removed it because mostly they don't know a better solution to it. So you see in every country is not just one doctrine.

Message edited 2008-10-22 12:18:44.757000.

Posted 10/22/08 12:16 PM
 

twiceasnice
LIF Adult

Member since 2/08

1126 total posts

Name:

Re: Question About Socialism

Posted by cjik

You know, the whole socialism claim is flawed, and I don't recall anyone calling Obama's economic plans socialism until the McCain campaign gave them that label. Why? To scare the hell out of everyone.




No because Obama said we need to "Spread the Wealth" and the McCain campaign repeated that.

Wikipedia:
All socialists advocate the creation of an egalitarian society, in which wealth and power are distributed more evenly, although there is considerable disagreement among socialists over how, and to what extent this could be achieved.

I think people are scared because what would be their motivation to work harder. Their family won't reap in their hard work. A coworker (single dad), I know, recently got a promotion which pushed him over to the next tax bracket. Since medical benefits went up, now he brings home 200 less/month. Is that fair?

The tax rate from 1945-1964 for top income (anything over 200,000) was 91 percent, (where bottom income earners paid 19%). The "rich" people literally worked 11 months out of the year to pay taxes and kept 1 month. Those were hard times then but I am using them as an example of why "spread the wealth" could be feared.

Posted 10/22/08 1:30 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Timeframe Question beena 3/24/06 3 Home
Personal question...... Diane 3/24/06 3 Multiple Births
To Find out or To NOT find out..that is the question!!! MrsSchwags 3/24/06 22 Pregnancy
Morbid but neccesary question sunny 3/23/06 15 Parenting
Question about walk through LIBOUND 3/23/06 4 Home
kinda silly question JavaJunkie 3/23/06 16 Pregnancy