Purse found Shannan Gilberts
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
Purse found Shannan Gilberts (12/07/11) OCEAN PARKWAY - During a press conference this afternoon, Suffolk County Police Commissioner Richard Dormer announced that items that they believe belong to missing New Jersey prostitute Shannan Gilbert have been found. |
|
Posted 12/7/11 3:44 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Purse found Shannan Gilberts I'm glad they at least found some clues. So sad... |
|
Posted 12/7/11 3:48 PM
|
|
|
Re: Purse found Shannan Gilberts This whole thing makes me so sick. I really hope they get a lot more clues and information! |
|
Posted 12/7/11 6:04 PM
|
|
|
Re: Purse found Shannan Gilberts They are now saying they don't believe she was murdered but that she was running away from someone and drowned in the marsh... |
|
Posted 12/7/11 6:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: Purse found Shannan Gilberts Posted by Mrs213 They are now saying they don't believe she was murdered but that she was running away from someone and drowned in the marsh... that's what i heard as well seems like an awful coincidence if she wasn't murdered.. but all those other people were? either way, i hope they find her remains soon so her family can get some peace |
|
Posted 12/7/11 7:01 PM
|
|
|
Re: Purse found Shannan Gilberts I really think that they found the purse months ago and held on to it, and are using it as bait for whomever the know killed all those women and that poor baby girl. |
|
Posted 12/7/11 8:50 PM
|
|
|
Re: Purse found Shannan Gilberts Posted by Otherme Posted by Mrs213 They are now saying they don't believe she was murdered but that she was running away from someone and drowned in the marsh... that's what i heard as well seems like an awful coincidence if she wasn't murdered.. but all those other people were? either way, i hope they find her remains soon so her family can get some peace I would agree except for the fact that the 10 other bodies found on the Ocean Pkwy weren't killed there but rather their bodies (or body parts) were left there. I think it's pretty plausible that she drowned in the marsh especially if she wasn't sober, which they were alluding to during the press conference. Anyway you slice it, it's a very sad situation. |
|
Posted 12/7/11 11:31 PM
|
|
|
Re: Purse found Shannan Gilberts Posted by Jennie0898 Posted by Otherme Posted by Mrs213 They are now saying they don't believe she was murdered but that she was running away from someone and drowned in the marsh... that's what i heard as well seems like an awful coincidence if she wasn't murdered.. but all those other people were? either way, i hope they find her remains soon so her family can get some peace I would agree except for the fact that the 10 other bodies found on the Ocean Pkwy weren't killed there but rather their bodies (or body parts) were left there. I think it's pretty plausible that she drowned in the marsh especially if she wasn't sober, which they were alluding to during the press conference. Anyway you slice it, it's a very sad situation. I'm not from this area and don't know of it all that well... but is it likely she was swimming in marsh?? Someone said it was rough terrain and bad conditions there... would people really go swimming there? I might be picturing something different than it is based on the descriptive words I'm seeing. I won't even swim at night at the beach... so anyplace being called marsh... is a no swim zone for me. heck.. I probably wouldn't even walk there at night. It just seems odd for her to run away and then be chased by someone in what *sounds* like a deserted not nice place and then drown... if she was running away why would she go to this location?? wouldn't there be better places to run off to?? again, IDK the location so I could be totally off... it's just the initial reaction I have based on what some have said. |
|
Posted 12/8/11 12:44 AM
|
|
|
Re: Purse found Shannan Gilberts Posted by MrsKS Posted by Jennie0898 Posted by Otherme Posted by Mrs213 They are now saying they don't believe she was murdered but that she was running away from someone and drowned in the marsh... that's what i heard as well seems like an awful coincidence if she wasn't murdered.. but all those other people were? either way, i hope they find her remains soon so her family can get some peace I would agree except for the fact that the 10 other bodies found on the Ocean Pkwy weren't killed there but rather their bodies (or body parts) were left there. I think it's pretty plausible that she drowned in the marsh especially if she wasn't sober, which they were alluding to during the press conference. Anyway you slice it, it's a very sad situation. I'm not from this area and don't know of it all that well... but is it likely she was swimming in marsh?? Someone said it was rough terrain and bad conditions there... would people really go swimming there? I might be picturing something different than it is based on the descriptive words I'm seeing. I won't even swim at night at the beach... so anyplace being called marsh... is a no swim zone for me. heck.. I probably wouldn't even walk there at night. It just seems odd for her to run away and then be chased by someone in what *sounds* like a deserted not nice place and then drown... if she was running away why would she go to this location?? wouldn't there be better places to run off to?? again, IDK the location so I could be totally off... it's just the initial reaction I have based on what some have said. She called 911 that night and said she was being attacked apparently she knocked on people's doors saying someone was after her and then they couldn't find her. So probably whoever was after her if there was an attacker didn't follow her in there, I guess is the speculation... |
|
Posted 12/8/11 1:33 AM
|
|
|
Re: Purse found Shannan Gilberts I missed part of the press conference - did they think she somehow escaped the killer and ran away and subsequently drowned, or do they think it's total coincidence that she was in the same area as the other victims and she is unrelated to those cases? |
|
Posted 12/8/11 7:09 AM
|
|
|
Re: Purse found Shannan Gilberts Posted by Karen I missed part of the press conference - did they think she somehow escaped the killer and ran away and subsequently drowned, or do they think it's total coincidence that she was in the same area as the other victims and she is unrelated to those cases? I was always under the impression that even though the bodies were there, that was NOT where those ladies were killed. I saw the highlights last night and they were saying that they didn't think it was related to the other victims. I also from what I recall hearing last year, that the other bodies were most likely dumped. They also were saying that the area is very muddy (sounded almost like a "quicksand" scenario) and that a lot of the police needed help getting out during the search because they were sinking deep in the mud and were stuck. I am not really sure what to think about what happened to her, if it's related to the serial killer or not, but I really don't have a good feeling they are going to find this woman alive. I am sure the men that were involved at that party that night in Oak Beach know more than they are saying. My only other thought too, is I wonder about her mental health state and if she was under the influence of alcohol and/or drugs, and maybe this lead her to running around all crazed like the witnesses reported that night and then she literally became lost in the water and drowned because of these things, not necessarily that someone was really trying to kill her. I don't know if we will ever really know the truth about what happened to Shannan. |
|
Posted 12/8/11 7:20 AM
|
|
|
Re: Purse found Shannan Gilberts J Brewer (the john) said they argued because he questioned whether or not she was a man or woman. He also said and apparently it was proven that the site he got her from had a different photo displayed and she was in no way what he was expecting |
|
Posted 12/8/11 8:22 AM
|
|











