Public vs. parochial school
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
Public vs. parochial school If you had this debate, what did you choose for your child(ren) and why? I was a product of public school, my husband catholic school. We chose a house specifically in a good school district (the same district where I went), even though we could have gotten more for our $$ one or two districts over. Now, DH is bringing up Catholic school again. Dd is enrolled in Catholic nursery (and will continue there for pk), which will allow us a taste of it. Just wanted to hear views of others. I should also add that while we can technically swing the tuition, it would never allow us to make home improvements, go on vacation, start a savings fund, etc. Tia. |
|
Posted 8/19/16 8:01 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
NervousNell
Member since 11/09 54921 total posts Name: |
Re: Public vs. parochial school If you are in a good school district, I see no reason for it. |
Posted 8/19/16 8:49 AM
|
|
|
Re: Public vs. parochial school Posted by NervousNell If you are in a good school district, I see no reason for it. You will have plenty of time to shell out tons of money for school when they go to college. IMO you are paying extremely high taxes on LI for the use of the schools. And you bought a house in a good district with that in mind, even though you could have gotten more for your money elsewhere. So to me, that would mean we are using the public schools that we are paying for. I can't see shelling out so much money for Catholic school when your district is good. Especially if it will prevent you from doing home improvements, saving money, going on vacations. Life is short. You shoudl be able to take travel, have money for extras, etc. They will get just as good an education in the public school IMO All of this. |
|
Posted 8/19/16 9:09 AM
|
|
|
Re: Public vs. parochial school The way I see it, you have chosen public (good school district usually means higher taxes & less house for your $). |
|
Posted 8/19/16 9:11 AM
|
|
|
Re: Public vs. parochial school Posted by NervousNell If you are in a good school district, I see no reason for it. You will have plenty of time to shell out tons of money for school when they go to college. IMO you are paying extremely high taxes on LI for the use of the schools. And you bought a house in a good district with that in mind, even though you could have gotten more for your money elsewhere. So to me, that would mean we are using the public schools that we are paying for. I can't see shelling out so much money for Catholic school when your district is good. Especially if it will prevent you from doing home improvements, saving money, going on vacations. Life is short. You shoudl be able to take travel, have money for extras, etc. They will get just as good an education in the public school IMO Agreed. We specifically purchased in our area, with higher taxes and less bang for our buck because of the great school district. DH went to public school until HS, I was Catholic school my entire life. Honestly, I don't think I had any advantage being in Catholic school. I actually hated the first Catholic HS I attended and found a lot of the teachers to be sub-par- and I'm talking honors classes teachers. Message edited 2016-08-19 09:13:07.680000. |
|
Posted 8/19/16 9:12 AM
|
|
|
NervousNell
Member since 11/09 54921 total posts Name: |
Re: Public vs. parochial school And in addition to my comment above, I feel when it comes to school, SO much of it is what the students put into it. |
Posted 8/19/16 9:13 AM
|
|
|
Public vs. parochial school You have a good public school district, I don't see why you'd consider catholic school. My wife and I had this discussion recently really wondering why people do this from good districts. Message edited 2016-08-19 09:47:14.570000. |
|
Posted 8/19/16 9:24 AM
|
|
|
Re: Public vs. parochial school Try public first, you can always transfer to private if you are not happy. We may consider private high school. As wonderful as our public highschool is, it's huge and apparently has had kids bringing drugs into the school and using during the day. Message edited 2016-08-19 11:05:52.733000. |
|
Posted 8/19/16 11:03 AM
|
|
|
Re: Public vs. parochial school Posted by NervousNell If you are in a good school district, I see no reason for it. You will have plenty of time to shell out tons of money for school when they go to college. IMO you are paying extremely high taxes on LI for the use of the schools. And you bought a house in a good district with that in mind, even though you could have gotten more for your money elsewhere. So to me, that would mean we are using the public schools that we are paying for. I can't see shelling out so much money for Catholic school when your district is good. Especially if it will prevent you from doing home improvements, saving money, going on vacations. Life is short. You shoudl be able to take travel, have money for extras, etc. They will get just as good an education in the public school IMO This .. I went to a Catholic School as a child and HATED it! They bullied me, tortured me and the nuns were just horrible. They let the other children spit on me. It's memories I'll never forget. Our property tax in Texas is extra high as we don't have a state tax. I pay a lot for my small house because I want to live in this school district. We have charter schools everywhere which are free and very good but again, I wanted this. She is getting a great education. If she wants to go into a charter school or specialty school later, that's her choice. I have a friend here who always puts her children into Catholic Schools when they get to middle school and high school so they have the 'right kind of friends'. She believes it gives them an advantage. I can't say I agree. She pushes me all the time to put my daughter in Catholic School so she can have those connections and proper advantages. I just see it as cliques and the elite of all keeping up with the jones'. No thank you. They are so full of themselves. Our Catholic and Christian Schools here are crazy competitive. No thank you. Reality is, no one cares when you go to college where you went to High School. Did you get good grades, good SAT, ACT scores? Do you have good extra curricular? Then good for you. I am hoping AJ goes out of state so no one will even care. I should know. My school closed and when I went to college in New York no one cared about my school, just that I had GT/AP and my grades. So I have learned that really.. High School isn't as important as one would think.. just get good grades do good so why spend extra money. |
|
Posted 8/19/16 11:34 AM
|
|
|
Public vs. parochial school I went to Catholic school because I grew up in Queens and that's just what everyone did (though really, my zoned public school was perfectly fine). I've always been happy that I went to Catholic school and would send DD in a heartbeat. Not sure how it is in the 'burbs, but I definitely felt a difference between the public and Catholic school kids growing up. We were a bit more sheltered (which is good or bad depending on how you look at it). Message edited 2016-08-19 11:50:51.330000. |
|
Posted 8/19/16 11:48 AM
|
|
|
Re: Public vs. parochial school Posted by NervousNell If you are in a good school district, I see no reason for it. You will have plenty of time to shell out tons of money for school when they go to college. IMO you are paying extremely high taxes on LI for the use of the schools. And you bought a house in a good district with that in mind, even though you could have gotten more for your money elsewhere. So to me, that would mean we are using the public schools that we are paying for. I can't see shelling out so much money for Catholic school when your district is good. Especially if it will prevent you from doing home improvements, saving money, going on vacations. Life is short. You shoudl be able to take travel, have money for extras, etc. They will get just as good an education in the public school IMO Completely agree with this! |
|
Posted 8/19/16 3:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: Public vs. parochial school Thank everyone. These are a lot of my same thoughts, but the community and events at the Catholic school seem so wonderful that I was interested to see what the draw is (other than these events) for families to decide on parochial schools. The funny thing is, my husband hated his experience in Catholic schools, and of both of our families (who all went to catholic schools except for me), I actually ended up at the higher ranking college and grad program! |
|
Posted 8/19/16 3:28 PM
|
|
|
Public vs. parochial school I live in what is considered to be a good school district. I bought my house when I was single but thought it would be good for resale value should I decide to sell. I have gotten married and had a child, and we send him to Catholic school (I went to Catholic school, DH to public). His public school experience was horrible - felt he didn't learn much at all. |
|
Posted 8/19/16 3:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: Public vs. parochial school this.is.coming from two parents who are public school educators, practicing Catholics and products of Catholic schools (Dh K-12 and myself K-6, public 7-12, Catholic college): |
|
Posted 8/20/16 12:15 AM
|
|
|
Re: Public vs. parochial school I really think it depends on WHICH catholic school you are thinking about. They are all different. My son attended a catholic school for 3 years (he's going into 2nd). I just withdrew him because they had an enrollment drop and it will only be 1 class of 30 kids in Sept. Way too many kids for me to be paying for. I really wish the manners and morals as you described, greeting someone in the halls, was taught there but sadly none of that was present either. |
|
Posted 8/20/16 7:34 AM
|
|
|
Re: Public vs. parochial school I think it depends on the Particular schools - u really can't get a general answer to this question. I had one in each and am pulling the one from the catholic school to put in public because the public school is better all around - especially academically. Also everyone at the Catholic school would say how the kids were so much nicer there and had better morals and discipline and, honestly, since I was able to directly compare the two I can tell u the exact opposite was true. Make sure u look beyond the fluff to the substance when u compare the schools. |
|
Posted 8/20/16 10:31 PM
|
|
|
Re: Public vs. parochial school I attended Catholic school my entire life, and I truly feel the schools played a tremendously positive role in my life, especially my high school--Holy Trinity Diocesan. |
|
Posted 8/21/16 9:16 AM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| public school vs. private school (Lutheran??) | kfox715 | 1/15/15 | 9 | Parents of School-Aged Children |
| Public school vs catholic school. please gove myour opinion | 04bride | 3/3/10 | 18 | Parenting |
| School Spinoff-If money wasn't the issue, would you chose private over public school? | Janice | 8/15/05 | 75 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| NYC public school secretaries | mtdr1106 | 2/21/07 | 1 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Private vs. Public School for kids | Lauren | 11/30/06 | 54 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| NYC Public School Teachers | Melbernai | 6/28/06 | 2 | Families Helping Families ™ |










