pros/cons daycare vs nanny

Posted By Message

gabbie83
2 girls <3

Member since 6/08

3037 total posts

Name:
gabbie

pros/cons daycare vs nanny

can you please list what made you choose what you chose and why

(from looking around i see that its not a difference in the price, not THAT much anyway) so just wondering what everyone's reasons are.

BTW DD will be 13 months when i will either get a nanny or put her in daycare.

Posted 7/12/10 8:22 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

headoverheels
s'il vous plaƮt

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: pros/cons daycare vs nanny

I've done both!

Daycare: Love the school-type setting, the interaction with all the other kids, the fact that they always had plenty of teachers so I didn't have to worry about a nanny being sick. But then of course they had exposure to other kids, DS was sick three times the first month he was there.

Nanny: Love that I don't have to wake them up and get them ready in the morning and drop them off - that would easily add another 1/2 hour to an hour to my morning. She comes to my house and often they are still sleeping when I leave! They eat the food that's in my house, so I know they're getting variety. They get a lot of one on one attention which is great, though they do lack interaction with other kids, so I make up for that with lots of weekend playdates.

So far, I'm liking the nanny situation better Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-07-12 20:30:13.350000.

Posted 7/12/10 8:30 PM
 

Kelly9904
Mommy to 2 amazing little boys

Member since 5/05

9306 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: pros/cons daycare vs nanny

I havent used either but these are things my friends have said

Daycare-
School setting
Exposure to other kids / races etc
More eyes watching
more structure

Nanny-
One on One
More flexibility with schedules (sleep, eating etc)
More controlled environment (if at your house)
Especially for 2 kids generally cheaper option

Bad for DC- basically the only thing I Have really heard people complain about is cost and kids getting sick so regularly - although alot of parents say by the time their day care kids got to school they were never sick whereas kids who were home got sick more often

Bad for nanny-
what to do if Nanny calls in sick
Not as much interaction with kids their own age

ETA I also have a few friends who take their kids to someone elses house, similar benefits to the in home nanny, but you have to drive your kid somewhere

Message edited 2010-07-12 20:37:21.820000.

Posted 7/12/10 8:36 PM
 

LittleBlueBug
Happy Mommy

Member since 9/06

4074 total posts

Name:

Re: pros/cons daycare vs nanny

TBH, I don't like the idea of someone in my home when I am not around. DC is a big pro for us because DS gets to play and interact with others his age, plus my DC has enrichment programs and a very good cirriculum, so I know he's getting stimulated too. There are things they do with him I don't think he would ever had the opportunity with a nanny. Besides he also doesn't have stranger danger since he's been with new people since he was 3 months old.

DS got sick monthly at first (pink eye, pneumonia, colds, 1 ear infection, RSV), but that was the only downside. DS has been in daycare since he was very little though, so adapting was a piece of cake. Since you DC is a little older, he may fair better with a nanny in some respect since a familiar environment. But you know your kid, and if you feel that he would adapt well to DC, go for it.

Posted 7/12/10 9:07 PM
 

MrsO
Big Brothers to Be

Member since 1/07

4521 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: pros/cons daycare vs nanny

I only have experience with a nanny

pros
Kids don't have to be out early in the am
kids are in there on environment all day
kids get one on one attention
less germs
Consistency in care - same person everyday
flexibility in scheduling if need to switch days


Cons
we have to take off if she can't come in ( very rare with our nanny)

I love our nanny and I know this is the best decision for our family.

Posted 7/12/10 9:19 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Daycare/Nanny related Rycois 11/20/07 9 Pregnancy
Letter for nanny or daycare? jaclyn78 11/19/07 1 Parenting
Nanny vs. Daycare JChia 10/6/07 10 Pregnancy
Childcare Dilemma - Nanny or Daycare EmmaNick 7/14/07 5 Parenting
Need advice regarding nanny/daycare Mommy2Boys 1/21/07 2 Pregnancy
Anyone using a Nanny instead of Daycare? JRG71 10/11/05 4 Pregnancy