Proposal to euthanize wild horses spurs debate

Posted By Message

Wendy
Wheeee!

Member since 5/05

13736 total posts

Name:

Proposal to euthanize wild horses spurs debate

By MARTIN GRIFFITH, Associated Press Writer
Mon Jul 7, 5:48 AM ET



Animal rights activists and ranchers are clashing over a federal proposal to euthanize wild horses as a way to deal with their surplus numbers.

Horse advocates will mount a campaign against the proposal announced late last month by the U.S. Bureau of Land Management, said Chris Heyde, deputy director of government and legal affairs for the Animal Welfare Institute based in Washington, D.C.

Federal officials said they're faced with tough choices because wild horses have overpopulated public lands in the West and they no longer can afford to care for the number of animals that have been rounded up.

But Heyde maintained the agency is seeking a "magic bullet" for budget problems caused after it began rounding up the mustangs at an unprecedented rate in recent years.

He said the roundups left too many horses for the public to adopt, requiring the agency to contract for more private long-term holding facilities.

The proposal "is killing pure and simple to balance the books for an agency whose reckless management has caused immeasurable harm to a national treasure at considerable cost to the American taxpayer," Heyde said.

Ron Cerri, of the Rebel Creek Ranch in Orovada and president-elect of the Nevada Cattlemen's Association, said ranchers would prefer horses be adopted but euthanasia may be necessary to keep their numbers down.

"Unfortunately, it's something they'll have to consider," Cerri said. "I don't know of another solution."

Cerri criticized the federal agency's proposal to stop roundups of wild horses to save money. Ranchers view mustangs as competition for forage on the range.

"That would be really unfortunate," he said. "We're starting to get close to what's called `appropriate management levels' of wild horses on the range. If we stop the roundups, that number will blow up again."

There are an estimated 33,000 wild horses in 10 Western states. About half of those are in Nevada.

The agency has set a target appropriate management level of horses at 27,000. About another 30,000 horses are in holding facilities, where most are made available for adoption.

Last year about $22 million of the entire horse program's $39 million budget was spent on holding horses in agency pens. Next year the costs are projected to grow to $26 million with an overall budget that is being trimmed to $37 million.

Lacy Dalton, president and co-founder of the Let 'Em Run Foundation horse advocacy group, urged the agency to consider alternative solutions.

They include efforts to step up birth control and legislation to provide tax breaks to large landowners willing to let horses roam on their property, she said.

"The American people have spoken — they want to preserve these wild horses," said Dalton.

"They are symbolic of the wildness and freedom and independent spirit of the West. We need to find ways to save them without being a burden on taxpayers," she added.

Agency officials said they stepped up the roundups in recent years because of ongoing drought that has left dwindling forage and water for the mustangs. Horse advocates insist the action was taken to placate ranchers.

The Bureau of Land Management's announcement marked the first time the agency publicly has discussed the possibility of putting surplus animals to death. Congress unanimously passed the 1971 Wild Free-Roaming Horses and Burros Act to protect the animals.

Posted 7/8/08 9:23 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

CallaLily
Thank you, Saint Gerard!

Member since 10/07

4937 total posts

Name:

Re: Proposal to euthanize wild horses spurs debate

I think that is disgusting. People treat animals as property instead of life. "Surpluse animals"...how horrible.

Posted 7/8/08 10:24 PM
 

MissJones
I need a nap!

Member since 5/05

22152 total posts

Name:

Re: Proposal to euthanize wild horses spurs debate

I'll support this when we also start to euthanize the surpluss of A-holes who roam the US!!!

Message edited 2008-07-08 23:33:11.403000.

Posted 7/8/08 11:32 PM
 

CaseyGirl
Mommy to 3 Boys :)

Member since 5/05

19978 total posts

Name:
Jen - counting my blessings...

Re: Proposal to euthanize wild horses spurs debate

Posted by Renee615

I think that is disgusting. People treat animals as property instead of life. "Surpluse animals"...how horrible.



I know I thought the same thing Chat Icon Is there anything we can do about this?!

Posted 7/9/08 7:25 AM
 

Diana712
RIP my beloved Brother Richard

Member since 5/07

6710 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Proposal to euthanize wild horses spurs debate

What happens to the horses if they do not euthanize them??? Are they tortured or left to die?? this is a very controversial situation that I just recentaly was eduacted on and I still dont know all of the facts. If these horses are being tortured, beaten or starved I really do not know what the right thing is here. Chat Icon

Message edited 2008-07-09 10:25:32.177000.

Posted 7/9/08 7:44 AM
 

lucyloo
nope

Member since 1/06

9758 total posts

Name:

Re: Proposal to euthanize wild horses spurs debate

Very sad.... but I'm sure this has been going on for a while. Instead of using birth control for some now they have to euthanize? Chat Icon

Posted 7/9/08 8:14 AM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Proposal to euthanize wild horses spurs debate

I don't understand. Why are they in "facilities" if they are wild and they take care of them? Why don't they just let them lose? The law of nature will take care of the weakest, etc...

Posted 7/9/08 10:03 AM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Proposal to euthanize wild horses spurs debate

I hate this. Its like the rationale hunters give for killing deer. The fact is that WE HUMANS have invaded and taken over the habitats of these animals. We have displaced or killed off their natural predators. We have left these animals with no where to go. Yet the solution is to kill them. YEP.

Posted 7/9/08 10:48 AM
 

Diana712
RIP my beloved Brother Richard

Member since 5/07

6710 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Proposal to euthanize wild horses spurs debate

Posted by SweetTooth

I hate this. Its like the rationale hunters give for killing deer. The fact is that WE HUMANS have invaded and taken over the habitats of these animals. We have displaced or killed off their natural predators. We have left these animals with no where to go. Yet the solution is to kill them. YEP.



Its sickning and heartbreaking!Chat Icon

Posted 7/9/08 10:55 AM
 

CaseyGirl
Mommy to 3 Boys :)

Member since 5/05

19978 total posts

Name:
Jen - counting my blessings...

Re: Proposal to euthanize wild horses spurs debate

Posted by dilb712

Posted by SweetTooth

I hate this. Its like the rationale hunters give for killing deer. The fact is that WE HUMANS have invaded and taken over the habitats of these animals. We have displaced or killed off their natural predators. We have left these animals with no where to go. Yet the solution is to kill them. YEP.



Its sickning and heartbreaking!Chat Icon



I know, good point....I think about this everytime I see YET ANOTHER shopping center, condo complex, office building going up...it really really bothers me. Chat Icon

Posted 7/9/08 1:04 PM
 

LaurenExp
Waiting patiently for baby sis

Member since 8/06

11613 total posts

Name:
L-Diddy EDD 11/11/11 :)

Re: Proposal to euthanize wild horses spurs debate

Posted by CaseyGirl

Posted by dilb712

Posted by SweetTooth

I hate this. Its like the rationale hunters give for killing deer. The fact is that WE HUMANS have invaded and taken over the habitats of these animals. We have displaced or killed off their natural predators. We have left these animals with no where to go. Yet the solution is to kill them. YEP.



Its sickning and heartbreaking!Chat Icon



I know, good point....I think about this everytime I see YET ANOTHER shopping center, condo complex, office building going up...it really really bothers me. Chat Icon



Me too. Chat Icon

Posted 7/9/08 1:09 PM
 

Juliet
Family is Complete!

Member since 5/05

5913 total posts

Name:
Juliet

Re: Proposal to euthanize wild horses spurs debate

This is horrible. I rememeber when I was young my uncle adopted 3 horses from the Adopt a Horse program BLM ran.

There are SO many horse lovers who would adopt these horses in a pinch. Why kill them?

Posted 7/9/08 1:49 PM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Proposal to euthanize wild horses spurs debate

Posted by Juliet

There are SO many horse lovers who would adopt these horses in a pinch. Why kill them?



No, there aren't. There are far more unwanted animals than homes, sadly.

I have been involved in horse rescue for over a decade. The idea that there are tons of qualified horse owners who are willing to take in ALL of these animals is untrue. Horse rescue programs, like local shelters, are overwhelmed with the number of animals coming in versus being adopted.

Horse people are well aware of the BLM adoption program -- Most of us simply can't afford to take in any more horses. (And this is coming from someone with TWO rescues. The price of horse keeping is rising with everything else - My horses cost me over $2000 per month and that doesn't include the money I spend on training and lessons.) It's cheaper in other parts of the country, but not so cheap people can just take in a horse like they would a dog or cat. Horses also require special care and expertise -- WILD horses require even MORE specialized care. There's a HUGE, enormous difference between a domesticated horse and a wild horse. Your average person with horse experience would be overwhelmed with a wild horse -- those without any horse experience would be a danger to themselves and the animal.

ETA -- and unlike small animal shelters, the overwhelming majority of horse rescues are no kill rescues -- In fact, I have never come across one that euthanizes animals who do not need to be euthanized... I'd be shocked to find a kill horse rescue.

I haven't really thought about this enough to form an opinion on the proposal to euthanize these horses. Do I think it's horrible? Yes. But I also think there are far worse fates than being humanely euthanized. I'm very conflicted on this one.

Message edited 2008-07-09 13:59:18.577000.

Posted 7/9/08 1:52 PM
 

TJLealand3
LIF Adolescent

Member since 6/07

839 total posts

Name:
Thomas

Re: Proposal to euthanize wild horses spurs debate

Fact ranchers need land to raise animals to earn a living, free range horses are great, but if they are taking the money out of your pocket you will ask the govenment for help, if you don't get any, you will kill the problem. That is why they have been herding the horses, the problem is that now they have no place for the extra animals. For everyone who thinks that they shoud run wild and we are intruding on their property, you should bulldoze your home and put a few horses there, be sure to buy feed and take them for a walk everyday.....

If the Vegans had their way, we wouldn't be at the top of the food chain........

Posted 7/9/08 3:47 PM
 

Juliet
Family is Complete!

Member since 5/05

5913 total posts

Name:
Juliet

Re: Proposal to euthanize wild horses spurs debate

Posted by Kara

Posted by Juliet

There are SO many horse lovers who would adopt these horses in a pinch. Why kill them?



No, there aren't. There are far more unwanted animals than homes, sadly.

I have been involved in horse rescue for over a decade. The idea that there are tons of qualified horse owners who are willing to take in ALL of these animals is untrue. Horse rescue programs, like local shelters, are overwhelmed with the number of animals coming in versus being adopted.

Horse people are well aware of the BLM adoption program -- Most of us simply can't afford to take in any more horses. (And this is coming from someone with TWO rescues. The price of horse keeping is rising with everything else - My horses cost me over $2000 per month and that doesn't include the money I spend on training and lessons.) It's cheaper in other parts of the country, but not so cheap people can just take in a horse like they would a dog or cat. Horses also require special care and expertise -- WILD horses require even MORE specialized care. There's a HUGE, enormous difference between a domesticated horse and a wild horse. Your average person with horse experience would be overwhelmed with a wild horse -- those without any horse experience would be a danger to themselves and the animal.

ETA -- and unlike small animal shelters, the overwhelming majority of horse rescues are no kill rescues -- In fact, I have never come across one that euthanizes animals who do not need to be euthanized... I'd be shocked to find a kill horse rescue.

I haven't really thought about this enough to form an opinion on the proposal to euthanize these horses. Do I think it's horrible? Yes. But I also think there are far worse fates than being humanely euthanized. I'm very conflicted on this one.



You don't think there are people who would adopt? Geez. Look at how many pay for retirement farms for their horses. Just taking one in and paying for it to live somewhere down south would be nice.

As far as taming them, I agree that it depends on experience. My uncle did it in the 80's and was somewhat successful but I would NEVER compare them to cats and dogs.

I guess I just don't like the idea of rounding them up and killing them. It just seems cruel even if they are being humanely euthanized. It's the idea of it.

Ugh, the cost of board is ridiculous on LI. I don't think I will ever be able to afford it.

Posted 7/9/08 3:51 PM
 

Diana712
RIP my beloved Brother Richard

Member since 5/07

6710 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Proposal to euthanize wild horses spurs debate

The problem is where does it end?? The situation has to be taken care of.. Hopefully if they do humanely euthanize these horses I would love for it to be a one and only time thing and learn from the mistakes that are being made. Not just keep letting this happen over and over. Like I said in my prior post this is such a contoversial subject. It just leaves you sad both ways you go.

Posted 7/9/08 4:14 PM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Proposal to euthanize wild horses spurs debate

Posted by Juliet

Posted by Kara

Posted by Juliet

There are SO many horse lovers who would adopt these horses in a pinch. Why kill them?



No, there aren't. There are far more unwanted animals than homes, sadly.

I have been involved in horse rescue for over a decade. The idea that there are tons of qualified horse owners who are willing to take in ALL of these animals is untrue. Horse rescue programs, like local shelters, are overwhelmed with the number of animals coming in versus being adopted.

Horse people are well aware of the BLM adoption program -- Most of us simply can't afford to take in any more horses. (And this is coming from someone with TWO rescues. The price of horse keeping is rising with everything else - My horses cost me over $2000 per month and that doesn't include the money I spend on training and lessons.) It's cheaper in other parts of the country, but not so cheap people can just take in a horse like they would a dog or cat. Horses also require special care and expertise -- WILD horses require even MORE specialized care. There's a HUGE, enormous difference between a domesticated horse and a wild horse. Your average person with horse experience would be overwhelmed with a wild horse -- those without any horse experience would be a danger to themselves and the animal.

ETA -- and unlike small animal shelters, the overwhelming majority of horse rescues are no kill rescues -- In fact, I have never come across one that euthanizes animals who do not need to be euthanized... I'd be shocked to find a kill horse rescue.

I haven't really thought about this enough to form an opinion on the proposal to euthanize these horses. Do I think it's horrible? Yes. But I also think there are far worse fates than being humanely euthanized. I'm very conflicted on this one.



You don't think there are people who would adopt? Geez. Look at how many pay for retirement farms for their horses. Just taking one in and paying for it to live somewhere down south would be nice.

As far as taming them, I agree that it depends on experience. My uncle did it in the 80's and was somewhat successful but I would NEVER compare them to cats and dogs.

I guess I just don't like the idea of rounding them up and killing them. It just seems cruel even if they are being humanely euthanized. It's the idea of it.

Ugh, the cost of board is ridiculous on LI. I don't think I will ever be able to afford it.



I know from experience that there aren't enough willing and qualified adopters to adopt these horses. I've worked with dozens of extremely well-run, well-marketed horse rescues for more than a decade and there have always been more unwanted animals than homes. Always.

The fact that the BLM project has been in place at least since the 80s and we are still overrun with animals no one will adopt is a testament to just that. Mustangs have been available through this project for decades and they are NOT easy to place or even sell for anything over meat prices.

It may sound harsh, but sometimes reality is. No, I'd never give up on horse rescues and I think every animal deserves a chance. That said, we need to accept the realities of the situation to make an appropriate decision here. I honestly don't have an opinion on this yet, but I'm pretty well versed in horse rescue.

Look at some of the horse-related message boards. See their "give aways" section -- often overrun with people giving away healthy, trained horses -- or at least domesticated ones. They are having a hard time even finding homes for those horses. It's a much easier sell than wild mustangs and PMU foals.

And when I rode as a pro, I worked with 2 BLM mustangs and a PMU foal. It's not a project most amateurs want to take on -- not one many pros do either.

I'm not saying this isn't sad and tragic -- I am saying that these homes we'd think would exist simply don't. I'm not sure we can change that. If we could, I don't think our local animal shelters would be overrun with unwanted animals.

It's not that I'm cold-hearted and want to see these animals die. To the contrary, I want people to recognize that there is not a simple solution here and at least understand the complexity of the situation so a decision in the best interests of these animals can be made. It's nice to think that there are all these horse lovers out there who want free horses. The reality is that there are tons of free / almost free horses out there -- and finding them homes isn't getting any easier. While adoption would be wonderful, the chances that will happen on a large enough scale to solve the problem are slim to none. Unfortunately, that is a reality that must be kept in mind in coming up with realistic, workable solutions to the problem.

Again, I honestly don't know where I stand on this... I'd rather see a horse humanely euthanized than starved to death, personally. I just don't have enough facts to form a real opinion on this one. I'd certainly want to give them any possible alternatives first.

That said, it's easy to say "oh, don't euthanize the poor animals!" It's not so easy to commit to taking on responsibility for one or more 1,000 pound wild prey animals that cost hundreds a month to keep fed, with proper vet care, de-worming, and proper shoes year-round... and let's remember that a horse is usually a 25+ year commitment.

I'm not trying to be Debbie Downer or advocate killing horses. I do want to be realistic, though, because that's the only way we can find workable solutions to these sorts of problems.

Posted 7/9/08 5:35 PM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Proposal to euthanize wild horses spurs debate

Posted by TJLealand3

Fact ranchers need land to raise animals to earn a living, free range horses are great, but if they are taking the money out of your pocket you will ask the govenment for help, if you don't get any, you will kill the problem. That is why they have been herding the horses, the problem is that now they have no place for the extra animals. For everyone who thinks that they shoud run wild and we are intruding on their property, you should bulldoze your home and put a few horses there, be sure to buy feed and take them for a walk everyday.....

If the Vegans had their way, we wouldn't be at the top of the food chain........



I'm sorry but I think your statements are absolutely absurd. So you think its right that we take over ever inch of land in the country and force out wild animals that have been around for a lot longer than us? And if they then get in our way to KILL them?

And what in the world do vegans have to do with any of this?

Posted 7/9/08 5:42 PM
 

Fourleggedfriend
LIF Zygote

Member since 6/08

30 total posts

Name:
Mary

Re: Proposal to euthanize wild horses spurs debate

No doubt it is to appease ranchers, some who are quite wealthy. So now the federal government will violate the very law they enacted to protect the horses.

Posted 7/9/08 7:15 PM