private school questions

Posted By Message

mommieofthree
LIF Infant

Member since 3/10

170 total posts

Name:

private school questions

please no flames, lol!

i dont want to start a public vs private school war. but. i had some questions. my DH reallllly is against sending our children (well 1 is ready to go into pre-k this sept) to private school.

i like the class sizes in private school and i feel like if im paying money for their education than im going to be happier. not sure.

he feels that all the teachers cant find jobs in public schools and they are just there, waiting to get out. i cant find a school district i like. we are in a very nice place now BUT i cant find something that is perfect.

any thoughts would be very appreciated.

Posted 8/27/10 2:02 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Sassyz75
Turning a new page

Member since 5/05

9731 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: private school questions

I really think it just depends..

It depends upon what is important to you in terms of your child's education.

It depends upon what private schools you are looking into and what your involvement will be in your child's education.

every school- both public and private- is different.. they have different levels of funding, different philosophies, etc.

so really- i'd suggest you actually do your homework.. not just look @ statistics but actually take tours of the schools you are interested in while in session.. that's what I did when I was deciding where DD would start pre-k.. and we decided to go public in our area due to the emphasis of the pre-k program and the extra curricular activities offered.

Posted 8/27/10 2:13 PM
 

snowprincess
My happy babies

Member since 3/06

3428 total posts

Name:

Re: private school questions

there are benifits and negatives to both

private
on the positive - there are smaller class sizes which is great especially for an average kid - who will not get any extra attention for special programs

the negative - not always programs available for gifted or learning disabilities - some kids have to go to their local district for services before there other school - amost no diversity

the teachers can be a mix - there are some teachers in private schools that love teaching and don't want to deal with overfilled class rooms or other district crap - also there are some teachers that leave the private sector and get jobs with minimal certificates but are amazing teachers


I went to public k-8th and private high school - I was honor student who was board in private school because they did not have a lot to offer me because it was a small school - but i had some great teachers and some terrible - but that can happen anywhere - but i may have been less board at a bigger private school

basic skills in elementry may be met better because the teacher has more hands on time but switching to public from private can be hard on some kids - they have trouble with so much freedom and get into trouble

this is just my opinion from going to both and watching kids i babysat - i lived in an area where about half the kids go to private school

Posted 8/27/10 2:16 PM
 

JC621
LIF Adolescent

Member since 8/08

616 total posts

Name:
JC

Re: private school questions

Posted by mommieofthree

he feels that all the teachers cant find jobs in public schools and they are just there, waiting to get out.



This may be true. But, on the other hand you are also likely to find teachers who work in private schools because they are passionate about that particular school's philosophy. Also, private school teachers are not tenured so you are also likely to find teachers who are constantly striving to prove that they are indeed an asset to the school that they work for. Private schools rely on positive word of mouth recommendations to keep their enrollment up, so it is in their best interest to hire good teachers.

Message edited 2010-08-27 14:24:08.473000.

Posted 8/27/10 2:22 PM
 

CunningOne
***

Member since 5/05

26975 total posts

Name:

Re: private school questions

My children are in private school. I absolutely love it there, it's like a family, and yes, the classes are small. My son's K class had 14 students in it. Almost all the teachers have been there 20+ years. I think that says a ton about their dedication. They are all qualified and certified and they follow the same NYS curriculum that the public schools do. There are many, many activities for them to be in, as well as sports. I don't feel like they get any less then their friends in the public school.

My DH was a product of the public schools and pushed for them as well. He wasn't "thrilled" with the idea of a Catholic school (which is all I've ever known), but said he would re-evaluate after the first year. After all, we are paying taxes and tuition, I couldn't blame him! Well, after my DS finished K, DH was floored with his progress and achievements and now he has no questions about the school. He loves it too.

FM me with any specific questions. I don't usually post since these threads often turn into a debate, although usually not intentional. Good Luck in your choice!

And I just want to say just because you spend money for their education doesn't mean you will be happy. It's a choice you will need to decide with your children in mind. It's not for everyone.

Message edited 2010-08-27 14:30:07.040000.

Posted 8/27/10 2:27 PM
 

computergirl
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3118 total posts

Name:

Re: private school questions

I'm a product of private school. Right now my DS is in private (catholic) preschool but I am choosing to send him to public school next year for kindergarten.

Honestly, it's very difficult to make any blanket statements about public vs. private. Every public school is different, every private school is different. Yes, looking back on my private school days, I think I did have some teachers who were there because they couldn't find work in public schools, but I also had some amazing teachers who were really dedicated. I'm sure the same range of quality can be found in public school.

Posted 8/27/10 2:36 PM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: private school questions

I've said this before - but you have to look at all the individual schools you are looking at and think of pros and cons for each. I don't think you can paint all private schools with the same brush and I think the same is true for public schools.

As a former private school employee, most of the people I worked with were not looking to leave the private schools, unless they really needed to earn more money. I was in high schools and would say that most of the teachers I worked with were certified and many had master's degrees. I liked the sense of community in the schools where I worked and most of the teachers I worked with stayed because they loved teaching and the school itself.

A few things to consider about public schools - if a child has any special ed needs, from my experience it is much easier to get services as a public school student. Some of the public schools have better programs in music, art, etc. If those things are important to you, I would ask at all the schools you are considering what they offer.

Posted 8/27/10 3:07 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: private school questions

I think everyone really said a lot of things that I was going to repeat. Definitely look at each school and their mission statement to know what their philosophy on education is.

As a private school teacher, I can tell you that we are not people who can't get jobs in public schools, we are people who wholeheartedly believe in our school's mission and in a different type of education than public schools. I could go get a public school job in a heart beat, in fact, I've been offered public school jobs, but I would never be able to teach my subject the way I know it needs to be taught.
I have more freedom to be creative with my curriculum and meet children where they are at, whether that be at a lower or higher level.
Like I said, definitely look at each school and their mission statement. Also, check out the nysais.org website and educate yourself more on independent schools. A good independent, private school (not a religious school) is accredited by the New York State Association of Independent Schools. NYSAIS makes sure that each school is living up to its mission statement and actually doing what they say they are. It's a common misconception that private schools can "just do whatever they want." While we are free to be creative with curriculum and what not, we do, like I said, have to actually DO what we say we believe in, not just talk about it.
HTH!

Posted 8/27/10 5:09 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
School district questions... Eriberry 5/23/08 2 Home
Spinoff to baptism... (school related questions) Xelindrya 3/12/08 4 Pregnancy
questions re: first week of school jewels 8/20/07 4 Teachers
Interview questions pre-school mikeswife06 8/14/07 1 Teachers
Teaching pre-school questions mikeswife06 5/1/07 2 Teachers
questions for teachers and school staff...backpacks janet 8/28/06 6 Families Helping Families ™