POWDER or RTF?

Posted By Message

pjay
YAY! I CAN WRITE HERE....

Member since 5/07

1551 total posts

Name:
PJAY

POWDER or RTF?

I have been solely using RTF and realized it is a heck of a lot more money )just did the math after going broke since we switched to allimentum).... Def thinking of switching to Powder..... what do u use? any reason not to switch to powder?

Posted 4/8/09 6:01 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

cjb88
Little Brother

Member since 5/05

3540 total posts

Name:
C

Re: POWDER or RTF?

some babies react to the powder differently then the RTF... every baby is different- for DD she did better on the powder vs. the RTF...

Posted 4/8/09 6:04 PM
 

Alli06
Baby #3 coming this June

Member since 8/05

6721 total posts

Name:
A

Re: POWDER or RTF?

I have been using RTF, but also want to switch to powder. I just bought a small can of powder to see how DS will react to it.

Posted 4/8/09 6:05 PM
 

pjay
YAY! I CAN WRITE HERE....

Member since 5/07

1551 total posts

Name:
PJAY

Re: POWDER or RTF?

Posted by cjb88

some babies react to the powder differently then the RTF... every baby is different- for DD she did better on the powder vs. the RTF...



how did she do better? less gas or something like that?

Posted 4/8/09 6:08 PM
 

Malishka31
LIF Infant

Member since 2/09

373 total posts

Name:

Re: POWDER or RTF?

my dd is 9 months now so now we can go to powder and actually regular similac works for us too but we HAD to use RTF if we wanted a normal child. Powder made her much much better than with milk based formulas but not nearly as good as RTF.

Powder contains corn maltodextrin (sp?) which some babies have a hard time adjusting too.

If i were you i would ask your PED for a sample size of powder alimentum to see if it works as well as RTF. You do not want to spend 30 bucks on powder to only throw it out- powder is only good for about a month once open.



on a side note- i bought ALL my alimentum from ebay and craiglists at about 4dollars a quart for RTF. Was cheaper than regular formula even that way

Message edited 2009-04-08 18:12:30.360000.

Posted 4/8/09 6:11 PM
 

pjay
YAY! I CAN WRITE HERE....

Member since 5/07

1551 total posts

Name:
PJAY

Re: POWDER or RTF?

Posted by Malishka31

my dd is 9 months now so now we can go to powder and actually regular similac works for us too but we HAD to use RTF if we wanted a normal child. Powder made her much much better than with milk based formulas but not nearly as good as RTF.

Powder contains corn maltodextrin (sp?) which some babies have a hard time adjusting too.

If i were you i would ask your PED for a sample size of powder alimentum to see if it works as well as RTF. You do not want to spend 30 bucks on powder to only throw it out- powder is only good for about a month once open.



on a side note- i bought ALL my alimentum from ebay and craiglists at about 4dollars a quart for RTF. Was cheaper than regular formula even that way



such great info.. thanks! i'll ask ped... they sell alimentum on craigslist? do u have a particular link to buy from? its safe? i never purchased anything like that on craigslist or ebay.

Posted 4/8/09 6:21 PM
 

pjay
YAY! I CAN WRITE HERE....

Member since 5/07

1551 total posts

Name:
PJAY

Re: POWDER or RTF?

Posted by Malishka31

my dd is 9 months now so now we can go to powder and actually regular similac works for us too but we HAD to use RTF if we wanted a normal child. Powder made her much much better than with milk based formulas but not nearly as good as RTF.

Powder contains corn maltodextrin (sp?) which some babies have a hard time adjusting too.

If i were you i would ask your PED for a sample size of powder alimentum to see if it works as well as RTF. You do not want to spend 30 bucks on powder to only throw it out- powder is only good for about a month once open.



on a side note- i bought ALL my alimentum from ebay and craiglists at about 4dollars a quart for RTF. Was cheaper than regular formula even that way

look at this..... link on craigslist

how do u know who to trust? why do u think she has 6 cases???????

Message edited 2009-04-08 18:24:30.820000.

Posted 4/8/09 6:23 PM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: POWDER or RTF?

we went to powder for cost and had no issues.

Posted 4/8/09 6:25 PM
 

Violet
content

Member since 7/06

1860 total posts

Name:
Mama :)

Re: POWDER or RTF?

I supplement with RTF, we did try powder last week, but DD spit out the nipple and made a face. We'll probably try again when is a few months older.

Personally I would only buy RTF from reputable stores, because you don't know how the individuals store the cans.

Posted 4/8/09 6:30 PM
 

july06bride
I'm a mom!

Member since 5/05

3966 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: POWDER or RTF?

We never used RTF but DD has not had a problem with powder. We use similac advance

Posted 4/8/09 6:31 PM
 

BeachMom
Love my 4 kiddos!

Member since 11/08

8346 total posts

Name:
Kristie

Re: POWDER or RTF?

Every child reacts differently to the different formulsa but it would definitly be worth it to thy the powder.
I used it with my DD and it was great!
It's so much easier to plan a day out with the powdered formula than the RTF.

Posted 4/8/09 6:33 PM
 

Malishka31
LIF Infant

Member since 2/09

373 total posts

Name:

Re: POWDER or RTF?

Well i had over 50 cases in my house and if i chose to trasition DD earlier i would have had many left and would have wanted to recoup my losses.

EVERY single time we went to pick up formula it was from people with kids. Small age kids , that clearly would have been on formula not long ago- no mother would ever sell bootlegged formula to another mother.

Also the packaging is hard to forge and once you smell alimentum you know that you can never replicate that nasty smell

have your child tested for a corn allergy which is very serious bc in america corn is in EVERYTHING.


in the case of the OP you can not just switch to powder because it should work the same, once you go to alimentum you already are sort of on the last straw for something that works and if thathappens to be RTF you thank god it exists b/c otherwise you would go insane as a parent .

Message edited 2009-04-08 18:38:30.403000.

Posted 4/8/09 6:36 PM
 

lkrpaul
Becoming a Big Brother!

Member since 5/07

2541 total posts

Name:
Laura

Re: POWDER or RTF?

My ped told us to use RTF until DS was at least 2 months because there's the smallest chance of contamination.

Posted 4/8/09 8:04 PM
 

TLC1018
I AM A BIG SISTER!!

Member since 8/07

3880 total posts

Name:
Tracy

Re: POWDER or RTF?

We use powder now. I used to use the RTF, but the powder is great too. I find it a lot easier to plan a day out with the powder formula, I just mix it as soon as she's ready for a bottle.

Posted 4/8/09 8:05 PM
 

dawnygirl25
Growing up soo fast..

Member since 1/06

14917 total posts

Name:
Dawn

Re: POWDER or RTF?

I used RTF mostly for the convenience bc I was working FT. I only used powder if we were going out somewhere bc it was easier to travel with.

Posted 4/8/09 8:24 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Anyone switch from RTF to powder? tell me if DC reacted btrflygrl 1/16/08 9 Parenting
Those who use carnation Good Start powder and Alimentum RTF MamaNDaddyof3 1/11/07 0 Parenting
powder vs RTF formula dawnygirl25 7/31/06 13 Parenting
Does anyone see a difference in baby with powder and the RTF formula?? bean 6/10/06 4 Parenting
I am giving in...no more RTF Similac it is powder for me.... bean 6/1/06 4 Parenting
Powder Formula vs. RTF? preciouslove 3/23/06 25 Parenting