Please shed some light on this

Posted By Message

jaysee00
LIF Adult

Member since 3/06

1647 total posts

Name:

Please shed some light on this

OK...my DD is 10 mo...has pretty much always been a great sleeper. She always uses the paci to sleep.

Anyway, she's been using the same pacifiers since she's been born. Chat Icon I bought some new ones a few months ago and threw a few in her crib along with the old and she has always gravitated towards using the old ones.

So tonight I only put the new ones in there and she's freaking out!!!!! She kept trying each one and kept getting frustrated. The old ones are obviously pretty soft. I don't *think* they would break but I don't feel comfortable taking the chance. I don't want to give in just to stop her from crying.

Am I doing the right thing or should I just give her the old ones? PLEASE I need opinions as I listen to her cry. Chat Icon

ETS: They are the Soothie brand. Please someone!! Chat Icon

Message edited 2009-12-01 19:25:35.340000.

Posted 12/1/09 7:24 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

randella
Love my little man

Member since 8/05

16290 total posts

Name:
Randi

Re: Please shed some light on this

I think as long as they are still sturdy, and can't break apart where it would become a choking hazard, it's ok. The soothies are also all one piece-- so, I htink you are pretty safe with that.

Posted 12/1/09 7:30 PM
 

organichic
LIF Adult

Member since 9/08

2223 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Please shed some light on this

Im not sure what the right thing to do is, but you got me thinking... DD is 10 months and still uses some of the same pacis from when she was born too (soothies also)Chat Icon Chat Icon I don't think I could tell the difference...

Maybe this is the time that you could wean her from pacis altogether if she doesn't take the new ones. I wouldn't give in (I would try my hardest not to) Hopefully she'll calm down in a few minutes!

Posted 12/1/09 7:32 PM
 

jaysee00
LIF Adult

Member since 3/06

1647 total posts

Name:

Re: Please shed some light on this

Thank you for your response!!! You see, they are very soft. It looks fine. It's just very soft. Uggh! I hate this. I feel so guilty because if I had switched them early on she wouldn't have known the difference. Oh, the mommy guilt. Chat Icon

Posted 12/1/09 7:32 PM
 

LIMOMx2
...

Member since 5/05

24989 total posts

Name:

Re: Please shed some light on this

Posted by randella

I think as long as they are still sturdy, and can't break apart where it would become a choking hazard, it's ok. The soothies are also all one piece-- so, I htink you are pretty safe with that.



I agree.

Posted 12/1/09 7:33 PM
 

jaysee00
LIF Adult

Member since 3/06

1647 total posts

Name:

Re: Please shed some light on this

Posted by organichic

Im not sure what the right thing to do is, but you got me thinking... DD is 10 months and still uses some of the same pacis from when she was born too (soothies also)Chat Icon Chat Icon I don't think I could tell the difference...

Maybe this is the time that you could wean her from pacis altogether if she doesn't take the new ones. I wouldn't give in (I would try my hardest not to) Hopefully she'll calm down in a few minutes!




Honestly, I didn't even think of switching them until my babysitter had mentioned that they make 3 mo & up ones. I did know that you had to be careful to make sure that you could tell they weren't going to fall apart.

The new ones seem sooo stiff in comparison. Maybe I could wean her. I went in a few minutes ago to soothe her. She started crying when I left, but she just stopped a min ago. Wish me luck.
Chat Icon

Posted 12/1/09 7:35 PM
 

randella
Love my little man

Member since 8/05

16290 total posts

Name:
Randi

Re: Please shed some light on this

Posted by jaysee00

Posted by organichic

Im not sure what the right thing to do is, but you got me thinking... DD is 10 months and still uses some of the same pacis from when she was born too (soothies also)Chat Icon Chat Icon I don't think I could tell the difference...

Maybe this is the time that you could wean her from pacis altogether if she doesn't take the new ones. I wouldn't give in (I would try my hardest not to) Hopefully she'll calm down in a few minutes!




Honestly, I didn't even think of switching them until my babysitter had mentioned that they make 3 mo & up ones. I did know that you had to be careful to make sure that you could tell they weren't going to fall apart.

The new ones seem sooo stiff in comparison. Maybe I could wean her. I went in a few minutes ago to soothe her. She started crying when I left, but she just stopped a min ago. Wish me luck.
Chat Icon



you know-- I stopped using this brand because I got the next size up and they are VERY hard...

If you are worried that she has been using these for a while and they need to be retired, just get new newborn ones. Sasha didn't like the harder ones either-- we use Nuks and Avents now.

Posted 12/1/09 7:43 PM
 

Elbee
Zanzibar

Member since 5/05

10767 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Please shed some light on this

DS is 2.5 and still uses the soothies. Who knows when the last time I actually purchased new ones was. I think its safe to give them to her.

Posted 12/1/09 7:48 PM
 

jaysee00
LIF Adult

Member since 3/06

1647 total posts

Name:

Re: Please shed some light on this

OK ladies. I am weak. Very weak.

I gave in. I can't believe it. I always thought I'd stand my ground on anything that came up. Yeah, right.

So now she's happily asleep. Thanks for the responses. Randi, buying the new newborn ones is a great idea. I thought these were hard because they were new.

I might also actually try to call the Soothie company this week. Thanks again!!

Posted 12/1/09 7:52 PM
 

LoriH
There's no place like home

Member since 8/07

4110 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Please shed some light on this

I would buy more of the newborn kind. DD HATED the other version of the soothies they are much harder.

Posted 12/1/09 7:54 PM
 

Elbee
Zanzibar

Member since 5/05

10767 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Please shed some light on this

I should have added we never moved to the 'harder' sizes - we kept the soft soothies. DS wouldn't take other brands either - he told me they were 'broken' when I tried Chat Icon

Posted 12/1/09 7:54 PM
 

organichic
LIF Adult

Member since 9/08

2223 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Please shed some light on this

That's probably why my DD doesn't notice the new ones vs the old ones... I kept with the small size. I got the bigger ones once and noticed how different they were, so I just went back to the smaller ones thinking "if it's not broken, why fix it".

Posted 12/1/09 8:25 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Can anyone shed some light on this . . . quehoraes 9/28/07 4 Pregnancy
OPK craziness! Can somebody shed light on this? alexlynn7 10/30/06 6 TTC
Can anyone shed some light???? ETA: If you HATE HATE HATE fuel prices too. come in and make some NOISE!~!!!!! Ophelia 2/25/08 10 Travel & Vacations
Xpost Question from preggo... Please shed some light 1stimemom 8/1/08 3 Parenting
can u girls shed some light **7/12 update MrsC 7/11/07 11 TTC