Please Help, Am I Making a Poor Choice?
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
Please Help, Am I Making a Poor Choice? My DD is 3 and a 1/2 years old. She is 41lbs and 43". We have the Britax Roundabout(40lbs max) which she's just grown out of. We were debating since she is there weight wise(over 40lbs) to switch to a highback booster seat and went to Babies R US and talked to what seemed like a very knowledgable/competent man who worked there. He said 100% positive that my DD IS ready for a highback booster and and that a 5-point harness is no good for her size anymore. After reviews I went with BRITAX again, the model is PARKWAY, SG. We ordered 3. Did I make the wrong decision being she isn't even 4 until October, but again, is over 40lbs? |
|
Posted 4/15/12 7:50 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Please Help, Am I Making a Poor Choice? I disagree about 5 point harnesses being not good for her age Message edited 2012-04-15 20:01:08.807000. |
|
Posted 4/15/12 7:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: Please Help, Am I Making a Poor Choice? This was discussed recently on Parents Of School Age Children...thought it might be helpful |
|
Posted 4/15/12 8:09 PM
|
|
|
Re: Please Help, Am I Making a Poor Choice? Posted by Bops This was discussed recently on Parents Of School Age Children...thought it might be helpful http://www.lifamilies.com/chat/topic-727794-1.html Thanks! The salesman said with a 5-point harness on a child whose bigger and if God forbid you're in an accident, it could hurt their neck because there's no give in the belt and the harness stays in place where as a seatbelt has "give" in it. |
|
Posted 4/15/12 8:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: Please Help, Am I Making a Poor Choice? I agree with Bops. My almost 6 year old is still in a 5 point harness (43lbs). I plan to keep her in one as long as I can. She has the Marathon so it goes higher than 40lbs, but I'd be getting her a bigger one if it didn't. As Bops said, when she sits in the booster in other cars, she is never tight enough with the seatbelt, turns around, messes with the belt, etc...I'm just not comfortable with it. |
|
Posted 4/15/12 8:16 PM
|
|
|
Re: Please Help, Am I Making a Poor Choice? Posted by BabyLove08 Posted by Bops This was discussed recently on Parents Of School Age Children...thought it might be helpful http://www.lifamilies.com/chat/topic-727794-1.html Thanks! The salesman said with a 5-point harness on a child whose bigger and if God forbid you're in an accident, it could hurt their neck because there's no give in the belt and the harness stays in place where as a seatbelt has "give" in it. Interesting....never heard that... Maybe FM Tarabelle (I think thats her SN)..She is the car seat pro
|
|
Posted 4/15/12 8:16 PM
|
|
|
Re: Please Help, Am I Making a Poor Choice? Posted by BabyLove08 Posted by Bops This was discussed recently on Parents Of School Age Children...thought it might be helpful http://www.lifamilies.com/chat/topic-727794-1.html Thanks! The salesman said with a 5-point harness on a child whose bigger and if God forbid you're in an accident, it could hurt their neck because there's no give in the belt and the harness stays in place where as a seatbelt has "give" in it. Sorry, but WHAT??? If that were the case, why would they make carseats that go up to much higher weights? |
|
Posted 4/15/12 8:17 PM
|
|
|
Re: Please Help, Am I Making a Poor Choice? Just saw that Tarabelle99 did comment on page 2 of the above thread, if you were interested in reading it |
|
Posted 4/15/12 8:19 PM
|
|
|
Re: Please Help, Am I Making a Poor Choice? My children are tall and pass the height restriction of the marathon before the age of 6. They have to switch to boosters. Message edited 2012-04-15 20:39:15.890000. |
|
Posted 4/15/12 8:37 PM
|
|
|
Re: Please Help, Am I Making a Poor Choice? Posted by BabyLove08 Posted by Bops This was discussed recently on Parents Of School Age Children...thought it might be helpful http://www.lifamilies.com/chat/topic-727794-1.html Thanks! The salesman said with a 5-point harness on a child whose bigger and if God forbid you're in an accident, it could hurt their neck because there's no give in the belt and the harness stays in place where as a seatbelt has "give" in it. I'm not a carseat specialist but that sounds like bull IMO. Even though the seat belt has "give" it will lock in an accident therefore keeping it in place. The salesmen is probably just that. He is telling you what he has learned and his opinions. I would contact tarabelle or carseatchris (sn?) And discuss it with them. Again, I'm no expert, but IMO, you should keep your DD in a 5 point harness. DS's seat (evenflo symphony 65) allows them to be harnessed until 65 pounds and in the seat up to 100 pounds. It has an adjustable headrest so taller children can stay in it longer too. As a parent you have to do what you feel is best for your child, but if you have to ask a question like this, I think you are realizing the answer is to keep her in the 5 point. |
|
Posted 4/15/12 8:49 PM
|
|
|
Re: Please Help, Am I Making a Poor Choice? Return all of them and buy 3 Graco Nautilus's..They harness up to 65lbs and then turn into a HBB and a LBB... They make higher weight ones because it is SAFER for them to be harnessed longer! Get his name and contact the manager. He has no idea what he is saying. |
|
Posted 4/15/12 9:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: Please Help, Am I Making a Poor Choice? Posted by BabyLove08 Posted by Bops This was discussed recently on Parents Of School Age Children...thought it might be helpful http://www.lifamilies.com/chat/topic-727794-1.html Thanks! The salesman said with a 5-point harness on a child whose bigger and if God forbid you're in an accident, it could hurt their neck because there's no give in the belt and the harness stays in place where as a seatbelt has "give" in it. Horseshit! There's not give in a seat belt when you're in an accident either.(know when you're driving and you hit the brakes and the belt locks on you? That's what happens in a crash..... which is the same as what a harness does) And that "give" that is there when the emergency locking retractor isn't engaged could be dangerous to a younger child because it allows them to be out of position. Also, a 5 pt harness spreads crash forces over more of the body than a seat belt does. An ill fitting seat belt, usually will ride up too high on the abdomen, can lead to severe abdominal injuries. A seatbelt on a smaller child it can actually allow them to submarine underneath it. Yes, the Parkway SG has a clip for the submarining issue but that doesn't resolve the myriad of other issues of boostering a 3yo. 3 year olds do not belong in boosters. The vast majority of 4 year olds do not belong in boosters, especially younger 4yos. Most kids aren't ready to full time booster until 5 or 6. It is recommended to keep them harnessed until they outgrow it now, usually about age 6. Yes, I know what's legal. Yes, I know it is legally to booster a child over 40lbs. Do you know why? Because when those laws were passed the majority of seats on the market didn't harness past 40lbs. Laws take time to be passed and are normally behind official recommendations. I just want to state that just because it's legal doesn't mean it's the safest option. The laws are the bare minimum, they're there for the kids who otherwise wouldn't be protected at all. Think of them as a "well it's better than nothing" type of thing. Can you FM me the BRU location so I can contact a manager about this? I hate when their sales guys do this. BRU and BBB's sales clerks are just that: Sales Clerks. Not CPST's. They receive little to no safety training, certainly nothing to the extent of a CPST. If you happen to meet one that IS a CPST then that is a rare thing. |
|
Posted 4/15/12 9:21 PM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Am I making a bad choice here, re: DD sleeping at night? | TaraHutch | 7/8/09 | 26 | Parenting |
| Should I get induced, my own choice, not my DR making me do it | pickles16 | 4/7/11 | 20 | Pregnancy |
| My poor DH... | KPtoys | 6/21/05 | 30 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Good products for making your hair MORE curly?? | maybride2004 | 6/18/05 | 1 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Poor Dharma UPDATE @ bottom | Jesaroo | 6/12/05 | 20 | Pets |
| my poor lizzy! | janet | 6/7/05 | 2 | Pets |






