Please be honest, will it look dumb...?

Posted By Message

~Melissa~

Member since 5/06

1462 total posts

Name:

Please be honest, will it look dumb...?

My kitchen has red oak hardwood floors, stained a honey color, sorta. The previous owners installed the floors when they gutted the kitchen a year before we moved in. The rest of the house is/was carpeted. (no wood floors under carpet)

The kitchen has two openings into the living room, one is a regular doorway, the other is a wider one (maybe the length of two doorways).

We ripped up the carpet in the living room 2 weeks ago and are trying to decide what kind of hardwood to put in.

My two choices are a) install the same red oak that is in the kitchen and try to match the stain
or
b) install maple floors Chat Icon and stain them a dark chocolate brown (sorta?).

DH and I realllllllllly want the maple, but are worried that it is going to look dumb, since the kitchen and living room floors meet up. What do you think?

Posted 10/28/08 4:50 PM
 
Prudential Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
  |   Long Island Weddings

Jenn627
Laaaaaaaambert!

Member since 5/08

9818 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: Please be honest, will it look dumb...?

go for it...

They're two separate rooms.

My brother has two diff color hardwoods in his house. The planks run in different directions though.

His hallway is a light honey color running up and down, his DR is a reddish brown hardwood running side to side.

It looks nice, breaks it up...

Posted 10/28/08 4:53 PM
 

SuzyQ
Mama to 3!?!?!?

Member since 7/06

8069 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: Please be honest, will it look dumb...?

Tough question. We just did our DR floors (replaced carpet with HW) and we matched everything else, but the entire foyer/kitchen/hallway are HW and we liked them. Maybe you can do the darker floors if you have some sort of separation between the 2 floors, like a section of floor going a different way in the doorway. Does that make sense? I think it might look ok. Do you have a picture so I could visualize more?

Posted 10/28/08 4:54 PM
 

kat151
LIF Infant

Member since 2/07

215 total posts

Name:
Kathy

Re: Please be honest, will it look dumb...?

Honestly yes. I only say it because we changed the majority of our wood floors when we moved into our new home with the exception of 2 bedrooms. Now we regret it so badly because you can never match the stain perfectly and it looks off. We saw a show that actually said that having 2 different types of wood flooring decreases the value of your home. Why can't you get the same red oak flooring and have your kitchen sanded down and stain all of them at the same time the dark color you want?

Posted 10/28/08 4:55 PM
 

~Melissa~

Member since 5/06

1462 total posts

Name:

Re: Please be honest, will it look dumb...?

I'm not sure if I like red oak when it is stained dark...I am scared of all the grain showing up a little too much. We like maple because it's not as grainy.

So, what if I said that the entire house will eventually be done in the dark maple floors with the exception of the kitchen? Does that make it better?

Oh, and what about doing the dark maple everywhere but sanding/staining the kitchen floor to match (even though it's oak)?

Posted 10/28/08 5:03 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Please be honest, will it look dumb...?

Posted by ~Melissa~



Oh, and what about doing the dark maple everywhere but sanding/staining the kitchen floor to match (even though it's oak)?



this is what I would do. good luck.

Posted 10/28/08 5:30 PM
 

kat151
LIF Infant

Member since 2/07

215 total posts

Name:
Kathy

Re: Please be honest, will it look dumb...?

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by ~Melissa~



Oh, and what about doing the dark maple everywhere but sanding/staining the kitchen floor to match (even though it's oak)?



this is what I would do. good luck.



I agree I would do that.

Posted 10/28/08 5:42 PM
 

SuzyQ
Mama to 3!?!?!?

Member since 7/06

8069 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: Please be honest, will it look dumb...?

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by ~Melissa~



Oh, and what about doing the dark maple everywhere but sanding/staining the kitchen floor to match (even though it's oak)?



this is what I would do. good luck.



I think I would do this too if it's possible.

Posted 10/28/08 5:43 PM
 

Summergrl73
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/07

510 total posts

Name:
Excited

Re: Please be honest, will it look dumb...?

My living room/dining room goes against my kitchen and the floors are different colors and it looks fine-- Go for It!!

Posted 10/28/08 5:46 PM
 

kellsbells7
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/07

590 total posts

Name:

Re: Please be honest, will it look dumb...?

It may cost a little x-tra money, but why not have the floor guys put a design incorporating both woods as like, a saddle, where the two rooms meet. I think that would look awesome!External Image

Posted 10/28/08 5:59 PM
 

~Melissa~

Member since 5/06

1462 total posts

Name:

Re: Please be honest, will it look dumb...?

Posted by SuzyQ

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by ~Melissa~



Oh, and what about doing the dark maple everywhere but sanding/staining the kitchen floor to match (even though it's oak)?



this is what I would do. good luck.



I think I would do this too if it's possible.



Okay I am leaning toward this option. :) Thanks for your opinions everyone! If I had my way Chat Icon I would replace the kitchen floors, but since they are practically brand new I can't justify it.

Posted 10/29/08 9:44 AM
 

Chatham-Chick
*********************

Member since 5/05

10312 total posts

Name:

Re: Please be honest, will it look dumb...?

Posted by ~Melissa~

Oh, and what about doing the dark maple everywhere but sanding/staining the kitchen floor to match (even though it's oak)?





That's what I would do

or

I would just leave the kitchen floors and use the maple w/dark stain throughout the rest of the house.

It's not uncommon for homes to have kitchens with different types of flooring then the rest of the house, so I wouldn't necessarily find it strange if the kitchen's flooring looked different.

Message edited 2008-10-29 10:06:56.203000.

Posted 10/29/08 10:06 AM
 

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: Please be honest, will it look dumb...?

Definitely do what you LOVE in the rest of the house .......I wouldnt' try to match something I was 'eh' about to begin with KWIM?

I personally don't think it looks bad if the wood floors don't 'match' - But I hate when everything in a house is matchy matchy -

If it were tile or something else, it wouldn't match anyway - KWIM?

If you wanted to, you could always try to stain the kitchen to match the rest of the house .......

Keep in mind though that DARK wood floors show every spec of dust - I don't know if I'd want it in the kitchen -invest in a LOT of swiffers !!! Chat Icon

Posted 10/29/08 11:09 AM
 

MrsS2005
Mom of 3

Member since 11/05

13118 total posts

Name:
B

Re: Please be honest, will it look dumb...?

Posted by kat151

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by ~Melissa~



Oh, and what about doing the dark maple everywhere but sanding/staining the kitchen floor to match (even though it's oak)?



this is what I would do. good luck.



I agree I would do that.


I agree. We saw a ton of houses and I always noticed the flooring. I personally hated when there were 5 or 6 different types of floors, especially when there were several different hardwood floors. However, the kitchen typically has different flooring than the rest of the house. I'd pick the type of floors you love and not worry if the kitchen is different.

Posted 10/29/08 11:21 AM
 

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

Re: Please be honest, will it look dumb...?

Posted by Jenn627

go for it...

They're two separate rooms.

My brother has two diff color hardwoods in his house. The planks run in different directions though.

His hallway is a light honey color running up and down, his DR is a reddish brown hardwood running side to side.

It looks nice, breaks it up...



My sister and BIL did the same thing - they have dark hardwood in the dining room and a very light maple in the kitchen, the floors are laid almost perpendicular to each other - it looks really nice!

Posted 10/29/08 1:08 PM
 

~Melissa~

Member since 5/06

1462 total posts

Name:

Re: Please be honest, will it look dumb...?

Okay so I made my decision. We are getting 5" wide maple planks, sanding the kitchen down, and staining all the floors the same color (dark). I think it will look better than leaving them light and being right next to the new dark floor.

Thank you sooo much everyone. Chat Icon
I will post picture when it's all done in a few weeks!

Posted 11/3/08 7:31 PM
 

LaPetiteSirène
:)

Member since 8/06

5196 total posts

Name:

Re: Please be honest, will it look dumb...?

I have two different types of hardwood in my house and I love the contrast.

Our entire house (except for the kitchen) has gorgeous oak floors that are original to the house. They are a mix of dark and light colors.

We wanted wood floors in the kitchen but we knew that we'd never be able to perfectly match up the unique look of 100 year old floors. The kitchen is all mahogany which matches the dark part of the rest of the house.

HTH!

Posted 11/3/08 7:39 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
ok..before i call the dr and look dumb i alex7-2 7/26/06 9 Parenting
Would it be dumb to look for a LI job if I knew I might be TTC in the summer? beautyq115 9/11/07 19 Teachers
Area rug over carpet?? Will this look dumb? - Now with pic Tine73 5/24/07 13 Home
Ok, I am about to ask a REALLY dumb question.... bean 3/20/06 3 Parenting
Dumb *** move of the day!! Karen 3/5/06 7 Families Helping Families â„¢