Nutramigen Vs. Alimentum questions, please help

Posted By Message

Deedlebugs
Blessed

Member since 12/05

10281 total posts

Name:
Kiki

Nutramigen Vs. Alimentum questions, please help

So, DS has been on Nutramigen for a week, he is doing amazing on it BUT barely eats. Its a struggle to get him to finish 3oz, he just hates the taste. The Ped. gave me a case of Alimentum RTF, he said that they are both the same and that it doesn't matter which one he is on. So, he seems to like the taste of the Alimentum and there doesn't seem to be much of a difference in his behavior BUT last night he actually woke to eat at 3am, which he hasn't done in a week. My question is this, is RTF different than powder? Will he feel full on the powder Alimentum? Should I just stick with the Nutramigen since he has been doing well on it and just deal with him struggling to eat it? Im so afraid to rock the boat BUT I also hate watching him struggle to taste the Nutramigen. The Alimentum from my insurance will be powder and not RTF so should I buy a can and try that? The only negative with the Nutramigen is that he barely eats it.

Posted 3/19/10 8:34 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

CucumberGirl
You give the best smiles!

Member since 1/09

2398 total posts

Name:
M~

Re: Nutramigen Vs. Alimentum questions, please help

I haven't tried Nutramigen but a friend of mine was going to for her DS and the smell of it made her almost vomit so she ended up using something else instead (I think she used Gentlease but her DS' allergy was not particularly severe). I use the Alimentum RTF and I wouldn't say it smells good, but it doesn't make me want to vomit either - it just smells like wet bread to me - so that makes me think it does taste better and DD does eat it heartily. I've been scared to use the powder because DD does really well on the RTF and I read a lot of reviews online from moms that said their DC just didn't do as well on the RTF so I'm planning on waiting until she's 3 months so her digestive system is a little more developed and trying the powder then. Our insurance will not cover this regardless so that's not a factor for us. I'm also thinking about trying soy then too. She may also be allergic to soy but she may not be so I'm considering trying it in the coming months. We'll see how brave I get. It's hard to mess with a good thing.

Posted 3/19/10 10:23 PM
 

Peainapod
Peanuts are here!

Member since 1/09

13591 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Nutramigen Vs. Alimentum questions, please help

hmmm..how old is your DC? DS started on alimentum at like a week old-10 days..i forget. but that stuff smells awful. PEd said if DS was starting at 2 or 3 months that he may give us a hard time eating b/c of the taste. But if you start early on its easier since they dont know anything different. DS sucks this stuff down...apparently the god awful smell doesnt bother him..LOL.

I used to feed DS every 2-2 1/2 hours b/c alimentum is very thin. Not sure if this is the same as nutramigen, but because its so broken down, Ive been told its common for them to eat more frequently. so maybe thats why he woke in the middle of the nite?

Posted 3/19/10 10:43 PM
 

mrswask
Pookie Love

Member since 5/05

20229 total posts

Name:
Michal

Re: Nutramigen Vs. Alimentum questions, please help

Does your doctor had you putting anything in the alimentum? Our ped (and the ped GI confirmed it) has us putting 1 teaspoon per ounce of oatmeal in the Alimentum - to help with his bad reflux and also to fill him up more since the Alimentum is so thin.

Posted 3/19/10 10:52 PM
 

Deedlebugs
Blessed

Member since 12/05

10281 total posts

Name:
Kiki

Re: Nutramigen Vs. Alimentum questions, please help

Posted by mrswask

Does your doctor had you putting anything in the alimentum? Our ped (and the ped GI confirmed it) has us putting 1 teaspoon per ounce of oatmeal in the Alimentum - to help with his bad reflux and also to fill him up more since the Alimentum is so thin.



No, nothing mixed with the Alimentum. I called the doctor and we officially switched him to the Alimentum today. He just couldn't stand the taste of the Nutramigin and was barely eating . The only downside so far or maybe its a good thing, is that he has only had 1 BM today and he is eating more oz per feeding.

Posted 3/19/10 10:56 PM
 

CucumberGirl
You give the best smiles!

Member since 1/09

2398 total posts

Name:
M~

Re: Nutramigen Vs. Alimentum questions, please help

Posted by Deedlebugs

Posted by mrswask

Does your doctor had you putting anything in the alimentum? Our ped (and the ped GI confirmed it) has us putting 1 teaspoon per ounce of oatmeal in the Alimentum - to help with his bad reflux and also to fill him up more since the Alimentum is so thin.



No, nothing mixed with the Alimentum. I called the doctor and we officially switched him to the Alimentum today. He just couldn't stand the taste of the Nutramigin and was barely eating . The only downside so far or maybe its a good thing, is that he has only had 1 BM today and he is eating more oz per feeding.



This may be a good thing - DD was going with every feeding - I didn't know that might be too much - and now goes 1-2 times a day. Most days only once. Ped said it's absolutely fine.

Posted 3/19/10 11:14 PM
 

mrswask
Pookie Love

Member since 5/05

20229 total posts

Name:
Michal

Re: Nutramigen Vs. Alimentum questions, please help

Since he's been on the Alimentum and oatmeal, DS is only going every other day. It's like clockwork! He does not seemed bothered by it though.

Posted 3/19/10 11:22 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Nutramigen vs. Alimentum? pumpkinpye517 7/20/08 4 Parenting
Weaning off Nutramigen/Alimentum? Lucky09 9/13/09 3 Parenting
alimentum/ nutramigen users luckyinlove 4/22/09 4 Parenting
similac alimentum vs enfamil nutramigen pjay 3/24/09 2 Parenting
Similac Alimentum & Emfamil Nutramigen - I'm ready to cry! runlikethewind 9/25/08 25 Parenting
nutramigen vs alimentum? Teri 1/6/07 14 Parenting