NPR: Frontline or Advantix (X-post)

Posted By Message

MayBbaby21
Baby no. 3 coming soon!

Member since 6/09

5738 total posts

Name:

NPR: Frontline or Advantix (X-post)

I posted this on pets but no one's responding, so I thought I'd try here. If you have a dog, do you have preference or know if one is better than the other?
We're having a flea issue since late October....we think they're gone and then a few weeks later we'll find one or two on him. He had Advantix at the end of Oct and followed up with Capstar (oral pill) from the vet. But now, we found a few on him this weekend.
We're neat freaks to begin with, but since this, we've really been crazy about cleaning. DH is actually an exterminator, but he can't spray in the house since I'm pregnant (and I'm anti-chemical to begin with, which is why I didn't pre-treat the dog). Baby is coming very soon. I need this to end!

So it's time for a follow-up topical treatment. Not sure if I should go with Frontline? It seems some people like it better. Thoughts?

ETA: Meant Advantix--not Advantage.

Message edited 2010-12-07 19:39:28.073000.

Posted 12/7/10 4:26 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Ivyqueenz
LIF Toddler

Member since 12/09

468 total posts

Name:
Sandra

Re: NPR: Frontline or Advantage (X-post)

I've never tried Advantage so I can't compare. But I use Frontline and have from the beginning. I know i am not help but I am offering Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon. Hope you can fix the problem before LO gets here.

Posted 12/7/10 4:43 PM
 

drwifettc
LIF Adult

Member since 6/10

2348 total posts

Name:

Re: NPR: Frontline or Advantage (X-post)

I've used both and couldn't tell you the difference. They both did their job, no fleas. We've been using frontline since early summer and are happy with it. I'd do it and maybe a really good flea bath before the baby comes. Hoping it clears up soon!

Posted 12/7/10 4:46 PM
 

MrsKS
Thank You St. Gerard.....

Member since 12/09

8306 total posts

Name:
Kerri

Re: NPR: Frontline or Advantage (X-post)

I had a flea issue and we used Advantage.

I think they are roughly the same.

What's more important.. is where is your dog going?? I think one of the places someone is taking your dog to must be infested... and every time he goes there more fleas will jump on him. I would start thinking about that aspect of it. So you can stop taking the dog to that area or location.

Of course if dog is covered with Advantage, you should be OK. But fleas are a terrible thing to have! and super hard to get rid of!! They live forever and never freaking die!!! External Parasites!!!!! UGH!!! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-12-07 16:55:07.153000.

Posted 12/7/10 4:54 PM
 

MayBbaby21
Baby no. 3 coming soon!

Member since 6/09

5738 total posts

Name:

Re: NPR: Frontline or Advantage (X-post)

Thanks ladies. I'm wondering if it's the groomer. It looks really clean, but who really knows. He was there 2 weeks ago and we noticed new fleas again this weekend. It could be our back yard, but it's getting so cold out there, I'd think they'd die off now. We've really been on top of it--cleaning, treating, bathing him, combing him with a flea comb, etc, so I am at my wit's end and have nightmares about fleas!
I've been told flea baths are really harsh and often ineffective. I bathed him in original Dawn this weekend because I heard that's a gentler approach that works, but DH found one today, so I guess not.

Posted 12/7/10 7:37 PM
 

KNic19
Baby's First Christmas

Member since 7/09

3541 total posts

Name:
Kim

Re: NPR: Frontline or Advantix (X-post)

We use Frontline, never tried Advantix. My MIL uses frontline on her 6 dogs, and has never had a flea problem.

Posted 12/7/10 8:07 PM
 

maybeababy2010
LIF Adult

Member since 8/09

1423 total posts

Name:

Re: NPR: Frontline or Advantix (X-post)

we've used frontline since we got our dog 5 years ago and have never had an issue.

Posted 12/7/10 8:38 PM
 

sunflowerjesss
Mommy to 3!

Member since 10/05

20369 total posts

Name:
Jesss, duh.

Re: NPR: Frontline or Advantix (X-post)

I've always used Frontline.

But any time we had a flea problem I would give the dog a Capstar 1x per day for 3 days and then again 1 week later to prevent them from rehatching and starting it all over again.

Also, make sure once you have given capstar to wash all bedding/fabrics and vacuum all the carpets. The vet told us a flea egg can survive something like 3-6 months before hatching, so I would definitely keep up on the frontline once you start.

Posted 12/7/10 9:01 PM
 

MayBbaby21
Baby no. 3 coming soon!

Member since 6/09

5738 total posts

Name:

Re: NPR: Frontline or Advantix (X-post)

Posted by sunflowerjesss

I've always used Frontline.

But any time we had a flea problem I would give the dog a Capstar 1x per day for 3 days and then again 1 week later to prevent them from rehatching and starting it all over again.

Also, make sure once you have given capstar to wash all bedding/fabrics and vacuum all the carpets. The vet told us a flea egg can survive something like 3-6 months before hatching, so I would definitely keep up on the frontline once you start.



Our vet would only let me give him 1/4 of a tablet of of capstar one day and then repeated one week later b/c he's a small dog. I don't think it did much--but yeah, we clean and launder anything he touches on the same day we give treatment.

Posted 12/7/10 9:34 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Pls. help regarding advantage / Frontline and FLEAS !! KittyCat 10/22/07 7 Pets
NPR but can't post this anywhere else - I feel like I found buried treasure lipglossjunky73 10/4/08 6 Parenting
I'm so mad...NPR but this is where I post the most...(Sorry it's so long) mommy0604 9/26/08 31 Parenting
NPR but this is where I post the most Lucky 8/16/08 12 Sports
NPR but with this post... bayla 5/26/07 4 Pregnancy
NPR: Post your favorite Wedding Pic! mommy2bella 12/12/05 27 Parenting