Need your opinion

Posted By Message

AMPirate
Missing our peanut :(

Member since 11/09

1678 total posts

Name:
Antoinette

Need your opinion

Here is the scenario:

Two people own a piece of property. There is no mortgage on the property-they own it free and clear. If one of the two people live in the house and the other dosen't, should the one who lives there be paying "rent" to person that doesn't live there? If yes, how do you determine how much? If no, why not? Thanks!

Posted 6/6/12 5:10 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

JennZ
MY LIFE!!

Member since 8/05

25463 total posts

Name:

Re: Need your opinion

I would think any "rent" would be the taxes and YES they should spilt them.

Posted 6/6/12 5:19 PM
 

MsSissy
xoxoxo

Member since 3/07

39159 total posts

Name:

Re: Need your opinion

If they both own it.
I don't think either should be paying "rent". I think the person living in it just needs to pay 1/2 the taxes and whatever utilities they use while living there.

Posted 6/6/12 5:22 PM
 

greenybeans
:)

Member since 8/06

6435 total posts

Name:

Re: Need your opinion

It depends on the situation. I think they should cover the whole tax bill and all of the household bills, including maintenance and repairs. For me that would be enough.

If they are paying rent I would expect the person who is not living there to cover half of the taxes, bills, repair costs, landscaping, etc...

ETA: If they were paying rent it would make more sense (to me) to buy the person out.

Message edited 2012-06-06 17:29:31.490000.

Posted 6/6/12 5:27 PM
 

FranM
And so it goes....

Member since 9/05

2217 total posts

Name:

Re: Need your opinion

If it were me I would like to keep it equitable. I would at it like this - If we were to rent out the property what would we each get for it? The person not living there should be able to get close to that amount.

Split the taxes, the person living there would pay a discounted fair market rent Discount the rent by half the fair market value plus a little more to take into account if the person living there will be caring for and maintiaining the home.

Message edited 2012-06-06 17:31:32.553000.

Posted 6/6/12 5:28 PM
 

PhyllisNJoe
My Box Is Broken

Member since 6/11

9145 total posts

Name:
Phyllis

Re: Need your opinion

i think the person living there should be paying 1/2 the taxes and obviously their own gas/lipa/water bc they are there using it.

Any major repairs (roof, plumbing, etc) should be split in half.

They would have to split those costs if they rented it out.

Posted 6/6/12 7:05 PM
 

Domino
Always My Miracle

Member since 9/05

9924 total posts

Name:

Re: Need your opinion

If a relative passed away and willed my brother and I their house, lets just say, and I wanted to live in it:

With the exception of major structural repairs, I believe that I should bear the cost of all expenses related to the home (taxes, utilities, maintenance), however I do not feel I should have to pay rent on top of it.

Posted 6/6/12 7:29 PM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Need your opinion

It would depend on who the two people are.

Theoretically if I am the person NOT living in it I am losing out on rent OR the money I would make if I sold the house.

If it were say, my brother, and I was not financially in need of the income I would not collect rent from him but would expect him to cover any taxes and other costs.

If it were someone else, I would expect rent or the person to buy me out.

Posted 6/6/12 8:28 PM
 

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Need your opinion

I think the person living there shoud cover all f the taxes and household bills. Basic maintenance repairs should be covered by the person living there, but big expenses like new roof, furnace, etc.. Should be split as that is basic expenses that come up for any home owner. If I was in need of money I would maybe try to become a mortgage holder to let the other party buy me out.

Posted 6/6/12 8:47 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Need your opinion

To make it fair, I would have both people split the taxes on the house. The person living in the house pays 1/2 of the fair market value on rent of the house (determined by looking at rental prices on the area).

As for the upkeep & maintenance, etc, I would treat the person living in it as I would any other tenant. If I were renting out the house, I'd have the tenant responsible for the lawn maintenance, etc. Big ticket items would be split evenly by the owners.

Does the non-tenant owner want to keep the house?

Posted 6/6/12 9:22 PM
 

Gdesq
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

1314 total posts

Name:

Re: Need your opinion

Posted by nrthshgrl

To make it fair, I would have both people split the taxes on the house. The person living in the house pays 1/2 of the fair market value on rent of the house (determined by looking at rental prices on the area).

As for the upkeep & maintenance, etc, I would treat the person living in it as I would any other tenant. If I were renting out the house, I'd have the tenant responsible for the lawn maintenance, etc. Big ticket items would be split evenly by the owners.

Does the non-tenant owner want to keep the house?




This

Posted 6/6/12 9:35 PM
 

AMPirate
Missing our peanut :(

Member since 11/09

1678 total posts

Name:
Antoinette

Re: Need your opinion

The situation is that neither want to live together anymore and neither want to sell their half of the property.

So let's say that one of the owners decides to live there for the rest of their life, the other owner would make no revenue from this property. That doesn't seem right to me.

Posted 6/6/12 10:12 PM
 

greenybeans
:)

Member since 8/06

6435 total posts

Name:

Re: Need your opinion

Posted by AMPirate

The situation is that neither want to live together anymore and neither want to sell their half of the property.

So let's say that one of the owners decides to live there for the rest of their life, the other owner would make no revenue from this property. That doesn't seem right to me.




What type of house is it, and where is it located?

Posted 6/6/12 10:36 PM
 

greenybeans
:)

Member since 8/06

6435 total posts

Name:

Re: Need your opinion

Without know where/what type of house it's hard to know what the rental would be worth.

If they bought the house, why would they rent a house they already own? Unless they were buying the other person out.

You have to figure taxes are around $700 per month. Gas, oil, water, electric, another 5-7 hundred. Maintenance- $60 per month. Repairs and updates would depend on the person. On the low end we're talking $1300 a month to run the house.

If you charge rent you would have to spit all of those bills.

Posted 6/6/12 11:30 PM
 

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Need your opinion

Posted by AMPirate

The situation is that neither want to live together anymore and neither want to sell their half of the property.

So let's say that one of the owners decides to live there for the rest of their life, the other owner would make no revenue from this property. That doesn't seem right to me.



Is this a two family house we're talking about? Or can you turn it into one? Maybe that would be the best solution. That way the one staying doesn't pay rent, but the one leaving collects all te rent fom the other apartment. Taxes on the house would be split.

Posted 6/7/12 7:20 AM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: Need your opinion

Posted by greenybeans

It depends on the situation. I think they should cover the whole tax bill and all of the household bills, including maintenance and repairs. For me that would be enough.

If they are paying rent I would expect the person who is not living there to cover half of the taxes, bills, repair costs, landscaping, etc...

ETA: If they were paying rent it would make more sense (to me) to buy the person out.



This exactly.

Posted 6/7/12 9:13 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Need your opinion

Posted by AMPirate

The situation is that neither want to live together anymore and neither want to sell their half of the property.

So let's say that one of the owners decides to live there for the rest of their life, the other owner would make no revenue from this property. That doesn't seem right to me.



They can force the sale of the house with a partition proceeding. The owner that wants to sell should speak to a real estate attorney. I'd have a few consultations with them to see what it would cost & maybe pay them out of the proceeds of the house.

I'm not sure why the non-tenant would want to keep a house they can't use unless it's for investment purposes (which isn't a good investment if they never plan to sell it or rent it to someone else other than the co-owner).

Message edited 2012-06-07 09:22:25.973000.

Posted 6/7/12 9:20 AM
 

lovemyfamily88
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/10

641 total posts

Name:
????

Re: Need your opinion

Posted by AMPirate

The situation is that neither want to live together anymore and neither want to sell their half of the property.

So let's say that one of the owners decides to live there for the rest of their life, the other owner would make no revenue from this property. That doesn't seem right to me.



I think legally the person living in the house has no right to do so unless the other party agrees. They will have to buy the other party out or come to some sort of financial agreement. I would talk to a lawyer.

Posted 6/7/12 9:22 AM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Need your opinion

Posted by lovemyfamily88

Posted by AMPirate

The situation is that neither want to live together anymore and neither want to sell their half of the property.

So let's say that one of the owners decides to live there for the rest of their life, the other owner would make no revenue from this property. That doesn't seem right to me.



I think legally the person living in the house has no right to do so unless the other party agrees. They will have to buy the other party out or come to some sort of financial agreement. I would talk to a lawyer.



agreed, IMO the person living there would pay an agreed upon rent but I do not know the legalities.

Posted 6/7/12 9:43 AM
 

mamabear
LIF Adult

Member since 3/08

4539 total posts

Name:

Re: Need your opinion

Is there an agreement that says one person can live there and the other cannot? Or can they both live there, and 1 chooses not to?

If the former, I think they really just should have included in an agreement who is responsible for certain payments. Maybe the one living there pays more of the taxes and upkeep. If the latter, I think things should be split. Except for things you only need by living there--like electric, heating, etc.

Posted 6/7/12 10:13 AM
 

dctead
It's 5 o'clock somewhere!

Member since 11/10

2139 total posts

Name:
Emily

Re: Need your opinion

Posted by greenybeans

It depends on the situation. I think they should cover the whole tax bill and all of the household bills, including maintenance and repairs. For me that would be enough.

If they are paying rent I would expect the person who is not living there to cover half of the taxes, bills, repair costs, landscaping, etc...

ETA: If they were paying rent it would make more sense (to me) to buy the person out.



Agreed

Posted 6/7/12 10:55 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
What is your opinion on Anna Nicole Smith and her pursuit of her DH's fortune? SweetestOfPeas 5/1/06 18 Families Helping Families ™
repost form NWR, shower location place? Opinion on Alias Smith and Jones in Oceanside. 04bride 4/26/06 5 Pregnancy
Can I ask you for your opinion??? PLEASE??? bellarina 4/5/06 34 Parenting
Hey Mommies...Need to know your opinion- Is the Diaper Genie necessary? AndreaLMT 9/21/05 23 Parenting
Do I go for a 3rd opinion? (sorry it's long) Donna 8/7/05 14 Infertility
What's everyone's opinion about having a seperate checking account that hubby doesn't know about for a safety net? JerseyMamaOf3 7/21/05 38 Families Helping Families ™