Need help figuring out which insurance plan?

Posted By Message

Kitten1929
LIF Adult

Member since 1/13

6040 total posts

Name:

Need help figuring out which insurance plan?

Right now, my company offers a plan of which they pay 80% - my DH's job offers a plan which is paid by the employer, but I can't figure which one is a better plan for our family? It's me, my DH and our DS. We go to the doctor 1x per year for an annual checkup, and DS has well visits. We don't see any specialists or take an medications other than Advair for DH's asthma.

My plan offers a family deductible of $6k. Once we meet the deductible, we have coinsurance at 80%, with a max OOP of $10k family. We have copays for doctor visits and RX drugs.

His plan has a family deductible of $4k, with the same OOP amounts as above. However, there are no copays, it seems everything thereafter is at 20% coinsurance. RX drugs apply to the deductible and are based on tiered amounts.

My insurance also provides dental and vision benefits and his does not.

Seeing it laid out like this, I think my plan is the better way to go even in spite of the deductible because it has a higher coinsurance amount.

My questions are, is there any benefit to having DH's insurance for secondary purposes? What would his insurance "pick up" from mine?

If FM is easier, feel free. My Bachelors degree is NOT in insurance comprehension Chat Icon

Message edited 2014-11-05 13:40:34.720000.

Posted 11/5/14 1:39 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Need help figuring out which insurance plan?

well here's my $0.02
Unless for some odd reason its different.. you don't NEED your health insurance to buy the dental and vision.

But here's another question
If he's picks him up solo at full cost why not leave him on his own?

We had him solo with AJ (because with child was cheaper on his) and his was 100% paid by the company (he only paid for AJ's portion) were as I had mine solo because it was cheaper than adding me to his policy.

We've never hit the big family deductible and we carry FSA to pick up anything out of pocket up to that individual deductible. Which for us is more likely.

When we were split up, his didn't offer vision and dental but mine did so he was on mine for dental and vision only.

It sounds messed up but it was cheaper!

His - Him & Her for medical
Me - Me only medical, all three vision & dental
FSA- thru mine for all
(the FSA said family household even if not insured on my plan were covered)

I have no Life & Health license but I just like crunching numbers


ETA: that was in NY with Aetna and Oxford. Now here in TX we are all on mine because his company offers none at all.

Thanks to ACA, his raise and bonus were reduced to pay for the planning of offering insurance though no one in his company wants to buy it. And my rates went up even WITH the higher deductible. Lovely!

Message edited 2014-11-05 14:14:48.083000.

Posted 11/5/14 2:12 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Best Prescription Plan If No Insurance Dulcinea 3/14/13 7 Families Helping Families ™
Repost: Those with the Empire Plan health insurance PotofLuck06 1/5/11 2 Parenting
Those with the Empire Plan health insurance (govt employees) PotofLuck06 1/5/11 4 Pregnancy
Anyone have Emblem Health EPO insurance plan? Smiles111 5/12/10 4 Health!
Empire plan insurance marriedandttc 6/11/09 5 Infertility
Switcing to DH health insurance-family plan shellybean 3/2/09 0 Parenting