Need Advice-Helping an Overweight Sibling?

Posted By Message

shopaholic07
LIF Adult

Member since 5/08

1535 total posts

Name:

Need Advice-Helping an Overweight Sibling?

My brother has always been on the heavier side but he's put on A LOT of weight over the last year (since he stopped smoking). I want to help him get back on track but I don't know where to begin. What kind of doctor does he need to see? I want to help him get on a plan that he can stick to. Can anyone offer some direction?

TIA

Posted 9/17/13 12:14 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

lilqtny
-Crossfit & pitbull addict

Member since 7/06

2830 total posts

Name:
Tracy

Need Advice-Helping an Overweight Sibling?

I am not sure what he should do as far as doctors are concerned. But I am a trainer and I am well versed in nutrition. (I'm studying it now too) and I would offer him advice and help if he is willing to listen. He can just email me or he can call me.

Either way I am willing to help, free of charge of course, to help him get healthy again.

Posted 9/17/13 12:23 PM
 

HoneyBadger
YourWorstNightmare.

Member since 10/06

15979 total posts

Name:
BahBahBlackJeep

Need Advice-Helping an Overweight Sibling?

Is he remotely active? If not, maybe see if you two can go walking together? As for doctors, besides his GP I don't know what other kind of doctor he would see unless he's morbidly obese, which in that case I would think a he'd need to see a bariatric surgeon.

Also, you might want to encourage him to see a registered dietitian who could help him get on a healthy eating plan and even exercise regimen. A friend of mine is not only a registered dietitian but also an ACE certified personal trainer, I'm sure she's not the only one out there who is dually certified.

Posted 9/17/13 12:27 PM
 

lynnd126
LIF Adult

Member since 3/11

2630 total posts

Name:

Need Advice-Helping an Overweight Sibling?

Did he ask you for help?

Posted 9/17/13 12:54 PM
 

missfabulous
#mommyneedswine

Member since 6/09

10031 total posts

Name:
<font color=purple><b>Colleen</b>

Re: Need Advice-Helping an Overweight Sibling?

Posted by lynnd126

Did he ask you for help?



I had the same question actually. As much as you want to help him out, he has to want it for himself.

If he did ask, I would suggest Weight Watchers.

Message edited 2013-09-17 13:04:31.460000.

Posted 9/17/13 1:04 PM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Need Advice-Helping an Overweight Sibling?

Posted by missfabulous

Posted by lynnd126

Did he ask you for help?



I had the same question actually. As much as you want to help him out, he has to want it for himself.




I agree. As someone who is overweight, it's a sensitive issue and I would be very annoyed and hurt if someone offered to help me out when I didn't ask, even if their intentions were good. It's something I would need to reach out and ask for myself.

Posted 9/17/13 1:07 PM
 

Jbon630
LIF Adult

Member since 12/11

1340 total posts

Name:

Re: Need Advice-Helping an Overweight Sibling?

He has to want it himself. If he does, i would offer to do as much with him as you can. Eat healthy with him, exercise with him, etc.

Posted 9/17/13 1:19 PM
 

jerrysgirl
I love my hot dog!!

Member since 6/06

5357 total posts

Name:
E & J

Re: Need Advice-Helping an Overweight Sibling?

Posted by ElizaRags35

Posted by missfabulous

Posted by lynnd126

Did he ask you for help?



I had the same question actually. As much as you want to help him out, he has to want it for himself.




I agree. As someone who is overweight, it's a sensitive issue and I would be very annoyed and hurt if someone offered to help me out when I didn't ask, even if their intentions were good. It's something I would need to reach out and ask for myself.



i agree. As I am overweight, i get offended from my family members in the ways they are trying to help out. what works for them, usually does not work for me.

Posted 9/17/13 1:28 PM
 

dctead
It's 5 o'clock somewhere!

Member since 11/10

2139 total posts

Name:
Emily

Re: Need Advice-Helping an Overweight Sibling?

Posted by jerrysgirl

Posted by ElizaRags35

Posted by missfabulous

Posted by lynnd126

Did he ask you for help?



I had the same question actually. As much as you want to help him out, he has to want it for himself.




I agree. As someone who is overweight, it's a sensitive issue and I would be very annoyed and hurt if someone offered to help me out when I didn't ask, even if their intentions were good. It's something I would need to reach out and ask for myself.



i agree. As I am overweight, i get offended from my family members in the ways they are trying to help out. what works for them, usually does not work for me.



Totally agree...

When I was at my worst - any mention, thought, advise given - (which in my case was always unsolicited) was insulting - but worse...made me feel worse about myself. Completely lowering my already low/practically non existant self esteem.

Even though I knew it came from a place of love from my family - it still hurt and was embarrassing, which only caused me to eat more.

My changes came when I wanted them to... That is the only way it works.

If he asks, be there for him 100%, but if he hasn't asked - please be very careful - it can be damaging.


Posted 9/17/13 2:15 PM
 

Jonsgirl04
Love my two girls! xoxo

Member since 9/08

6079 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Need Advice-Helping an Overweight Sibling?

Not sure how into running you are but maybe you guys can train together for a race. My DH and my SIL just did the survival Race and they had a blast! They both pushed eachother and my Dh who didnt need to lose weight but wanted to get healthy is now an avid runner. Something like the survival race or any type of mud run is fun and could be really motivating. Its only a challenge to yourself. Now that iam not pregnant anymore I feel motivated to do this type of event and hopefully get in the best shape of my life. Tell him you are trying to get a team together! Oh and there were so many different ages from young to old and from skinny to overweight. So you dont have to be in shape to run it.Chat Icon

Message edited 2013-09-17 14:44:44.937000.

Posted 9/17/13 2:40 PM
 

jam11308

Member since 11/07

7273 total posts

Name:

Re: Need Advice-Helping an Overweight Sibling?

Posted by dctead

When I was at my worst - any mention, thought, advise given - (which in my case was always unsolicited) was insulting - but worse...made me feel worse about myself. Completely lowering my already low/practically non existant self esteem.

Even though I knew it came from a place of love from my family - it still hurt and was embarrassing, which only caused me to eat more.

My changes came when I wanted them to... That is the only way it works.

If he asks, be there for him 100%, but if he hasn't asked - please be very careful - it can be damaging.




I can relate to & completely agree with this poster...

Posted 9/17/13 2:46 PM
 

Smileyd17
kids

Member since 5/05

20997 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Need Advice-Helping an Overweight Sibling?

I agree with others that HE is the one who needs to address it and wants the help.

I also kind of disagree too.

how long do you NOT say anything?

Esp when it comes that they continue to gain more and downspiral and then health becomes a concern.

Sometimes I feel that it can be helpful and motiviate someone as long as they know and understand that its only in their best interest. Not to hurt them but to know that they have support.

its tough. very tough.

Posted 9/17/13 3:16 PM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Need Advice-Helping an Overweight Sibling?

Posted by Smileyd17

I agree with others that HE is the one who needs to address it and wants the help.

I also kind of disagree too.

how long do you NOT say anything?

Esp when it comes that they continue to gain more and downspiral and then health becomes a concern.

Sometimes I feel that it can be helpful and motiviate someone as long as they know and understand that its only in their best interest. Not to hurt them but to know that they have support.

its tough. very tough.




For me personally, my mom tried to control my weight from the time I was a teenager - no dessert, put me on WW, made a comment about everything I ate. Were her intentions good, yes. But it turned me into someone who snuck food I wasn't "allowed" to have and it spiraled from there. I ate junk out of spite, especially when I left for college and went from a "normal" size to much bigger. And even though I am OW, my general health is quite good. Well, except since I got pg, but before I did, my cholesterol was normal, thyroid normal, glucose levels normal, BP normal, etc.

So for me, and it seems many others, it's something that "we" need to do for ourselves, by ourselves.

Posted 9/17/13 3:26 PM
 

halfbaked
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

6937 total posts

Name:

Re: Need Advice-Helping an Overweight Sibling?

Posted by Smileyd17

how long do you NOT say anything?




I get what you're saying, but you think they don't know? They know. They just can't face it. and pointing it out *usually* isn't going to help them face it.

I DO like the idea of training for a race. Obviously, I don't know how heavy or otherwise this person is, but would it be weird for you to mention you're training for a race and invite him along? That way it's not because he's too heavy or you feel he needs to exercise, but because you wanted a training buddy. At least it'd soften the blow.

Posted 9/17/13 3:35 PM
 

HoneyBadger
YourWorstNightmare.

Member since 10/06

15979 total posts

Name:
BahBahBlackJeep

Re: Need Advice-Helping an Overweight Sibling?

Posted by Smileyd17

I agree with others that HE is the one who needs to address it and wants the help.

I also kind of disagree too.

how long do you NOT say anything?

Esp when it comes that they continue to gain more and downspiral and then health becomes a concern.

Sometimes I feel that it can be helpful and motiviate someone as long as they know and understand that its only in their best interest. Not to hurt them but to know that they have support.

its tough. very tough.




I agree with this 100%.

And with what everyone else has said about treading lightly I think if you talk to him about your concerns for his health and offer to help him or work out or walk/run with him then maybe the blow won't be so hard on him.

I get that you're (op) coming from a position of love and caring but I agree with everyone else that said you need to tread lightly.

My earlier response was based on you helping him with his blessing.

Posted 9/17/13 3:55 PM
 

peanutbutter2
Carpe diem!

Member since 11/10

5287 total posts

Name:

Re: Need Advice-Helping an Overweight Sibling?

As others have said, I would not do anything unless he asked for it.

Imagine how you would feel if he told you he wanted to help you "work on" one of your flaws.

Posted 9/17/13 9:15 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Need Advice-Helping an Overweight Sibling?

I wouldn't get involved unless you are asked for help.

And I know how difficult it is. Both my parents are overweight.

They're whole schedule revolves around food.

When I speak to them daily, I get a run-down of what they ate the day before, what they're eating later and even plans of places they have for down the road involving restaurants.

My mother especially claims she is doing "Weight Watchers", yet, goes to Mickey D's daily and gets an egg Mcmuffin and claims it's only "X amount of points".

They also both have diabetes which IMO, has clearly developed because of their eating.

When they come to our house, frequently will fight with DH and I because our eating habits don't revolve around theirs.

At this point, I feel like they have an eating disorder..........but they need to want to change it, just like any other issue someone may be struggling with.

I also personally have put on weight this year and am very aware of it. I'd be pissed if someone mentioned it to me too.

Posted 9/18/13 5:35 AM
 

klingklang77
kraftwerk!

Member since 7/06

11489 total posts

Name:
Völlig losgelöst

Re: Need Advice-Helping an Overweight Sibling?

Posted by ElizaRags35

Posted by missfabulous

Posted by lynnd126

Did he ask you for help?



I had the same question actually. As much as you want to help him out, he has to want it for himself.




I agree. As someone who is overweight, it's a sensitive issue and I would be very annoyed and hurt if someone offered to help me out when I didn't ask, even if their intentions were good. It's something I would need to reach out and ask for myself.



This.

To the OP, I had the same situation with my brother. He was very heavy. He still is a bit, but he's working on it. My family and I would constantly worry, and my mom made a few suggestions, but he didn't want to hear it. He wanted to do things his way.

We also think he was depressed about things. That just added to it.

What turned him around? A close to two week stay in the hospital with congestive heart failure and finding out he was borderline diabetic. Also it was pretty humiliating to be weighed on a bed scale. It scared the sh*t out of him. Now he listens to everything the doctor and nutritionist have to say.

Anyway, I know it's painful to be so worried. Chat Icon

Posted 9/18/13 7:04 AM
 

greenfreak
.

Member since 9/06

11483 total posts

Name:
greenfreak

Re: Need Advice-Helping an Overweight Sibling?

I'm a formerly obese (borderline morbidly obese) person who also gained a lot of weight when I quit smoking. Your body and life goes through a lot of changes when you quit and you are already deciding to do something awesome for yourself. It's a great thing but the weight gain can be inevitable for a lot of people. It's possible he needs time to get used to the idea of being a non-smoker and making it stick before he takes on another very difficult life change.

I have to agree about being hypersensitive to the slightest judgement on my weight - even if it wasn't a judgement and came in a message of caring and love. I had people encouraging me to exercise, eat better, give me advice that I didn't ask for, etc and it didn't spur me to lose.

A combination of situations led me to doing something about my weight. All of them were negative and came from a place of self-loathing. I found it to be a great motivator in the beginning so I embraced it. I had my husband take photos of me from all angles (because when I was as heavy as I was, I avoided looking at myself at all costs) in only spandex shorts and a sports bra. It was a horror show. Chat Icon But it was MY negativity and being sick of myself, not coming from others. Once I took action, the support and encouragement from everyone turned the negative into positive and kept me going.

So I would do this... If you must talk to him about it, tell him you will only say it once. And have it come from a focus of being worried for his health and make no comments on his appearance. Then drop it. If you see ANY initiative of his to lose weight or eat better, be really supportive and talk to him about it. Wait until it's a habit and then offer to do healthy things together. But don't make him an example by making weight-healthy food and telling everyone it's for him or anything like that.

Just my two cents here. Hope this helps. Chat Icon

Posted 9/18/13 9:49 AM
 

meloyellow
LIF Adult

Member since 3/13

1843 total posts

Name:

Re: Need Advice-Helping an Overweight Sibling?

Posted by missfabulous

Posted by lynnd126

Did he ask you for help?



I had the same question actually. As much as you want to help him out, he has to want it for himself.

If he did ask, I would suggest Weight Watchers.



that was my first thought as well. He has to want it fo4 himself or the motivation he needs to have a successful plan won't be there. You may also really offend him and plunge him into depression. Its a very personal and emotional journey.

Posted 9/18/13 10:15 AM
 

MK2010
LIF Toddler

Member since 7/10

401 total posts

Name:

Re: Need Advice-Helping an Overweight Sibling?

Is your family competitive at all? It sounds silly - but recently my whole family got pedometers. You can set it up so they track online and my crazy competitive extended family went a little nuts. The idea behind it is that if you are in competition and you come to a set of stairs or an escalator - you are going to choose the stairs because of the competition. Also, everyone has found that when they are at like 8750 steps - they will find a way to get to 9000. It works because you don't have to be super fit or athletic to participate. Also - for those "gym haters" - it can completely be avoided. Chat Icon


I would not make it about weight or even mention that - just make it a fun thing you want to try as a group.

Message edited 2013-09-18 13:40:29.860000.

Posted 9/18/13 1:36 PM