Need a new carseat, under $200

Posted By Message

pharmcat2000
Mom of 2 + 1

Member since 10/05

7395 total posts

Name:
Catherine

Need a new carseat, under $200

Considering:

Graco My Ride 65

Graco Nautilus

Evenflo Titan Elite

Safety 1st Complete Air 65

Safety 1st Alpha Elite 65

Britax Roundabout 55

Any others?

** I'm not TOO worried about the weight limit, as DD is just about 3 and only weighs 28lbs. And DD#1 is just about 6 and only weighs 44lbs.



Posted 4/15/12 11:20 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

tara73
carseat nerd

Member since 11/09

3669 total posts

Name:
Buttercup

Re: Need a new carseat, under $200

All depends.

Are you going to keep her RF or move her FF? What's she in now?

ETA: there aren't many seats that I hate, but the Safety 1st Alpha Omega/3 in 1/Eddie Bauer 3 in 1 is the one that I just despise. I wouldn't recommend it for anyone for any reason. They don't make good boosters, have short harnesses, are a MAJOR PITA to install correctly.. they're the jack of all trades, master of NONE>

Message edited 2012-04-15 23:24:56.693000.

Posted 4/15/12 11:23 PM
 

pharmcat2000
Mom of 2 + 1

Member since 10/05

7395 total posts

Name:
Catherine

Re: Need a new carseat, under $200

Right now she is in the regular Roundabout. I plan to make her FF soon. What about the other Safety 1st ones? I sort of remembered reading bad reviews for the Alpha Omega, but then saw some decent stuff for the Alpha Elite, but am nervous b/c of the bad rap of the other Safety 1st seats.

Posted 4/15/12 11:33 PM
 

tara73
carseat nerd

Member since 11/09

3669 total posts

Name:
Buttercup

Re: Need a new carseat, under $200

I can take or leave the Complete Air, to be honest. But, the only Safety 1st/Dorel/Eddie Bauer/Maxi Cosi/Cosco seat (yep, all one company!) I tend to recommend is the Cosco Scenera. Take that for what it is worth :)

There are a bunch of new seats coming on the market, for FF, I would look at the

Nautilus/Argos
Britax Frontier
Evenflo Secure kid 300/400
BabyTrend Trend Z Fast Back.

I would let her outgrow the Roundabout and then move to a FF seat.

Posted 4/15/12 11:44 PM
 

pharmcat2000
Mom of 2 + 1

Member since 10/05

7395 total posts

Name:
Catherine

Re: Need a new carseat, under $200

Posted by tarabelle99

I can take or leave the Complete Air, to be honest. But, the only Safety 1st/Dorel/Eddie Bauer/Maxi Cosi/Cosco seat (yep, all one company!) I tend to recommend is the Cosco Scenera. Take that for what it is worth :)

There are a bunch of new seats coming on the market, for FF, I would look at the

Nautilus/Argos
Britax Frontier
Evenflo Secure kid 300/400
BabyTrend Trend Z Fast Back.

I would let her outgrow the Roundabout and then move to a FF seat.



I'm concerned about the "expiration" of the Roundabout she is in now. I've had it since DD#1 was an infant. So, 6 years now. I was just told that it is probably "expired". Is this true? Otherwise I will definately let her outgrow it.

Posted 4/15/12 11:53 PM
 

tara73
carseat nerd

Member since 11/09

3669 total posts

Name:
Buttercup

Re: Need a new carseat, under $200

6 years from date of manufacture, so you'll have to look at the sticker on the seat. You should be able to see it on the side above the lockoffs under the cover.

Posted 4/15/12 11:55 PM
 

pharmcat2000
Mom of 2 + 1

Member since 10/05

7395 total posts

Name:
Catherine

Re: Need a new carseat, under $200

Posted by tarabelle99

6 years from date of manufacture, so you'll have to look at the sticker on the seat. You should be able to see it on the side above the lockoffs under the cover.




Thanks. I'll look tomorrow.

I may actually be in the market for 3 seats! 2 new for her, plus a new one for DH's car for DD#1! Chat Icon

Posted 4/15/12 11:57 PM
 

PeasandCarrots
♥

Member since 5/07

9579 total posts

Name:
L

Re: Need a new carseat, under $200

DD is 2.5 weighs 26lbs and is 36 inches. She is in the My Ride 65 and we love it. We will be buying the Graco Nautillis(?) for her when we get a newer vehicle as I want them to be in a 5pt harness as long as possible. DS is 5months 15lbs and 25 inches in a My Ride 65 and we also like it very much. He, obviously, is RF, DD was RF in her 65 until 1 day shy of her 2nd birthday and she was fine with that.

Posted 4/16/12 2:51 AM
 

teaforthree
My Handsome Boy!

Member since 12/10

2549 total posts

Name:

Re: Need a new carseat, under $200

I ordered the Britax Roundabout online at BRU.com and picked it up in store. It was $40 cheaper online! (159 compared to 199 in-store). It was only available for pick up at the Massapequa BRU. We needed a good, but less expensive seat for the sitter and it's great! Our other Brita seats were about $360 each!

Posted 4/16/12 7:32 AM
 

JenMarie
One day at a time

Member since 11/07

7397 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Need a new carseat, under $200

Posted by tarabelle99

I can take or leave the Complete Air, to be honest. But, the only Safety 1st/Dorel/Eddie Bauer/Maxi Cosi/Cosco seat (yep, all one company!) I tend to recommend is the Cosco Scenera. Take that for what it is worth :)

There are a bunch of new seats coming on the market, for FF, I would look at the

Nautilus/Argos
Britax Frontier
Evenflo Secure kid 300/400
BabyTrend Trend Z Fast Back.

I would let her outgrow the Roundabout and then move to a FF seat.



Can I ask why you can take or leave the Safety 1st Complete Air? We just got it for DD and I really like it. She seems very comfy in it, it seems very well cushioned, and it installed easily (and we had it checked by a technician). It seems like a good quality seat. My favorite feature is the harness adjustment from the front. Curious as to your view on the seat because I want to get a new seat for DHs car and was going to get another Complete Air. We have the Cosco Scenera in his car but it seems so flimsy.

Posted 4/16/12 8:54 AM
 

ny55angel
car seat tech & geek :-)

Member since 2/06

4346 total posts

Name:
P

Re: Need a new carseat, under $200

I know its not on your list, but I have an evenflo symphony 65 and LOVE it!! The newer model is the LX and then there is the E3 which is a little more then the $200.

It is easy to install, adjusts easily, is roomy for DS and has higher weight limits. RF to 40 pounds, FF with harness to 65 pounds and can be used as a high back booster until 100 pounds. The head rest adjusts so taller kids can stay in it longer too.

Posted 4/16/12 9:40 AM
 

tara73
carseat nerd

Member since 11/09

3669 total posts

Name:
Buttercup

Re: Need a new carseat, under $200

Posted by JenMarie


Can I ask why you can take or leave the Safety 1st Complete Air? We just got it for DD and I really like it. She seems very comfy in it, it seems very well cushioned, and it installed easily (and we had it checked by a technician). It seems like a good quality seat. My favorite feature is the harness adjustment from the front. Curious as to your view on the seat because I want to get a new seat for DHs car and was going to get another Complete Air. We have the Cosco Scenera in his car but it seems so flimsy.



I used to recommend the CA, but when Dorel stated to techs who asked that the line on the CA must be level with the ground, even when the line causes the seat to be OVERreclined, I stopped. They use stickers instead of bubble or other leveling device on their seats. Other manufacturers know that sometimes a sticker can be wrong and state the seat can be used 30-45deg, KWIM?

I also have issues with the the 40" height limit, period, with no regards to torso height, it's not such a great value anymore. They do not follow the 1" clearance rule for RF for THIS seat, but they do for other seats.

And I just don't like them as a company, but that doesn't stop me from recommending them, it only stops me from buying them. Chat Icon

ETA: The reasons listed above are why I don't normally recommend the seat, it's not any less safe than any other properly used carseat. The seats I recommend are based on ease of use, value, how long seat can be used etc.

Message edited 2012-04-16 10:31:39.733000.

Posted 4/16/12 10:07 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Does anyone have the new Graco Signature Series Smart Seat All-in-One Carseat MayBbaby21 10/4/11 3 Parenting
Help me with a new carseat. MorningCuppaCoffee 9/5/09 20 Parenting
Do i need a new carseat?-Accident related bayla 1/7/09 7 Parenting
Selling a brand new Chicco Key Fit carseat base (not recalled) Mrs. Patticakes 6/22/08 1 Pregnancy
New Convertible Carseat (The First Years) metsgirlie 2/21/08 1 Parenting
I have a extra brand new carseat partyof6 8/28/07 4 Pregnancy