nature v nurture

Posted By Message

MarathonKnitter
HAPPY

Member since 2/07

17374 total posts

Name:
EMBRACING CHANGE

nature v nurture

this is not a very scientific question... so please give anecdotal info, if you wish Chat Icon

two people are raised in the same household (one is a biological child of the couple and the other is adopted) (both of the same gender), and they are raised like there is no difference in their biology.

if they are raised in a very neat home, and both grow up to be messy/sloppy, would you feel that they might be both rebelling against the neatness? and it could be a factor of the very upbringing?

we were having a discussion about this, yesterday... would like others' opinions/thoughts on the topic

Posted 5/9/11 5:26 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: nature v nurture

I would assume it was them acting out against how they needed to be in their youth.

Posted 5/9/11 5:28 PM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: nature v nurture

No, some people are just neat people, and some aren't. Me and my 3 sibs were raised very neat. Sis is very neat, I'm more of an organized chaos type, with bouts of extreme cleaning, and bro is not neat at all.

Posted 5/9/11 5:33 PM
 

MarathonKnitter
HAPPY

Member since 2/07

17374 total posts

Name:
EMBRACING CHANGE

Re: nature v nurture

Posted by GoldenRod

No, some people are just neat people, and some aren't. Me and my 3 sibs were raised very neat. Sis is very neat, I'm more of an organized chaos type, with bouts of extreme cleaning, and bro is not neat at all.



yes. this was another perspective given... maybe the couple just "lucked out" and adopted a child who was going to grow up to be not-neat, just like the biological child

Message edited 2011-05-09 17:44:44.307000.

Posted 5/9/11 5:38 PM
 

Palebride
I am an amazing bakist

Member since 5/05

13673 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: nature v nurture

I grew up in a house with 4 children...we were all born within 4 1/2 years, so we're all really close in age.
My parents were very serious about making sure we were all raised the same....equal treatment for everyone.

Now.....you could not find 4 more different adults if you tried. My husband is shocked that we were all raised in the same family. Different personalities, different lives, different interests, different political beliefs, etc.

The one thing we all have in common is our love for our family, and we all feel that family is important, so I'd say that's from my parents....but the rest of it...Nature 100%!!

Posted 5/9/11 5:42 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: nature v nurture

Posted by Palebride

I grew up in a house with 4 children...we were all born within 4 1/2 years, so we're all really close in age.
My parents were very serious about making sure we were all raised the same....equal treatment for everyone.

Now.....you could not find 4 more different adults if you tried. My husband is shocked that we were all raised in the same family. Different personalities, different lives, different interests, different political beliefs, etc.

The one thing we all have in common is our love for our family, and we all feel that family is important, so I'd say that's from my parents....but the rest of it...Nature 100%!!



We are 4 kids too. All very different! All raised by same mother.

I think it's a combination of nature and nurture. You can learn to be neat because your parents were but in the end, your own nature will take over and will dictate how you want to live.

Posted 5/9/11 6:26 PM
 

evrythng4areason
And then there were 4

Member since 1/10

5224 total posts

Name:
Kayla

Re: nature v nurture

my sister and i are night and day

im very studious, self-motivated-she's not
im a neat freak bordering on ocd-she's a slob
i am more reserved-she speaks her mind

my mother and i are pretty polar opposite as well

Posted 5/9/11 10:05 PM
 

OrganicMama
So in love with my little man!

Member since 6/08

5172 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: nature v nurture

Posted by GoldenRod

No, some people are just neat people, and some aren't. Me and my 3 sibs were raised very neat. Sis is very neat, I'm more of an organized chaos type, with bouts of extreme cleaning, and bro is not neat at all.



ITA with all of this!

Posted 5/9/11 10:25 PM
 

peanutbutter2
Carpe diem!

Member since 11/10

5287 total posts

Name:

Re: nature v nurture

I think it's completely a combination. I have two brothers and in some very specific ways, we are so similar (We're all stubborn, love all types of seafood, and we love to cook), but in other ways we are so incredibly different (I love going out and am very extroverted, while my brothers are more stay-at-home times and are more introverted than I am to varying degrees).

Posted 5/9/11 10:43 PM
 

IrishLasss334
I'll be there soon!

Member since 1/08

6549 total posts

Name:
Patty

Re: nature v nurture

I think people are just neat people and some are messy people. My sister and I were raised in a home that was clean - was my Mom a neat freak? No.

My sister is a neat freak. I am not. Is the house clean? Yes, is it spotless everyday, no.

Posted 5/10/11 10:29 AM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: nature v nurture

Posted by GoldenRod

No, some people are just neat people, and some aren't. Me and my 3 sibs were raised very neat. Sis is very neat, I'm more of an organized chaos type, with bouts of extreme cleaning, and bro is not neat at all.



ITA.

Posted 5/10/11 10:33 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: nature v nurture

Posted by GoldenRod

No, some people are just neat people, and some aren't.



I agree.

Posted 5/10/11 10:36 AM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: nature v nurture

I think that's a hard thing to gauge.

My sister is may parents' biological child. I was adopted.

My mom is a serious clean/neat freak. You could have eaten off my kitchen floor growing up. My mom and sister have like OCD like tendencies about things all being in place. I'm more comfortable in a home that's "lived in" and not a museum.

HOWEVER, having grown up in a very clean house, I need things to be clean. I can deal with clutter, but not dirt. I DO appreciate the lack of clutter to SOME degree

FH grew up in a flithy, cluttered house and has absolutely no appreciation for a clutter-free anything. He doesn't even SEE piles of crap everywhere or dishes in the sink for days. Like, it's so normal to him.

So I think there are a few things at play. I think there's nurture, like in how I like things neat and clean, and FH doesn't really get it the same way.... and nature in how my sister and I were both raised in a VERY clean house and she chose to embrace it and I chose to rebel a bit.

I don't think this is really the best example for the nature/nurture debate

Posted 5/10/11 5:18 PM
 

drpepper318
MIR MIR MIR!

Member since 6/07

8274 total posts

Name:
me

Re: nature v nurture

I think we're all born with certain tendencies or characteristics, and our environment just reinforces it in either a positive or negative way.

From personal experience, myself & my two brothers were raised by the same parents in the same environment, but turned out completely different in most ways (people who know us always comment on how different we all are), although we all do share a few basic personality traits (we are all introverts, for example).

Message edited 2011-05-10 20:40:26.200000.

Posted 5/10/11 8:39 PM
 

AngnShaun
Sisters

Member since 1/10

21015 total posts

Name:
Ang

Re: nature v nurture

Posted by GoldenRod

No, some people are just neat people, and some aren't. Me and my 3 sibs were raised very neat. Sis is very neat, I'm more of an organized chaos type, with bouts of extreme cleaning, and bro is not neat at all.



ITA

Posted 5/10/11 9:39 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Spinoff to sleeping through the night..Nature vs Nurture?? avamamma 6/17/09 8 Parenting
Nurture VS Fun.....i think i got my answer....UPDATE! Angel321 6/18/10 10 Parenting
Well, I guess nature decided to take its course... ExpectingBabyNumber2 6/18/09 49 Pregnancy
Pics from today - Sweetbriar nature conservancy, and FIRST HAIRCUT!!!! lipglossjunky73 3/30/08 40 Parenting
Is my kid a freak of nature or is this normal? waterspout4 2/6/08 7 Parenting
Lactomania...totally TMI, but everyone please come in and tell me what a FREAK OF NATURE I am... yankinmanc 8/26/06 13 Parenting