Nanny versus Daycare

Posted By Message

beckyb3
LIF Infant

Member since 5/10

130 total posts

Name:

Nanny versus Daycare

Our nanny just gave us one month notice. Her mom is ill and getting worse so she wants to stay home and take care of her. My daughter is 11 months but will be 1 year once we need somebody new. I am debating now whether I should try to find a new nanny or start her in daycare. We looked at daycare in the beginning but we weren't really comfortable leaving her at daycare when she was so young (and the one we looked at wasn't available the day we needed it). Now that she is a little bit older, I am wondering if we should reconsider. She really likes being around other kids so she may really enjoy going to daycare but I am still nervous that she is too young for daycare. Just curious what people's thoughts are and why they chose one over the other.

Posted 5/21/12 9:20 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

NewLeaf2012
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

2741 total posts

Name:
....

Re: Nanny versus Daycare

If I had to chose, I would stick with a Nanny for another year or so. I am a germophobe and I wouldn't want my DS exposed too all that stuff until he was a little older... JMO
You can still enroll her in classes with other kids. When I worked as a Nanny, I would take the little ones to a library class once a week. We went to Mommy and Me, and we went to the park all the time!

Message edited 2012-05-21 23:58:59.487000.

Posted 5/21/12 11:57 PM
 

alli3131
Peanut is here!!!!!!

Member since 5/09

18388 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Nanny versus Daycare

I would pick daycare. My DS is with family a few days and daycare a few days. He is only 5 mons but I see how much the daycare does with him. Way more than my ILs do. My IL play with him and keep him stimulated but the daycare is actually teaching him things. Also I love that he is around other kids

Posted 5/22/12 7:05 AM
 

JenMarie
One day at a time

Member since 11/07

7397 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Nanny versus Daycare

Personally, I'd pick daycare. DD was with my MIL until she was 6 months and then we put her in daycare. Huge difference in DD! she loves being around the other kids and is learning so much from them. And I never have to worry about a nanny being sick or leaving.

Posted 5/22/12 9:29 AM
 

rkl1130
LIF Adult

Member since 10/07

1476 total posts

Name:
Rose Ann

Re: Nanny versus Daycare

I'd personally try the daycare route. I stayed home with DD until she was about 18 months old and then put her in daycare. We see the difference and she loves being around other kids. She learns and gets the stimulation and social interaction that is needed to develop.

Posted 5/22/12 9:49 AM
 

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: Nanny versus Daycare

My personal opinion would be for daycare for two main reasons
1. I like them to be around other kids.
2. I prefer that they are in a controlled 'school' type of environment where there is accountability among the staff. A nanny makes me very uncomfortable.

We all have our own paranioa - Chat Icon

Posted 5/22/12 9:50 AM
 

snowprincess
My happy babies

Member since 3/06

3428 total posts

Name:

Re: Nanny versus Daycare

i have done both and for one I would probably choose daycare. My son learned tons. They eat at a table and learned to drink from cups . My daycare gave a great lunch meals - he always had protein, veg and fruit. he made tons of friends and loved being there


Here is my pros and cons list for daycare and nanny

Nanny
con
- cost goes up over time -nanny get raise
- need to include costs of all meals for kids and plan all meals
-need to inlcude extra heating and ac costs
- costs for extra programs to keep kids busy
-need more toys at home
-house messier - gets dirtier faster
-want a mom day off can't relax at home
- if nanny needs day off or is sick - need back up or take day off
Pro
- if sick she stays with kids
-- one on one interaction
- get to sleep at home
- kids set schedule
- come to your house
-help with other kid chores
- more flexible
- more reasonable for multiple kids


Daycare
con
-get sick lots
- after 15 months - they dictate the schedule
- have to drop them off and pick up within a set window of time
- set days off

pro
- lots of kids to play with
- learn to eat at a table with other kids
- costs go down as they get older
- multiple people looking over kids - lots of oversight
-lots of toys to play with and they rotate new ones in and out
- when you want a mommy day off you can drop them off and relax at home - really nice when you are sick

Message edited 2012-05-22 09:52:15.963000.

Posted 5/22/12 9:51 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Daycare, nanny or just stay home? And questions about daycare... ko123 9/2/10 6 Parenting
Does anyone use or plan to use a nanny/sitter rather than daycare? NervousNell 1/20/10 11 Pregnancy
WWYD: Which would you prefer - PT daycare or PT nanny? Bridex100 5/20/09 11 Parenting
Considering switching from daycare to nanny/sitter - with lots of questions! clwp 5/7/09 6 Parenting
Please help! PT daycare/nanny? pixie 7/1/08 6 Parenting
If money weren't an issue would you have a nanny or daycare? leighla 9/17/07 45 Parenting