More autism Q's

Posted By Message

beachgirl
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

7967 total posts

Name:
sara

More autism Q's

The other post got me thinking about this statement that doctors say you cannot blame the vaccine as the symptons presentthemselves at the same developmental age as the age when the vaccine was administered, but isnt one of the first signs of autism when the child starts to withdraw? I may be wrong so please correct me.

My DD for ex is 16mths and is really vibrant and interactive with me. She doesnt have a lot of words but I am not worried too much as she babbles, makes eye contact, understands everything I ask her to do etc. If I had chosen to give her the MMR at 15mths and suddenly she started to withdraw now couldnt I say with 100% certainty that it occurred because of the vaccine and not because of her developmental age?

Maybe the moms who work with autistic kids or moms who have autistic kids could answer this.

Chat Icon

Message edited 2007-06-07 12:17:57.150000.

Posted 6/7/07 12:16 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

LuvMy2Girls
@>---------

Member since 5/05

11165 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: More autism Q's

I had a long convo before I gave DD the MMR/chicken pox vaccine at her 1st birthday appt.

My PED told me that baby's show signs way before they are diagnosed or show signs around the time the MMR vaccine would be administered.

He also commented that less and less children are being diagnosed at having mental handicapped cause schools do not have the resources to help these kids, so those same kids are being diagnosed as autistic. The data behind that 1 in 160 kids with autism shows a direct spike in autism and a opposite exact decline in mental retardness diagnosis.

More and more autism/aspergers syndrome is being pinpointed as a genetic disease.

Def have a convo with your PED about this, I found mine to be very knowledgeable about both ends of the topic.

Posted 6/7/07 12:23 PM
 

beachgirl
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

7967 total posts

Name:
sara

Re: More autism Q's

My Ped doesnt want to hear about me not giving the MMR. I told her I wasnt giving it at 15mths and said "well I hope you will give it at 18mths"..I said I hadnt decided yet. There are two peds at the office I go to and the other ped just flat out told me I was over reacting to scare tactics in the news when I told her at my DD's 1yr check up that I would not be giving my DD the mmr at 15mths. She went on to say that the evidence that this doctor who started all this vaccination/autism talk was found to be incorrect and therefore there was no other evidence linking it.

I may have to move peds as they are very militant about it in this office.

Posted 6/7/07 12:31 PM
 

Porrruss
Nya nya nya

Member since 5/05

11618 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: More autism Q's

sorry- meant for fm

Message edited 2007-06-07 12:51:44.360000.

Posted 6/7/07 12:51 PM
 

michele31
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3372 total posts

Name:
Michele

Re: More autism Q's

My nephew has autism. I do not believe that the gov't is conspiring to hurt all of our children. I think the gov't has done some really AWFUL stuff, but this I think would involve way too many people/departments and have NO whistle blowers for sooo long. Plus some very weathy people have children/grandchild with Autism and I think that link would have really been put out there by now.
I held off the MMR until Molly was 18 months old because while my head KNOWS this does not matter, my heart was afraid since we deal with this in our family. Your child cannot attend camp or daycare or even public school without their vaccine.

If you believe that something might be going on with your child do not let a doctor push your concerns off. My SIL asked the doctor for MONTHS about my nephew. He was not speaking but he did make sounds, would not make good eye contact with people very often, lined up his toys and would not play with toys normally. Finally my Dad told my brother to search the Internet about Autism and after reading everything they both their son had it. The Ped did not support them before that at all...he just kept saying that children develop differently. I am a firm believer that if a parent is unsure then they should reach out to Early Intervention and request testing. It is not invassive or painful and could truly help.

Message edited 2007-06-07 13:09:43.980000.

Posted 6/7/07 12:59 PM
 

KPtoys
I'm getting old

Member since 5/05

8688 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: More autism Q's

Posted by beachgirl

My Ped doesnt want to hear about me not giving the MMR. I told her I wasnt giving it at 15mths and said "well I hope you will give it at 18mths"..I said I hadnt decided yet. There are two peds at the office I go to and the other ped just flat out told me I was over reacting to scare tactics in the news when I told her at my DD's 1yr check up that I would not be giving my DD the mmr at 15mths. She went on to say that the evidence that this doctor who started all this vaccination/autism talk was found to be incorrect and therefore there was no other evidence linking it.

I may have to move peds as they are very militant about it in this office.



Wow I would switch peds! I know they have MD after their names but your name is mommy... your decisions trump all theirs. I waited to give all my kids their shots and it was perfectly acceptable by my kids ped. Jeremy is 2 1/2 and has yet to get the MMR.

Posted 6/7/07 1:28 PM
 

MrsR
My love.

Member since 5/05

6247 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: More autism Q's

I agree - I would never let a PEd. make a decision over my word. Yes, they know more than we do medically - but if you ask me...they don't know enough about vaccinations and the side effects.

The truth is - NO ONE knows what causes autism. They do know it is a genetic predisposition along with an "event" that causes it. No one knows what that event is - is it an illness? A trauma, a SHOT? they dont know - so they can't tell you 100% that it isnt the vaccination.

I had my DD's MMR shot seperated into three seperate shots...its another option if you are worried about the effects of it.

Posted 6/7/07 4:04 PM
 

beachgirl
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

7967 total posts

Name:
sara

Re: More autism Q's

Thanks for your replies ladiesChat Icon

Posted 6/7/07 7:25 PM
 

twicethefun
Loving life

Member since 7/06

4088 total posts

Name:

Re: More autism Q's

As a special educator I see children with autism and autistic tendencies. I think some parents do not know what to look for until their babies reach a certain age when they suddenly realize thier child is not communicating the way their peers are. Additionally, there is a very broad range considered to be on the pdd/autism spectrum, thus so many more children are being labeled. Some babies don't make eye contact, develop speech or have the most basic skill of imitation. I don't think any of this is related to shots, just timiing.

My pediatrician's child is autistic and she totally advocates shots without mercury.

My son gets all his shots.

Posted 6/7/07 9:28 PM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: More autism Q's

Posted by mimih

As a special educator I see children with autism and autistic tendencies. I think some parents do not know what to look for until their babies reach a certain age when they suddenly realize thier child is not communicating the way their peers are. Additionally, there is a very broad range considered to be on the pdd/autism spectrum, thus so many more children are being labeled. Some babies don't make eye contact, develop speech or have the most basic skill of imitation. I don't think any of this is related to shots, just timiing.

My pediatrician's child is autistic and she totally advocates shots without mercury.

My son gets all his shots.



VERY well said!

I would not be happy with my ped. if he/she addressed my concerns in the way you presented them. I even discussed the MMR with my dr - I want to split them up because I got very sick when I was little from it and would hate to put Cailen thru that - if you have seen my other posts, you will know where I stand in my opinion - you can FM me if you want - I know these ladies may be sick of me posting my opinion on every autism thread! Chat Icon

But I will tell you this - I have seen many home videos of children with autism as babies, and right from the start there is just a lot less relatedness, less babbling, etc... It sounds like your daughter is developing nicely.... Chat Icon

Posted 6/7/07 9:44 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
The Autism Clause: A handful of new schools charge up to $140,000 a year to educate an autistic child. Who can pay that much? Anyone with the right lawyer. nrthshgrl 10/24/06 11 Parenting
Interesting article about Autism. Sassyz75 1/16/07 0 Parenting
Autism Question partyof6 10/26/06 12 Parenting
mercury and autism cdunn 9/25/06 14 Pregnancy
spinoff to those who work with kids on the autism spectrum... JTK 8/7/06 13 Families Helping Families ™
For those who work with children on the autism spectrum: Jax430 8/7/06 17 Families Helping Families ™