Med Malpratice Ins. Quest

Posted By Message

MRSE
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

1420 total posts

Name:
(112903)

Med Malpratice Ins. Quest

Hi Ladies,

I was reading the article in Newsday the other day regarding OB/GYN's and their malpractice insur... Many OB's will opt to not deliver babies any longer. The State has ok'd an increase upto 20%. Some Dr's just can't afford it anymore.. Does anyone know where I can write a letter complaining? I would hate to lose a Dr I am sooo comfortable with because of this.. Perhaps if more people write letters this could get adjusted. Thanks!!

Posted 7/18/07 10:24 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Med Malpratice Ins. Quest

I don't know where you could write a letter to. But it does stink for OBs. I used to work for a med mal attorney and I would feel bad for the OBs that we were suing most of the time bc something can go wrong in an instant after a perfectly normal pregnancy.

That being said, that is why most OBs get sued, b/c of something going wrong in that instant and a child needing care for the rest of their lives. Most baby cases are not cases that are frivolous at all and it is most definately not ambulance chasing.

The first OB/GYN that I went to stopped practing OB, then stopped practicing as a doctor all together.
Chat Icon

Posted 7/18/07 10:27 PM
 

SkyzTheLimit
Bring on summer!!!

Member since 3/06

2483 total posts

Name:
Jamie

Re: Med Malpratice Ins. Quest

I know. It's crazy. The doctor that just delivered my daughter the end of Jan. Will know long be deliever babies after this coming Dec. Dr. Scott Berlin who was in the article.

Posted 7/18/07 10:29 PM
 

MRSE
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

1420 total posts

Name:
(112903)

Re: Med Malpratice Ins. Quest

wow My Dr was quoted at the bottom of the article.. Dr. Wanerman.. I guess I am jsut waiting to see if that practice will stop.

Posted 7/18/07 10:32 PM
 

Lillykat
going along for the ride...

Member since 5/05

16253 total posts

Name:

Re: Med Malpratice Ins. Quest

Posted by KateDevine

I don't know where you could write a letter to. But it does stink for OBs. I used to work for a med mal attorney and I would feel bad for the OBs that we were suing most of the time bc something can go wrong in an instant after a perfectly normal pregnancy.

That being said, that is why most OBs get sued, b/c of something going wrong in that instant and a child needing care for the rest of their lives. Most baby cases are not cases that are frivolous at all and it is most definately not ambulance chasing.

The first OB/GYN that I went to stopped practing OB, then stopped practicing as a doctor all together.
Chat Icon



I used to work for a major med mal insurance company until I became a SAHM. I have to agree with KateDevine. Unfortunately, there are some VERY good dr's out there who get sued and they are human but there are some very horrible dr's out there who are getting sued too. Some of the dr's I had had more than 7 or 10 open suits for really horrific mistakes that ended up with a severely brain damaged baby who will need life long care in a home or for the wrongful death of the mother.

Those cases are worth millions b/c they have to set up structured settlements etc to take care of that child for the rest of their lives. It is really sad - but that is the reason some OB/GYN's are having insurance issues. In general they don't raise their premiums I don't believe until they have had several suits or large settlements. Unfortunately there tends to be a lot of these type of suits as it is a high risk area of medicine to practice compared to say podiatry or dermatology.

What I would like to see is the end of a lot of the frivioulous suits that should never be in the courts in the first place.

Message edited 2007-07-20 09:47:31.333000.

Posted 7/20/07 9:46 AM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Med Malpratice Ins. Quest

I just lost my doctor of 10 years because of this. I'm so unbelievably depressed about it Chat Icon

Posted 7/20/07 10:08 AM
 

SweetCin
My green-eyed boy

Member since 5/05

13499 total posts

Name:
Cin

Re: Med Malpratice Ins. Quest

My dr. was also saying to me recently that they are trying to make VBAC's virtually eliminated in NY....

Posted 7/20/07 10:23 AM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Med Malpratice Ins. Quest

Posted by Lillykat


Unfortunately, there are some VERY good dr's out there who get sued and they are human
.



I equate cases like this like having car insurance. You can be an excellent driver, but get into a stupid accident. In my office, quite a few of our baby cases were like this, deciding not to do a c section fast enough with not good conequences, etc, etc.

It IS a shame, but if the child needs care for the rest of their life, the parents have a right to collect on that in my opinion.

Posted 7/20/07 1:10 PM
 

DancinBarefoot
06ers Rock!!

Member since 1/07

9537 total posts

Name:
The One My Mother Gave Me ;-)

Re: Med Malpratice Ins. Quest

When you find out, let me know. I'm currently PG w/ first child and my GYN of the past 20 years has informed me he won't be delivering and I have to find a new practice.

Posted 7/20/07 2:10 PM
 

MRSE
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

1420 total posts

Name:
(112903)

Re: Med Malpratice Ins. Quest

I do understand that there is a need (if an error was made by a dr during a procedure ) that people should be compensated so to speak. But there are many necessary cases out their that are driving the premiums up. California has a cap on medical malpractice awards and so do other states. At this point in time I believe Dr's have to focus on being a doctor and caring for their patients then having to worry about these issues. I spoke to my OB in great length about this issue yesterday and I am currently gathering my information for a letter to a few people. Please FM me if anyone else is interested.

My Dr. brought to my attention that some of the older more experienced Dr's have to leave LI and the 5 burroghs to make a living doing what they love. Somethings got give.... not only on this issue, but why are so many people leaving NY.

Edited for spelling.. at work at typing to fast

Message edited 2007-07-20 15:50:57.717000.

Posted 7/20/07 2:41 PM
 

Lifnewbie
LIF Infant

Member since 7/06

87 total posts

Name:

Re: Med Malpratice Ins. Quest

I couldn't disagree with you more that caps on awards are the answer. If a legitimate error is made (and believe me, even good docs can make errors, mostly because of poor communication between them, the hospital staff, and patients) then people deserve to be compensated. That is precisely what insurance is for. And it is quite difficult to recover, even in a legitimate case. Many of the bad cases are not even accepted by attorneys, the okay cases are often thrown out by the courts and the good cases sometimes are lost at the jury level. There are protections at every step of the process to get rid of the bogus cases. Yes, the system is not perfect, like any system. But caps on awards will not rectify the problem of liers and cheaters and will only hurt those that are MOST hurt by legitimate mess ups. It is EXTREMELY difficult to prosecute those cases ... they take years and years, and the expert fees alone can cost a fortune. If you want to go after someone, go after the insurance companies. They are making millions off the premiums, keep raising them yet at the same time make it very difficult for the real victims to get paid in a timely manner and force lawyers on both sides of to incur unnecessary expenses.

I used to be in this field, and got out of it because the whole thing is very ugly. But caps on awards are not the answer. Insurance companies are better business-people than doctors AND lawyers. But no one seems to want to take them on directly.

Posted 7/20/07 5:10 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Med Malpratice Ins. Quest

Posted by Lifnewbie

I couldn't disagree with you more that caps on awards are the answer. If a legitimate error is made (and believe me, even good docs can make errors, mostly because of poor communication between them, the hospital staff, and patients) then people deserve to be compensated. That is precisely what insurance is for. And it is quite difficult to recover, even in a legitimate case. Many of the bad cases are not even accepted by attorneys, the okay cases are often thrown out by the courts and the good cases sometimes are lost at the jury level. There are protections at every step of the process to get rid of the bogus cases. Yes, the system is not perfect, like any system. But caps on awards will not rectify the problem of liers and cheaters and will only hurt those that are MOST hurt by legitimate mess ups. It is EXTREMELY difficult to prosecute those cases ... they take years and years, and the expert fees alone can cost a fortune. If you want to go after someone, go after the insurance companies. They are making millions off the premiums, keep raising them yet at the same time make it very difficult for the real victims to get paid in a timely manner and force lawyers on both sides of to incur unnecessary expenses.

I used to be in this field, and got out of it because the whole thing is very ugly. But caps on awards are not the answer. Insurance companies are better business-people than doctors AND lawyers. But no one seems to want to take them on directly.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

I think that med mal gets a bad rap. It gets thrown in with "ambulance chasers" and PI attorneys who do more car accidents which are usually soft tissue.

My old office wouldn't take a case until it was evaluated by a doctor who said the action would be meritorious. Believe me, I hate my old attorneys, but my clients were mainly nice people who had a bad thing (or things) happen to them.

Like I said earlier, you wouldn't drive a car without insurance, right? Even if you had had some accidents in the past and you had to pay higher premiums? It is the same thing. Especially OBs. And it isn't just delivery either. A well known OB forgot to have a patient sent for the glucose test, she had GD and delivered the baby at 32 weeks and she has a lot of problems. It happens.

Posted 7/20/07 7:01 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Anyone delivering at Mercy Med Center in Rockville Cntr?? sweetie 7/18/07 1 Pregnancy