Math question for teachers
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
Math question for teachers No snark here but just wondering why kids need to know such advanced math skills. Not just at elem age, but even in high school. I never used a quadratic equation in real life, kwim? I don't feel it's helped me in any way in my current life as an adult. Message edited 2013-01-13 14:35:10.337000. |
|
Posted 1/13/13 2:31 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Math question for teachers As a teacher I COMPLETELY agree with you. The problem is, we are required to teach certain skills by the state, which leaves close to no time for the much more functional skills. |
|
Posted 1/13/13 2:34 PM
|
|
|
Re: Math question for teachers Posted by Jbon630 As a teacher I COMPLETELY agree with you. The problem is, we are required to teach certain skills by the state, which leaves close to no time for the much more functional skills. What can we do as parents? I'm literally dreading this. |
|
Posted 1/13/13 2:35 PM
|
|
|
Math question for teachers I understand that for some concepts, you need basic concepts to build on them but some of these methods only one or two students "get" and those children have "math minds" |
|
Posted 1/13/13 2:36 PM
|
|
|
Re: Math question for teachers Posted by EatingMyVeggies Posted by Jbon630 As a teacher I COMPLETELY agree with you. The problem is, we are required to teach certain skills by the state, which leaves close to no time for the much more functional skills. What can we do as parents? I'm literally dreading this. Wish I knew. Until we are able to stop "teaching to the state test", I don't think there is an answer unfortunately. |
|
Posted 1/13/13 2:37 PM
|
|
|
Re: Math question for teachers Posted by Jbon630 Posted by EatingMyVeggies Posted by Jbon630 As a teacher I COMPLETELY agree with you. The problem is, we are required to teach certain skills by the state, which leaves close to no time for the much more functional skills. What can we do as parents? I'm literally dreading this. Wish I knew. Until we are able to stop "teaching to the state test", I don't think there is an answer unfortunately. I think the new standards are coming from a good place, wanting to improve our students' mathematical understanding, but its the pacing that is the problem. A lot of the things they want are developmentally inappropriate. There is a lot of higher-level thinking and reasoning skills, and some of our students just aren't there yet. At my school, we have two math curriculums-one that our standardized students use (test-takers) and one that our alternate assessment students use, and the alt. assessment program is great-lots of functional skills. The program I am teaching is very difficult for my students. There is very little direct instruction, instead they are supposed to learn from these activities, but my students are functioning with a VERY concrete level of thinking. If they don't see it, exactly how to do the specific problem, they aren't going to figure it out. The 3rd grade test is laughably difficult. What is sad is that my students, who are on the spectrum, will fail it miserably, and then be placed in alternate-assessment, because the school won't want their test-scores bringing down the school average, and they will be tracked into getting an IEP diploma at such a young age. They set these kids up to fail. If we had more arithmetic and basic math, not only would they have more functional skills, but these kids might have a shot in hell of passing this test. This is what happens when you have people who are not teachers making the laws and tests.
|
|
Posted 1/13/13 2:48 PM
|
|
|
Re: Math question for teachers After seeing the other post, I am very scared. My worst subject was math...always. From elem, to hs, to college....now, i see these posts about 1st grade questions and my head is spinning. I cannot answer them!! I don't understand the logic behind these math questions and I am scared my weak math skills will hurt my kids b/c i cannot answer these!! |
|
Posted 1/13/13 2:53 PM
|
|
|
Math question for teachers I think the intentions of Common Core were great. The point was for them to be focusing on fewer skills so that they can understand them better. There is supposed to be a balance between having lots of rote practice for fluency along side application questions that help them apply their knowledge at a higher level. When I watched the video where I think it was the chancellor of education explaining common core I thought it was great. Just what I've always thought we needed. |
|
Posted 1/13/13 3:29 PM
|
|
|
Re: Math question for teachers Posted by rsquared Posted by Jbon630 Posted by EatingMyVeggies Posted by Jbon630 As a teacher I COMPLETELY agree with you. The problem is, we are required to teach certain skills by the state, which leaves close to no time for the much more functional skills. What can we do as parents? I'm literally dreading this. Wish I knew. Until we are able to stop "teaching to the state test", I don't think there is an answer unfortunately. I think the new standards are coming from a good place, wanting to improve our students' mathematical understanding, but its the pacing that is the problem. A lot of the things they want are developmentally inappropriate. There is a lot of higher-level thinking and reasoning skills, and some of our students just aren't there yet. At my school, we have two math curriculums-one that our standardized students use (test-takers) and one that our alternate assessment students use, and the alt. assessment program is great-lots of functional skills. The program I am teaching is very difficult for my students. There is very little direct instruction, instead they are supposed to learn from these activities, but my students are functioning with a VERY concrete level of thinking. If they don't see it, exactly how to do the specific problem, they aren't going to figure it out. The 3rd grade test is laughably difficult. What is sad is that my students, who are on the spectrum, will fail it miserably, and then be placed in alternate-assessment, because the school won't want their test-scores bringing down the school average, and they will be tracked into getting an IEP diploma at such a young age. They set these kids up to fail. If we had more arithmetic and basic math, not only would they have more functional skills, but these kids might have a shot in hell of passing this test. This is what happens when you have people who are not teachers making the laws and tests. ITA. I am also so disappointed that now there is either Regents diploma or IEP diploma. So many kids are going to get weeded into an IEP diploma when they could have been fine with the "regular" diploma we used to have. |
|
Posted 1/13/13 3:33 PM
|
|
|
Re: Math question for teachers I also think because so many other countries are so far ahead of us in math, they want us to catch up to them. I am a first grade teacher and while I understand the reasoning behind the core, I think way too much is expected of children these days. |
|
Posted 1/13/13 5:29 PM
|
|
|
Math question for teachers While I'm not a teacher (or a parent) I think that the higher math (quadratic equations, calculus, etc) help teach people to think more logically - apply rules - form conclusions - speculate - and work thru problems until resolution. |
|
Posted 1/13/13 6:19 PM
|
|
|
Re: Math question for teachers Posted by Blazesyth While I'm not a teacher (or a parent) I think that the higher math (quadratic equations, calculus, etc) help teach people to think more logically - apply rules - form conclusions - speculate - and work thru problems until resolution. While I don't work with math specifically in my profession, I think it has helped me become a better problem solver. I was a teacher and I agree with this. However, it's so hard to have this insight when you're dealing with triangle proofs in geometry and you just KNOW you'll never use that shiz in your real life! My students (middle school) would often ask why we're learning a given topic and my response would be some variation of "because it will be on the state exam in May"
|
|
Posted 1/13/13 6:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: Math question for teachers Posted by PennyCat Posted by Blazesyth While I'm not a teacher (or a parent) I think that the higher math (quadratic equations, calculus, etc) help teach people to think more logically - apply rules - form conclusions - speculate - and work thru problems until resolution. While I don't work with math specifically in my profession, I think it has helped me become a better problem solver. I was a teacher and I agree with this. However, it's so hard to have this insight when you're dealing with triangle proofs in geometry and you just KNOW you'll never use that shiz in your real life! My students (middle school) would often ask why we're learning a given topic and my response would be some variation of "because it will be on the state exam in May" Even when I was in college and in Calc 2 and Physics 2 I thought "Why do I need to be in these classes, I want to work in computers and not math." As they say, hindsight is 20/20. I would have rather NOT taken those classes, but they have helped me in my career. Not because of the actual content but learning them developed and honed my skills. |
|
Posted 1/13/13 6:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: Math question for teachers Posted by Blazesyth While I'm not a teacher (or a parent) I think that the higher math (quadratic equations, calculus, etc) help teach people to think more logically - apply rules - form conclusions - speculate - and work thru problems until resolution. While I don't work with math specifically in my profession, I think it has helped me become a better problem solver. I agree. I loved math when I was in school & I enjoyed solving the problems. Even if it's not something that every person uses in everyday life, I still consider it worthwhile. |
|
Posted 1/13/13 7:26 PM
|
|
|
Re: Math question for teachers Posted by Blazesyth Even when I was in college and in Calc 2 and Physics 2 I thought "Why do I need to be in these classes, I want to work in computers and not math." As they say, hindsight is 20/20. I would have rather NOT taken those classes, but they have helped me in my career. Not because of the actual content but learning them developed and honed my skills. I agree. Logical, analytical thinking and problem solving are valuable skills that will serve you well in many professions, even if you never apply the actual math principles you learn. |
|
Posted 1/13/13 7:35 PM
|
|
|
Re: Math question for teachers Posted by Blazesyth While I'm not a teacher (or a parent) I think that the higher math (quadratic equations, calculus, etc) help teach people to think more logically - apply rules - form conclusions - speculate - and work thru problems until resolution. While I don't work with math specifically in my profession, I think it has helped me become a better problem solver. YES!!! As a non-math HS teacher, I always have told students that math is probably their most important subject because it was mental exercise. I find that it's usually the opposite - I do use math quite often in my daily life - and I am not a math teacher. |
|
Posted 1/13/13 7:43 PM
|
|
|
Re: Math question for teachers Posted by Blazesyth While I'm not a teacher (or a parent) I think that the higher math (quadratic equations, calculus, etc) help teach people to think more logically - apply rules - form conclusions - speculate - and work thru problems until resolution. While I don't work with math specifically in my profession, I think it has helped me become a better problem solver. I agree. It helps with critical thinking skills, forming logical conclusions etc |
|
Posted 1/14/13 3:50 PM
|
|
|
Re: Math question for teachers Posted by Jbon630 Posted by rsquared Posted by Jbon630 Posted by EatingMyVeggies Posted by Jbon630 As a teacher I COMPLETELY agree with you. The problem is, we are required to teach certain skills by the state, which leaves close to no time for the much more functional skills. What can we do as parents? I'm literally dreading this. Wish I knew. Until we are able to stop "teaching to the state test", I don't think there is an answer unfortunately. I think the new standards are coming from a good place, wanting to improve our students' mathematical understanding, but its the pacing that is the problem. A lot of the things they want are developmentally inappropriate. There is a lot of higher-level thinking and reasoning skills, and some of our students just aren't there yet. At my school, we have two math curriculums-one that our standardized students use (test-takers) and one that our alternate assessment students use, and the alt. assessment program is great-lots of functional skills. The program I am teaching is very difficult for my students. There is very little direct instruction, instead they are supposed to learn from these activities, but my students are functioning with a VERY concrete level of thinking. If they don't see it, exactly how to do the specific problem, they aren't going to figure it out. The 3rd grade test is laughably difficult. What is sad is that my students, who are on the spectrum, will fail it miserably, and then be placed in alternate-assessment, because the school won't want their test-scores bringing down the school average, and they will be tracked into getting an IEP diploma at such a young age. They set these kids up to fail. If we had more arithmetic and basic math, not only would they have more functional skills, but these kids might have a shot in hell of passing this test. This is what happens when you have people who are not teachers making the laws and tests. ITA. I am also so disappointed that now there is either Regents diploma or IEP diploma. So many kids are going to get weeded into an IEP diploma when they could have been fine with the "regular" diploma we used to have. Not to get off topic but the IEP diploma is a bunch of BS and is useless. It is not a diploma and is not recognized as such to employers, or anyone else in the "real world". There is a big push to change the IEP diploma again (or at least offer something between the IEP and Regents diploma) within the special ed world and hopefully it will be changed again before it affects our kids. |
|
Posted 1/14/13 4:01 PM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| need help from any teachers.. math question 5th grade | janet | 6/1/05 | 6 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Math question(elementary) X-POST FROM TEACHERS | ChrisDee | 3/10/11 | 0 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| MAth Teachers - Sillly Question | spooks | 5/14/07 | 1 | Teachers |
| Teachers....I have a question....(REPOST) | FLaCaTaCa | 6/23/05 | 0 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Question for teachers...mortgage programs | sasha96 | 5/23/05 | 2 | Home |
| Question for teachers | MamaNDaddyof3 | 5/17/05 | 9 | Families Helping Families ™ |











